The Syndicate

My travel schedule for work seems to finally be calming down so I believe I have time to actually play a game of mafia!

Count me in for this wild ride.

My heart goes out to you, FZ. I've had my home broken into and quite a lot stolen before and I know how unsettling it is. Take all the time you need and don't worry about the game.

As for the game, yay for hobbits!!!

I am so glad I didn't miss sign-ups for this! In!

Thank you sooooooooo much for hosting this, MP! This game was an absolute blast to play despite the fact that I was literally a vanilla civvie the entire game. It was so weird for people to have so much info and to personally feel so in the dark since nothing happened to me at night (at least that I...

I want them both to win so I voted Boomslang on the off-chance of forcing a tie (there's still plenty of people left to vote!).

This game was amazing.

I agree.

*votes*

Epi voted for Hedgeowl and Metalmarsh voted for TH.

*Linki*

Oh my gosh, MP. I am so so sorry to hear about your flights getting all screwed up again! Travel safely and don't worry about the game right now.

Private detective's office!

RIP Hedgeowl, I think you were good based on reading back and some things you said. :( Good game, Elohcin! You almost had me convinced we were wrong about you! So the game isn't over. Does that mean we need to take care of Cohen? Or is there another baddie unaccounted for? Those buttons have me scar...

I guess I suck too, then.

*Votes Elohcin* If she's not Creeper then some shenanigans have gone down for sure.

I agree, Creeper's decision to kill SD was odd. I see what Hedge might be hinting at, but like you said, Nev, if she was the original target last night, that doesn't make much sense either. I am trying to look at things from every angle. The only Kate voter's who are still alive are bea, birdwithte...

S~V~S, how would you have us play differently? I am not using anything that isn't 100% available in the game thread to form my theories and opinions. Yes, MP might be screwing with us, but where's the evidence of that? So far I think almost everything that has happened this game can be explained by...

What I quoted had nothing to do with Moriarty's role. Jack Torrence - [The Shining] – Can post his thoughts to the thread each night. If found by Delbert Grady, they gain BTSC and a nightly kill, changing Jack's alignment. Jack is like a gossip role. Since Jack was dead, then another role was respo...

This is the part of the Night 9 post that has me pondering DF. The players then walked over to the bus, ready to head to Illinois. Then, familiarly, it started raining papers, which read: "I feel pretty confident that DF is a civvie. Also Bea and DH are pretty trustworthy, imo. Not so sure abo...

I know I flip-flopped on the Martell issue. It's because I was really, really surprised that Mongoose was Penny. So I sort of had a moment of doubt that it was true.

RIP and welcome back Spacedaisy. I suppose prizes could be in play, but considering I had already started thinking you weren't bad based on your past votes, I feel good about this. Right now my top two suspects are Hedgeowl and Elohcin, plus a little bit of Boomslang. There isn't really evidence di...

I am not against lynching baddies, I am against wasting lynches on unlynchable roles. Yesterday Boomslang unlynchable. So forgive me if I didn't want to waste a day lynching him. At this point, my big question marks are Hedgeowl, Elohcin, Spacedaisy, and DFaraday in order of most unsure of to unsure...

MacGyver doesn't look for Penny. Penny looks for MacGyver. If Mongoose had found MacGyver, she would have had back up in the thread and Bea, the only person actively defending her, is not MacGyver. MacGyver is basically a vanilla civvie without Penny finding him.

Elohcin, I can't fathom why you are pushing this lynch Boomslang stuff so much. The facts show he wasn't lynchable yesterday. If Boomslang is Cohen, he isn't a direct threat (except to those who voted him--of which you are one, is that the reason you want to lynch him so badly?). If he is Fetus, acc...

Well poop on a grenade. :rip: I had her at Penny/MacG for a few seconds, but then someone I thought might be one of the two, phrased something in such a way that killed it for me. :sigh: MacGyver should try and have a successful kill tonight if they're still alive. Based on how the roles are writte...

Or Catherine Martell?

If she really was Penny that sucks. I can't help but feel skeptical.

RIP Mongose. Disappointing and surprising result.

I voted Mongoose. I'm watching TV and didn't want to lose track of time and miss the vote later.

Yesterday Mongoose, Bea, and Elohcin voted for Boomslang. Elohcin came across sounding like either an indy who just had their win condition made almost impossible, or a very frustrated civvie. Bea has been giving me some squirrelly vibes so it's possible something is off with her, I'm undecided on t...

I don't see how it would provide any info. If he survived once, he'll survive again and the same roles will be considered. And if he is Cohen, like Nev thinks, then he's not as immediate a threat as Creeper or Fetus.

I am torn on who to vote for today.

I think he's bad too. But the question is, is he lynchable?

Yeah, if the Manipulators are completely eliminated then that would explain Creeper's odd night killing. I didn't mean to confuse. I think the Manipulators are no more, but I proposed an alternative explanation just in case. This is a complex game and I want to look at things from every angle.

