Search found 101 matches

by Gotrees
Sun Nov 02, 2014 12:51 am
Forum: Previous Jobs
Topic: Dr. Who Mafia - Night 12
Replies: 7359
Views: 189373

Re: Dr. Who Mafia - Night 12

Long Con wrote:Too many recruits, too much freedom of recruiting. I figured when Epig was saying the Civs had no chance that he was speaking from a behind-the-scenes perspective, and that this end is what he meant.
I think he actually started saying that even before we had recruited him.
by Gotrees
Sat Nov 01, 2014 10:37 pm
Forum: Previous Jobs
Topic: Dr. Who Mafia - Night 12
Replies: 7359
Views: 189373

Re: Dr. Who Mafia - Night 12

:D

Good game, everyone! I really had fun!
by Gotrees
Sat Nov 01, 2014 9:47 pm
Forum: Previous Jobs
Topic: Dr. Who Mafia - Night 12
Replies: 7359
Views: 189373

Re: Dr. Who Mafia - Night 12

You've convinced me. Someone rezz this guy already.
by Gotrees
Sat Nov 01, 2014 2:42 am
Forum: Previous Jobs
Topic: Dr. Who Mafia - Night 12
Replies: 7359
Views: 189373

Re: Dr. Who Mafia - Day 12

Sorry Dom.

I can't help but feel like that just about confirms it. :(
by Gotrees
Thu Oct 30, 2014 8:20 pm
Forum: Previous Jobs
Topic: Dr. Who Mafia - Night 12
Replies: 7359
Views: 189373

Re: Dr. Who Mafia - Day 11

Yep, after that last lynch I'm gonna have to go with Dom again.

Sorta disappointed the Cybers didn't go for him last night, but oh well, at least we possibly have the recruiter out of the way.

RIP ZeeKeys.

linki Chris - I would say to keep the Cybers around to help target Dom (both with their night kills and their votes during the lynches) until he's dead, but after last night, idk. At least it was generally assumed that zeek was bad, I think, so maybe they were still working in favor of a temporary civ-cyber alliance.
by Gotrees
Tue Oct 28, 2014 10:27 pm
Forum: Previous Jobs
Topic: Dr. Who Mafia - Night 12
Replies: 7359
Views: 189373

Re: Dr. Who Mafia - Day 11

Chris wrote:So to be clear Gotrees, you're voting Dom based on your gut that he's bad?

And fewer lives left to be lost? He never survived an NK...

I don't understand your vote to be honest...


LINKI @ LC: No, Snow Dog is The Cyber Head.
I voted Dom because he seems more bad than DF.
by Gotrees
Tue Oct 28, 2014 10:22 pm
Forum: Previous Jobs
Topic: Dr. Who Mafia - Night 12
Replies: 7359
Views: 189373

Re: Dr. Who Mafia - Day 11

Chris wrote:Gotrees, you plan on voting? I see you there lurking...
Yes.
by Gotrees
Tue Oct 28, 2014 10:21 pm
Forum: Previous Jobs
Topic: Dr. Who Mafia - Night 12
Replies: 7359
Views: 189373

Re: Dr. Who Mafia - Day 11

Okay, I'm a bit late to the party (sorry), but it looks like it's between Dom and DF right now. I don't want to waste my vote again, so I'm gonna vote Dom tonight.

Between the two, I just don't understand how it could be DF. As a quieter player, I sympathize with him, and he comes across as genuine to me. At the very beginning of the game, Dom was overly-anxious to vote for Made, and I think he got some slack for that because most people ended up agreeing with him, but lately he seems to be a lot less anxious to accuse people like that. Might it be because he has fewer lives left to lose?

