The Syndicate

This was a game.

And it was good.

HILARIOUS non-player poll option Logan.

Boogs wrote:Rip Mata so we think Mongoose? Can you explain why you think she's Wadsworth or Boddy, MP?

He cannot because me being bad isn't even a thing. Spreadsheets can be wrong, spreadsheets can be Enron'd.

These are not the droids you are looking for.

Vompatti wrote:Do we want to kill Boddy?

I've thought about this a lot. His role doesn't mention any secrets (maybe the blackmail has some kill provision based upon how the target responds? maybe it's chance?), but he's a Last Man Standing, which is contravenous to both civs and mafia. Due to the LMS nature of his role, it would behoove him to sow discord and doubt through the thread -- that player is definitely going to be steering us into chaos.

Epignosis wrote:
Mongoose wrote:
Epignosis wrote:I am recreating my spreadsheet from scratch.

Question about Boddy targets:

SVS was Boddy's target on Night 1. Correct?

MP was targeted by Boddy on Night 4. Correct?

That means Boddy HAD to have voted on Day 4, correct?
That seeems right to me.
If this is true, Bass has to be Boddy. I've recreated my spreadsheet three times now.

Ture, him surviving the vote is hardly conclusive, YET in my mind it makes it more likely than not.

MovingPictures07 wrote:Bass or Vomps or Mata?

I feel strongest about Vomps currently.

This is my spreadsheet. I have nothing to hide.

Epignosis wrote:I am recreating my spreadsheet from scratch.

Question about Boddy targets:

SVS was Boddy's target on Night 1. Correct?

MP was targeted by Boddy on Night 4. Correct?

That means Boddy HAD to have voted on Day 4, correct?

That seeems right to me.

Matahari wrote:
Vompatti wrote:I really think we should vote Bass again. I only voted for Mr. because I felt like it. This is an emotional moment for all of us.
gawd you're so goofy

I think a Vomps vote would be a safe vote.

I wouldn't mind that tbh.

Mister Rearranger wrote:^wb and seeya next game! lol

Wait, am I dead?

I'm here! I spent the whole weekend at my family's place in the woods without internet! Aaaack

*night's
*too

MovingPictures07 wrote:
Epignosis wrote:
MovingPictures07 wrote:Okay, I see what you're saying now.

Well, I'm more than willing to give you the BOTD then and lynch Mata and then Vomps. That should end the game, right? Unless it's MR?

I just think MR is least likely, since I was reading him as civ, but maybe I'm wrong.
Lynch?

Bitch, you don't lynch anyone. You don't vote.

Seriously, that's what I am asking. Mongoose thinks MR is good, and she thinks you are good. I cannot see why she would vouch for two civilians if she was bad.

If Bass is the Chief, then it HAS to be Matahari.
I missed two votes. I promise it won't happen again.

I'm fine with that plan then.

I'm still feeling awfully squirrelly about Vomps. Sometimes that feeling will abate about someone (usually after I have a good nights sleep because I turn into a gremlin if kept up to long), but it's not for me in this case. For all his wackiness, he is an uber-intelligent dude and could very easily evade even the most diligent of scrutiny if left unchecked.

Maybe Epi will finally get his Rudy moment this game.

Epignosis wrote:Also, Rikki Tikki Tavi ftw. I love kipling.

I'm legit adorable in that.

I hate to see Bass throw in the towel :/

MovingPictures07 wrote:Only here for a second, but I'll try to be back later, real busy day.

If we want to catch Boddy today, isn't everyone in agreement on this matter who it is? Seems like one player in particular is probably Boddy. I'm curious what people are thinking here, so for now I'll refrain from mentioning who I think it is, and I'll come back.

I think this is a winner winner chicken dinner. I'm not as virulently opposed to the sustaining of the indie pop like some players, but I'd rather it be an indie than a civ any day. I just don't think we can take that chance at this point in the game (Day 5, natch).

Epignosis wrote:
Mongoose wrote:
Vompatti wrote:MP is good for sure! I'm a slightly nervous horse about the mongoose though.
That makes sense, Vomps, as I'm a slightly nervous horse about you as well.

