The Syndicate

Metalmarsh89 wrote:
DFaraday wrote:I was right about Eloh all along! I'm not sure why she never got lynched. And once I saw the votes in my lynch, it was obvious who the baddies were (except Lacey, I wasn't sure on her).

Did my targeting actually have any effect on anyone?
I think you forced me to take myself off the lynch poll one day (assuming it was you who targeted me).

No, I didn't target you. I did target Lacey the night before I died.

I was right about Eloh all along! I'm not sure why she never got lynched. And once I saw the votes in my lynch, it was obvious who the baddies were (except Lacey, I wasn't sure on her).

Did my targeting actually have any effect on anyone?

I was literally in a car accident trying to get here in time to vote(it was the other guy's fault, but I was only in that lane to stop by the library), and I still missed. Oh well.

DFaraday wrote:
Elohcin wrote:
LoRab wrote:
Russtifinko wrote:Well, many words I can't say in front of Simon. Sorry, guys. I feel like I let the team down there. So, is it LoRab then, or am I way off base there too?

The baddies have had us way bamboozled this game, and I dunno if it's them playing well or just us playing really, really poorly.
you are way off base there too.
Everyone is saying, "its not me" but its got to be someone :P Who's lyin', huh?
Very true, I'm sure at least one baddie is one of the players who has been in the spotlight recently, either suspecting or being suspected. But it looks like all 3 baddies are still alive, so finding them all is getting to be more and more urgent.

I just looked at the roles again and realized there are 4 pigs.

That makes it even more urgent.

Elohcin wrote:
LoRab wrote:
Russtifinko wrote:Well, many words I can't say in front of Simon. Sorry, guys. I feel like I let the team down there. So, is it LoRab then, or am I way off base there too?

The baddies have had us way bamboozled this game, and I dunno if it's them playing well or just us playing really, really poorly.
you are way off base there too.
Everyone is saying, "its not me" but its got to be someone :P Who's lyin', huh?

Very true, I'm sure at least one baddie is one of the players who has been in the spotlight recently, either suspecting or being suspected. But it looks like all 3 baddies are still alive, so finding them all is getting to be more and more urgent.

Russtifinko wrote:
FZ. wrote:I'm down with voting Made. If he flips bad, we know DF is his team mate.
Why is this?

Yes, why is this indeed.

I tend to opt for the simpler solution, so I agree with Splints that it's more likely that Made is the lynch-surviving civ than that some other shenanigans saved him.

I'm sticking with *voting Elo* since she was my prime suspect even before MP made his list. I wouldn't mind LR or Made getting lynched either, but I haven't read back to find anything pingy about them other than MP's post.

I think the best place to start today is with the people MP mentioned. I haven't reviewed LoRab yet, but I'll look over her posts in a bit. Of course it could be someone trying to frame one of them, but I think the simpler explanation is that the Pigs knew MP was onto them and got him out of the way.

Metalmarsh89 wrote:
Boomslang wrote:RIP, boo. So it goes :/. But this thread has been really quiet tonight... too quiet. Time to start some things :P

Blooper, has the death of boo helped you reconcile your number of mafia suspects with the number of actual mafia?
Russ, you didn't post at all Day 2. What are your thoughts?
Elo, you mentioned wanting to look at quiet players today; who's highest on the list?
You wanna be starin' something?

I will be gone all day tomorrow, with basically no chances to check in, so I'm going to go ahead and *vote Elo* right off the bat.

MovingPictures07 wrote:
DFaraday wrote:I feel like some of the suspicions of Splints are disingenuous. Her 3 posts don't strike me as suspicious enough to sway nearly the entire thread into believing she's bad, so I'm guessing one or two of the people saying they feel baddie for her are just going with the flow.

My main suspicion is still Elo. I still feel that she was bandwagoning, and has not presented much of a satisfactory explanation since.
Which one or two seem most likely to be going with the flow?

I'd say Lacey and TB, since they voiced their suspicions of Splints after several others had, but neither provided any reason for it.

I feel like some of the suspicions of Splints are disingenuous. Her 3 posts don't strike me as suspicious enough to sway nearly the entire thread into believing she's bad, so I'm guessing one or two of the people saying they feel baddie for her are just going with the flow.

