The Syndicate

Bullzeye wrote:
Matt wrote: Dead Floyd - You can't answer, but I'm having trouble with your last post. I'd like to know what your "legitimate reason" of voting me was, considering you are the rolechecker? Seriously wtf? The only thing I can think of is you checked Bullz and he checked out civvie, so you figured I was a baddie going after him?
The obvious solution to this is that he checked you and you came back bad. Not sure why you're even asking him since as you point out he can't answer.

This. I think Floyd checking Matt night one makes sense. Voting Matt.

TheFloyd73 wrote:I'm honestly appaulled. I go away for two days after I make a legitimate vote with reason.

Civs, you're fucked.

Appalled*

You do you. I do me.

Scotty wrote:
Sorsha wrote:Seeing as the doctor and the cop are accounted for and there is a third power role out there I don't understand zebras insistence that him role claiming would be so detrimental to the civvie cause. I could see a couple of the roles already claimed fitting with a power so I'm not inclined to trust his claim.
I understand the hesitancy beforehand, (and I'm still slightly mad at you for claiming so early ) because at that point there was still secrecy that could be used to our advantage. I don't trust ANY claims except you right now.

Typhoony wrote:Are we to assume that all 3 power roles are civs btw?
Well I never thought of that, but I find that unlikely in any case. OR at least I hope so.

Don't be mad at me, be mad at the redneck jackass

I suppose one of the baddies could have a power role.. Wouldn't rule it out.

Seeing as the doctor and the cop are accounted for and there is a third power role out there I don't understand zebras insistence that him role claiming would be so detrimental to the civvie cause. I could see a couple of the roles already claimed fitting with a power so I'm not inclined to trust his claim.

Bullzeye wrote:
Sorsha wrote:I interpreted what Typh said as not all the roles from the show made it into the game and Golden told the others what roles are not in the game i.e. Safe to fake claim.

Linki- I was hoping you were Kate and that Jack saved Kate last night but ok, Shannon.

I'm pretty sure Kate would have made the cut... Anyone going to claim that?
I literally did in my last post. Bolded it and everything.

Sorry... It didn't show up in my linky

I interpreted what Typh said as not all the roles from the show made it into the game and Golden told the others what roles are not in the game i.e. Safe to fake claim.

Linki- I was hoping you were Kate and that Jack saved Kate last night but ok, Shannon.

I'm pretty sure Kate would have made the cut... Anyone going to claim that?

Ok these are the hints/claims that I have found:

Zebra- won't claim
Long Con- Locke
DrWilgy- Michael
Sorsha- jack
Nutella-Jin
Scotty- Charlie
Bullzeye- couldn't see any hints
Typhoony- no hint but I'm pretty sure he's a lostie
Matt- sun
S~V~S- Sayid
Epignosis- Sawyer
--------
Floyd- Hurley
DF- Boone

Typhoony wrote:
a2thezebra wrote:Because of what you said in these two posts, or is there more to it?
Typhoony wrote:I am tempted to vote Floyd for breaking this glorious tie, or Epi for not making it an even bigger tie.

But I'll change my vote to SVS for now, because she seemed to be setting up a vote on DF if Matt wasn't going to post something suspicious here, which he seemingly has done now. I don't see it, but okay.

Typhoony wrote:I'd like to hear more from Epi.

He hasn't made a case yet that made me go "wtf have you been smoking today" and it's almost Day 2.
First one was nonsense.
Second one was genuine.
His case on SVS did not make me think "wtf have you been smoking".

In Pikmin I was comfortable with Epi's posts from the beginning and never really feel like lynching him. In this game, none of his posts are making me comfortable.
There's also the very obvious Sawyer roleclaim. I think that Golden did indeed give the baddies fake roles to claim, making roleclaims completely useless, and Sawyer is the perfect role for Epi to claim since he fits that role naturally (minus the being a hunk ofcourse). I could see Epi acting like Sawyer in a Lost game regardless of if he had that role or not, but now he went over the top, enjoying it just a bit too much for me to think he is doing this as a civ.

I'd love to see Sayid come and torture Sawyer like in the show

Sorsha wrote:
nutella wrote:@ sorsha - Wilgy already said hasn't even seen Lost, so no way he'd make that up.

anyway, shit, RIP Floyd. Kinda weird how those votes suddenly happened, I'm not really clear on why. But I just want to lynch Zebra even more.
I disagree that he'd make it upon he's on a team.

I disagree that he'd make it up if he's on a team*

nutella wrote:@ sorsha - Wilgy already said hasn't even seen Lost, so no way he'd make that up.

anyway, shit, RIP Floyd. Kinda weird how those votes suddenly happened, I'm not really clear on why. But I just want to lynch Zebra even more.

I disagree that he'd make it upon he's on a team.

Ok I get it now svs

DrWilgy wrote:Can we please lynch Zebra now?

Im Dawson... Roleless and boring

I see no reason for hinting at what we are since RC'ing is allowed. May as well and claim while we can.

And wilgy picks the lamest role to claim. I'm not sure I believe you, Sir.

