The Syndicate

Matt wrote:I believe we were all terrified of your legendary talents and thus had to destroy you.

That explains why you tried to kill me N1

How would you have resolved a tie then?

Ah, I was under the assumption that if there was 1 baddie and 1 civ left, the baddie would win the game. Was it wrong of me to assume that?

Why was there no kill last night?

This is OUR island now!

The day Matt died was when people used Floyds info to lynch him, that doesn't mean much.

And yesterday Wilgy was the other one up for lynch, so that doesn't mean much other. He was very hesitant to lynch Scotty and tried to get me to make a triple tie.

Scotty named Zebra and nutella as his main suspects. His main case yesterday was on nutella.

DrWilgy wrote:What do you think is optimal then?

Good question.

You
Epi
Nutella
Bullz/Zebra
SVS

Something like that.

I don't think that's optimal lynch order

I appreciate you trying to keep me alive Wilgy

You're making me want to lynch you next, Wilgy.

Boom. Thank god. After Pikmin I was wondering if I was ever going to be able to lynch a baddie again.

Linki: Not if I kill you first nub.

*changes vote to Wilgy*

61 minutes.

I'm not gonna change my vote on my last day alive on the Island, sorry

I don't know if I'm right. At the very least this Day will give a lot of info to work with for tomorrow, regardless of the outcome.

He?

I'm more confident that Scotty is bad than that Wilgy is bad, hence my vote on Scotty.

Also do you really think Zebra would have pulled that D2 stunt with saying Matt was 100% bad, getting all the votes on him and then lynching Floyd as a baddie? It's one hell of a play if so.

Note that that is not the only reason I think Zebra is civ, but it's an example.

To Epi: You say you were surprised about Michael or Boone being in the game, but remember this is a S1 game.

The 13 claimed players have all had flashbacks in Season 1, making them most likely roles to appear in the game.

Still Epi or Wilgy :P

It didn't.

Epi seems genuine, albeit mistaken at times. Wilgy seems clinically insane.

What happened this last page?

Who are you voting Epi?

Sure seems like it.

Jesus, Epi. Put some effort into the game, will you? Thanks.

no u

"A play style you don't agree with"

What are you talking about?

DrWilgy wrote: <with regards to Scotty>
I thought I had stated I wouldn't betray you? I don't intend to.

Where the hell did you say this, except for earlier today?

Would you not expect me to lose my shit over all the role claiming?

Scotty wrote:

Typhoony wrote:

Scotty wrote: Ok. I mean you named me as your top suspect at top of the night yesterday with no reason, but yeah, take your time.

Annoyed, are we?
I don't think you're gonna get nutelLA lynched today, btw. I have no interest in voting her. You're better off putting your vote on Wilgy if you don't want to die.

Anyway, why I think you are bad:

1) You hinted at your role early on
While this is true that I did so, this is pure WIFOM and I'm hardly the only one to do so. Why am I the target of your ire for that and not "udders" or "city slicker"?
You are not the only one. Notice I also mentioned Epi down here. Who said "city slicker"?
As I explained earlier with Epi, I think baddies are more likely to do this than civvies. Baddies know that civvies do not know that baddies have a safe role to claim, so the incentive of claiming a role becomes bigger since you can use the defence "I hinted at my role from the beginning. Clearly that means I am actually that role". You cannot use that defence after everyone else has hinted or claimed. Waiting till the last minute to hint or claim opens you up to suspicion, so why not do it nice and early as a baddie... like in your first post?

2) You seem afraid to name people you think are civ, thereby leaving the door open for a future lynch.

I looked through your posts, but you never go out of your way to proclaim someone a civ.

I hardly ever go out of my way to call someone civ unless I am confident in it. I actually think I came close with Matt, though that didn't turn out well. Typh, we haven't played that much together, but trust me in that statement now and in future/past games. I'm still not apologizing for that- in fact, I would admit it's better in general to be suspicious of everyone. Paranoid Scotty gonna be paranoid.
There's a difference between what you are doing and what the rest is doing. Most of the people left alive seem comfortable with following, or at the very least trusting, someone else in the game. You seem to keep every option open at all times. Being paranoid is fine, being too paranoid is not.

There's no shame in being caught as a baddie Scotty.

SVS what is your opinion on Bullz?

What

He seems to be just throwing stuff out there in the hope that literally anything at all will stick.

Maybe Epi can call him the shitslinger from now on.

And I guess you're not responding to what Zebra said?

Wilgy, you're doing a shit job of making me think you're a civ atm.

What word? You never promised to not vote Scotty.

Apart from that I'm not gonna create a tie just for the sake of creating a tie at this point in the game. Neither should anyone else.
It is also impossible for me to create a 3-way tie atm, nub Wilgy.

Voting records would point to Wilgy and Scotty.
Day 1 Scotty and Wilgy voted Dfaraday. Epi voted Nutella
Day 2 Scotty and Wilgy voted Zebra. Epi was the first vote on Floyd.

Problem is that I don't think they are teammates based on their interactions in the thread. So it it Scotty + Epi or Wilgy + Epi?

I don't think it's SVS, nutella or Zebra. Bullzeye is pretty neutral for me, I'm mostly going on SVS' read of him.

Scotty wrote: Ok. I mean you named me as your top suspect at top of the night yesterday with no reason, but yeah, take your time.

Annoyed, are we?
I don't think you're gonna get nutelLA lynched today, btw. I have no interest in voting her. You're better off putting your vote on Wilgy if you don't want to die.

Anyway, why I think you are bad:

1) You hinted at your role early on

As I explained earlier with Epi, I think baddies are more likely to do this than civvies. Baddies know that civvies do not know that baddies have a safe role to claim, so the incentive of claiming a role becomes bigger since you can use the defence "I hinted at my role from the beginning. Clearly that means I am actually that role". You cannot use that defence after everyone else has hinted or claimed. Waiting till the last minute to hint or claim opens you up to suspicion, so why not do it nice and early as a baddie... like in your first post?

2) You seem afraid to name people you think are civ, thereby leaving the door open for a future lynch.

I looked through your posts, but you never go out of your way to proclaim someone a civ.

A glaring example of your hesitance to call anyone civ is with me and Sorsha. You always keep the back door open. You say that you trust Sorsha and me, but that we are not cleared. Later on, when I say I am 100% certain SVS would not kill me on Night 1, you say you will "keep it in mind"
It's Day 4, surely there are people out there now that you trust. It seems like you've paid attention to the game, so the fact that you aren't willing to say "I don't want to lynch that person, I'm pretty sure they are civ" combined with the fact that you've got nutella and zebra as your others doesn't make you look good. They are two people that I am pretty confident about.

I'd also like to hear from Bullzeye if he still thinks Zebra is bad and what he thinks about Epi/Scotty/Wilgy

I'm not used to that much text in one post in this game. I will read through it because you clearly put a lot of effort in it though.

Scotty, I'll try and formulate why I think you're bad tomorrow.

Can you give examples of what you are saying about Wilgy?

Scotty

Hey Epi who do you think are bad?

Rude

But Zebra isn't?

Nah it's epi and scotty

DrWilgy wrote: Matt, who is definitely not on your team other than Zebra?

What's with this then?

Who do you think are bad Wilgy?

CHAH-LEE, THEY TOOK MAH BAY-BEE

Gimme something to comment on Zebra