I really don't think Boomslang survived for a civvie reason unless prizes were involved. The only reason to continue focusing on Boomslang today is if there's a chance he's Fetus. As Cohen he's not a threat (except I suppose he will want to see the three people who voted for him lynched or NKed so h...

Nevinera wrote:Wouldn't Catherine have gotten moriartys kill if she were still in?

Yes, but if the teams got merged then I was assuming the kill would stay with Creeper. I don't think Catherine is alive, but I figured the possibility should at least be considered.

RIP Timmer, pretty sure you were civvie based on everything that's happened. So Creeper killed Timmer! That must mean Manipulators are no more! Or they merged and Catherine is still alive and with the Video Game baddies now? As for Boomslang, are the only known ways to currently survive a lynch MacG...

The only thing I don't like about TImmer's scenarios is that he has me as likely bad in 3 of the 4. I am not bad. *pouts* why is he wrong in that analysis then? I didn't say the analysis was wrong. I was joking about disliking that he has me as potentially bad in the majority of the scenarios. But ...

Turnip Head wrote:I'm here because I saw on the Internet that I get a free monster truck for signing up, and everything on the Internet is true.

The only thing I don't like about TImmer's scenarios is that he has me as likely bad in 3 of the 4. I am not bad. *pouts*

@BWT: The mafia teams were merged when I played Six Feet Under on RM. I know I've seen it happen in other games, but that one immediately popped into my head because I was the last baddie on my team and got merged with DP who was the last baddie on his team. I agree that Mongoose doesn't look any be...

Elohcin, I didn't say meh to you. I sighed at the situation. Making this personal is really not cool with me. If I'm wrong then I'm truly sorry (and based on the last few minutes it seems like I made a bad decision), but saying "fuck you" to us and waiting until the last minute to start po...

I am fine with voting Elohcin. She has been lurking for the past half hour or so and not posted and her lack of defense didn't make me feel better.

*Linki* Geez!

Home now. I'm not sure of anything right now. I'll pretty much be voting on gut. Df, fh or Boom. Right now I'm debating between: the chance that boom really just didn't get a bunch of things about bwt etc., the fact that fh is usually pretty feisty when she starts getting eyed as a baddie, and df's...

DF said something earlier that I felt potentially hinted to his role which has given me pause for suspecting him at the moment. Though he could be pulling the wool over my eyes. I am torn between voting for Mongoose who is getting defense from a few people but has some decent evidence supporting her...

@Elohcin: Funny you make that point. I think the lack of Epig claiming "Elohcin is a civ. Trust! :srsnod: " is actually not in your favor. I feel like Epignosis would jump at the chance to gain some civvie cred if you were actually a civvie. However, that being said, I have no other read o...

Thanks for the response, DF. I checked back on voting records and saw that SD voted two days in row to lynch Epignosis, and one of those days he came close to getting lynched (he had 5 votes to Vomps' 7 votes). So I think it's less likely that she's a Video Game Baddie. She could still be a Manipula...

I was thinking about juliets and Creeper killing her. Could juliets have been Creeper and last night she exploded hoping to take down 4 people with her? The 2 players above her and 2 players below her alphabetically are me, Hedgeowl, Lizzy, and Mongoose. Lizzy is a civvie and I'm a civvie, not 100%...

I was thinking about juliets and Creeper killing her. Could juliets have been Creeper and last night she exploded hoping to take down 4 people with her? The 2 players above her and 2 players below her alphabetically are me, Hedgeowl, Lizzy, and Mongoose. Lizzy is a civvie and I'm a civvie, not 100% ...

Oh, I wanted to mention, I live in the Southern US and am about to get slammed with this winter storm. Apparently there's a pretty good chance we'll lose power. *lame* I assume I'll still be able to get online through my phone if that does happen, but if I vanish from the site for a day or so, that...

Sorry that people think I've been uncharacteristically quiet. I think I've been about normal for myself (this notion that I'm a talkative player makes me laugh because I am rarely a top poster in games). I'll do a list too! :smile: bea - trust, I think she's a civvie BWT - trust, civvie Boomslang - ...

I'm loving this game, but wow is it doing my head in. So like many others, I absolutely thought bea was Meat Boy after her suicide and resurrection. I see that some other ideas are bouncing around now about her that might possibly fit. RIP and welcome back, BWT. RIP and welcome back (again), BWT. RI...

If that's true bwt, then Bea warrants a reread. Word. But I dont understand how that would be possible given the suicide and the BdH defense. Something isnt adding up... Linki so do we think bdh really is thomas? Or cathy? Since he was mod-killed and not lynched, I doubt he'd have gotten to choose ...

Damn--I didn't realize the poll was ending early today.

If BWT is claiming the role I think he's claiming then I have definitely got to reevaluate some things. Though I guess the lynch post will prove whether he's lying or not.

Search found 742 matches