The Syndicate

Nice... maybe I need to actually put my banners in my sig for once

MacDougall wrote:That they could have. That they could have.

No, the way I see it is you circle lot played way good and deserve the win more than most I've seen get it. Except Golden. He's a stinky traitorous swine.

I was kind of upset that you didn't get to try your buddy up to Timmer idea. Once you posted it in the chat I copy and pasted it in our Circle chat.... we had a good laugh

Golden- I'm really surprised you didn't suspect me once sig and Epignosis were taken out like right after you and I met.

The fleshstone was actually intended for killing statues, turning them from stone to flesh, getting around the whole no NK thing. It was activated when Matt became the Avenging Statue but could have been used to kill Dom also. It's side effect I guess, was that if you used it on flesh (Golden) it would make him stone and the kill would fail.

linki- what Dom said

Epignosis wrote:Have civilians ever won in a recruitment / map game?

Civs won the LOST map game on Rev Mafia.

Metalmarsh89 wrote:I don't think Sorsha liked my poetry either.

What poetry?

Metalmarsh89 wrote:For the record. Mac, Sorsha, and Golden (and those in that giant BTSC on I think Day 7). I really did think SVS was a civilian then. She didn't tell me until afterward otherwise.

I don't think anyone believe me that Sorsha was bad until it was too late though.

I thought she was civ in G9 also, I had a few moments of doubt though. I tried stealing from her as we left G9 and she came back as the Essence Elemental and I think I believed it for about a minute. My team didn't really believe me that she was bad either. When did you know I was bad MM?

Metalmarsh89 wrote:

MacDougall wrote:Also who the fuck blew up the summoning circle with me on it?

Apparently that was fingersplints. She set the beacon off the day before we all arrived.

SVS told me it was her that set it off, splints just thought she did it with the beacon.

MacDougall wrote:Golden managed to have a baddie from both teams there claiming they were confirmed good, and one of them brought their puppy with them.



And he gets recruited and gets to win the game.

We were making fun of golden and his LD skills quite a bit before we recruited him

Epignosis wrote:

Black Rock wrote:If the civvies only voted for Dom. They would have had a chance. What a nail biting game. LC thought it would have been over a week ago, but the Circle got confident and made some mistakes. Such a close game. Well done all players.

I was really hoping Matt F would get to play his new role. That would have really fucked up the bad guys. You played an excellent game Matt, it was really fun hosting you.

To my dear Witherdeath friends, I was really rooting for you guys. Such bad luck for you guys.

Congrats to the winners, even if that includes Turnip Head. That's for picking on me in games.

I die for crazy reasons in your games. That why civilians lose.

We had the option of using the Obsidian Dagger and our usual night kill to either double tap Golden and save me from getting caught by his LD or to take you and sig out and try to recruit Dom.

It was close, we were ready to kill Golden but then I made a crappy LD statement that he fell for so we went with plan B. It was also amazing luck that timmer ended up on the same square as you and sig when you got the Star Gem. TH was able to track you and go for the kill to get the Gem after timmer killed sig.

MacDougall wrote:I can't even begin to figure out how this even begins to make sense. Dom, Golden, Sorsha, HB... teammates. Wow. HamburgerBoy of all people...

Golden was recruited by us when HB died. So at the time of the gathering in G9 golden was still a civ.

Great game guys. Awesome team!



Can we just play this game again?

Metalmarsh89 wrote:

Sorsha wrote:

LoRab wrote:*hands Sorsha some zombie wine*
*offers Sorsha some popcorn*

Thanks LoRab!

To the civs!

Welcome to Deadytown.

Thanks

LoRab wrote:*hands Sorsha some zombie wine*
*offers Sorsha some popcorn*

Thanks LoRab!

To the civs!

*calls the Ghostbusters*

Dom wrote:

Sorsha wrote:What Dom

Just... it makes me uneasy.

I'm not happy either

What Dom

Draconus wrote:Golden and Sorsha, I'm sure you're right about SVS. Hypothetical: After lynching her, who would you vote for, and in what order (assuming there are 2 or 3 baddies left)?

I feel the same as I did here:

Sorsha wrote:Tranq might be completely right about Dom and LoRab being Circle. The problem with your case Tranq is that if we save svs for "last" and she's not actually the last Cabal. Civs lose.

I'm fine with lynching Dom or LoRab tomorrow after we find out if svs is the last Cabal.

I want SVS lynched today because I think she is cabal. Unfortunately things have happened and if I keep my vote on svs today it could mean I'm a goner here too so I'll be moving my vote to LoRab. I'm not happy about this.

Linki: *feeds SVS's raccoon some cookies and pats it on the head nicely*

SVS's mission is to kill all the circle members for killing MM. Why would she make a deal with one?

S~V~S wrote:Sorry for all the multi posts. I amwaiting for someone to say something, anything, and it isn't happening.