With everyone else's theories thrown in as well, the arrows point more to Dom tonight, it seems to me.
by Gotrees
Sat Oct 25, 2014 10:44 pm
Forum: Previous Jobs
Topic: Dr. Who Mafia - Night 12
Replies: 7359
Views: 189373

Re: Dr. Who Mafia - Day 10

Blooper, thanks for the response. It seems genuine enough, although I'm still going to keep an eye on you. I still have a few pages left to read through, but I've got to go to dinner right now and don't want to miss a vote. For now I'm going to stick my vote on Elo. I do see the suspicion behind Bass, and do think he will probably turn up bad. I approve of him being lynched tonight. However, due to the fact that Elo still hasn't responded to me, AND the fact that it looks like she can potentially be the master, I'm gonna put my vote there to hopefully try to get a response out of her. I'm in a rush right now, but I have a few less-urgent things to say when I get back.
by Gotrees
Fri Oct 24, 2014 1:00 am
Forum: Previous Jobs
Topic: Dr. Who Mafia - Night 12
Replies: 7359
Views: 189373

Re: Dr. Who Mafia - Day 10

Aww, such a romantic story. :(

RIP you two.
by Gotrees
Thu Oct 23, 2014 11:37 pm
Forum: Previous Jobs
Topic: Dr. Who Mafia - Night 12
Replies: 7359
Views: 189373

Re: Dr. Who Mafia - Night 9

keys56000000000 wrote:If I die, look towards Bass, DF, Gotrees, Nijuukyoshryuken, and maybe even Dom, Elocin and BR (although I'm more doubtful about those three) as your remaining mafioso.
Metalmarsh89 wrote:keys is a she right? Or did I misread somewhere?
Correct.
Keys, I really wish you could elaborate on why you suspect me. I've answered pretty much everyone else's questions, but it's really hard for me to respond to you when your argument is "I have a gut feeling."
by Gotrees
Thu Oct 23, 2014 11:08 pm
Forum: Previous Jobs
Topic: Dr. Who Mafia - Night 12
Replies: 7359
Views: 189373

Re: Dr. Who Mafia - Night 9

Gotrees wrote:
nijuukyugou wrote:Shit, I thought the poll ended late like the other nights. Sorry, hosts :(
Ms Bloops I'm still awaiting a reply from you.
http://www.mafiathesyndicate.com/viewto ... 481#p92481
by Gotrees
Thu Oct 23, 2014 11:07 pm
Forum: Previous Jobs
Topic: Dr. Who Mafia - Night 12
Replies: 7359
Views: 189373

Re: Dr. Who Mafia - Night 9

nijuukyugou wrote:Shit, I thought the poll ended late like the other nights. Sorry, hosts :(
Ms Bloops I'm still awaiting a reply from you.
by Gotrees
Thu Oct 23, 2014 8:23 pm
Forum: Previous Jobs
Topic: Dr. Who Mafia - Night 12
Replies: 7359
Views: 189373

Re: Dr. Who Mafia - Night 9

zeek wrote:Night poll:

Tigus - Under Galatic Heritage in the novels, i.e. protection, the Doctor was stranded here once for all of five minutes before he worked out an escape.

Uranus - Mining of Uranus helped power the Time Destructor created by the Daleks. Some not so nice species like the Ice Warriors went to a moon there to observe a reaction on the surface of the planet.

Woman Wept - Visited by the Doc and Rose once (unseen), the whole planet was also taken by Davros and the Daleks during the Stolen Earth storyline, when they tried to use the Reality Bomb.

Vulcan - Human colony almost taken over by the Daleks. Doctor saved the planet and the Dalek survivors went into the Dalek Asylum.


Tigus sounds safest.
Thanks for doing this, zeek. One thing I'd like to add though: at first glance Tigus looks to be the obvious choice, but I don't think it is. If you look at the guy who tried to get the Doctor stranded there, he was a Time Lord named The Monk. From The Monk's wiki page:
For some time there was speculation that the Monk was actually an earlier incarnation of the Master or the War Chief,
In an alternative timeline, the Monk cooperated alongside the Master, the Rani and Drax to try to destroy the world using a DNA recombinator, turning the human race into a gestalt consciousness which could be used as a weapon to conquer the universe.
That sounds absolutely terrifying. And also very Master-y.

Woman Wept, on the other hand, might be the best option for this vote. In fact, I'm almost sure of it:
According to REF: The Doctor's Lives and Times, the race for Enlightenment began in orbit of Woman Wept.
Enlightenment was a prize offered to a group of Eternals by the White Guardian and Black Guardian in a race. [...] It was claimed to bring anyone's heart's desire to life and Wrack wanted to win so she would never be bored again.
it was revealed that Enlightenment was in fact the ability to choose between good and evil, concepts of which the Eternals had no knowledge. Turlough threw the diamond at the Black Guardian and upon contact with Enlightenment he was consumed by flames from the blinding light of the prize.
So, looks like if Woman Wept goes through, we might get the opportunity to bring somebody back to life, OR to tell the difference "between good and evil."

