The Syndicate

Snapshot

Also, I'd like to say that Balaam AND his ass were trying to get Deborah out for days, so well done for calling it. I should have listened.

Snapshot

Noted, Lot. Why do you think Rahab is more likely to be a wolf than Pilate? I agree on starting off with Rebecca. I cannot fathom her behavior has a town mindset at this point. She has had my trust and has indicated she believes I'm civ. She could hardly vote for me. She could, however, leave the d...

Snapshot

I'm hitching myself to team Jephthah. It's the least I could do. Lord, I send out a prayer of thanks for NOT lynching me. What say you now, Pilate? Stephen, I think your list of best bets is petty good although I think I'd flip around Rahab and Pilate. I'd definitely start off with Rebecca. Of cours...

Snapshot

DAY 1 RESULTS: 1. SAMUEL (Paul) <---voter = NK'ed by heathens 2. SAMUEL (Samson) <---voter = civvie 3. LOT (Gideon) <---voter = NK'ed by heathens 4. UZZIAH (Pilate) 5. REBECCA (Rachel) <---voter = NK'ed by heathens 6. PAUL (Martha) <---voter = NK'ed by heathens 7. BARNABAS (Stephen) 8. UZZIAH (Job)...

Snapshot

Actually, I think you could consider subbing Rahab in for Pilate, possibly. Some combination of those four.

And Lazarus vote s only worth one, so I'm still saveable if anyone wants to believe in me.

Snapshot

I am absolutely thoroughly unsurprised that Rebecca turned up to vote for me. If I'm lynched, take a good long look at Deborah, Rebecca and Pilate guys. We need to catch three more, but they are running out of places to hide. A lynch on me, if successful, is something that I think is quite foolish a...

Snapshot

Also, if one of the selling points against Deborah is her "trust" in Pilate, then why not go straight for the source? Either one could go but I feel worse about Pilate, especially the vibes in this last cycle. I could have gotten behind either one too, but Stephen's vote for Deborah yeste...

Snapshot

Technicolour lists updated, not really sure we can call Jonah a civvie, so... I guess best case scenario would be he is a heathen who is modkilled, but that doesn't seem likely. I feel like the heathen are beginning to take control of this game, we need to fight back by getting a couple. I also thin...

Snapshot

I literally can't believe people are actually considering I could be bad. My role ought to be incredibly obvious by this point. Absolutely not surprised Absalom is dead. Deborah is the way I would choose to vote if I could. Really, she voted Isaac because she 'trusts pilate'? I'm absolutely certain ...

Snapshot

Voting LOT Agreed. Sorry Isaac. So, now that we know Isaac is good, you are going to lynch the person who you claimed was HIS baddie teammate... Also the person doing the examining of potential vote trains to try to save Ruth and Mordecai while lynching Isaac... What sense do you even think this ma...

Snapshot

I think Balaam is being completely off topic and he is just having fun, I don't think we should read anything in to it. Also, there were some scummy votes for Isaac for sure. If I, Mr Isaac tunnel vision, could tell he was civ after the last lynch, I'm not buying a lot of the arguments for voting fo...

Snapshot

DAY 1 RESULTS: 1. SAMUEL (Paul) <---voter = NK'ed by heathens 2. SAMUEL (Samson) <---voter = civvie 3. LOT (Gideon) <---voter = NK'ed by heathens 4. UZZIAH (Pilate) 5. REBECCA (Rachel) <---voter = NK'ed by heathens 6. PAUL (Martha) <---voter = NK'ed by heathens 7. BARNABAS (Stephen) 8. UZZIAH (Job)...

Snapshot

Yeah, that's what I was getting at BUT that is two layers of gut read laid on top of one another - a gut feel about who the sock is, and a gut feel about their civ game. It's definitely not better than real evidence.

And her vote record is pretty bad looking.

Snapshot

Well, put it this way. Ruth voted for Isaac 4th yesterday, putting him in a position where there was a genuine chance he would be lynched instead of her. Why would the heathen team risk lynching someone no-one knows is heathen instead of someone we already know is? Samuel's view on Isaac persuades ...

Snapshot

This vote is pretty exciting!

Snapshot

Well, put it this way. Ruth voted for Isaac 4th yesterday, putting him in a position where there was a genuine chance he would be lynched instead of her. Why would the heathen team risk lynching someone no-one knows is heathen instead of someone we already know is? Samuel's view on Isaac persuades m...

Snapshot

I haven't read back on Rahab today. I did not so long ago and came back with a) civ vibes and b) a potential RL identity for the sock whose civ game would mesh with that. But the voting record is definitely poor. I'm surprised the voting record has you definitely convinced not to vote the other thre...