S~V~S wrote:I have decided to return to the beach, thus changing my story arc; even though Epi & I differ, I still believe we were both on the plane.

And Scotty, I was referring to Typh. He seems to be seeing something different than I am seeing. This both makes me nervous, and makes me want to second guess mysefl. Although on short eracquaintance, I also trust your judgment when you are civ. So there is that too. I have to think on all of this.

I took this to mean. Returning to the beach, away from the caves. How did you mean it?

S~V~S wrote:
DrWilgy wrote:Yay nihilism!

Was Lost just spoiled for me? I was lookong forward to watching it! Kappa

@Scotty I haven't had the opportunity to catch up, only lightly skim so my thoughts remain the same.
Not really, no. Since many of us originally came from a LOST forum, it did not occur to me that LOST spoilers would be a problem. But that was not really a spoiler, it was more my bitter & jaded reaction to what might have been a spoiler ha ha.

Linki, ooo interesting. I wonder if anyone got my hints, probably everyone or noone ha ha.

All i saw was a hint at being one of the losties who were staying at the caves.

That would be:
Jack
Hurley
Jin
Sun
Locke
Charlie
Claire
Michael
Walt

The first four have been claimed already and I caught a hint from someone for the Locke role also. All of those roles can't possibly be in the game though as I'm sure we would have a Kate, we have a dumb redneck as well and Boone was DF. I guess it depends on which roles golden would include in the game but the list is pretty narrow for who you could possibly be.

Since golden says it's ok for us to list what people have claimed or hinted at I'm going to work on a list, I'm not always the greatest at picking up hints so I hope someone else would do so as well.

Ok. Well, you don't have to switch your vote to her out of courtesy to me. I'd rather have you vote for who you're suspicious of.

Do you think svs would have tried killing you night 1?

I protected typhoony last night

Oh... were you really going to change your vote anyway?!?! Give me a break. In all my years playing mafia I have played with quite a few bullies but you really take the cake. Congrats!

I'll wait to hear from everyone else if they want that revealed or not. If the person who I protected says no, I'm not saying.

What happens is if I don't get lynched I die tonight. So thanks for ruining the game for me Epi.

Ok smart ass. I'm Jack.... Wanna know who I protected last night? Sure as fuck wasn't you.

Apparently not. What's role claiming going to do? I say I'm civ, you say I'm lying. I claim a role and what.... All of a sudden you'll believe me?

You want me to role claim? Just know that it's more important that a dumb redneck.

That's right, you don't know a thing about me, or my role.

I don't necessarily find you suspicious no.... but I do think you are a hypocrite... I gave better reasoning for my Matt vote than you did your nutella vote. By your reasoning I should be finding you suspicious but at least I can admit that I'm not good at reading you, something that you would never admit about me.

And I will not vote for myself. I'd rather die and have my CIV role revealed and prove you wrong again.

Oh... She want playing ok right. Did you say that then? Or did just just vote without giving a reason?

What was your reason for voting nutella on day one Epi?

Sorsha wrote:I guess I should just random vote like you n day one. What was your reason for voting nutella again? I had a looksee and couldn't find one.

I guess I should just random vote like you n day one. What was your reason for voting nutella again? I had a looksee and couldn't find one.

No mafia ever does that. Right. Ok. Thanks for the education Epi.

Vote for me all you want Epi, when have you ever been right about me? Not once that I can remember.

Day one and my vote for someone fucking sucked, sue me ok Epi, its day fucking one.

The fact that Matt make a joke post about wanting to vote someone and once people weren't following his lead he turned it into a real suspicion. To me that was suspicious. like he just wanted bullz voted out but he had no good reason.

Exactly... what is wrong with that? Nothing. You're the one finding something wrong with it.

Well I'm sorry my suspicions don't fit to your outline of how a suspicion should look but that is what it is.

I don't really care about your hang ups with the word "seem." Matt made a post that seemed like it was joking. Then he got serious about his suspicion when before it had "seemed" like he wasn't serious.

I questioned him about his bullz suspicion before those posts... Guess you need another looksee.

Yes I did explain why I found Matt suspicious on day one. You go have yourself another nice looksee.

And ok, you're right my suspicion of LC and nutella was from night one but it still stands for today since night one and day two are when we all talk about our day two lynch candidates.

Woah there Cowboy! I think you need to get your eyes checked. I have named suspicions. Matt day one. LC, nutella day two so far and now SVS. Zebra is raising some alarms also.

Typhoony wrote:I voted Sorsha for now. I feel like she's been putting in just enough effort to skirt by, but not enough effort to stand out.

No U

I'm voting for SVS until I hear some suspicions from her. I feel like she's laying low lately (lately being today pretty much).

After reviewing my suspects from yesterday I'm not sure I want to vote for any of them right now.

I still feel kinda iffy on zebra and Floyd but Nutella and LC have taken a back seat for the moment. I'd like to hear some suspicions from Nutella though. And from SVS- who are you most suspicious of today SVS?