My main suspicion is still Elo. I still feel that she was bandwagoning, and has not presented much of a satisfactory explanation since.

LoRab wrote:Honesly, no idea whom I find most suspicious.

FZ. wrote:I agree with Boo as well. Lorab, a baddie team would be foolish to put all the eggs in one basket just in case that person got blocked, so I think it's a lot more likely that they spread their powers.
First off, we can't know what the baddies chose to do, even if it wasn't good strategy. Baddies don't always do what is the "best" choice. Also, if someone on the baddie team has to be chosen to make the kill, which is a frequent set up, then it's not all the eggs in a basket, it's making the choice of which basket to put them in. Regardless, someone can be blocked. Which is why in most games I've played, there is an individual on the baddie team that holds the kill--and usually, in my experience, when that isn't specified as a role, the team chooses who carries out the kill. Are you intentionally missing my point? Or is that not the case on this site (which I find hard to believe).

What FZ is saying is that it's unlikely that the baddies would put all of their powers on one person. Of course it's not impossible, but I give all of our players more credit than to do something like that. Occam's Razor suggests that, since there haven't been any apparent effects from the Night Phase, the eagle used his power.

And holy vote spread, Batman! We're just going off in all directions. I'll be *voting Daisy* because her Scotty vote felt bandwagony and her Made vote came from out of nowhere.

Boomslang wrote: Now that I think about it—DFaraday, you're claiming Elo voted "after the votes started rolling in." She was the second Scotty voter and the sixth overall. I don't think that quite qualifies as "bandwagoning." I agree it wasn't the most well-grounded of votes, but I'm interested in the way you lumped the timing of her vote together with Daisy's (who voted 17th).

It was more the feel behind Elo's vote. It came across as, "Well, Scotty is under fire, I might as well throw a vote there" rather than genuine suspicion. It might not be bandwagoning per se, but it felt like she was just latching onto a convenient suspicion.

Today I'm primarily looking at the posters who bandwagoned Scotty. Elo and Daisy's votes stood out the most to me as not being grounded in much, and coming after the votes started rolling in.

As for LR/Lacey, I have a civ vibe on Lacey. Not sure about LR; that rather specific post she made sounded like she might have knowledge of the blue birds' powers, but LR is much too savvy a player to reveal knowledge she has in the thread. I think that's all supposition, and I suppose I'm inclined to feel just slightly good about her overall.

Scotty wrote:
LoRab wrote:voted Scotty. Weak suspicion, but day 1. I thought by pointing out Lacey and I, he was seriously trying to point figures in any direction other than his. Which doesn't seem like a civ tactic. And he knows from the last game that I have quiet days because of life, so...doesn't seem so authentic to point in my direction because I hadn't posted during this RL day. And voting now because I'm exhausted and starting to fall asleep.
If you have followed me at all in any game I play here, my Day 1 is usually centered around looking at people that haven't checked in/posted. My view is if you're in the game, play the game. Why should we keep you around?

Should I not be pointing in directions other than myself? Or should I just vote myself? I'm not sure what constitutes a civ tactic.

Just so you feel better, DFaraday also hasn't posted today.

And hello lipstick! Nice to hear from you, and I hope to get to play with you past Day 1!

I was working from 8-8 and had no chances to check in.

My really quick summary of the posts makes me feel okay about Boo and Scotty. I'm not sure about FZ, specifically going after Boo for his logic angle (which he always plays anyway). I don't feel like trying to scrutinize posts tonight, so I'll go with my feeling and *vote FZ*

I will thank Boo for his vote, and reciprocate.

The Syndicate

Search found 16 matches

Re: Angry Birds [ENDGAME]

Re: Angry Birds [ENDGAME]

Re: Angry Birds [Day 5]

Re: Angry Birds [Day 5]

Re: Angry Birds [Day 5]

Re: Angry Birds [Day 4]

Re: Angry Birds [Day 4]

Re: Angry Birds [Day 4]

Re: Angry Birds [Day 3]

Re: Angry Birds [Day 2]

Re: Angry Birds [Day 2]

Re: Angry Birds [Day 2]

Re: Angry Birds [Day 2]

Re: Angry Birds [Day 2]

Re: Angry Birds [Day 1]

Re: Angry Birds [Day 0]