The Syndicate

Rih MP, good game

Darth Vader out! Nice job, town.

So Mac, I'm guessing you don't see Daisy as an MP teammate?

I'm gonna vote DFaraday. Roxy had him and MP pegged as baddies, I think, so either one is cool with me.

Also, going through the thread and noticing about three different rainbow reads where Canuckle is at the very top or second. Sooooo Canuckle is either super good or super bad using force powers?

Sooooo

What does everyone think of DFaraday?

Just ISO'd him after Roxy had him on her sus list. On day 2, when Bass and Enrique were tied at 5 votes a piece, DFaraday puts a third vote on Roxy (a civ). The day bcornett was lynched, DF throws his vote on Bubbles (despite sussing BCornett way earlier in the game for an interaction he had with Golden. Which by the way, I don't think DF ever brings up again). The day Enrique is officially lynched, DF puts his vote on Simon (a civ). Helped lynch Simon a day later.

I dunno. Someone else ISO this guy and look at his poll records, what do you think?

Bullz, can you name me some suspects? Just looked through your ISO, and there's practically nothing when it comes to suspecting people.

I believe you mentioned Roxy, Elo, and Mac.

What are your current thoughts on Elo/Mac? Are they still your top suspects? If not, what do you got for us?

Derp. Lol I read Daisy's post but it must've not computed.

Okay then. Elsewhere.

Bye sig

So that's funny. sig dies and sorsha is smiley cursed right after I involve them in my theory.

I'm being set up already

Anyway, Mac's Wilgy posts had me rollin'. That's funny, I often forget Wilgy is playing with the exception of Pet Sounds where I think he had more posts then anyone in the game haha.

Zebra - You never commented on me voting you last phase, I don't think. Should I vote for you again or look elsewhere?

Sorsha, sig - What do you think of my theory?

It's quiet.

Someone tell me how bad my theory is. Go!

WILD SPECULATIVE THEORY

Soooo

At the beginning of the game in Day 0, I recall DH saying a secret event had been triggered.

Within minutes, both sig and Golden posted descriptions of each planet from the Day 0 poll. About 20 minutes later, Sorsha did the same.

Is it possible the secret event was for these three players to post their descriptions of each planet? Furthermore, is it possible each player is from a different faction? Golden being indy, sig/sorsha one being good, the other bad. Perhaps DH picked the winner and that faction won a prize of some sort?

Hmmm

One problem with this theory is that sig and Golden both posted their descriptions exactly 4 minutes after the event had been triggered, but it's possible DH let them know ahead of time they would be involved in this contest.

Anyway, probably wrong. But I just thought of it and wanted to share haha.

MacDougall wrote:

Matt wrote:So far I have about 5 suspects as Golden's 2 Jawa partners, one of them being dead lol.

One of them I'm sure about, though. Of course that doesn't mean jack but oh boy I'm sure

Mac - Golden wasn't Mafia, he was a pretty harmless indy as far as I can tell, so for all intents he was a civ IMO. He suspected you and went so far as to 1 v 1 you. I'm not trying to start a pissing match, but by Golden's ghost I don't think it's something we should just ignore.

Golden said that his flip would reveal nothing. Using his role as a basis for suspecting me goes against his requests. He always attained his read on me as bad was findable in my ISO. So if you want to scum read me look at my ISO.

You won't find anything, but don't misrepresent the dead.

He also cooled hard on me as a bad guy by the end, and had other suspects.

If he gets me lynched posthumously because of you, he's going to be a very sad panda.

Lol. I think you severely overestimate my ability to control the direction of the thread, but for using the saaaaad panda reference, I will consider your request. That being said, my point wasn't that his role reveal somehow dictated your alignment, just that Golden seemed pretty effin' sure you were bad. I've been workin' a lot the last few days, though, so I'll have to review his most recent thoughts on you.

So far I have about 5 suspects as Golden's 2 Jawa partners, one of them being dead lol.

One of them I'm sure about, though. Of course that doesn't mean jack but oh boy I'm sure

Mac - Golden wasn't Mafia, he was a pretty harmless indy as far as I can tell, so for all intents he was a civ IMO. He suspected you and went so far as to 1 v 1 you. I'm not trying to start a pissing match, but by Golden's ghost I don't think it's something we should just ignore.

So Mac, what are your opinions post Golden flip? Not a civ, but not necessarily bad. My guess is Golden just had to survive until the end. How does his flip make you feel in light of his calling you out a few days back?

Been ISOing Golden for the last 20 minutes (over 400 posts, really Golden? ).

RIP Golden.

Good call, DF.