I imagine the hosts must've put up a bunch of Dalek planets expecting us to go for the non-Dalek, Master-related planet. But now that the Daleks are dead, I don't know what we have to lose. Gonna vote for Woman Wept.
by Gotrees
Thu Oct 23, 2014 7:18 pm
Forum: Previous Jobs
Topic: Dr. Who Mafia - Night 12
Replies: 7359
Views: 189373

Re: Dr. Who Mafia - Night 9

Metalmarsh89 wrote:
Gotrees wrote:I think Elo has been acting strange this whole game. Starting off with a Juliets 1.0 vote, then an Azure vote, then a bunch of votes where she was the sole person voting for Dana, then suddenly she began voting very accurately and with the crowd, (Made, Enrique, MM, Roxy).

Might this shift in voting habits be due to being recruited? I don't know. What I do know is that (1) Elo doesn't appear to be any more active in thread to suggest that she actually has any reason to make these informed votes, and (2) every single vote since the Made vote, she has voted with Blooper, with the exception of one vote. In that vote, Blooper voted for Elo's favorite enemy, Dana. I feel like the recruiter might be recruiting these silent players and using them as pawns or something, I imagine it would be a good way to fly under the radar. I think it's generally being assumed that Elo is good because she survived the early Strax attack, but if my theory is right she was recruited just before the Made vote, and would not have been a baddie at the time of Strax's NK attempt.

I notice that Blooper was posting a few hours ago, but failed to reply to the concerns I mentioned earlier about her. If there really is a connection between Blooper and Elo, there might be one with Epig too (maybe as recruiter?). Although I realize this would definitely need a closer look.

Let me know if I'm insane, it's past 3 in the morning and I need some sleep. For that reason, I also won't be posting the planet summaries up right away, but I'll try to get them done before the poll closes tomorrow. I will mention, though, that Vulcan has made an appearance before. My summary of it can be found here. It had strong Dalek connotations, but now that the Daleks are dead I don't know what that means for us. Personally, I would still avoid it.
You should also be aware that Strax tried to kill Elo, but failed. Hence, she is either a civ or a baddie with protection.
Yeah, I addressed this. I don't think she had been recruited yet when Strax attempted to kill her, so she still turned up good/saved.
by Gotrees
Thu Oct 23, 2014 6:20 am
Forum: Previous Jobs
Topic: Dr. Who Mafia - Night 12
Replies: 7359
Views: 189373

Re: Dr. Who Mafia - Night 9

Ugh, I'm sorry guys. I forgot the poll was closing earlier today and accidentally slept through it. I am a terrible person, I know. :(

These past few hours have been crazy. So many suspicions, I'm not even going to try to address them all, but I'd like to just say that I think my opinions on Chris have changed, for the most part. At least, I'm probably about 75% convinced that he's not the Master. When I made the Occam's Razor reference, I wasn't aware that he was claiming to be Captain Jack. Reading over his posts, it seems possible to me, and he seems to be consistent in that respect. (although not with much else). That being said, he does scare me. Honestly, it seems like he does make a few good points, but he presents them in a way that seems paranoid and obsessive. He seems to think that everybody's out to get him, and that is only making people more suspicious of him. At least that's the vibe I'm getting. I don't think this excessive paranoia will end well.

Now, for my own paranoia:

I think Elo has been acting strange this whole game. Starting off with a Juliets 1.0 vote, then an Azure vote, then a bunch of votes where she was the sole person voting for Dana, then suddenly she began voting very accurately and with the crowd, (Made, Enrique, MM, Roxy).

Might this shift in voting habits be due to being recruited? I don't know. What I do know is that (1) Elo doesn't appear to be any more active in thread to suggest that she actually has any reason to make these informed votes, and (2) every single vote since the Made vote, she has voted with Blooper, with the exception of one vote. In that vote, Blooper voted for Elo's favorite enemy, Dana. I feel like the recruiter might be recruiting these silent players and using them as pawns or something, I imagine it would be a good way to fly under the radar. I think it's generally being assumed that Elo is good because she survived the early Strax attack, but if my theory is right she was recruited just before the Made vote, and would not have been a baddie at the time of Strax's NK attempt.

