The Syndicate

Snapshot

In what is becoming a pattern, Deborah has a lot to say about Pilate and a lot less to say about Rahab, and it is all essentially before the point at which we know Judas is bad anyway... here is the Pilate stuff. I'm not liking the case against Rachel. Yes, her opinion of List Man seems a bit wishy ...

Snapshot

Ruth expressed some suspicion of Pilate in her first life. My opinion of Balaam is colored at this minute by that question. I missed it, shoot me. Jeez. If Job flips civ, I can see that being possible. He did get my attention earlier with this: Sorry Mary. I did not want to force a tie and have a no...

Snapshot

Uzz had nothing to say about Rahab, but did have this exchange with Pilate (before we got to day 9, of course). Found this during my re-read: I admit I may have been somewjat ambiguous on purpous. I'm just zany and fun like that! The above is the root meaning though, is it not? So are you going to s...

Snapshot

Bathsheba wrote:Lot do you remember anyone building cases on either Pilate or Rahab?

Not off the top of my head. I do remember some stuff about Pilate being a teammate of Uzziah back around day 7 or 8, which I want to track down.

Snapshot

I do think one thing it's worth doing and I probably will try to if I get time is rereading all the known heathen and seeing what their attitudes towards Rahab and Pilate were and if those attitudes ever changed.

Snapshot

I also think it looks good for Pilate that Esther voted for him and it looked like Rahab was wound up to vote for him but voted Esther in the end because she was gone anyway and he thought it might help his cred. (that last part was conjecture taken from the facts) Yeah, I agree that looks good, bu...

Snapshot

Also, I'm not reading anything into the Samuel kill. Rahab would kill him because his mind seemed made up. Pilate would kill him to make it look like Rahab.

Snapshot

Bathsheba, I agree. If you've suckered me then well played, but I'm pretty confident in my reasoning for why you can't be Judas. We can share the workload on this, vote together (since I don't have to vote Lazarus!!! YAY!) and just hope we figure it out.

Snapshot

I've removed day 1 for each (no conversion before then), and put the rest into green for 'could still be civ' and red for 'must be heathen'. Rahab Day 2 - Vote 6 on Cain, Uzz had 3 (could work as civ or heathen BUT interesting flip from the day before) Day 3 - Vote 4 on Uzz, MM had 5 (looks civ) Day...

Snapshot

Here is what I have so far. Judas was probably a civilian to begin with, and became a heathen either a) by being activated by another disciple or b) by being found by the heathen. Either way, I assume that his conversion happened during the night and was only notified at dawn. Judas killed Balaam on...

Snapshot

Thank you Judas, whoever you are. I'm grateful for the opportunity to be involved in this day, no matter how it should play out.

Snapshot

This is it - the final technicolour list. The one that hopefully helps point to our Judas. I'm sure none of you will be disappointed that this is the last of them. DAY 1 RESULTS: 1. SAMUEL (Paul) <---voter = NK'ed by heathens 2. SAMUEL (Samson) <---voter = civvie 3. LOT (Gideon) <---voter = NK'ed by...

Snapshot

I'm not sure how much more participation I'll get done before the NK, but I'm pretty sure that should I be around tomorrow my vote is about who is more persuasive out of Rahab and Pilate. I hope I'm still around, because I've really loved playing this game and would love to see it through to the end.

Snapshot

Also in favour of Bathsheba - there was an empty sock at times when Judas was making kills. I am absolutely positive Bathsheba is not Judas.

Snapshot

Why Lot is not Judas: Did I not just fight hard for the successful lynches of Deborah and Esther? Why Bathsheba is not Judas: Bathsheba's vote record since she was replaced has been essentially impeccable. Why Samuel is not Judas: Samuel was the decision point in that vote. If Samuel voted Pilate, R...

Snapshot

I, for one, am open to hearing what Rahab has to say. She would be the easy vote tomorrow, but it doesn't necessarily make her the correct one. Let's be careful.