Bullzeye wrote:

Matt wrote:I'm wondering if there is some sort of dark force power that makes people quit

I still haven't caught up. Really I apologize but I've been catching up on AWR, doing laundry, my boys came over and we're playing CoD 2 (it'd be great if one of us could purchase 3 haha)

But right now, I think Mac is possibly bad. Why the F would he up and quit after Roxy just did so as a civ? I don't buy it.

Anyway, on that note, going to vote Zeebs. I won't be back for the remainder of the day phase and I'll ask kindly that nobody question me on that.

Good day!

COD 2 as in the one that came out 10 years ago?

Whoops my bad. I was just informed that it is Black Ops 2 we play.

Also, just effin' around with my last post. I figured with the quits left and right it'd be funny to act as if I'm force voting Zeebs. But I'm not, that was a real vote.

Going to WinCo for a few hours, that's why I won't be around but again, I thought it'd be funny to stir some shit and be weird but as a civvie I shouldn't be trying to distract the town so my apologies.

Peace

I'm wondering if there is some sort of dark force power that makes people quit

I still haven't caught up. Really I apologize but I've been catching up on AWR, doing laundry, my boys came over and we're playing CoD 2 (it'd be great if one of us could purchase 3 haha)

But right now, I think Mac is possibly bad. Why the F would he up and quit after Roxy just did so as a civ? I don't buy it.

Anyway, on that note, going to vote Zeebs. I won't be back for the remainder of the day phase and I'll ask kindly that nobody question me on that.

Good day!

Lol. The irony of quitting because of labeling someone else "touchy".



MacD, come back and play. So I can vote you for being either Golden's or Dom's teamie.

I believe it. Bullz, when are we gonna be Mafia together again?

Er...DFaraday is a he. Haha.

MovingPictures07 wrote:I'm probably fucked anyway because I would need at least 3 other people willing to vote zebra (or 4 for GlorfinDaisy) for me to even survive, including my own vote, and that's assuming no one else votes for me. I already know certain non-entities will likely miss the vote (Bass 2.0, for example). But if I do die, I want to at least be able to say that I left you all with my thoughts and that I tried to save myself this latter part of the Day period.

I'm thinking of voting Zeebs. She's deserving of a revenge vote anyway AND she was tops on Roxy's Day Four suspect list.

I'm also interested in DFaraday. Not only did she make Roxy's Bad List on day 4 (second I believe?), but I believe she also had a back and forth with him.

Hmmmm

Linki - Bullzeye, 8:30 pm eastern is when the poll is over. Derp. You make me think you're bad when asking such silly questions.

Roxy wrote:The people I think are bad and I will bevoting one of them:

Zebra
DFaraday
Dom
TheFloyd
Canuck
Wiggly
Ninjabloops

This was on Day 4. Also, Roxy seemed to go after Elohcin quite a bit.

I'm still catching up but wanted to ISO Roxy based on her role, and this seemed like a good post to quote.

I consider your ping, sir, and revoke it.

Looks like peeps are leaning MP or Zebra. I've been trying to be objective on Zebra because she helped lead the town against me on Day One and then voted Bass (a civvie) instead, but it's soooo hard to be objective.

Anyway, will start catching up. I still have pages 35 - 60 to go, and then afterwards, I will feel comfortable doing ISO's and whatnot.

Yo peeps. Today's my day off, will be catching up some more. I read the thread a bit last night but was working on my super awesome cool JLA game ya all can check out in the Drawing board and by the time I was done, was tired af.

From the gist...peeps think MP is a baddie? I'm not qualified to read MP (am I really qualified to read anyone? haha) but I did suspect him unfairly solely based on SD replacing in.

Also, it looks like Golden and Mac have done a complete 180 (as far as last night goes) and are now Super Best Friends. Yay. So, teamies? Haha.

Off to the store for a bit, then I'll be back and catching up all day today if it kills me and will also be keeping current on the thread.

Peace

RIP Roxy. I hope you're okay, dudette. I know we clashed in Talking Heads pretty badly, but I remember I had a lot of fun with you back in the day. Anyway peace

MacDougall wrote:When more than one person makes a point of saying that things were fun when you weren't around and are no longer fun you should walk away man. I ain't about to change. I can and will stop pissing people off, I'll just stop playing!

Derp. I don't agree. If you like playing Mafia here, then stay. Like I said you're pretty refreshing with your humor and you've got cool ideas like the Mafia League you're tryin' to start.

Don't let others bring you down, man. It's all good.

Catchin' up. I noticed Roxy won the lynch vote from the poll, but don't know the results yet.

MacDougall wrote:If there are any votes left lynch me because I don't want to be disruptive and make people not want to be here and it appears as though I've done that. I'm a civilian but at least the Golden drama would be over and apparently nobody wants to lynch him, and people will have more fun without me.