I notice that Blooper was posting a few hours ago, but failed to reply to the concerns I mentioned earlier about her. If there really is a connection between Blooper and Elo, there might be one with Epig too (maybe as recruiter?). Although I realize this would definitely need a closer look.

Let me know if I'm insane, it's past 3 in the morning and I need some sleep. For that reason, I also won't be posting the planet summaries up right away, but I'll try to get them done before the poll closes tomorrow. I will mention, though, that Vulcan has made an appearance before. My summary of it can be found here. It had strong Dalek connotations, but now that the Daleks are dead I don't know what that means for us. Personally, I would still avoid it.
by Gotrees
Tue Oct 21, 2014 2:02 am
Forum: Previous Jobs
Topic: Dr. Who Mafia - Night 12
Replies: 7359
Views: 189373

Re: Dr. Who Mafia - Day 9

In reply to juliets' reply to me: Thanks for understanding. I'm going to make a stronger effort to keep up from now on, and I'll also try not to use my hiatus as any excuse for my future actions. I understand how that can be annoying and also suspicious.
nijuukyugou wrote: Just so I don't leave you hanging, I'm catching up a bit - I honestly missed the whole case on sabie, so that'll give you an idea of how far behind I am :sigh:

As far as Epi goes, I really do think he's just burned out. I've said it before and I'll say it again - people say he acts strange/different/like a baddie, but he really just acts like himself, so it's not particularly weird behavior to me. Even though I know I'm a quieter player, I advocate having a look at quieter players, since surely not all of the baddies are out in the open like he is.

Are people saying Chris is the Master? I think I saw that a few pages back, but haven't gotten a chance to see exactly why this is so. I'm begrudgingly willing to glean posts and posts for it, but I'd much appreciate the shortened version if someone can oblige me :D
Some bits trimmed out for relevancy.

Ok, I'm a bit confused by this. You start off by saying you're far behind, and end by saying that you are far behind, but in the second quoted paragraph you feel informed enough to weigh in on a topic which had only been brought up a few hours before your post? And all you have to say about that topic is pretty much that you stand behind Epig and think he is probably a civ? Sounds a bit suspicious. You can take my first official eyeball. :eye:

I feel like the topic of Epig (at least the one blooper is referring to) would take more than a brief skim of the posts to understand. I could be wrong. I'd appreciate an explanation.

Also, regarding Chris. I think this would be a good time to refer to Occam's Razor. It's possible that all these people had some convoluted scheme to frame him and take him down, but right now, I just think it's unlikely. I'll keep an eye on you Chris, and listen to what you have to say, but right now I'm leaning more towards thinking you're the Master than some valuable civvie role. The alternative is just too complicated.

Also, should I text Dana or something to try to get her back in here? Or would that be considered BTSC/against the rules?
by Gotrees
Sun Oct 19, 2014 9:46 pm
Forum: Previous Jobs
Topic: Dr. Who Mafia - Night 12
Replies: 7359
Views: 189373

Re: Dr. Who Mafia - Night 8

Long Con wrote:balloonery
by Gotrees
Sun Oct 19, 2014 9:00 pm
Forum: Previous Jobs
Topic: Dr. Who Mafia - Night 12
Replies: 7359
Views: 189373

Re: Dr. Who Mafia - Night 8

Chris wrote: Gotrees was simply absent. I suppose when the Daleks were dead, and Sabie started taking heat, it could make sense to just disappear.
I didn't even know the Daleks were dead until a few hours ago. (BTW: Hooray! The Daleks are dead! :fiesta:)
keys56000000000 wrote:Gotrees - I don't have anything in particular against you, no thread evidence. I just feel like I sense nonchalance in you. That's how I felt about Sabie. That's how I feel about DF, Hedgeowl, and sure Chris, Bass too. I forgot about Bass.
Noted. I guess I'll start trying to act more chalant.
by Gotrees
Sun Oct 19, 2014 8:53 pm
Forum: Previous Jobs
Topic: Dr. Who Mafia - Night 12
Replies: 7359
Views: 189373

Re: Dr. Who Mafia - Night 8

Dom wrote:
Thank you..
Why do you have time to do so much planet research, but not enough time for game play and reading?
If you check, I've not done any planet research during my absence these past few days. In fact, I've hardly done anything online, both inside and outside of mafia. Last week I didn't even sign in to Skype or Steam or IRC or hardly anything else (with the exception of maybe a half-hour-long Skype call on Friday). As for now, I've sort of given up hope of me ever catching up. More than twenty pages would take me hours. If somebody could recommend a closer place to start reading from, I would be more willing to do that.