SVS LIST OF WHO IS NOT CIRCLE

Draco
Golden
Splints
SVS
Tranq

COULD BE CIRCLE

Sorsha

If there are 2 original circle left plus the recruit, then it has to be Sorsha. If only one,I apologize, Sorsha. Telling me you stabbed my raccoon was not helpful.

NO REASON TO THINK THEY ARE ANYTHING BUT CIRCLE

Lorab
Dom

Everyone on that first list i have very very very good reasons to think they are either civs, or people not involved in the death of Metalmarsh.

If you know different, Lorab, please tell me

Linki,so Sorsha,maybe Draco,maybe Splints? Maybe Tranq?

That is who you think is potentially in the circle?

Lol... That raccoon thing was a joke svs, come on. That's not even something that could happen...

Or what if there is no deal and Tranq is just a member of the cabal with svs?

The fact that players are not voting for a sure thing makes me think that svs is not the last cabal member. What is we save her for "last" and she's not actually the last one?

I thought it was pretty obvious from the night post that MM and TImmer killed each other? And why wouldn't TImmer kill MM if he know MM was coming for him? What am I missing here?

Golden wrote:

Sorsha wrote:Because we don't know for sure Tranq is bad Golden. If svs isn't the last Cabal then I'll consider a Tranq vote.

How do we know for sure SVS is bad?

Right now I don't feel sure of anyone, but I feel most strong about tranq.

I think there is more evidence of that than of Tranq.

Because we don't know for sure Tranq is bad Golden. If svs isn't the last Cabal then I'll consider a Tranq vote.

Yeah... And I don't like the idea of making deals with baddies. I understand why svs is upset but we can get the circle lynched tomorrow. I'm like 100% certain that I won't live through the night if svs lives today.

Tranq might be completely right about Dom and LoRab being Circle. The problem with your case Tranq is that if we save svs for "last" and she's not actually the last Cabal. Civs lose.

I'm fine with lynching Dom or LoRab tomorrow after we find out if svs is the last Cabal.

I'd like to see the case/post Tranq makes about Dom and LoRab but right now I see a lot of assumptions and a few things I disagree with in his summary there.... mainly the stuff about what the possible roles are and what their secrets might be.

I definitely want to explore circle suspicions but SVS is a sure thing imo.

LoRab and Dom- who are your circle member suspicions?

Oh look, timmer got himself off the poll again

Well I guess I'll take that! RIH Lich!

Aww why you vote me TH?

Because he is basically an alignment checker.

And you don't know Goldens role?

Well then MM and SVS, explain to me then how I've "tricked" or "played" Golden. You both seem to believe him civ, I have proven my role to him beyond his checks and you guys know I'm not the trickster. So how would I possibly be anything but civ here? I'm not understanding.

Understood!

Something else just occurred to me as I was washing dishes.

Golden shouldn't have too much doubt over my role. Iirc I was able to prove it to him before he even checked me. So as far as me not being the trickster there shouldn't be a doubt in his mind, and if I'm not the trickster then there would be no way for me to fool his check.

I have no problem with him checking again or whatever but if golden is to be believed then I don't know how he could seriously be doubting me. But paranoia, so yeah.

I don't remember exactly where the hall is... D2 I think? But if you know he was at the tribunal then that must be one of the ways it's happening so there are a minimum of three then.

I think that chances of it not being svs are extremely unlikely, as in nil.

What do you think of Tranq? I forgot that he'd been rezzed.

I'm not bad LoRab and Goldens trust in me isn't misplaced. I'm a civ and always have been.

To me, preventing the creation of a serial killer seems important. If we lynch the wrong person (if the watched person is not SVS) then we will have an extra kill at night and at this point in the game that seems really dangerous!

I was asking about the hall of mirrors because I thought maybe that's where timmer is and not the tribunal. I don't want to underestimate the numbers on his team but maybe it isn't as many as we think. It doesn't sound like they even attempted a kill on their last night which could be because there was no one near. But I don't know. It's most likely the tribunal, I'm just trying to look at other angles.

Tranq wrote:

Sorsha wrote:To ensure our safety after eliminating the Cabal, MM needs to go first. I don't see a way around it.

And is there a way to remove a player from the poll in the hall of mirrors? If there is then maybe there are fewer circle than I thought.

There are several ways around it.
- Circle NKs MM
- Circle NKs SVS
- We eliminate Circle and lynch SVS

Name 1 dead Circle. Name 2 dead Circles.

Tbh you aren't doing a very good job convincing me you aren't Circle after all. I don't want to believe it, but this doesn't sound like a Sorsha trying to get a civ win.

