The Syndicate

I think the case on Mary is pretty compelling. I'm placing my vote there.

Okay Entjen then who do you think is bad? The only person being discussed that I see right now is Mary, who I will get to in a bit. We need to be talking about more than one person in order to see which way the discussions head toward. As you have said before yourself there is more than one baddie out there.

I have thoughts on other players that I'm trying to get organized, but I'd like to hear your thoughts on other players as well.

Entjen Gillis wrote:

Agnes Sampson wrote:

Anne Whittle wrote:As far as Agnes goes the way she was written back in is quite different than others. I could see a possible recruit sitch.

Nice try Anne to dismiss me completely as soon as I get back. I have not been recruited I am HARRY POTTER do you really think I would join the Dark Lord? I can't tell you exactly why I'm alive but it's because I have an important role to play. I doubt Ill be alive much longer but I will do some damage to the death eaters while Im here.

I am surprised to see Entjen is still alive. She is squeaking through lynches by the hem of her skirt. Someone is trying to save her that much is certain. I am trying to read the posts of the players who voted me and she still stands out the most to me, Ill try to pull some quotes later I have to keep reading now.

No one but me is trying to save me. Is there a reason you are so narrowminded against me? you did this before you died, and it looks like that hasn't changed. I am still a student though so go for it all you want I have nothing to hide. I'm not going to waste all my time going back and forth with you when we have actual baddies to find.

I will try not to be narrowminded about you Entjen and like I said I WILL be looking at other players today for my vote. But since you asked I do believe I have good reason to suspect you.

Here's the quotes for Margarethe and anyone else who might be interested in seeing them.

Entjen Gillis wrote:

Katharina Henot wrote:

Entjen Gillis wrote:

Agnes Sampson wrote:

Entjen Gillis wrote:I voted Agnes. Had to vote now :/ sorry. I'm far from confident about her, but i don't like some of her responses this past day
and better you then me

Your responses leave something to be desired as well. Plus you are not reading when I say I WILL NOT BE LYNCHED:

I guess you thought nothing of lets say Bridget for jumping on your post and voting me? I ill guess not.

I'm not sure why I should trust you when you say you won't be lynched. I don't know your role, and what am I supposed to do anyways... Just let myself get lynched instead? I know I am a civvie, I can't say the same for you.

I plan on looking at everyone who jumped on all sides of this discussion. And the ones who didn't contribute for that matter. There is more than one baddie to find.

call me crazy, but this post feels like "I'll look where ever I have to so that you don't think I'm bad, while I dismiss the people who followed my vote (IE Bridget)

I'm still playing catch up so maybe this is resolved. I'm just posting what I see as I read along.

Nah. she just kind of implied I was only looking at her, which isn't true. just stating the obvious that we have multiple baddies to catch so a narrow minded witchhunt isn't helping anyone

But you WERE only looking at me Entjy. This quote is from you from day 1 and even then you accused me of being narrow-minded against you when I NEVER WAS. I even asked you what you thought about other player's votes for me to see if you had thoughts about them but I don't think you ever answered me. You were not concerned with finding anyone else or talking about anyone but me.

Entjen Gillis wrote:

Bridget Bishop wrote:

Entjen Gillis wrote:

Bridget Bishop wrote:

Entjen Gillis wrote:a bit surprised by the choice there. Ripiywg Agnes

I'm not surprised at all. She can't be lynched. She's not bad.

The end.

There are secrets. Just because she wasn't lynched doesn't mean she is automatically good. There wasn't a high probability of her being lynched again today, I just wasn't expecting her to be nightkilled since there was so much focus on her.

She got killed so she wasn't good? How is that possible?

There are two mafia teams. So while she was killed by one it is still possible she was a member of the other.

Entjen tries to argue that the professors are a mafia team so I could still be bad. Gosh what a thing to say Entjen, why were you still trying to smear my good name even after your team killed me?

Entjen Gillis wrote:The only way you'd know she was good Bridget is if you are a member of the other team

Entjen accuses Bridget of being a professor so she must be bad, because Bridget assumed I was good. Literally throwing blame in every direction but her own and trying to make me seem evil in the process.