Snapshot

The reason I suspect Isaac is because when it ended in a tie between Mordecai and Isaac, Mordecai threw his vote off instead of using it to save himself. This makes no sense to me if Isaac is civ. It only makes sense if Mordecai and Isaac are on a team. This is actually a pretty good argument... In...

Snapshot

It's not hard to do a readback of Rebecca. She had only 28 posts. She hasn't spoken for four 'days' - yet votes have still occurred... where are you Rebecca? Why spaketh thee not a lot? Rebecca started a bit louder. A full 8 of her posts are on the first day. Almost everything she posts for days and...

Snapshot

For Esther's sake - it is clear there have been substitutions in this game and the host has never mentioned them. Isaac and Stephen were two that were clear before Bathsheba.

I don't blame Epi for wanting to have a full house of socks for endgame. Still wondering what to do about Malchus.

Snapshot

And finally Samuel Samuel Day 1 - Vote 7 on Samson, 5 on cain, 3 on uzz (bandwagon vote) Day 2 - missed vote Day 3 - missed vote Day 4 - Vote 5 on Job, Balaam on 3 (just about determined which civ would be lynched... not exactly heathen but not necessarily not either) Day 5 - Vote 3 on Jephthah, Uzz...

Snapshot

I don't think Deborah's Day 1 vote is un-Heathen like. It was early and very few votes had come in. A teammate could safely have voted as she did, knowing there were other teammates ready for a save if necessary. I also think the Day 4 and 5 votes are incriminating. It would have looked bad for her...

Snapshot

Short break - back for Samuel later. So far, based solely on voting orders, I'd rate from most to least suspicious

Rebecca
Rahab
Deborah

Snapshot

Deborah Day 1 - Vote 1 for Cain, 2 on Samson, 2 on Uzz (this vote doesn't look too bad in isolation, less likely for heathen) Day 2 - Vote 4 for Cain, Uzz on 1 (solidifies Cain's lead over Uzz) Day 3 - Vote 5 for MM, 3 on Uzz (pretty suspect, big role in saving Uzz) Day 4 - self vote (no accountabi...

Snapshot

Stephen, I really wish you would contribute more than these drop ins. You could be so helpful, you've had reasonably good instincts.

Snapshot

I'm just working on Deborah, but I've noticed in these rainbow lists some clear patterns emerging with Mordecai, Uzziah, Ruth AND some of those people I'm analysing, and those patterns are that they are frequently the first vote on people (whether or not those people end up with lots of votes) and a...

Snapshot

Rebecca Day 1 - Vote 1 on Jephthah, Samson on 4 (staying out of civ lynch) Day 2 - Vote 1 on Jephthah, Cain on 7 (staying out of civ lynch again, consistency) Day 3 - Vote 1 on Mary Magdelene, Uzz on 3, Job on 2 (this one is interesting - worth a look to see if Rebecca was a key thread reason for M...

Snapshot

Samuel wrote:I have my reasons for mentioning him that week become clear once you lynch me.

Yeah, I really don't buy this.

Snapshot

Votes of each player - noting in each case whether or such a vote would be normal if bad - and if so why. Doing each one at a time. Rahab Day 1 - vote 3 on Uzz, after Samson had 7 (distancing) Day 2 - Vote 6 on Cain, Uzz had 3 (increasing safety margin) Day 3 - Vote 4 on Uzz, MM had 5 (less likely -...

Snapshot

Indeed. And my answer to the second is - let's see what he has to say first, and I still want to do the analysis of all Isaac voters before I think we should commit to any one specific direction . No. You all have already decided to lynch me so do it. I'm really over this kind of attitude. It's exa...

Snapshot

Because if his vote increases, then why would he skip voting?. Two potential explanations for Lazarus skipping voting - one good, one bad. 1) If he is good, skipping voting means he won't vote me and thus won't lynch me (this also has the side effect that I don't try all out to lynch him) - good fo...

Snapshot

Absalom wrote:Or civ-unfriendly death conditions.

The question is, do we believe him?

Indeed.

And my answer to the second is - let's see what he has to say first, and I still want to do the analysis of all Isaac voters before I think we should commit to any one specific direction.

Snapshot

It was surely curious wording too, don't you think Absalom? Let me be clear. Lynching me will not get the result you all are hoping for unless you are not a civ. No one good will like the end result . You can present voting records in whatever way you want. Civs can have bad voting records. I am not...

