The Syndicate

Just finished binge watching the show. Will you be doing anything with ALIE?

What is my favorite Addie story?

I make an amazing cottage pie. I hope that will do? I bet it would. Alcatraz sounds great! What else? Muir woods? Have you seen a grove of Redwoods? Spring Training sounds fun. I hope you like the Indians. ;) I'd watch the Indians play the A's. Who else would you want to see? Anyone playing the A's...

OMG - I LOVE INDI'S QUESTION ALMOST AS MUCH AS I LOVE HER!!!!!!! Follow up questions: Why are you so proud of doing that thing? She took care of me all of my life. It was the least I could do. What is the second thing you are most proud of doing and why? I'm going to say it was a CCG I did the game...

Oooh, I have one!! http://img.photobucket.com/albums/v508/MMSSMM/Smileys/smiley-raising-waving-hand.gif There are lots of things you've done that I'm proud of you for, but what is something you've done that you're proud of you for? (Yep, you're going to have to brag on yourself for a minute. Sorry ...

Dex!!! Bea!!! What's new? How's stuff? Anything exciting happening? Not much. I finally returned by circuitous route to my ancestral homeland in the East Bay of California. So that's all good. Favorite comfort food? Shepherd's Pie? Favorite way to spoil indi? Baubles Favorite way to be spoiled? Lon...

Golden wrote:Hey Dex..

How awesome is indiglo?

You have no idea.

Well, actually, you may have some inkling.

Why Dex? It's short for Dexter Stratton, which was my username on LP. We all thought the DS on Charlie's ring stood for Drive Shaft, but it really was the name of his grandfather, Dexter Fuckin' Stratton. Have you seen Dexter? Yup, and enjoyed it. While it was running people would think that was wh...

How long have you played mafia for? Four or five years? I don't play all that often. I rather prefer to host. How did you first start playing? Poorly? I think Illy's Dr. Horrible game at HV was my first. How has your game play evolved? I'm still terrible at reading people so I look more for other s...

Ricochet wrote:I still don't get how the baddies knew LC was precisely Cain.

I wasn't mafia at the time, but for me the icing on the cake was when LC segued from denying he was Cain to defending Cain.

I played as I did because I was going to die on Day 6 anyway. Would have been nice of some of you to actually give me a chance to get there like I asked, instead of voting for me and foolishly wasting a lynch. :mad: Next time listen to me when I say to give me a chance to prove myself. 11) Please t...

JaggedJimmyJay wrote:Nice job indiglo. You were my vote for theme.

I went with Dex for the other one. I know how it feels to work hard in a town effort only to be converted into a losing cause.

Thank you for that sir.

Takes a little of the bite out of that suckfest.

No he wasn't. Poor Long Con was quite mad at me about that one, because he asked if Wilgy's claim would work if he jumped the fleet before he did it. And I told him that no, Wilgy's claim wouldn't work if the fleet jumped beforehand and he was already lynched. So, LC jumped the fleet when Wilgy wou...

So anyway, the post that convinced me that Wilgy was a civ cylon came right after Long Cain was lynched: And I have a win condition again! Yay me! Who doesn't have win conditions under martial law? Right after this, Goldama posted an admonition against discussing win conditions, which I thought was ...

Ricochet wrote:DFaraday (mafia) [successful)

DFaraday wasn't mafia

11) Please to answer: DFaraday / Dex, did you ever determine a lynch?

I determined Long Cain would be lynched. But then he was just lynched anyway. D'oh! I sure could have used that power later.

10

You're unbelievable. Nero didn't call SpaceDaisy bad anymore than I called Juliets good.

Votes John Cavil

#9 I believe Dex is bad, Epig. I need to vote because I'm going to bed. I'm still leaning bad on you Epig but the point you are raising against Dex looks reasonable. Makes me wonder if Glorfindel really was bad/seemer. Out of the other F5 I like Juliets way more than Daisy. Vote Dex Let's think like...

8. I don't think you understand my argument. If Dex is good, and he thinks juliets is good, and he thinks the two-on-two ratio holds (which he must based on the reasoning he used to condemn Nerolunar), then he must necessarily condemn Spacedaisy as bad. He didn't do that. He called her "in betw...

7. Argh. I'd like to hear from Dex though why he felt this way exactly , and why his read did not develop from pre-resurrection to post-resurrection. It was her charge on Long Cain and her willingness to actually go and find the Wilgy post I'm always talking about - assuming she wasn't just lying ab...

6. All I was doing was ranking a set of three suspects from most to least suspicious, and voting for the most. If there had been even one other suspect in the set, your three-card monte logic wouldn't even be possible. I have learned from my albeit limited experience that when you resort to one four...

5. Dex is also anti-Nerolunar: Post #7 I don't want to vote Epi or S~V~S. Epi because I guess I'm not just over lore yet. Boomer spent an entire season being good, but Athena was never evil. And S~V~S because she has been one of my stronger civ reads ever since she lead the charge on Cain. I just ca...

4. Again I ask: how sure are you. Just because my numbers are what I present does not mean that's my entire case. Simply that's what I choose to present. I need to know asap, please sir. I'm positive. If you want to look for the post I can't talk about, try an ISO of him around the time he declared....

3. Dex: what's your surety on Wigly being a civvie? Can you back it up with anything? Because I can back my end up and unless something is amiss, that boy is bad. It kind of weird a me out that you sound sure, when I know you can't be (or he's got multiple personality disorder.) The same way you've ...

#2 Trust you before resurrection I did but a question I have. Why in quotes is your post? Suspicious this looks. Yes, suspicious. As if in another thread you wrote it once before and for posting here copied it you did. D'oh! Started with a much larger post with lots of quotes and decided to simplify...

