The Syndicate

what is the case against jack I mentioned a couple of things earlier on, one of which was his dismissive and outright hostile attitude to early suspicions. The post I quoted where he tells Nutella that he thinks she's town but will tunnel her if she doesn't drop her suspicion of him is all kinds of...

I'm happy to JackofHearts based on his vote history and attitude toward suspicions as mentioned in my earlier post. Linki: I was being criticised for not having taken any strong stances or shown many opinions, now I'm being criticised for trying to do that. :shrug: Hey at least I used human words a...

I'm happy to [VOTE: JackofHearts] aubergine based on his vote history and attitude toward suspicions as mentioned in my earlier post.

Linki: I was being criticised for not having taken any strong stances or shown many opinions, now I'm being criticised for trying to do that.

DH I am interested in your point about us voting the same person in a bid to not die. If we can agree upon a mutual suspect it may be worthwhile. Personally I wouldn't mind a Jack or Speed lynch today but could be swayed to Sprit or K-Ness based on their records. I don't think it's worth lynching an...

DharmaHelper wrote: ↑Sat Oct 06, 2018 5:16 pm Bulls if you vote for me then I'll have to vote for you which puts us at a null point. but if we vote for the same, different person, then that person will have two votes.

Damn, you're good at maths.

Going through and reviewing the ISOs of the remaining players. I had planned to do this today anyway but got pushed into defense mode. DFaraday [/u][/b] 3 posts, literally nothing to comment on. DF is good at being a blendy low-flying baddie but I don't think we're seeing that here, I think he's jus...

Its not like I'm saying you've done awfully. I'm just saying you could be doing much better. And fortunately I'm here to make sure that happens. who do you think should be lynched today? The bullzeye case appeals to me. How much of that is influenced by the fact we're both leading the lynch right n...

Its not like I'm saying you've done awfully. I'm just saying you could be doing much better. And fortunately I'm here to make sure that happens. who do you think should be lynched today? The bullzeye case appeals to me. How much of that is influenced by the fact we're both leading the lynch right n...

Given himself a lovely bit of wiggle room there for when I flip civ and he can say "damn, I was 25% sure he wasn't bad". It's interesting to me that Speedchuck's first vote for a baddie was the second Marmot lynch, he didn't vote Luna and voted Simon during the tie. So are you saying that...

Finally read the Bullz case cover-to-cover and it looks like a solid piece of work to ya boi. I also like that its not a full on "Here's how Bullz is bad" thing, and is careful enough to put him at "75%" bad instead. Given himself a lovely bit of wiggle room there for when I fli...

Finally read the Bullz case cover-to-cover and it looks like a solid piece of work to ya boi. I also like that its not a full on "Here's how Bullz is bad" thing, and is careful enough to put him at "75%" bad instead. Given himself a lovely bit of wiggle room there for when I fli...

I've never claimed to be good at this game. I just like it. For a more serious reply, when you're in btsc you know exactly who your team are and it's easier to feel invested in their success. Maybe that's just me. No, I do get that. The only reason I even bother to try if scum is because of teammat...

If any of the inactive players are scum and is doing background work, that is just fucking boring and I'm not even going to acknowledge it as game play. Given how extremely inactive some of the players are, I'd be very surprised if their silence was a tactical gameplay decision. I've never known an...

Yeah half the time I'm too busy to post and the other half I'm too lazy. :shrug: I'd care more if I felt like I had teammates I was letting down by not being around but when I'm civ I feel like I'm just invested in my own survival tbh. If I only let myself down, that's fine. Town wins as a team. Th...

Sure does. A really good teammate would've also moved their vote to Simon when he was checking the thread from his phone and saw how the lynch was going ;) Whaaaat is thiiiis? The truth. Why did you not vote either Marmot or Simon? Neither bandwagon had really gotten moving first thing on Day Four ...

Dyslexicon wrote: ↑Fri Oct 05, 2018 5:52 pm
Bullzeye wrote: ↑Fri Oct 05, 2018 2:13 pmSure does. A really good teammate would've also moved their vote to Simon when he was checking the thread from his phone and saw how the lynch was going
Whaaaat is thiiiis?

