The Syndicate

Ben Linus

Something a particularly sagely player I know likes to do is point out how hard it is to lynch certain players. Naturally, mafia are harder to lynch than civilians, because mafia have a tea, running interference for them. Reywas 2 you're being ridiculous. You are correct on the "buddying up&qu...

Ben Linus

Two more minutes and I'd break a tie by voting "Eloh"? Seriously? Why Eloh and not cookie? My suspicions on both haven't changed much, in that I've reading Eloh bad and got mixed stuff from Cookie. The "win con" stuff she got tangled it got my eye as well, but for once she hasn'...

Ben Linus

I'm gonna backpedal and change my tune re: Cookie 2. I went back and read and I totally see Ricochet 2's point. It makes no sense for Cookie 2 to bring up "splints hates alive or dead win cons" in the context of this game if she's civ.

Ben Linus

Ben Linus

Golden 2 wrote:Well hey "rey" did the honors.

Voted myself.

Ben Linus

I'm leaning towards Golden being genuine and BR being the seemer. The more I look at it, the more it seems like a set-up than a genuine way to help the civs. As it's been pointed out, she did take her time disputing a role that supposedly belonged to her. No small task to dispute the role of suppos...

Ben Linus

Elohcin 2 wrote:but Rey's interactions with being questioned about how Golden could be on LC's team look floundering to me.

Explain what you mean.

Ben Linus

I think when BR2 told us to not look at her cases, she meant look at Golden 2.

Telling us not to look at her cases is a civvie move in my book btw. A seemer would want us to pursue all her "suspects".

Ben Linus

I think Blooper 2 is Bass and I think he'd be more involved if he had a team.

Ben Linus

@rey - thinking about seemer choosing an identity that is not their own makes me think... if BR 2.0 was a seemer, could she have chosen from absolutely anyone not playing the game? If so, the person I'd choose to gain cred is juliets. And I did find it surprising juliets was playing given she has b...

Ben Linus

I'm still suspicious of Elohcin 2 but there's no momentum there because she doesn't post. She's not giving us anything to work with one way or the other. I think she looks bad due to her involvement in the LC2 lynch but she's not around for me to question her or get a better feel for her. She seems ...

Ben Linus

Rey, yesterday you gave the most rational argument for waiting on golden. I wish we could flesh this out but I feel like end of day is too close now, because I'm interested in why your sudden change of heart. If I'm reading you right, I feel like perhaps it is entirely about sock identification? Co...

Ben Linus

Here's my problem Bass 2. You asked MM2 if he thought I was misconstruing him on purpose. Why did you ask JUST him? Why didn't you ask the thread at large, or offer your own opinion before asking for MM2's? My answer to that question is you did it because you were preying upon his ego and hoping to...

Ben Linus

Do we know that LC2's team killed Golden 2? So then there is evidence of a second baddie team, and you need to reassess. abcdefghijklmnopqrstuvwxyz He also could have been killed by the civ ninja so I don't think this is as cut and dry as you want to make it seem :shrug: If I feel that there's suff...

Ben Linus

One problem I've got with Golden 2 is his kitschy posts leading up to the LC 2 flip. He posted those How I Met Your Mother memes and finished up with the classic "Dary!" as if he was already expecting the result. I mean what was Golden 2 gonna post if LC2 flipped civ? That was bizarre IMO...

Ben Linus

Do we know that LC2's team killed Golden 2? So then there is evidence of a second baddie team, and you need to reassess. abcdefghijklmnopqrstuvwxyz He also could have been killed by the civ ninja so I don't think this is as cut and dry as you want to make it seem :shrug: If I feel that there's suff...

Ben Linus

Do we know that LC2's team killed Golden 2?

Ben Linus

Also: Reywas 2, can you explain is to me. You do not want to lynch Synonym 2, because it is unconfirmed there are 2 baddie teams, but you are not willing to apply the same logic to Golden 2. Why? abcedfghijklmnopqrstuvwxyz I don't understand what you're asking me. I think Golden 2 is on LC2's baddi...