I know I annoyed the shit out of you (and ummmm others) in Talking Heads but dude you have me crackin' up with nearly every post you make. I hope you're not serious with this post.

Wtf is with everyone being so down and wanting to get lynched?

Anyway peeps, I'm out. Good luck town!

Linki - Back atcha Golden. I was kind of upset earlier when you named MP your best friend here when we are clearly besties, but it's okay, I forgive you. Late!

Dom wrote:

Golden wrote: One straight answer, please.

This is how I always feel when I talk to Matt.

Lol.

Again, I love this site.

MovingPictures07 wrote:I'd vote for Roxy at this stage, frankly, but I'd like to ISO her, Dom, and others before I commit... we'll see how far I get. GTH I agree with Matt that I don't think a civilian Roxy would say "you'll catch a baddie", but I really don't know; she could just be a civilian saying that because she's so beyond wanting out of the game.

Well, I know DH and Epi must've had to reach deep into their bag of replacements to allow me to come back in (just kiddin' hosts...ummm kinda), so if Roxy is really done, then she's probably mod-killed, right?

In that case, I'm going to vote Roxy. Peeps seem to think she's bad anyway, and this way, we see her alignment as opposed to not if she's mod-killed.

MP and Daisy, Question - In Talking Heads, I sussed Black Rock for being bad simply because she replaced in and Long Con had been lynched and flipped mafia. I figured "Well hey, they are an item so they probably discuss their roles with each other if one of them isn't playing and therefore BR must be bad too." My question is, do the two of you discuss your roles with each other if the other isn't playing?

Linki - Yeah Zebra, I knew Mac was being funny, but thought I'd ask what peeps thought since no one seemed to bring it up.

Alright, all caught up from last night. Still have to catch up from pages 35 to about 60, but that'll have to hold.

What do people make of Roxy saying "vote for me, you'll catch a baddie" ? Is that bad Roxy getting mad and quitting, or is that good Roxy getting mad and trying to screw over town? I don't see good Roxy doing that sooooo

What do people make of Mac listing himself as Mafia in his G2H reads? Lol

I have about 30 min before I place my vote.

Hmmm

I know MP would rather us go to Mods and all, but I'm not upset, I just want to make a point re: Roxy

I've been belittled, ridiculed, called irrational, insane, had a policy lynch called upon me, and much more that I'm sure I can't remember at the time, since I came back about two months ago...

I love this effin' site. BRING IT ON BITCHES!!!



Back to reading. I have about 50 minutes and 3 pages to go.

Right now I'm really not liking Golden and Mac being swell with each other suddenly. I get people can change their minds, but I dunno, convenient?

I think I may vote for Golden but I still have a few pages.

Roxy wrote:Matt Bad

Lol.

Let me guess, you random'd me being bad, right?

Ugh

I just read 2 pages where Golden and Mac repeatedly called each other stupid.

Derp

I have like 5 pages left of this. Although at this point they seem to be friends now.

Back to reading

Bullzeye wrote:If it makes you feel any better Matt, when I first replaced in and read through everything I was quite surprised anyone wanted to lynch you because you looked your typical zany civ self to me. I'd have said as much if I were here.

Thanks buddy!

Anywho, Bullz is bad? J/K DUDE

Also, decided to reorder some stuff, get ready FIRST. So now I'm here for about an hour and a half. Yay.

Catching up from last night...

Golden wrote:2) I saw Matt as a better vote than Brian because the case on Matt was also good. He was not acting like his civ self.

This has less to do with Golden's statement and more to do with something I've wanted to say. Was gonna just drop it, but since this was posted, will address it...

I absolutely played Boba like I would any civ role. I mentioned Death Star like 8,000 times because I thought it would be cool to go there...there was no ulterior motive.

Just FYI, people. IMO, you didn't "catch" bad Matt.



Anyway, I have about two hours before I go in...which gives me about an hour and fifteen before I start gettin' ready...catchin' up...

Btw I dunno why, but I'm not so sure I'm correct on you wanting a 1 v. 1 with 3J in THeads. But maybe it was someone else. I dunno.

Anyway night peeps

Thanks Daisy.

Still, if MP were Crumb and if you subbed in as his teammate, then a brilliant answer.

Going to trust you for now. I think the drunken posts are believable.

I'm kind of interested in what happens if Golden is lynched. Though last time Golden pulled this as a civ (if he is indeed a civ this game) he ended up getting poor bea lynched.

Anywho, managed to read 4 pages tonight. Woot! I'm gettin' there peeps but I'm out for now.

Peace

Linki - Golden, dude, in the few times I've seen this from you, it hasn't worked out so well. I think in TH it was a 1 v. 1 you wanted with 3J, who was civ. And then in Dune I think you wanted a 1 v. 1, and Zebra ended up being civ.