Glad you didn't die, MR. Feeling pretty good about you.

Bass - I think that's a brilliant point, but it's one of those wifomy issues as well. Would Mr. Boddy intentionally do something rookie in order to dispel attention? Would Mr. Boddy do something so rookie in order cover his tracks or make us think it's a newer player when it's Captain Veteran? I'm not sure.

Also: We know now thanks for Mr Boddy that Sockface is male, but that's not exactly revealing information since most of the roles are male.
So you would rather lynch Bass instead of MR?

Yep. Not tremendously so, but I would.

@ Logan - Dude I have no idea where my eyeballs went today. I see him in the middle of the pack now.

thellama73 wrote:
Mongoose wrote:@ Host - Is Vomperdoodle's sexclusion from the poll intentional?
No, as evidenced by the fact that he is on the poll.

No, it wasn't intentional?

Vompatti wrote:MP is good for sure! I'm a slightly nervous horse about the mongoose though.

That makes sense, Vomps, as I'm a slightly nervous horse about you as well.

Glad you didn't die, MR. Feeling pretty good about you.

Bass - I think that's a brilliant point, but it's one of those wifomy issues as well. Would Mr. Boddy intentionally do something rookie in order to dispel attention? Would Mr. Boddy do something so rookie in order cover his tracks or make us think it's a newer player when it's Captain Veteran? I'm not sure.

Also: We know now thanks for Mr Boddy that Sockface is male, but that's not exactly revealing information since most of the roles are male.

@ Host - Is Vomperdoodle's sexclusion from the poll intentional?

I still do think he's a slippery fish.

If I had to choose to vote only between him and MR, I'd choose Bass certainly.

Vompatti wrote:Was there a lynch poll and did I miss it?

I chose the prettiest object, which is the revolver.

You did, and I voted for you because you are bad.

(You know why).

Can you elaborate on our super awesome plan to eliminate Boddy? I'm really confused about that role since it's LMS but no kill power?

Epignosis wrote:Allowing for the assumption that Mr. Boddy has been active all game (he did reveal info about S~V~S Night 1), that means he is going to be either Bass or MR. One of them is Mr. Naughty.

Bass has been a bit of a slippery fish...hmm.

Um the candlestick?

thellama73 wrote:
Mongoose wrote:The Knife are a Swedish electronic music duo from Gothenburg, formed in 1999.
Way to read the host post, he said pretty sarcastically.

Crap on a catapault. Can I be a pacifist?

thellama73 wrote:
Mongoose wrote:Voting Vompatti

linki oh hell

(was cooking food for lunches)
It is not lunch time. Your story is full of holes!

Lunches for the week, what the heck man.

The Knife are a Swedish electronic music duo from Gothenburg, formed in 1999.

Voting Vompatti

linki oh hell

(was cooking food for lunches)

These are some interesting extrapolations, but surely this isn't foolproof?

MovingPictures07 wrote:Wow, that sucks. Why were there two deaths...???

My guess is it had something to do with the Maid. She chose Person X to be her companion and so they done died too.

That got awkward fast.

I chose Conservatory for probably obvious reasons to my personality.

Crap on a catapault.

Welcome Matahari!

PS Let the record reflect that I'm def getting the civ vibe from Sockface.

To reiterate on what Hedgeowl said on the previous page, it just seems way more likely like The Cook is responsible for the SVS death and not a lynch switch. We don't even know if there are lynch switches this early in the game.

There's only been the one contest so far.

linki wait what. I wasn't intimating she was btw.

Did we discuss The Cook's role in all of this?

I'm not sure which way I'll go today. Gonna stick around and read another 2 hours.

I made this in college.

Bass_the_Clever wrote:
Epignosis wrote:
Bass_the_Clever wrote:well we dont even know if the indie has a kill yet or not so why worry about epig ?
Oh ffs.
well I wouldnt know how to be the last man standing without a kill.

This. I'm not sure it would even be possible. Not just unlikely -- sheer impossible. Usually when the indie doesn't have a kill, it seems like that role can win with either civs or mafia. but LMS?

Epignosis wrote:It looked like Hedgeowl wanted to say something but now she doesn't.

How do you know? Was she lurking?