Entjen Gillis wrote:I'm voting for krystyna, it seems like its going to come down to me or her. knowing my role, I know that I am not a baddie and can see how krystyna is twisting things.
I'll probably be gone the rest of the day, not that it matters since people's minds seem to be made up

If you had a lynch switch and were really hunting for scum you would not have voted for krystyna using the me or her excuse. Come on Entjen why weren't you trying to find someone else to switch the lynch to if you weren't suspicious of krystyna? Is it because you're mafia and you didn't care which student you switched the lynch to?

Entjen Gillis wrote:

Katharina Henot wrote:what are you thinking entjen?

Well, I legitametly understand some of the suspicion of me. Misguided as it is. But I also think some are hoping on it because its easy.

I'm not too worried though.

Oooo so you even admit to not being worried who would be lynched instead of you

In conclusion I do not think Entjen would have played the way she has so far if she is a student with a lynch switch ability. If that were the case why wouldn't she have been looking for scum instead of using the "better her than me" excuses when two lynches came down to Entjen + me or Entjen + Krystyna. Why wouldn't you have tried harder to find someone you really believed was a death eater, if you had the ability to save yourself and switch the lynch? You were okay with both bandwagons against me and Krystyna. So,



I really do have thoughts on players other than Entjen I swear, I will get to them soon, Im glad we have 24 hours and not a only a few like Margarethe almost had me believing! :P But alas, I am likely not long for this world so I will have to hurry in any case.

Anne Whittle wrote:As far as Agnes goes the way she was written back in is quite different than others. I could see a possible recruit sitch.

Nice try Anne to dismiss me completely as soon as I get back. I have not been recruited I am HARRY POTTER do you really think I would join the Dark Lord? I can't tell you exactly why I'm alive but it's because I have an important role to play. I doubt Ill be alive much longer but I will do some damage to the death eaters while Im here.

I am surprised to see Entjen is still alive. She is squeaking through lynches by the hem of her skirt. Someone is trying to save her that much is certain. I am trying to read the posts of the players who voted me and she still stands out the most to me, Ill try to pull some quotes later I have to keep reading now.

I'm rereading the thread now, guys. There is a lot to catch up on. I have some thoughts, but I need to organize them before I am ready to share. I am seeing a lot of behavior that makes me nervous.

Cool it with the snark everyone. Zombie don't play that. Anyway, we have more important things to discuss. The underworld was most illuminating. I can't be very specific, but let me just say that names can be deceiving.

Hey guys!

Alizon either you did not read the thread or Barbara is lying to you. Your "gist" of it is completely wrong. You really should read back on Day 1 because I was the one who started discussion then got lynched for it even though I told them I would not be lynched. Entjen just added thoughts and a vote to me. She was also unwilling to discuss any of my suspicions I think its because one of them was her.

I was just jumping by to say a bunch of white shit they call snow fell in my dorm room. I am too busy shoveling out to post and respond properly to the votes against me. I hope to get it done before the end of the night.

Entjen Gillis wrote:I voted Agnes. Had to vote now :/ sorry. I'm far from confident about her, but i don't like some of her responses this past day
and better you then me

Your responses leave something to be desired as well. Plus you are not reading when I say I WILL NOT BE LYNCHED:

I guess you thought nothing of lets say Bridget for jumping on your post and voting me? I ill guess not.

Entjen Gillis wrote:

Agnes Sampson wrote:We are wasting time as soon you will see. Should have had some discussion about what I said instead of voting for the only person who tried to discuss supicions.

I will not be lynched so there

Bubble bubble toil and trouble over that.

Voted Entjen. For making a mountain from a molehill.

You are far from the ONLY ONE who tried to discuss suspicions.

And lol I did no such thing.

Orly? Who brought up an on topic suspicion before I did and then I became the suspicion?

Bridget Bishop wrote:I saw Agnes Sampson with the devil!

No u.

Really we should focus on those who added noting but a vote on a very poorly planned bandwagon.

We are wasting time as soon you will see. Should have had some discussion about what I said instead of voting for the only person who tried to discuss supicions.

I will not be lynched so there

Bubble bubble toil and trouble over that.

Voted Entjen. For making a mountain from a molehill.