I dunno dude. i'm tired. Not sure who I'll be voting for tomorrow but I have to vote earlyish, long work day tomorrow

Question - Does anyone else think MP could be Salacious Crumb? In one of his earlier rainbow lists, he puts Bcornett near the top in green...then later makes a bunch of drunk posts. I'm wondering if making up drunk posts in the thread would be a way to amuse Jabba.

Just splitballing. I recall earlier people thinking MP and Enrique had some sort of connection, which would also work in favor of this theory.

Back to reading.

Dom wrote:

MacDougall wrote:You ask Golden to tell you why I'm bad, he gives you an answer that I easily refute, you vote. That's that.

Not a good look Dom.

I think you are too arrogant in your beliefs to catch a baddie.

In Dune, his first three susses of the game were all Mafia. Just FYI.

Anywho, if I had to vote now, and it was between solely Mac or Golden, I'd pick Golden.

For two reasons...

a) I think, of the two, Mac has a better case.

b) Golden seems to not care if he's lynched, and if he's civ and has some master plan, then eff it.

That being said, is this just a Mac vs Golden thing today, or are we going to do as sig suggests and look for other candidates as well? Golden threatened to derail the thread though (very civ like, Golden) if we don't lynch him or Mac, sooooooo I dunno.

That being said, looooong effin' work day, goin' to start from page 32 onward, and we'll see where I land before my eyes can't stay open any longer.

Oh I almost forgot...

Golden wrote:

MacDougall wrote:What exactly am I crafting Golden. Crafting indicates I am producing a story. All I am doing is looking at what happened in the thread and pointing it out. That's not crafting, that's looking. And how does any of this have the end goal of me trying to not look Hutt? Are you saying that I am bussing you? Really? Are you trying to plant a seed of doubt in towns mind that I have actually bussed you when you flip Hutt?

Oh of course, Matt, because everyone would buy that I was bussing my final teammate if I flipped Hutt

Derp, you do realize that me and Mac aren't the same person, right Golden?

Linki - DFaraday what up!! I mentioned you earlier and asked what everyone thought of you, but nobody wanted to play that game

Beatles Forever, my friend. Your awesome game is why everyone has to tolerate my ass haha

Golden wrote:Mac is not wrong about me.

Anyway, on that note, see ya all tonight!

Just looked at the roles list, so I see why.

However...

Matt wrote:Probably post pitifully per phases. More monologue Monday, methinks.

I'm pretty sure the player above has made a vote in every poll, so I'm not sure I agree with you Golden.

Linki - Will do, Mac. I have to start getting ready in about 15 minutes, but I'll skip ahead and read your stuff on Goldy when I get home.

Golden wrote:I think C3PO vexed roxy.

Then a big F you to C3P0

J/k C3P0

Why do you think that Golden?

Roxy wrote:Voting vixen that vexes her victims

That's interesting.

Zebra, have you been vexing people?

Question - Does anyone know why Glorfindel was replaced? I notice he seemed to get upset with some players and the way they talked to him.

If he was replaced because he simply didn't like the thread's conduct, then I would have to give him/SD the green light for now. I figure as Mafia with partners, he wouldn't be upset. But again, I'm not sure what happened.

Linki - I skim a lot when I'm actually current with the thread and need to catch up a few pages, but since it's 40 pages I'm reading, I'd figure I'd take it nice and easy.

a2thezebra wrote:Yes, flip-floppy as hell. All flips and all flops were justified IMO.

Okey dokey.

Fyi, I'm on page 31 now. Reading kind of slow but I'd rather take it all in then skim the shit out of the thread before getting back into it.

I know I "voted" for DFaraday the other day, but what are people's opinion of him?

Zebra, I'm only on page 30, but I notice you seem to go after Enrique, but then after a post of his, you say "Okay I'll take that into consideration", then you sus him again, then Canuckle makes a big post about good/bad guy reactions regarding Enrique as good, then you say "dammit I'm convinced".

Flip floppy?

Golden wrote:And if people continue to think his case is rational, I would ask people why on earth I'd just bus two teammates for the hell of it - because no, the suspicion had just come off Enrique before I put it back on. And I pushed Enrique ahead of Simon. And noone was after BC when I went after him.

Question - Are you under the impression that the Hutts knew Enrique was Greedo?

That MattDougall thing went over my head. But I'm sure I'll get there.

Anyway Golden, I never take offense from you. I know we're besties

Haha j/k.

But for real, chill. I might vote for you if you keep up with the "I'm not going to read people and I don't want discussion just vote for me" tantrum.

Golden wrote:And, in all seriousness Matt, anyone who thinks the theory has any merit should vote for me.

Right now, just stop talking to me and vote for me.

Please.

Golden

If that's really how you wanna play it