The Syndicate

...might have pushed Mongoose innocently, however Hedge seemed to go along with that and then now you. I think they are opposite teams if both bad, but I think statistically we need to vote Hedge with a higher chance of being bad. I hope that there aren't 4 baddies left and just 2 or we are in a he...

No, my bad, that is most likely what you said. I was mixed up, Hedgeowl is still alive, I meant Mongoose. Damn bird names.

Replace names, repeat question.

Hey all, sorry I haven't been around much, it's a combination of busy times and computer with hard drive sickness. Posting from my phone since forever, I have been keeping up, but I admit to possibly skimming some of the larger posts. A recent thing caught my attention, Boogs, you mentioned Bullzeye...

Ok, looks like a Mongoose lynch. I advocate this with a vote.

I also haven't changed my feelings on Mongoose. I will likely be voting for her or Bullzeye today. I find Bullzeye's arguments for Boogs' baddieness little thin. Just because we haven't seen a "curse" before, it doesn't mean it's fake. I've seen plenty of curse roles that can invent the w...

I also haven't changed my feelings on Mongoose. I will likely be voting for her or Bullzeye today. I find Bullzeye's arguments for Boogs' baddieness little thin. Just because we haven't seen a "curse" before, it doesn't mean it's fake. I've seen plenty of curse roles that can invent the wa...

Nooooo! Splintsy! Really sorry to see you go, I really felt like you brought an honest and direct angle to a lot of the discussions, in a way that really kept it real.

So she was the mysterious Herbert.

Good point about Keterman, Splints. That's the kind of basic Mafia detective work that sometimes gets ignored when there's a spicy tête-à-tête du jour.

llama has been lynched he was Dennis' Mom - a Civvie It is now night 7 Are you saying this is not llama's role/alignment? No, I'm saying that Dennis' Mom isn't revealed in the page 1 roles yet. Canuck, I think you've got the right idea. I was waiting till Mafia Dawn to talk about it, but I can't by...

If this so-called infodump is real, then I suspect that Boogs won't survive the night. Maybe we'll be able to assess his role and alignment by morning. Not that we have Llama's yet. I think. I'll check page 1.

Mongoose wrote:Llama was good.

He thought I was good.

Therefore, I must be good.

There are literally no holes in that logic.

Let's wait for his role to come up on the first page and see what we can ascertain from that.

Sorry, Llama, looks like you were a Civvie after all. LORB, why didst thou direct us to kill this innocent Llama? Interesting Boogs/Bullz back and forth. Bullzeye is reading like Vince Vaughn to me here. It's pretty good. However, I am going to vote LC this go round. I think he could have done more ...

The Civs believe in God more than they believe in you. Not that we've heard from Her in a while.

Juliets - yes I would think he is forced or would be punished. It's all a bit weird though. As bullz pointed out, why would someone curse a player who is barely posting? Let alone twice in a row? That is assuming there are two cursers (I'm operating under the assumption double targeting isn't allow...

Boogs is talking funny. Boogs is being forced to say these things. I can't wait to kill the curse-maker, or whatever it is. Sorry, Boogs, but if you want to convince me of Bullzeye's guilt, make a case on him on Day 8 please. For now, my vote goes to Llama. Voting now... I normally don't vote so ear...

So Boogs, you want us to not lynch Llama today?

juliets wrote:Should i know who Herbert is?

And RIP Keterman, nice to play with you.

He's the prince that just wants... to SING!

I searched back a bunch of pages (ten on 100 posts/page) and found no result for "more than a fe"... thought I might find a clue from Herbert, but nothing came up. RIP Keterman!

How about hosting LC?

MM, I think Lorab being concerned about you voting for her would happen if she were Civvie of baddie. You know? I don't understand what you're saying here. Maybe I read too much into your "maybe that's what you're worried about" post. I thought you were saying that worried means baddie , ...

MM, I think Lorab being concerned about you voting for her would happen if she were Civvie of baddie. You know? The stuff I've said makes sense to me in a microcosm way. Like if you have 10 mins to scroll through posts and do the best they can, they make sense. For you who have been around more and ...

I will try again, Mongoose. Any particular starting point you can give me?

I have to vote tonight and i am the most worried about Mongoose. I believe her comment about Canuck being a red herring was meant for baddie bts and she posted it here by mistake. That is further supported by her replies to long con... interesting theory. I haven't heard anything that makes any sen...

Now Mongoose voted Canuck... Such weird! Except the opposite because Canuck's not on the poll. I haven't been getting the civviest feelings from Mongoose's posts, but my real problem is llama. I have been pretty sure he is civ, but reevaluating if I am super off. People said Mongooses defense of hi...