SO SAY WE ALL! #1 SUSPECTS JOHN CAVIL For my own part, I doubt that a vote for Cavil will do anything more than to buy him more time. I have to agree that a focus on the 4ofF5 is our most productive approach, even though that includes me. If we have to eliminate Cavil's team to get to Cavil, one or...

#4 Hey Cavil. Recruit me if you can. I agree with Sig (at least in regards to where are attention should be). I've never been fond of using lynches with unknown repercussions. Let's scumhunt until we are in a position where lynching cavil again is safe. Dex, you still God? Baloney(3) I hope for a sw...

#3 This took quite a while to think off (which is quite the understatement, given what I've focused on yesterDay), but what are the chances of Boomer having been a sort of seemer - not in terms of showing up as someone else, but showing up as town? One reason that keeps nagging me is the role of Cal...

#2 Also since Cavil resurrected, which has not happened since Epignosis' lynch and we considered it to be implausible, once the sortie mission conclude, let me check if there's not something we're supposed to "trigger", just like back on Day Two. Resurrection Hub Cylon Colony John Cavil hu...

DrumBeats wrote:Oh wow, great job people who voted for SVS. I am absolute shit, I'm getting off for the night. I'll try to look at things with fresh eyes later, but wow I was wrong.

Me too. She really had me fooled.

Post #7 I don't want to vote Epi or S~V~S. Epi because I guess I'm not just over lore yet. Boomer spent an entire season being good, but Athena was never evil. And S~V~S because she has been one of my stronger civ reads ever since she lead the charge on Cain. I just can't see a Cavil cylon doing tha...

#6. Ugh. One more question, and this applies to all four final five revived people, how many of the final five do you believe are likely Cavil-aligned? Just take a guess @ Dex @ juliets @ Spacedaisy How many people in the F5 do you believe are mafia? I feel like the four who have returned are two an...

#5 I do not think I am comfortable with believing that both Wilgy and Epig are civ after the Glorf flip. Dex, what do you think in that regard? . I am comfortable with that. What makes you uncomfortable? @Dex Why are you basing anything on lore! It's proven that lore is wrong and now knowing Glorfin...

#4

In which case, I'm back to defending Epi, based on lore. Athena was never mafia.

#3 DrWilgy: do not know his role but still KNOW HE IS CIV. The Boomer flip has no bearing on the evidence I found that he is civ You present a defense of Wilgy being Conoy, right? Is that still viable? If not, on what grounds do you read Wilgy civ? (I'm asking for reiteration, in case you already co...

#2 First of all, massive apologies to Glorfindel. He was telling the truth the whole time and I was not buying it. I knew he had to be Cavil, Doral, or Boomer, and I was convinced because of the show - just as Glorfindel said - that they were all bad. That Boomer flipped civ has taken me aback. Blac...

SO SAY WE ALL!

First post. I'm baaaaaaack!

JaggedJimmyJay wrote:rabbit replaced a2thezebra.

My bad.

I have a bad feeling about tonight, so just a couple of thoughts in case I don't make it. ObbsAll, I know we haven't seen eye to eye in this game and we don't know each other, but I'd like you to please consider that when I said I was certain that LC was Cain he was, and that when I said I was certa...

Epignosis wrote:I already know the person I want to lynch Day 8.

Do tell.

MISSED VOTES:
bea
Black Rock
DrumBeats
DrWilgy
JaggedJimmyJay
rabbit8
Ricochet
SokothQultuq
Vompatti

Which of these were due to punishments? Not Bea or Rico.

S~V~S wrote:I think he is a civ.I have thought so pretty much the whole game.

Me too, so his focus on you puzzles me. It seems to be related to his Cavil-before-Cain thing, but that also puzzles me.

Ricochet wrote:Honestly, if someone saying Resurrection Ship was the buzzword to trigger the hunt, I'm fairly sure anyone with lore knowledge would have duly brought up the idea.

Perhaps, but only after a cylon was lynched and then rezzed, which we were lucky to do on the first day.

Bea Bea's voting record does not look good. She did not vote Nutella on Day 2. On Day 3, after LoRab claimed, she jumped on the Nero bandwagon, contributing to the Tighe lynch. 3J called this "the most suspicious" vote in Nero's wagon. The next day, after LoRab' immunity has expired, she j...

My own take is that there was a 4-player BTSC team, Cavil's faction, of which only Cavil and Doral remain. But we'll also have to contend with the Final Five, and I have no idea how that mechanic is going to play out. Additionally, I have become convinced that we are going to see a Gaeta's rebellion...

Anyway, post-flip, I don't know what this tells us about sig. There was an absolute defensive bond between the two, but sig still likely survived a lynch as second wagon, so unless it's the mafia team that had a lynch stop, his status is still ambiguous. Not sure what to say of Matt reading the two...

JaggedJimmyJay wrote:
Dex wrote:I am amused that everyone who had been punished for not properly replying "So Say We All" are now diligently saying it - even though it's not currently required by the rules.
Those who made no posts on Day 7 were still subject to the SSWA from Night 6.

Ah! Of course.

I am amused that everyone who had been punished for not properly replying "So Say We All" are now diligently saying it - even though it's not currently required by the rules.

It's probably for the best that I wasn't around. I'd have resisted that lynch for most of Day 7. Can you say why? I don't think it's a total certainty that this role was a "bad" one, but lore would suggest that it is -- and if lore doesn't determine alignment then I have no idea what woul...

Way to fight the good fight Glorfindel.

We're down to Cavil and Doral. I'd say we're in pretty darn good shape.

My suspicion of ObsAll has cooled significantly on account of her early vote for the Glorf. My three top suspects at this time are Rico, Bea, and BR.

Now THAT was a good period of hockey...

Search found 320 matches