Snapshot

Actually, I didn't notice before, but Samuel's voting record is downright terrible, but without the redeeming qualities of Deborah's. I'd vote for him today over her. I agree that Samuel looks the worst of them, and as of right now he is my preferred option. I want to go back and do a bit of a read...

Snapshot

So, Lazarus is no threat to me today if he is the zealot. It merely means my vote continues to be wasted.

I shall vote Lazarus, because he probably deserves it.

And I'll try to do a vote analysis of those who voted Isaac when I get a moment, to see if we can see some as more scummy than others.

Snapshot

Also, it's possible Lazarus is tactically not voting some days, such as yesterday. The Zealot's role says: "for each Day in a row that he votes the same person, his vote increases by one." What's unclear to me is - epi, you could help her - If the zealot takes a day off from voting the sam...

Snapshot

DAY 1 RESULTS: 1. SAMUEL (Paul) <---voter = NK'ed by heathens 2. SAMUEL (Samson) <---voter = civvie 3. LOT (Gideon) <---voter = NK'ed by heathens 4. UZZIAH (Pilate) 5. REBECCA (Rachel) <---voter = NK'ed by heathens 6. PAUL (Martha) <---voter = NK'ed by heathens 7. BARNABAS (Stephen) 8. UZZIAH (Job)...

Snapshot

I am happy now. Who are we lynching today? Lazarus? Isaac? I'll be honest, the late train on Isaac (looking at you, Spacedaisy) makes me not want to vote for him very much. It looks like Lazarus never showed yesterday, so I'm fairly comfortable leaving him at least another day. I agree with you tha...

Snapshot

Not to mention Deborah!

Snapshot

Wow. That was very interesting indeed. As much as I have been thinking Isaac is bad - Rebecca, Ruth, Samuel... a who's who of people without the best voting records... that looked an awful lot like a save could have gone in. And this late in the game, they might be feeling like a single lynch could ...

Snapshot

Absalom, all I ask is that whatever comes, you vote Lazarus tomorrow (even if Ruth survives today - I hope she does not if she is in fact the personw ith the most votes). For me, it's a win/win. Either he is bad, or he is going to lynch me. Plus it will free up my vote to be useful. When I have my v...

Snapshot

Metalmarsh89 wrote:Would you kindly eat my shorts.

Yes, but only if they are behind a spoiler tag.

Snapshot

Putting important information behind spoiler tags is not on my agenda, no. Think it's something the heathen would like me to do, which might be why you didn't put your sock on.

If I'm doing long quotes to respond to them, that's one thing. Vote analysis, I'm not going to hide.

Snapshot

Oops, quote fail. I'm just gonna quote Balaam's most recent one each time and add in the new info. Also, I feel a little better about a Ruth vote after her last post. Apparently she knows death's win condition? And it makes a lot of logical sense. Unfortunately for Ruth, it also justifies rezzing he...

Snapshot

I may as well take over from Balaam on the technicolour list front, so here is where we are at: DAY 1 RESULTS: 1. SAMUEL (Paul) <---voter = NK'ed by heathens 2. SAMUEL (Samson) <---voter = civvie 3. LOT (Gideon) <---voter = NK'ed by heathens 4. UZZIAH (Pilate) 5. REBECCA (Rachel) <---voter = NK'ed b...

Snapshot

I'm not thinking from an extreme. I'm very open to any outcome that nets us a baddie. I am trying to argue in favour of thinking things through and taking care. This is not an extreme. This is common sense. Believing Ruth could be a trap is having an open mind, not a closed one. I'm not determined t...

Snapshot

OK - do whatever... I told you that ages ago. If you have no inclination to change your mind, stop playing a game with me. I don't have any energy to be fighting you in the thread.

I'll be back after the lynch, I can't be bothered being back before then.

Snapshot

@absalom - how do we know? My point exactly. No... MY point exactly. That's why I don't want to lynch Ruth right now. And what, she can't wait? If she is heathen and nothing to do with death, she can't keep until tomorrow? I honestly wouldn't be surprised if she goes away by herself. If she is stil...

Snapshot

@absalom - how do we know? My point exactly. No... MY point exactly. That's why I don't want to lynch Ruth right now. And what, she can't wait? If she is heathen and nothing to do with death, she can't keep until tomorrow? I honestly wouldn't be surprised if she goes away by herself. If she is stil...

Snapshot

I didn't push at all against Mordecai. I did push hard against Isaac because I caught him in a boldfaced lie - something most people didn't bother to read. I just find this game too tiring right now. It's pointless being in the thread because neither my words nor my vote have value. And because no-o...

Search found 861 matches