The Syndicate

nijuukyugou wrote:Thanks a lot, chief (Just kidding )

Great game while I was alive! I think I talked more in this than any of my games and really enjoyed it, especially beating everyone single-handedly at the numbers game Great game, llama!

Oh yeah! That was funny as hell. I was so damn mad.

I was killed three times. lol

MovingPictures07 wrote:

Epignosis wrote:

MovingPictures07 wrote:YES!!!!! AWESOME!!!

Truly epic to win as a civilian alongside you, Epig, so thanks for all your help this game!

Yeah, you weren't much help. You almost lynched me!

I tried.

And that's not true, I never even voted you, once you responded to my case against you, I was pretty much like... well, that didn't hold up to shit.

Glad to win with my old friend from PA. You're a good person to celebrate my first civilian win with.

MovingPictures07 wrote:YES!!!!! AWESOME!!!

Truly epic to win as a civilian alongside you, Epig, so thanks for all your help this game!

Yeah, you weren't much help. You almost lynched me!

Hedgeowl wrote:Epi, you worked your tuchas off in this game, so definitely a well deserved civ win. Congrats you guys!

Thanks Hedge. That means a lot. You almost persuaded me too!

thellama73 wrote:Also, Mrs. White could have been taken down by Yvette, if she were not taken down by Mr. Green first.

I had Eloh pegged as the Cook due to misinfo

I had a heap of fun playing this. It was my first game ever that I kept a spreadsheet. Thank you llama.

I WON AS A CIVILIAN!

And only because I had a nigh invincible role. Damn I'm good.

I could cry.

Boogs wrote:Epignosis your "logic" doesnt give a reason, just an accusation. I'm not bad. If Vomps isnt Wodsworth, I'm looking at you tomorrow as the top suspect. I dont see anyone else as being suspicious atm.

That's right folks. I tried to kill my own damn self. Twice.

This is why I don't listen to you, MP.

Boogs wrote:It's not me lol But I don't understand why i am even a suspect for Wodsworth. I typically trust MP's intuitions so I will vote Vomps so we can win if he's right.

It's logic Boogs. This is Clue. Either Vompatti is bad or you are.

Logic.

Suits me.

MovingPictures07 wrote:Damn, that sucks.

So should we vote Mongoose again or Vomps? I think Vomps is Wadsworth.

I will follow your lead for a change, if you feel sure. Mongoose is the safer vote, but Wadsworth needs to go too.

Damn! RIP Matahari.

Ding ding ding. We have a winner.

thellama73 wrote:And no one really knows what's going on at all.

Patently false.

I have voted.

Suits me. I'll vote before bed unless anyone raises any other point.

I'm not going to comment further on the host's last post. I hope that's okay with everyone.

Folks, may I remind you that the vote ends tomorrow morning? Unless someone can make a strong point against Boogs or Vompatti, I will be voting Mongoose.

Waddy suspects: Boogs and Vompatti
Boddy suspects: Mongoose

MovingPictures07 wrote:I'm confused, what does this mean?

It means that Boogs shouldn't have rushed in here to vote like that.

I'll post the Wadsworth and Boddy suspects when I finish computing.

See? Shenanigans!

Recreating my spreadsheet for a fourth (!) time.

Bass_the_Clever wrote:I'm calling bull shit on epig I am 100% he isn't civ this game. He knows I know and thats why he is pushing my lynch today.

So you're a lynch switcher, a role checker, and a mind reader.

Matahari wrote:If Bass is voted and revealed to be the chief, who would your next suspect for Boddy be?

If Bass isn't Boddy, then I call shenanigans.

Matahari wrote:I'm excluding myself from the list, obviously because I know my own role. On day four, three players voted - MP, Bass, and Epig, and Boddy targeted that night. I tend to trust Epig. I'm unsure of the other two. Bass pulled a fairly risky bluff by implying he had something to do with one of the switches. MP kind of questioned it, and then came back later and said he thought he understood, (his post wasn't all that clear to me), so I'm wondering if something has happened that totally rules MP out as Boddy, as Boddy could self-target )long shot, I know. Any help would be appreciated.

I have MP ruled out as Boddy for three reasons.

Mongoose wrote:

Epignosis wrote:I am recreating my spreadsheet from scratch.

Question about Boddy targets:

SVS was Boddy's target on Night 1. Correct?

MP was targeted by Boddy on Night 4. Correct?

That means Boddy HAD to have voted on Day 4, correct?

That seeems right to me.

If this is true, Bass has to be Boddy. I've recreated my spreadsheet three times now.

I am recreating my spreadsheet from scratch.

Question about Boddy targets:

SVS was Boddy's target on Night 1. Correct?

MP was targeted by Boddy on Night 4. Correct?

That means Boddy HAD to have voted on Day 4, correct?

That...was not at all what I was expecting to happen.

I am sorry MR.

I'll cast the first stone I guess. Again, we're expecting a no lynch if this is correct. Voting MR.

MovingPictures07 wrote:I wasn't reading MR as Boddy, but it seems to be the best option I suppose. I'd be willing to try it too, worst case it's wrong and it REALLY is Bass, right?

You were reading me as Boddy, so no, pardon me if I am not interested in your reads.

But if it's not MR or Bass, I'll take the rope and hang my own damn self in the kitchen.

MovingPictures07 wrote:I feel about trying to lynch Bass again since it seems he makes more sense as the Chief though.

My view was that the Cook was involved, but if the Chief switched the lynch, the Cook couldn't do diddly shit about that, no matter how good the food was.

I am willing to go down the MR road.

MovingPictures07 wrote:

Epignosis wrote:Do you trust Mongoose?

I don't know. So, I suppose by default, no.

I just have no idea what to make of her this game, honestly.

I had a civilian role in mind for her, but she says things that don't make sense with that role. I don't know.