The truth.

Oh I also had a flawless run in Bioshock as a baddie, but our dear host changed alignment and murdered our entire team in what's still one of my favourite mafia moments of all time.

No worries, I think the final comment in that post may have come off a bit harsher than I meant it but you could totally go read some old games. Off the top of my head my best baddie run on this site is probably in Epi's Shawshank game where I survived to the final three but got owned by Dom who was...

First part is notable now that Luna has flipped scum. Bullzeye was very cautious about commenting on that (LC) case. Second part is an okay response to an actual problem. If I seemed cautious about the LC case it's because I was. I thought it was both a great point and obviously wrong at the same t...

I'm very interested to hear more about how I'm suddenly such a baddie. I’m interested in you being interested in other things. Same. Yeah but Simon was lynched over Marmot despite the tie, we don't know the behind the scenes thought process that went into that move but it would seem like they knew ...

Turnip Head wrote: ↑Fri Oct 05, 2018 3:50 pmYes

I felt like your comment about Nova was an attempt to repeat the chaos of Day 1's ending and try to get heat off either Luna, Sloonei, or both (definitely Luna in hindsight) with a cfd onto someone you saw as an easy target. That's why I replied to it at all.

@speedchuck You were right to barf when Bullzeye feigned interest in a Nova wagon. That was the first post that made me think he and Luna were connected. Case looks thorough, I hope it gets the clicks. Would you be interested to hear that I was feigning interest because I thought you might be tryin...

Yawn. Too obvious. If I was on a team with Luna and Marmot then I'd have voted Sloonei during Luna's lynch and would've come up with an excuse to vote for Simon during the tied lynch.

Very initial first impression of the thread: Jay feels off, don't know why though Probably trying to avoid the obvious conclusion that he was recruited. Why is it obvious Jay would be recruited? The sign-up thread mentions that the baddies recruit roles, not players. How many bad robots do we think...

speedchuck wrote: ↑Fri Oct 05, 2018 2:35 pm But sure, I can do case stuff

Please do. That way rather than just telling you you're wrong I can point to specific examples of wrongness.

I'm very interested to hear more about how I'm suddenly such a baddie.

Turnip Head wrote: ↑Fri Oct 05, 2018 2:07 pm Bullzeye voted for Sloonei during the Simon vs Marmot tie. Feels like a move a teammate might make.

Sure does. A really good teammate would've also moved their vote to Simon when he was checking the thread from his phone and saw how the lynch was going

Oh only four lynches. Oh ok. If DH has any teammates in BTSC, they aren't helping him to catch up. The case against marmot, the use of their power to skip a day, etc. DH has been relying on us. Three possibilities. 1. He has no teammates. 2. He has no ACTIVE teammates. 3. They're being smart about ...

Has anyone else noticed that out of the four robot master roles to have been revealed in the opening post, two are now confirmed baddies? Wondering if the other two are also bad tbh...

If Marmot is town, Gemini Man is scum and almost certain Speedchuck. If Marmot is scum and not Gemini Man, same conclusion. Can Marmot not be town and Gemini Man? The main thing I don't understand is why in my catch up people seem to be assuming Gemini Man is definitely a baddie with what appears t...

Bullzeye - I know next to nothing about his playstyle. Bullzeye, can you talk about it a little bit? With differences between your town and scum games? At the moment, I don't have any reason to rule him out. Being a returning player, maybe he'd be more likely to take a backseat in BTSC. I don't rea...

If Marmot is town, Gemini Man is scum and almost certain Speedchuck. If Marmot is scum and not Gemini Man, same conclusion. Can Marmot not be town and Gemini Man? The main thing I don't understand is why in my catch up people seem to be assuming Gemini Man is definitely a baddie with what appears t...

Step 1 - Night Kill the fuck out of inactive players Step 2 - Lynch whoever the fuck we want based on whatever the fuck we want because the players we don't Nightkill will be like "yeah that is in the thread therefore it makes sense to do that" Active players, that should say on #1 You ar...