Ben Linus

One problem I've got with Golden 2 is his kitschy posts leading up to the LC 2 flip. He posted those How I Met Your Mother memes and finished up with the classic "Dary!" as if he was already expecting the result. I mean what was Golden 2 gonna post if LC2 flipped civ? That was bizarre IMO...

Ben Linus

https://i.imgflip.com/rid4b.jpg https://i.imgflip.com/moifr.jpg Long Con 2 has been lynched. With Long Con 2's death, the effects of the polyjuice potion wore off and revealed his true identity. Long Con 2 was a baddie Elohcin. To the surprise of no one she had a lynch switch. . https://i.imgflip.c...

Ben Linus

@Bass could you explain your vote to me as well? Reywas 2 misunderstood Metalmarsh 2 in a strange way earlier in the thread. When I asked MM2 about whether or not he thought Reywas 2 intentionally misconstrued what he had said, Reywas 2 claimed that I was only acting interested in MM2's thoughts an...

Ben Linus

Busy RL once again, but I'll try to catch up in the next hour or so. For now, I cannot say I get the jump on "Dom", except for "Cookie" having a problem with his ISO on her. I'd have to go back and study his posts, but the ISOs, overall, didn't give me the impression that they'r...

Ben Linus

Metalmarsh 2 analysis: He begins the game on Day 0 by listing people he won't be voting for. His criteria was seemingly that he didn't want to vote for people who hadn't appeared yet. However, the below quote convinces him to not vote Cookie 2, but instead vote either Long Con 2 or Synonym 2. You a...

Ben Linus

Rey, I see your point in how we can test golden long term. He catches us baddies or we lynch him, and in the mean time the baddies have to know that if they leave him alive he rats them out. It's a good plan. What do you think of the thing I quoted from cookie, above? You quoted her twice so not su...

Ben Linus

One problem I've got with Golden 2 is his kitschy posts leading up to the LC 2 flip. He posted those How I Met Your Mother memes and finished up with the classic "Dary!" as if he was already expecting the result. I mean what was Golden 2 gonna post if LC2 flipped civ? That was bizarre IMO.

Ben Linus

OK, cookie, two questions 1) If Juliet is bad, can you think of a plausible motive for making the move? 2) If we give golden the benefit of the doubt, how are we to figure out his trustworthiness long term? If Golden 2 is a civvie then we need to make him the baddie's problem. They'll either need t...

Ben Linus

Metalmarsh 2 analysis: He begins the game on Day 0 by listing people he won't be voting for. His criteria was seemingly that he didn't want to vote for people who hadn't appeared yet. However, the below quote convinces him to not vote Cookie 2, but instead vote either Long Con 2 or Synonym 2. You a...

Ben Linus

Golden 2 wrote:
Reywas 2 wrote:For what it's worth I don't think Golden 2 has been acting very Gamer Guy-esque. I have another player in mind for his sock.
It's called role playing.

Nerd alert!

Ben Linus

Metalmarsh 2 analysis: He begins the game on Day 0 by listing people he won't be voting for. His criteria was seemingly that he didn't want to vote for people who hadn't appeared yet. However, the below quote convinces him to not vote Cookie 2, but instead vote either Long Con 2 or Synonym 2. You a...

Ben Linus

For what it's worth I don't think Golden 2 has been acting very Gamer Guy-esque. I have another player in mind for his sock.

Ben Linus

Okay but if that's true we still have the problem of 2 civvie trackers because BR2 wasn't Gamer Guy.

Ben Linus

I guess that's fair but I think it's highly unlikely he's on LC2's team and I think we're better off pursuing other leads. My two cents: I think Syn 2 is just indignant re: interactions with LC2 and the thread at large, and felt genuinely vindicated by the LC2 flip. I don't think he's on LC2's team...