Entjen Gillis wrote:

Agnes Sampson wrote:

Entjen Gillis wrote:Yea, I really don't see how I was "awfully quick to find a scapegoat". A scapegoat for what exactly? All I was saying, and my point still stands, is that I hate to see someone lynched Day 1 for starting the discussion.

I have one vote for:

Margaret Pearson wrote:Voted for *Entjen* for deviously attempting to lure us into lynching the innocent Agnes.

I didn't "attempt to lure" anyone. Quite the opposite actually. I don't know Agnes is innocent, and I don't know Margaret is trustworthy for that matter either. I can only speak for myself.

But in your first post you ride the fence so to speak saying it could be good or bad then in your very next post you say it is lynch worthy.

No, I do not say it is lynch worthy. I said I have seen people lynched for less. What question did I not answer? When someone asked me to name 5 people? Oh, sorrry I didnt want to answer a question that would deliberately reveal my identity such as listing games I have played in which people have been lynched day 1 for a shitty reason.

I am still and will be on the fence until I hear what her pings were.

Well since you quoted me I wrongly assumed you read my posts t see what my initial ping was. Or did you forget who was suspicious to you (aka me) lol

Entjen Gillis wrote:Yea, I really don't see how I was "awfully quick to find a scapegoat". A scapegoat for what exactly? All I was saying, and my point still stands, is that I hate to see someone lynched Day 1 for starting the discussion.

I have one vote for:

Margaret Pearson wrote:Voted for *Entjen* for deviously attempting to lure us into lynching the innocent Agnes.

I didn't "attempt to lure" anyone. Quite the opposite actually. I don't know Agnes is innocent, and I don't know Margaret is trustworthy for that matter either. I can only speak for myself.

But in your first post you ride the fence so to speak saying it could be good or bad then in your very next post you say it is lynch worthy.

Sorry I got caught up trying to calm Myrtle down so I could shower without her constant moaning not gonna happen lol

Nice to see some actual discussion. My initial arched brow was small but glad it led some to post.

I did not like Anne Redfern's list of her take on the Day 0 poll options. I felt she was trying to dismiss some straight out and make you feel bad if you thought differently. I felt she subtley pushed Creatures and poss. Divination. Like I said a small arch of the brow. It makes me wonder if she won anything from the poll.

Best thing from this that we learned:

Jane jumps immediately to my post saying there has been no on topic posts which clearly is not true. Tries to discount me before I have a chance to elaborate.

Then who comes along next and jumps on Jane saying they agree?
Barbara.
and Entjen.

Entjen started by giving me the botd but also saying it could be a baddie thing. Then in her very next post she says to Barbara who had said no one has mentioned lynching me that it was worth lynching me because people have been lynched for less. She never answered Malins post. .

Now Rebecca has voted for me because she thinks I havent caught up. What a load of crapadoodle!

Great post Prof Lizzy!

Although it is early there are a few posts that caused my eyebrow to arch but I want to see how this day plays out.

Anna Koldings wrote:

Mary Eastey wrote:I would pick Divination, but Prof. Trelawney is a ditzy idiot.

Sounds like someone is afraid of getting The Grim in her tea cup.

Mary does have a little Grim on her face lol

I don`t want Prof Trelawney either if she gets a vision it is very accurate. :o

Anne Redferne wrote:Pfffffffft... Neerrrrdddddddd.

I much prefer to live in the moment. *wizard shades*

Oooo thanks I am quite proud of my nerdiness and geekawesomeness. So sweet of you to say!

Anne Redferne wrote:Hmmm let's see.

Study of Ancient Runes: Theoretical subject of runic scriptures, no real everyday practical usage.
Astronomy: This is stars and shit... is this even magic?
History of Magic: Boooooooooring.
Care of Magical Creatures: Well... I have always been quite partial to the magical creatures.
Divination: Learning how to predict the future, I can see how this could be useful.
Arithmancy: Studying the magical properties. No thanks. Sounds boring as hell. But then again could this be useful too?

You are boooooooooring.

I voted History of Magic - knowing how the past happened has always proved quite helpful in my life. Too bad there are no healing courses, could have been an easy A for me. :P