Hedgeowl wrote:
nijuukyugou wrote:
MovingPictures07 wrote:
nijuukyugou wrote:RIP SVS!

Wow. Did NOT realize people were gonna come after me like that. MP, you're even pointing out the weirdness that these people suddenly come out the woodwork to "agree" with you and muddling the so-called facts (e.g., saying I voted for sabie "at the end." No. Did not happen. I voted for her third out of five people, after discussing and logically changing my mind, with plenty of time to save her had she been my teammate. I'm tired of repeating myself). What are you thinking now, Mr. Sock?

Hedge, you point out my MR vote, and I'll be honest - I forgot about sabie voting for MR in the first poll and didn't think that through when I was posting earlier (I had just spent an hour and half catching up with DW and was both a little brain-dead and needing to leave by 7 to be where I needed to be tonight on time. Excuses, excuses). However, I stand by thinking his behavior/voting patterns have been suspicious and blendy - he voted Epi with no explanation Day 1, then seems inclined to agree and vote with Epi for SVS, then turns around and votes Canuck with no previous inclination towards her, nor an explanation of his own to back it up. Perhaps he's busy. Perhaps he's playing an unconventional baddie game as his teammate votes for him. Perhaps he's Boddy. But he's definitely acting suspicious.

Oh, y'all should totally come to Raeford. It's an experience. I'll make gnocchi for everyone!
I hope I survive long enough to think about this and see what others have to say, as well as look at others, too. Also, voting gnocchi because I made a batch last week and it. Was. AWESOME.
Yeah, the fact that people followed me was strange, the fact that they were getting the facts wrong was even stranger. Civvies not paying attention or baddies looking to slide by?

What I'm thinking now is that I don't believe you're bad, and that I look forward to hunting alongside you again, assuming we both survive the night.

What did you think of the votes made against you? Like, does any of them stick out as particularly suspicious? I have my thoughts, but curious to see if you agree.
Personally, I think Bass's vote was stranger for getting the facts "mixed up," and then when it was indicated that no, I didn't "hop on" in the end as stated, (s)he (sorry Bass, I'm not sure of your gender ) waffled back and said "oh no, those other votes that were REALLY at the end were strange, too!" Seems like a way to rouse more suspicion for me while being able to easily double back if (s)he's wrong. What are you thinking?
It was, but Bass voted first for sabie, so unless he thought she would be safe it was a ballsy move. Mongoose would be the other possiblity as she did not vote sabie, but i have a terrible time reading her and shes been pretty busy recently.

Thank you for explaining your MR vote. I was shocked when SVS voted him again as well, but considering she was civ and sabie didnt follow her vote, maybe just forgetful as well. Idk. MR seems like the least likely candidate in my book, so i dont get the continued suspicion there at all.

I lilke Hedgebowl' s tjhouhts here.

I have a hangover from sleeping too much.

Aren't those both new players? They'll come back to the sweet lure of mafia.

Anisette sounds almondy, so I'll go there, but mostly because I have a sweet tooth like whoa.

Epignosis wrote:
Bass_the_Clever wrote:
Epignosis wrote:
Hedgeowl wrote:Wait, what? RIP SVS.
Not complicated. So far people haven't been reading the roles. This is textbook business.
Well you think someone switched it?
I don't think "SOMEONE" switched it. Come on man.

Imma need you to spell that out for me like this is the Tufts Spelling Bee.

Whoa lynch switch?

Also, can we have a Mass Mafia Meetup soon please? I've loved everyone I've met IRL to absolute pieces.

Tick-tock, Logan!

This is like Godzilla v. Mechagodzilla

S~V~S wrote:I think MP made an interesting case, although I am not sure I see Ninjajujube as quite that ballsy. I am going to vote MR again. I think Blooper makes a good point, and he is unlikley to be lynched in any case. i am not going to hold my vote to save. It is what it is.

Well if I had seen this beforehand, perhaps we could have coordinated better. I was trying to save yo' butt.

I don't buy SVS as a baddie. If she was bad, she'd have every motivation to let herself be blackmailed.

I'm casting in with the Blooper party. Hope this is the right decision.

Search found 77 matches