Ben Linus

I guess that's fair but I think it's highly unlikely he's on LC2's team and I think we're better off pursuing other leads. My two cents: I think Syn 2 is just indignant re: interactions with LC2 and the thread at large, and felt genuinely vindicated by the LC2 flip.

Ben Linus

Can people explain why they want to vote synonym 2? Apparently I'm missing something.

Ben Linus

I'd like to hear who Golden 2 thinks we should lynch. I'm leaning towards believing BR2 was the tracker because she sounded genuine to me but I'm not ready to make a judgment.

I'm still leaning towards an Elohcin 2 vote at this point. Her defense did nothing for me.

Ben Linus

I can't believe people are voting for Syn 2 at this point. Unreal. I'm voting for Elohcin 2. I don't think you have to look very hard to see the subtle defending of Long Con 2 followed by tossing her under the bus when she was about to flip baddie and it's strange that more people aren't talking abo...

Ben Linus

I would be shocked if Cookie 2 flipped bad. Why is that? The thing with Elohcin 2 that's interesting to me is that on Day 2 when the lynch result was in question she says the reasons people were suspecting LC 2 were bad reasons. Her Day 3 post about LC2 is all hindsight. She sees LC2 has 10 votes a...

Ben Linus

The thing with Elohcin 2 that's interesting to me is that on Day 2 when the lynch result was in question she says the reasons people were suspecting LC 2 were bad reasons. Her Day 3 post about LC2 is all hindsight. She sees LC2 has 10 votes and catches up on the thread, and then summarizes all the r...

Ben Linus

I would be shocked if Cookie 2 flipped bad.

Ben Linus

Can we talk about what I want to talk about?

Reywas 2 wrote:I got my eye on Elohcin 2 for subtly defending LC2 on Day 2 and then throwing her under the bus when the Day 3 lynch was inevitable. Anybody seeing what I'm seeing there?

Ben Linus

I got my eye on Elohcin 2 for subtly defending LC2 on Day 2 and then throwing her under the bus when the Day 3 lynch was inevitable. Anybody seeing what I'm seeing there?

Ben Linus

Nicely done. Now I will have to reconsider my read of lacey because I thought she was Elohcin. That's crazy talk. Why did you think that? Lacey 2 is playing nothing like Elohcin. Not really something I can discuss as that would reveal my identity (which I may have done already anyway). Well it soun...

Ben Linus

Dom 2 wrote:Nicely done. Now I will have to reconsider my read of lacey because I thought she was Elohcin.

That's crazy talk. Why did you think that? Lacey 2 is playing nothing like Elohcin.

Ben Linus

Ben Linus

You're just arguing semantics. No, you said your theory was not contrary to what he claimed his power was, if he was telling the truth, and I was outlining why it was. In an event where he has the most votes, the power you said you thinkhe has would mean that he does not in fact have the most votes...

Ben Linus

Bass 2 wrote:Unless someone wants me to vote Long Con 2 for numbers purposes I'm just going to vote myself. There's no heinous/manipulative intent in that, but I'm sure you'll find some, and that's the name of the game so c'est la vie.

So why do it?

Ben Linus

You're just arguing semantics.

Ben Linus

I think we're gonna need a lot more votes for LC2 if we want this to work. Are you all illiterate? I told you how it works. Can anyone in the class tell me how I get lynched? Was anyone listening? Yeah that's it. Me no read good. Here is what you posted: I was joking about being unlynchable. And ye...

Ben Linus

Bass 2 wrote:
Reywas 2 wrote:I think we're gonna need a lot more votes for LC2 if we want this to work.
LC2 has 8 votes while Synonym 2 has 5 votes. Do you think LC2's prospective ability would protect him from that much of a deficit?

It did last time.

Ben Linus

I think we're gonna need a lot more votes for LC2 if we want this to work.

Search found 448 matches