Lol- that reply to BR belongs in the champions game

Matt wrote:Zeebs, I'm not bad dudette. Nobody saved me to my knowledge, and if they did, it's one of two possibilities...

a) Someone who voted DF is a cop, got a good guy check at the beginning, and got me.

b) There are baddies in the DF voters who intentionally "saved" me only to get me lynched the next day.

Or

c) Bullz is bad, let's get 'em! (and SVS, too!)

Do you still think bullz and svs are bad today? My suspicion of you is lessened today and I doubt I'll be voting for you again. Your defensive posts yesterday sound genuine to me.

@Scotty- I like your suspicion list. I'll have to review Floyd and zebra a bit more but I agree on LC and Nutella.

LCs voting antics yesterday aren't sitting right with me- especially the back and fourth on DFaraday at the end. It looks like a baddie not sure if he wants to be involved in a civ lynch to me.

@BR- thanks for clearing that up!

nutella wrote:Whoops, sorry, I kinda forgot about this game today.
RIP DF. I've caught up but I don't really get all the hullabaloo between him and Matt and as usual I'm really not taking anything away from Day 1 nonsense. There's really no way to glean much of anything from that, and if anything I'd lean towards thinking the people getting more involved in the discussion are not the baddies.

Epignosis wrote:I'm votin for my spottieottiedopaliscious nutella. Damn damn damn damn.
????? What even

Yeah, sorry I've been under the radar so far, but I didn't really have any thoughts yesterday since it was just getting started and I didn't remember to catch up until after the lynch. (I'll be gone all day tomorrow too but it'll be night so hopefully I won't miss as much discussion) otherwise I'll try to pay more attention and start to form some thoughts on day 2. Honestly even though my vote for Floyd was pretty pseudo-random I wouldn't mind pursuing him a bit since he also seems to have remained pretty under-the-radar.

Ok... So the people participating in the discussion are not the baddies but you are not participating in the discussion.

And you vote for Floyd for being under the radar but he's really been more present than you have been...

RIP BooneFaraday

@Matt- I didn't think you were picking on him. You just started out kinda jokey about the bullz thing then turned serious about it when no one was agreeing.

Going to make this a 4 way tie and vote for Matt, for now.

Matt wrote:If Bullz were lynched and ended up civvie, just know deep down he was really mafia and wanted a town loss. I'm surprised more players aren't aware of Bullzeye's consistent anti-town sentiment.

You seem like you're taking this lynch bullz a bit more seriously here whereas you were saying earlier it was more jokey.

Long Con wrote:
nutella wrote:
TheFloyd73 wrote:G'day, I'm finally here.
Matt, I'm assuming you're voting for Bullz due to being scum in other matches. What makes you certain that they are scum here?
Nutella, care to explain your vote?
I don't really have an explanation. It's day one and votes are changeable so I threw it on. Call it a random hunch, it's pretty meaningless. Like reading tea leaves.
Give us an Oracle-like reading of the tea leaves then - what did you see that made you vote for Floyd instead of DFaraday or Epignosis?

Nutella... Did you see...... A GRIMM!?!?

Sorsha wrote:
Matt wrote:I've never played a Lost game before, this will be fun!

Liking Zeebs right now, she seems like her scary civ self...

Bullz, why shouldn't everyone vote for you Day one?
You like Zeebs this game... What do you think about her thoughts on wilgy this game? Agree or disagree?

Ebwop

Matt wrote:I've never played a Lost game before, this will be fun!

Liking Zeebs right now, she seems like her scary civ self...

Bullz, why shouldn't everyone vote for you Day one?

You like Serbs this game... What do you think about her thoughts on wilgy this game? Agree or disagree?

Sorsha wrote:
Bullzeye wrote:
S~V~S wrote:Did you see that dinasaur? I'm going back to the beach.

diarmeyhowley wrote:recently i was watching a lost video on youtube.i noticed a flash of white smoke just arriving before the back smoke in dis video.i would like other people to look at it and tell me what they tink.around a year ago i herd da rumour dat the black smoke was invisable dinasaurs, sounds stupid i know. but wen luking at dis video i seen da flash of white smoke.it was at 13 seconds in.its really hard 2 pause took me like 20 pauses.its between da tree and the house.wen pausing i seen wat luks alot like a dinousasurs head.it may be my* mind playin tricks,but my friends agree with it being a dinasaur head.please luk at it nd get bk 2 me......i cant give a link cuz im new on dis.on youtube type in ''lost season 5 begins february 4,2009(video 1 of 2)'' ....13 seconds in,it will take a while 2 pause right on da spotil try and send da pic i got as atachment
I wonder about that guy sometimes. Like does he know just how crazy a cult following that thread got? It literally spawned an entire community which is still active to this day (I assume, haven't visited Hedville myself in a long time!). If he hadn't posted his groundbreaking theory about dinasaurs so many many things would never have happened and LP would've been a very different place. I wonder how he feels about his bizarre internet fame. Do you think it's something he often tells people about?
Didn't he host a mafia game at Hedville?

Nevermind it wasn't diarmy it was lostwillnevarend with his Lilo & Stitch

Search found 52 matches