WTF? I get back from DC to 5 votes on me? I'm neither a vamp nor Glory.
I posted about Illy because I suspected Illy--it was mostly gut, but I also tried to provide some other reasons to help explain where my thoughts were coming from, because I know the culture here tends to appreciate more than just meta. I
speedchuck wrote: ↑Mon Feb 12, 2018 2:52 pm
Last vampire is Sig, SVS, or Tranq.
Glory is probably not LoRab.
Someone who knows the lore, tell me what conditions could have caused Oz-mageddon
My best guess would be the death of Willow.
S~V~S wrote: ↑Mon Feb 12, 2018 4:36 pm
Although I could be talked out of it for a LoRab vote, she has been blending and sliding, sliding and blending.
I don't think I've either blended nor slid. As I posted in the sign up thread, it was a busy week last week and I was travelling for work chaperoning teens in dc this weekend, so I haven't posted much recently. I've been doing the best I can.
MacDougall wrote: ↑Mon Feb 12, 2018 5:54 pm
I dunno. She said she was reading her mafia as pure gut and meta but then gave thread based reasons. That looks like distancing gone wrong.
As I said, I gave thread reasons because I know they are appreciated, especially when others don't know a player. And the way I read gut and "meta" are directly connected to the way people post. Not every pattern would read bad for me with every player--what I pointed out are things that read baddie for me with Illy. And so I posted why I was suspicious. I posted about her as soon as I got on that day, having had the thought during the night before, and someone else had mentioned it before.
S~V~S wrote: ↑Mon Feb 12, 2018 6:00 pm
It could also be read as distancing which got out of hand, since it is the only post of substance she made about Illy. It isn't a hard case. Next was "Vote Illy" and then analyzing other peoples illy votes. I would not put anything past LoRab (said with all love and respect for her and her game). Also Illy did not show up for a few days, it is possible she knew this in advance and her team did as well.
I trust you, sig and Tranq. I know who I am
that leaves Mac and LoRab, and I think he is more likely as the SK. But either way,they are the baddies we seek.
Yes, I didn't make another post about Illy--I was unable to get back to the computer to post any more and I didn't have anything to add about Illy that I hadn't already said or someone else had said--I didn't see a point in repeating myself. And you're right--it isn't a hard case, it was an explanation of why I was pretty sure Illy was bad--and I was right. A gut read is rarely "hard" and I've often been able to gut read Illy--my only hesitation was that I was out of practice.
And that I'd take advantage of a teammate not being there doesn't make sense to me (perhaps you can elaborate)--I generally hate lynching people who aren't there to defend--it's easy to find that about me and several players in the game (like you) know that about me. I voted in this case and didn't change because I was confident--and had no reason to think Illy was unable to come back to defend, just that she wasn't coming back.