Snapshot

Also, well played Esther. You really did have my trust for a very long length of time, but a read back last night made you look very bad. I'm glad I did it. So now we just need to find our Judas. I really think we need to make sure we look at everyone carefully. I'm going to put as much legwork as I...

Snapshot

Looks like Jacob was Joshua.

Snapshot

It does look that way. But I think we are better off keeping an open mind for now.

Snapshot

I hope it's right too.

I wish other more vocal people like Absalom and Stephen were here as it would give me more confidence. I don't much like being responsible for what I think is the critical lynch. I really hope you are heathen, Esther.

Snapshot

Looks like you could safely vote now, laz, if you wanted to avoid any potential penalty. I will too if you do. We can save the forgetfulness for the next day if you like.

Snapshot

I think I have an idea what's up with Lot. :ponder: We talked a while ago about Job being forced to go at Uzziah (and maybe Uzziah to go at Job, as well??) rather than having tunnel vision - I think Jonah acknowledged the possibility and then so did I - and that it might be a Horseman's doing (War?...

Snapshot

I'm glad you are defending yourself! I really am.

I just think Pilate was the wrong choice to go after. Rahab went after Pilate too. For me, the thing about Pilate is this: I can't see his teammate. It doesn't make sense that he has one, to me.

Snapshot

I'm not going to be convinced to vote for you OR Pilate. The only person you could convince me to vote for is Lazarus. But I doubt you could convince me of that, either.

Snapshot

As I said to Bathsheba - everyone alive I trusted. I trusted you I trusted Rahab I trusted Pilate I trusted Samuel I was wrong about someone. Probably two someones. That's why I needed to revisit voting records and thread reads. By the way, I did that for everyone who I did the voting record of, I j...

Snapshot

OK, well Esther you scramble away. If you are civ, I've said sorry, I did my best to solve it, I don't need to 'lay it out on you like a kindergarterner' - despite your protests my posts last night were entirely clear. I understand you are doing what you have to do, but I don't believe you. It's Sam...

Snapshot

And trust me, if I were bad, Lazarus would have died at some point in the last 8 days or so. This is also why I believe Lazarus is good. Having both of us alive and unable to vote meaningfully is helping the baddies, not hindering them. But besides that, as I've said many times, it is patently obvio...

Snapshot

And for goodness sake Esther - I went off and did my research in the thread. What has Esther said, how can it be perceived. Your case against me is 'I'm really worried lot is bad because he changed his mind in a 'contradictory set of posts' which by the way was me analysing one person at a time, tal...

Snapshot

Lot wrote:But overall, I suggest that out best option would be to lynch Esther today, and then if we get that one correct we can regroup for tomorrow. Thoughts? Agree? Disagree?

After the whole analysis, this is what I said.

How can you say I didn't reach a conclusion?

Snapshot

Laz, why do you trust me more than anyone else? I'll vote Esther. I was wondering that too, and I hope he is right. Sounds like Esther is the way it's going. I'm really sorry if I did all that analysis and came to the wrong conclusion, guys. Although honestly Esther's reactions today don't make me ...

Snapshot

@esther - that's funny... bathsheba and samuel seemed to find my analysis meaningful.

Snapshot

I really hope that we have it, Bathsheba! Hopefully, we have figured it out before it is too late, and I'm sure Pilate and you would vote Esther if Samuel does. But... I just hope the three of you really are the other ones of God's chosen

I'm nervous now!

Snapshot

So Esther and Rahab are going to be voting Pilate... So here we stand... what call do we make. I cannot promise I am right, I have no info. But I feel like Pilate's behaviour in recent times has looked quite civ to me (including his going after me). I certainly trust Bathsheba. I hope I'm not mispla...

Snapshot

Nice ass, balaam!

Snapshot

Also, Balaam came to me in a dream, and lo unto me he said: ESTHER: I would watch her, frankly. She missed the first two votes, which are oh so important when trying to look back at the votes. My notes show that Day 3 she actually defended Ruth from Belshazzar- go find that! Day 5 she places a prett...