If Marmot is town, Gemini Man is scum and almost certain Speedchuck. If Marmot is scum and not Gemini Man, same conclusion. Can Marmot not be town and Gemini Man? The main thing I don't understand is why in my catch up people seem to be assuming Gemini Man is definitely a baddie with what appears t...

I got home a lot later than anticipated yesterday because my brother and I decided to explore London for a few hours rather than immediately jump on the first train home. By the time I got in I was knackered and basically went straight to sleep. I've read bits over the weekend but not much and what ...

Also I'm leaving now. You might not see me again until Night 4. Have fun!

I'm going to throw my placeholder vote down on Sloonei because I'm still not convinced either way on him. A lot of his defence yesterday really boiled down to WIFOM. I'm going to make notes on my phone to check in tonight and tomorrow morning as well as maybe after the show, so if anything interesti...

sprityo wrote: ↑Sat Sep 29, 2018 4:37 am long Con, do you have anything else to add or is this it?

I feel like the same could be asked of your response to his comments. Looking at the poll results so far it seems LC forgot to actually cast a vote, but your reply kinda makes me want to fix that issue for him.

Kyle's fanfic is the greatest and I cannot wait to read more. I'm particularly happy with the title "Every DFaradog has his DFaraday". I will need to throw down a vote that's at least a placeholder within the next half hour or so, as I mentioned yesterday I'm going to be away all weekend. ...

K-Ness wrote: ↑Fri Sep 28, 2018 2:46 pm
Bullzeye's remark about someone being absent Day 2 was odd considering there wasn't a Day 2. But the overall feel from his ISO leaves me leaning town on him.

I feel like it's incredibly obvious that that comment was a joke...

I should probably mention I'm away this weekend and probably won't be around at all. I'll try to vote from my phone first thing but I'm unlikely to have chance to get involved at all through Day 4, if I do it will be very brief and I'll probably be quite drunk. Should be back on Monday evening assum...

I've been afraid to bring this into the fold because for those who are already on my case it's just an added layer of WIFOM and a chance to say "of course you'd update your strategy in this game", but here is my post history from Ancient Greece Mafia. The dynamic between Mac and I was ver...

Tell you this. I’ll stop harassing Sloonei for tonight and we can talk someone else. I definitely think Sloonei is full omgus mode for suspecting speed and I Hey now, I was proud of myself for working to a point where I suspected you without relying on self-defense. Also my speedchuck decision is b...

Your second post in the game was to vote for me and you seemed pretty confident in it at the time. The only real elaboration you gave is that I "write like scumz write". I don't remember if we've ever played a game together before (don't think so) but if we had you'd probably be able to t...

is there a place where the points against lunalee are at in a convenient package that would be easy to view while i'm playing video games You could stop playing Zelda and play mafia for a bit :O im playing pokemon Im about to face 3rd Giovanni in FR for my first Nuzzlocke challenge. Nuzlocke runs a...

It doesn't take much imagination for me to paint Bullz and Luna as scumbuddies right now :smoky: Unfortunately, paint is not an effective scumhunting tool. You make a big mess, and never get the color you want. Have you tried ISO-propane? In all honesty I'd rather not be painted at all. I have work...

Turnip Head wrote: ↑Thu Sep 27, 2018 5:09 pm It doesn't take much imagination for me to paint Bullz and Luna as scumbuddies right now

I forgive you.

I've been afraid to bring this into the fold because for those who are already on my case it's just an added layer of WIFOM and a chance to say "of course you'd update your strategy in this game", but here is my post history from Ancient Greece Mafia. The dynamic between Mac and I was ver...

Turnip Head wrote: ↑Thu Sep 27, 2018 4:48 pm Still down for a Nova wagon if there's enough people who would lynch him over Sloonei and/or Luna

Part of me wants to see where Sloonei vs Luna goes but if there's a better option then why not. What makes you want a Nova lynch?

I'm going to end up staying up until the lynch ends and be too tired for work tomorrow...

Search found 3412 matches