Your plan atm is the following:
- lynch a role nobody needs dead
- let the Circle NK someone
- lynch SVS
- let the Circle NK someone
- at which point we have 7 players alive including 3-4 Circle members. If there's 4 it's game over. If it's 3 we have to hope Skrippletitz is dead or it's game over.

How is this a better plan than lynching one of the Circle Jerks today?

This is why I can't be left alone Tranq! :P I blame you for going and getting yourself killed.

Ok, so if we lynch TH today there shouldn't be enough left to get timmer off the poll tomorrow and we can lynch him tomorrow.

How do we know the circle will kill mm and svs though?

To ensure our safety after eliminating the Cabal, MM needs to go first. I don't see a way around it.

And is there a way to remove a player from the poll in the hall of mirrors? If there is then maybe there are fewer circle than I thought.

Don't you need the Cabal dead to win Tranq?

Circle= timmer, maybe TH or Dom, maybe you. LoRab I doubt is and splints is maybe a maybe. But most likely TH and Dom.

Is there a way to get off the poll at the hall of mirrors?

Metalmarsh89 wrote:Sorsha.

Metalmarsh89 wrote:

Sorsha wrote:What do you think of SVS?

What about you?

She bad.

Tranq wrote:lol @ the random votes already. Timmer is off the poll again. Again, was anyone asked if they wanted to take him off the poll? He has to have 2 or 3 teammates helping him out.

We need a landslide Circle lynch today or the game will be over soon. TH is our best bet at that, let's just hope he isn't Scrippleskitz.
Dom: Why aren't you voting TH? Name your best guess at Timmer's 2-3 teammates.
Sorsha: Why aren't you voting TH? Name your best guess at Timmer's 2-3 teammates.
MM: Why aren't you voting TH? Name your best guess at Timmer's 2-3 teammates.

Is TH confirmed baddie?

What do you think of SVS, MM and LoRab?

Turnip Head wrote:

Sorsha wrote:When you were poisoned? I'm too lazy to go look now, what day?

I know svs did one day too, the day you apparently got cured. Not very nice of her.

Night 1

Tranq was on my case as soon as I mentioned it too. Like a piranha to blood in the water.

Jeeze TH learn to read. What day did Golden vote for you not what day were you poisoned.

Should I yell at Mac for creeping in the thread like he did to me during Talking Heads?

@ Mac. Hammy too

When you were poisoned? I'm too lazy to go look now, what day?

I know svs did one day too, the day you apparently got cured. Not very nice of her.

Turnip Head wrote:Where's all this talk about MM coming from? He's flown under the radar most of the game, with nary a peep about him from anyone.

Remember when he voted for you when you were poisoned? That wasn't very nice of him.

Metalmarsh89 wrote:

Sorsha wrote:

Metalmarsh89 wrote:Sorsha

Congrats on not dying fingerplints.

No U

You're obviously bad. A civ Sorsha would not benefit from lynching me.

Every civ on this game needs you dead in order to win. I am a civ. I need you dead to win.

Linki- what do you think of LoRab then MM?

Metalmarsh89 wrote:

Turnip Head wrote:

Metalmarsh89 wrote:Sorsha

Congrats on not dying fingerplints.

What do you think of Golden? I'm more or less 100% sure he's bad.

I'm pretty sure he's civ tbqh.

Between him and Sorsha, I think Sorsha is far more likely to be evil.

What do you think of SVS?

Metalmarsh89 wrote:Sorsha

Congrats on not dying fingerplints.

No U

timmer wrote:Why am I never on the poll?

Maybe you're already dead.......

I'm more upset that he seems to be doubting everything when not everything he knows is wrong than I am that he may or may not trust me anymore.

There's also the possibility that he isn't distrusting as much as he seems to be I don't know, I'm tired.

I posted a couple days ago about why I'm focused on Cabal:

Sorsha wrote:

S~V~S wrote:Personally I think, as I said regarding Bass, that letting the Circle entrench further and then handing them the Cabals kill is a bad idea. Especially if Sorsha is wrong about this person.

I am sure about 3 out of 4, not so much the 4th. I need to do some reading today.

Normally I agree, but if we eliminate one team and are all focused towards the same goal of eliminating the circle I think the lynches are going to become clearer for us.

I think if we eliminate one team and are just civs vs 1 baddie team it's going to be much easier to come together. Rather than civ v bad team 1 vs bad team 2. Its easier to fight a war on one front than two. If timmer is on the poll tomorrow I'll likely go for him though I'm very, very concerned about a potential SK working with the Cabal though so I don't know for sure.

I think the circle has a minimum of three left. Timmer and anyone of TH, LoRab, Dom, Draco or you could be even. I thought I could trust who Golden trusted but now it seems like he's not even trusting who he trusted which really upsets me tbh. I was the one who pointed out a few days ago that I believed he was mistaken about someone and its led to him not trusting anyone it seems.

If you think Dom is Cabal do you think he is the last one?