Oops, yeah, Canuck voted Mongoose. Sorry for the error.

Now Mongoose voted Canuck... Such weird!

For Llama, you did an extra-creative, A-plus effort post in his defense. For Canuck, I've been trying for the last twelve hours to get what you're saying, and you've responded several times, and I still don't have a clue what you mean. Who is setting Canuck up? Why do you believe she's Civvie? When ...

I'm having trouble understanding still, are you saying she's a Civvie set up as a baddie?

Mongoose wrote:
juliets wrote:As I pointed out earlier, bwt was talking about ninjajellobabies and Canuck right before he died. His suspicion of Canuck seemed stronger. I personally believe she is a civ. I do agree that everyone should read it for themselves.
Canuck has got to be a red herring.

In what way?

As I recall, it was the way you said it. What Canuck said was not as suspicious to me, when I get back on a computer I'll try and go back, look, and explain why.

I think Canuck is Civ this game. I could be wrong, just think her posts are genuine.

I have to admit, as suspicious as I find you. I am fairly tempted to go after a quiet person this time, because I feel like the baddies are letting the noisy people kill each other while they stay silent. After Made and SVS, I am nervous about lynching another very active, high posting player. Seem...

RIP bwt ;( I don't like the limited poll options, but I wasn't around to help with the competition anyways so I guess I can't complain too much about being on the losing side. Given the way the conversation has been going, I find them quite a relief, actually. Yes, very timely! Congrats on the win.

Protip: Dennis doesn't know any more than the rest of us.

No change, my theory comes from the idea that he's got blind devotion to the idea he's a Civvie, and yet God insists very strongly that he is bad. Recruit makes sense.

I should just qualify that unprompted. Some people insist Llama is a Civvie, but God is adamant that he is bad. Maybe those people who are so steadfastly insistent he is Civvie should consider that Llama has turned bad, and their read on him, or info, is not reliable any more. He's pretty much the m...

Is S~V~S God? Is God likely to be a Civvie role? Well, maybe you all shouldn't have ignored my post. :) RIP, S~V~S, sorry I was after you for most of the game, I did back off when it was obvious you were God. I'm assuming the secret part of your role is something that led you to believe that Llama ...

Is S~V~S God? Is God likely to be a Civvie role? Well, maybe you all shouldn't have ignored my post. :) RIP, S~V~S, sorry I was after you for most of the game, I did back off when it was obvious you were God. I'm assuming the secret part of your role is something that led you to believe that Llama ...

Weird, Mongoose. :) Just to touch on the concept of "baddie behaviour" , there certainly is such a thing. Baddies have to do things that Civvies do not, things related to deception. It's just the natureof the game. Some are better at covering it than others. When I see someone accuse anoth...

And I am amused at the idea S~V~S and I are teammates. I'm sure she will be as well.

2) I think LC's sudden turn on llama for a comment I thought was rather innocuous to be...odd. I've seen other people accuse players of only being on when it's convenient and possibly being in a chat, so...not really understanding why THAT happened to be the comment that set him off. Is there more ...

You can do what you like, but tagging along with someone else's suspicion, accusing someone based on false evidence, backpedaling, and playing the "no u" card are all baddie behaviour.

"her posting pattern alone indicates" she's often in a Chatzy. The "alone" implies that that's just one reason out of multiple... What were the other reasons then? Do they exist, or were you just pushing her as a suspect because you were hoping people would listen to you and ask ...

So now you don't think she's bad, yet in this recent quote you said you've been increasingly suspicious of her.

So which is it?
Sorry for the weirdness, posting from phone and accidentally submitted early.

So now you I missed your thoughts on Canuck, Keterman. Now that I go back and look at them, they are astonishingly astute. I've been increasingly suspicious of Canuck this game as well. Her posting pattern alone indicates someone who spends most of their time in a chatzy and occasionally pops in to ...

thellama73 wrote:Why would I make a case on someone I don't necessarily think is bad and am not planning to vote for?

But if people had just gone along with your accusation then it would be a different story. They didn't, so now you're trying to back out.

Votes can change. Your refusal to make a case at all speaks volumes. If the rest of the thread still can't see what I see at this point, then you've got them right where you want them.

Not yet, I'll be happier when you give us the sample of posts you used to come to your conclusion. Take us through your logic, show us the case instead of mudslinging.

You avoided my question.

An observation about the frequency of Canuck's posts, right?

2) I think LC's sudden turn on llama for a comment I thought was rather innocuous to be...odd. I've seen other people accuse players of only being on when it's convenient and possibly being in a chat, so...not really understanding why THAT happened to be the comment that set him off. Is there more ...

Search found 22219 matches