The Syndicate

Paul Stevens

Know what is going on Dom why did you vote for yourself? I briefly thought about quitting because someone in their real account told me to shut up after I voiced my opinion on players lynching boo. I wasn't around for the whole fiasco, but to me the actions were completely unnecessary and kind of h...

Paul Stevens

Cookie 2 wrote:One thing I can say with 100% certainty; Dom is most definitely not inhabiting his own sock, becasue Dom 2 is acting exactly like the anti-Dom lol.

Would you like a rainbow list next?

Paul Stevens

Lipsticklacey 2 wrote:Except for the part where it is a game that is played for fun, not a job.

Touche

Paul Stevens

Do you still think a baddie role that can't be lynched is ludicrous? One that can't be lynched? Yes. As we've seen, Synonym was not a baddie and Long Con only had one chance to switch it. Do you still think it's viable? I think it was a valid possiblity at the time I said it. the fact that you blew...

Paul Stevens

Whether boo flips good or bad, it is an easy lynch. Anyone who thinks otherwise needs to reevaluate. The votes for him have been because he made "dumb" comments (some of which none of us have even seen). This does not correlate to alignment in the slightest. I didn't say in my post that i...

Paul Stevens

Do you still think a baddie role that can't be lynched is ludicrous? One that can't be lynched? Yes. As we've seen, Synonym was not a baddie and Long Con only had one chance to switch it. Do you still think it's viable? I think it was a valid possiblity at the time I said it. the fact that you blew...

Paul Stevens

Whether boo flips good or bad, it is an easy lynch. Anyone who thinks otherwise needs to reevaluate.

The votes for him have been because he made "dumb" comments (some of which none of us have even seen). This does not correlate to alignment in the slightest.

Paul Stevens

Cookie 2 wrote:Do you still think a baddie role that can't be lynched is ludicrous?

One that can't be lynched? Yes.

As we've seen, Synonym was not a baddie and Long Con only had one chance to switch it. Do you still think it's viable?

Paul Stevens

Dom just voted Eloh, so if I'm right about him, then Eloh is town. About Cookie, I find the zany reasons for voting there disquieting. Look: Please consider that Dom's "ISO" of her was extra conscious of how BR would flip. He didn't even vote Cookie. Eloh was not town. But I don't think t...

Paul Stevens

I used to be a moderator, but I was fired.

Paul Stevens

What?

Paul Stevens

I voted Felt because I won, and Mongoose needs to host a future rendition.

Paul Stevens

I hope you enjoyed your intermission. Our next act is about to begin: "The reign of Scum is o'er"

Have you heard the news? The dogs are dead.

Paul Stevens

Baa Ram Ewe

Paul Stevens

Jesus f'ing christ everyone. I leave for a day, and I'm suddenly getting votes?

I'm still busy, but will be back in soon. Voting Elohcin.

Paul Stevens

HOSTS how are seemers designed? Do they get assigned different random roles upon flip? They pick their own Boom. So much for "astounding coincidence", hmm? Treat me and "BR" on the same page. One of us chose the tracker as a fake flip. Judge which one, that's all I'm asking. Som...

Paul Stevens

EBWOP: Did I say Golden? I meant juliets/BR 2.

Paul Stevens

HOSTS how are seemers designed? Do they get assigned different random roles upon flip? They pick their own Boom. So much for "astounding coincidence", hmm? Treat me and "BR" on the same page. One of us chose the tracker as a fake flip. Judge which one, that's all I'm asking. Som...

Paul Stevens

Welcome back Gamer Guy that is not the real gamer guy but actually a doctor.

Paul Stevens

Whether or not Golden voted Bass on purpose, I think there is other evidence to look at that is less touch-and-go.

Paul Stevens

The argument that Golden didn't lynch Black Rock and accidentally voted Bass makes little sense. We didn't get a list of which mafia was on her lynch or anything like that. This argument seems to be reaching especially since Golden said he would vote for her. I'm weighing why if mafia he would purp...

Paul Stevens

Also, this post from Golden which was a reaction to BR's death/flip. Unless there is more than one tracker, he couldn't be the real one. A seemer faking as tracker may have forgotten the role they were faking. I'll give this some thought tonight. what the what RIP though, "BR"/jules. I tec...

Paul Stevens

Welcome back and congrats on your rezz Golden 2, assuming of course that you are good. I'll be gone to see about the horses part of the day tomorrow but will be back in plenty of time for discussion. What do you mean "assuming of course that you are good" he is writeup mod-confirmed as to...

Paul Stevens

I am a little behind on current posts, but I did just see this for the first time. boo 2 boo's first suspicion. Boo calls out Gamer Guy's post suggesting what roles are around. The problem that I have with this suspicion is that it is also a way to stifle discussion. It is an original suspicion, bu...

Paul Stevens

Well, RIP Smaug/juliets.

Paul Stevens

Black Rock 2 wrote:Look carefully at my posts - not the ISOs - there is one in particular I want you to be sure and see.

Why didn't you just stop playing for three days and get modkilled so we can use precious lynches on baddicons?

Paul Stevens

Golden 2 wrote:HOSTS: Can I write my vote for "BR" in the thread and have it acknowledged as such or did I dun goofed for good?

(If the former: *voting BR*)

You probably dun goofed for good.

I'd rather lynch Elohcin than Synonym today. I'm putting my vote there.

Paul Stevens

Hey all, help me with some catching up. the case against Syn is that we don't know how many baddie teams there are, and his actions, while definitely anti-LC2, sort of read as bad and/or shifty, thus the thinking is that he is either on a second baddie team, or was going after his own teamie? The c...