Wadsworth tried to kill. Presumably, he can't kill for a while now. I think taking out Boddy is still advisable. And easiest, because it's either Bass or MR.

We tried Bass, and he survived. That fits with the Chief or Boddy. If Bass IS the Chief and already used his switch, then it was incredibly wasteful of him.

Huh. Just thought of something. Remember I said that Bass fucked up my spreadsheet? That may not be true. What I believed and what he claims happened could both be true.

Anyway, if we try him again, and he's the Chief, then he dies. I propose we lynch MR. If MR is Boddy, then he'll survive and we know to immure him, Poe style. If he is not Boddy, then Bass is.

A little "witch hunty," I know, but them's the breaks.

Do you trust Mongoose?

Boddy= Bass or MR

Wadsworth = Boogs, Vompatti, or Mongoose (assumptions allowing)

Who would try to murder me twice?

MovingPictures07 wrote:I thought Wadsworth was eliminated to less before, or am I wrong there? Did you revise it?

Isn't Mata a possibility for both too or are you not considering her?

Frankly, the fact that Wadsworth tried to kill you AGAIN last night tells me that player isn't paying enough attention.

I am telling you what my spreadsheet says on the most conservative level. Allowing for certain assumptions, however, I have it down to three. Those assumptions are: 1. Bass didn't throw sabie under the bus, and 2. sabie didn't vote for her own teammate.

Matahari is making too much sense this late in the game for me to question her intentions.

MovingPictures07 wrote:

Epignosis wrote:

MovingPictures07 wrote:Epi, what are you thinking?

Personally I think we should vote for someone who could be Boddy OR Wadsworth, or if that's not possible then Boddy, then Wadsworth. At least get something accomplished.

Let me get my stick drive.

What do you mean?

You're not a Luddite, are you? I mean, somehow you're posting here.

My spreadsheet allows for five people to be Wadsworth logically speaking. That's not particularly helpful, I realize. Both Bass and MR are on the list, for what it's worth, and one of those two is Boddy.

MovingPictures07 wrote:Epi, what are you thinking?

Personally I think we should vote for someone who could be Boddy OR Wadsworth, or if that's not possible then Boddy, then Wadsworth. At least get something accomplished.

Let me get my stick drive.

Matahari wrote:Does anyone think it might be worthwhile to go ahead and lynch wads worth instead of Boddy? That's assuming that everyone is in agreement about who Wadsworth is. Or do you think Boddy will get to pick up the nightly kills, if Wadsworth is gone?

I am fine either way. I simply have a vested interest in eliminating Boddy first, and he's one of two people.

Wadsworth is murkier territory for me, I am afraid.

Matahari wrote:So, Wadsworth gets to kill every night now? Or was my count off?

MP is not the role I thought he was, because he's a male role (I had forgotten that). Back to the drawing board.

Bass might have lied or not?

I trust MP even if he doesn't trust me.

Bass...I have to think about him. And MR.

Mister Rearranger wrote:Well now I have a lead Boddy suspect, at least.

Yes? Do tell. Because I have one fewer.

This is getting tiresome.

No objection here.

Matahari wrote:No hard feelings. I'm so clueless, I'm no help to anyone. But I do have a way of proving I'm a civ. if you're interested, let me know.

Always interested. Please.

MovingPictures07 wrote:But if somehow you do end up being Boddy, then screw you. :P

I cannot end up being something I am not already.

Matahari wrote:

MovingPictures07 wrote:Okay, I see what you're saying now.

Well, I'm more than willing to give you the BOTD then and lynch Mata and then Vomps. That should end the game, right? Unless it's MR?

I just think MR is least likely, since I was reading him as civ, but maybe I'm wrong.

Could anyone kindly make a case on why I might be Boddy or baddie? I'm not a sly little mongoose you know. Just a confused puppy.

It's just logic, love.

And I am THIS close to winning as a civilian. First time ever. Eight wins bad. Zero wins good.

THIS IS IT.

No hard feelings I hope.

MovingPictures07 wrote:Okay, I see what you're saying now.

Well, I'm more than willing to give you the BOTD then and lynch Mata and then Vomps. That should end the game, right? Unless it's MR?

I just think MR is least likely, since I was reading him as civ, but maybe I'm wrong.

Lynch?

Bitch, you don't lynch anyone. You don't vote.

Seriously, that's what I am asking. Mongoose thinks MR is good, and she thinks you are good. I cannot see why she would vouch for two civilians if she was bad.

If Bass is the Chief, then it HAS to be Matahari.

MovingPictures07 wrote:

Epignosis wrote:

MovingPictures07 wrote:Fair responses, but I still think you're probably Boddy.

I am not, and I swear to God, if you lynch me, I'll hold a grudge.

Come on dude.

Look, don't make it personal. I'm sorry. I want you to be civ.

You don't have to WANT me to be a civilian. You just have to listen.

Do me a favor. Go read the roles. Which civilian could I be?

MovingPictures07 wrote:

Epignosis wrote:

MovingPictures07 wrote:And it can be Mata, since when? Did I miss something? It's possible I did since I've been kind of in and out.

You're in and out and you're trying to get me lynched? Jesus! I've been NEGLECTING things to win this. Think about that.

I have been playing this game but honestly most of my mafia attention is on Dr. Who right now, so yeah, I've been a bit in and out -- and especially since this game is faster and my schedule comes in spurts of busy vs. spurts of not busy.

Look, I'm fine with trying to lynch Mata since she could either be bad or Boddy (right?), but I think Vomps is probably Wadsworth. And I can't help it if you seem like you'd fit the Boddy bill and there are only a few possibilities.

According to my sheet, this is right. Matahari could be Boddy or Wadsworth. Vompatti could be Wadsworth too.