Snapshot

All up, where I am at is this, I trust: Lot, Lazarus, Samuel, Bathsheba. I really want all four of us to discuss who we think the town should vote for. Pilate and Rahab - I would think that each of you would also look favourably on what I'm about to say if you are town. I think the most likely teams...

Snapshot

Pilate Day 1 - Vote 1 on uzz, noone else had more than 2 (this vote looks good) Day 2 - missed vote Day 3 - missed vote Day 4 - Vote 1 on Rachel (first vote all up, not meaningful) Day 5 - Vote 1 for Uzz, first vote all up. Uzz lynched. (Good for Pilate, but not amazingly good because his vote timi...

Snapshot

Bathsheba Day 1 - missed vote Day 2 - vote 8 on Cain, lynch realistically already over (doesn't help either way) Day 3 - missed vote Day 4 - missed vote Day 5 - missed vote Day 6 - vote 9 on Ruth, lynch realistically already over (doesn't help either way) Day 7 - missed vote Day 8 - missed vote Day...

Snapshot

Esther Day 1 - missed vote Day 2 - missed vote Day 3 - vote 4 on Job, MM at 5, Uzz at 3. (Could be creating distance for Uzz as second option, but overall this vote looks ok) Day 4 - vote 7 on Job, Balaam at 4 (not much to say on this either way, but she didn't avoid looking bad for being on a civ ...

Snapshot

Rahab Day 1 - vote 3 on Uzz, after Samson had 7 (distancing) Day 2 - Vote 6 on Cain, Uzz had 3 (increasing safety margin) Day 3 - Vote 4 on Uzz, MM had 5 (less likely - close result to tighten the gap BUT Ruth voted right afterwards to increase gap again) Day 4 - Vote 2 on Lazarus (no accountabilit...

Snapshot

That didn't include Jacob and Stephen being good, I could only do so much this late.

Snapshot

DAY 1 RESULTS: 1. SAMUEL (Paul) <---voter = NK'ed by heathens 2. SAMUEL (Samson) <---voter = civvie 3. LOT (Gideon) <---voter = NK'ed by heathens 4. UZZIAH (Pilate) 5. REBECCA (Rachel) <---voter = NK'ed by heathens 6. PAUL (Martha) <---voter = NK'ed by heathens 7. BARNABAS (Stephen) 8. UZZIAH (Job)...

Snapshot

Lot, could you tell me why you have me so high on your suspicion list? I know you are going to look at the votes and I think you'll find mine to reflect my civvie status but I'd like to know what I've done or said that puts me high on your list. Every single person left in the game is a person I've...

Snapshot

I'll post some technicolour lists when we get a moment. We are in real trouble. Seven left, and without my vote and Lazarus vote. That means we are effectively three on two. And that's assuming both Lazarus and I accidentally forget to vote today. If we remember to vote, it's game over, because the ...

Snapshot

So, Lot has no voting record to analyze. People aren't vouching for him because of a Horseman curse. Has he led the lynch on a lot of baddies? Pilate I'd ask you, respectfully, that before you continue to go on suspecting me you actually read the thread. The reason people are vouching for me is mos...

Snapshot

If it's 24 thats fine, but I prefer a sedate 48.

Snapshot

I'm not vouching for stephen out of any knowledge. Just look at his vote record.

Snapshot

This has been very easy, lets hope that isn't a bad sign.

At this point, though, if Rebecca is bad I guess what other choice does Rebecca's last remaining teammate have but to conform with the crowd.

Snapshot

I'm thinking, as a guess, that Belshazzar won the bible trivia (and so Esther was removed from the poll) and so Belshazzar got to remove a name from the poll and chose Malchus. An interesting choice. I wonder if he wants to wifom us into thinking Malchus could be bad. But he could have messed with u...

Snapshot

Thanks, Lot. I would agree with you that Rahab is the #2 after Rebecca, but what do you make of Pilate spearheading the move against you this past lynch? That's what put him above Rahab for me. I still think there is a chance that Pilate just isn't reading the thread. He dropped back into reading i...

Search found 861 matches