Paul Stevens

Jesus Christ all you "Syn" voters. :suspish: Why do you find the case for him being civilian so compelling? Do you think the baddie teams would have a role with a lynch pardon, and a role with a lynch switch? If there are two teams, it would be a form of symmetry, which I could see. If th...

Paul Stevens

Ricochet 2 wrote:
Golden 2 wrote:Jesus Christ all you "Syn" voters.
Why do you find the case for him being civilian so compelling?

Do you think the baddie teams would have a role with a lynch pardon, and a role with a lynch switch?

Paul Stevens

Assuming he is Cobalt, why is he bad? I'm not sure whether or not linking to past mafia chat is allowed here, but this is something Cobalt does when he is bad. I can copy and paste from that chat, but I don't want to post against the rules. Also, this statement ignores a little bit of truth. Cobalt...

Paul Stevens

I suspect boo the most, but I doubt a vote there would make any difference. Of the three with multiple votes, I still suspect synonym and not either of the other two. So I'm voting synonym. Bummer. I might have followed your vote on that. I still might actually. I have a slight baddie read on him, ...

Paul Stevens

I wish people would stop asking to be lynched. It's one thing if you've got 5 votes on your already, but another thing entirely if one or two people suspect you a little bit. Defend yourself away, but scumhunting will contribute more to the civvie cause than your civilian lynch (if you're a civilian).

Paul Stevens

BR2 I feel like you're dwelling on when you subbed in too much. It feels like you're trying to use that as an excuse for behavior that seems scummy. If you really thought you hadn't done anything "baddie-like" I don't think you would be so defensive of your actions using your sub in as a ...

Paul Stevens

I am considering an Elochin 2 vote but there are a couple of people I want to look into. One is Cookie 2: Cookie 2 Posts 1,2,3: Off topic posts about yay game, cookies, and sock accounts. Post 4: Not sure that people having info on the polls makes a difference. Post 5: Asks how long the hosts will ...

Paul Stevens

Epignosis 2 Votes Day 1 - missed Day 2 - missed Day 3 - Long Con [/color] His vote record doesn't say much. He did break a 4-4 tie between Long Con and Synonym on Day 3, but nothing aside from that. Was this guy replaced Night 2 or something? That was his first post. So Night 2, comes in and commen...

Paul Stevens

On an unrelated note, the four players to die so far this game are both renditions of Gamerguy and both renditions of Long Con.

Paul Stevens

Paul Stevens

Why Timmer? I find Elohcin 2 suspicious and could vote for them day 1, however, i'm also curios about MetalMarsh 2 posts about Synonym. I see that you missed the Day 1 vote, but I don't think voting for her on Day 1 now will help. http://www.progarchives.com/forum/smileys/smiley24.gif I like alcoho...

Paul Stevens

Sig 2 Votes Day 1 - Long Con Day 2 - missed Day 3 - Long Con [/color] Here is Sig's first on-topic post. Now I think I see what Cookie kept pushing the suspicion onto him. Sig says he will eye anyone who pushes the Synonym thing as a slip. On the other hand, Sig never really pursued anyone, includi...

Paul Stevens

Players I still need to ISO.

Black Rock 2
Epignosis 2
Lipsticklacey 2
Llama 2
Metalmarsh 2
Reywas 2
Ricochet 2
Scotty 2
Sig 2
SVS 2
Synonym 2
Timmer 2
Turnip Head 2

I've taken Golden off the list because he's already flipped town.

Paul Stevens

Epignosis 2 wrote:Why Timmer?

I find Elohcin 2 suspicious and could vote for them day 1, however, i'm also curios about MetalMarsh 2 posts about Synonym.

I see that you missed the Day 1 vote, but I don't think voting for her on Day 1 now will help.

Paul Stevens

I know I have been flogging the "civ/civ" horse pretty hard, but even i am having a hard time thinking either of you are civ at this point, LC & Syn. Especially you, Syn, since you & Sig both seem to know something about the Day One lynch that the rest of us don't. This looks like...

Paul Stevens

I would be shocked if Cookie 2 flipped bad. Why is that? The thing with Elohcin 2 that's interesting to me is that on Day 2 when the lynch result was in question she says the reasons people were suspecting LC 2 were bad reasons. Her Day 3 post about LC2 is all hindsight. She sees LC2 has 10 votes a...

Paul Stevens

I agree with the Elo2 suspicion. There was still time for someone else to be lynched on Day 2 when she voted for MM2 (who to be fair is also suspicious to me), and the baddies could have wanted to try to make that happen before deciding to use the switch ability. I also thought TGG2 picked up on so...

Paul Stevens

I would be shocked if Cookie 2 flipped bad. Why is that? The thing with Elohcin 2 that's interesting to me is that on Day 2 when the lynch result was in question she says the reasons people were suspecting LC 2 were bad reasons. Her Day 3 post about LC2 is all hindsight. She sees LC2 has 10 votes a...

Paul Stevens

Elochin: First couple of posts were joking in sock mode. Third post says she doesn't want to vote for LC or Synonym. Then quotes Cookie on Cookie's sig 2 suspicion, but goes on to say she won't vote for sig 2 either but will vote for MM for a non-existent reason for voting Synonym. I'll have to go ...

Paul Stevens

Cookie Votes Day 1 - Sig 2 Day 2 - Sig 2 Day 3 - Sig 2 [/color] Looking at just her votes, Cookie looks consistent, but also may be a victim of tunnel vision, forced or otherwise. Long Con has taken tons of votes each day, and was finally lynched Day 3. Yet Cookie has voted Sig each of these days. ...

Paul Stevens

Dom wrote:
S~V~S wrote:Quiet living people make me sad
^^^

^^^

Paul Stevens

I'm doing some ISO's rey, but I'll look into Elohcin next. I'm on Cookie now.

Search found 618 matches