Before my hiatus it wasn't an issue of not having enough time, it was more an issue of helping everyone the best way I could. Up until a few days ago I did a pretty good job at keeping up and reading everybody's posts. If you like, you can read my reply to juliets for more on that.
by Gotrees
Sun Oct 19, 2014 7:35 pm
Forum: Previous Jobs
Topic: Dr. Who Mafia - Night 12
Replies: 7359
Views: 189373

Re: Dr. Who Mafia - Night 8

keys56000000000 wrote:I don't think Sonw Dog or Epignosis are mafioso. Chris, I think you're reaching.

My suspects for Sabie's teammates are:
DF,
Gotrees,
Hedgeowl,
in no particular order.
Anything I can clear up for you about myself, keys?
by Gotrees
Sun Oct 19, 2014 7:34 pm
Forum: Previous Jobs
Topic: Dr. Who Mafia - Night 12
Replies: 7359
Views: 189373

Re: Dr. Who Mafia - Night 8

Bit late, but here's this:

Biblios

Image
Pictured: A member of the Vromyx race

Biblios was a library planet (Not The Library, but similar). It collected all the data of the universe, except for the data related to weapons. The library was staffed by robot librarians.

Two enemy races, the Vromyx and the Garynths, did not believe the claims that the library contained no weapons data. As a result, they fought a 50-year-long war against each other in an attempt to gain access to these fictional records. This war prevented anyone else from accessing the library. The Doctor found out, blew up an empty building, and told the enemies that he had blown up the weapons data. They now had nothing to fight over, and the war was over. Hooray.

Before the start of the 21st century, Biblios was placed under the protection of the Galactic Heritage, joining Earth and a bunch of other planets as a planet which theoretically would be protected from purchase or invasion by the Galactic Council.

http://tardis.wikia.com/wiki/Biblios

---------------------------------------------

Collactin

Image
Pictured: The planet Zanak

Collactin is pretty much only famous for being destroyed.

An evil man named The Captain hollowed out the planet Zanak. He would then make it materialize around smaller planets, which he would subsequently compress and strip of their minerals. This is what happened to Collactin.

http://tardis.wikia.com/wiki/Collactin

---------------------------------------------

Demons Run

Image

PSA: Series 6 spoilers for this planet.

This is the planet where Amy gave birth to River Song/Melody Pond.

After her honeymoon, Amy was kidnapped by the evil Madame Kovarian and taken to Demons Run. She was replaced by an almost-identical clone of herself. This clone thought she was actually the real Amy, so she kept traveling with the Doctor like nothing weird was going on.

Just before giving birth, the Doctor realized what was up and “terminated” the clone. He then proceeded to gather an army of people/aliens he had helped in some way over the years, including Strax, Jenny, and Madame Vastra. On the way to Demons Run, Rory also blew up a bunch of Cybermen for good measure. (To intimidate the kidnappers).

In the Battle of Demon’s Run, the Doctor and his allies at first seemed victorious, but soon the Headless Monks revealed themselves and killed almost everybody, including, it seemed, Strax.

Turns out Strax was able to be saved by Jenny and Vastra, much to his dismay. He agreed to travel with them back to Victorian London to solve crimes and protect the Empire. (As seen in this glorious, 360p, Portuguese-subtitled YouTube video which I somehow had never seen until just now.)

It should be noted that the name “Demons Run” comes from a poem: Demons run when a good man goes to war. It is to be assumed that in this case, the good man is the Doctor.

http://tardis.wikia.com/wiki/Demons_Run

---------------------------------------------

Florana

Image

According to the Wiki, one of the most peaceful and beautiful planets in its galaxy.

Early in Florana’s history, a Dalek crash-landed on the planet, took control, and pretended to be God. When the human High Priest to this “God” found out that he had been worshipping a false god, he used a big weapon to try to kill all non-believers. Out of the ashes of the people murdered grew the flowers from which Florana gets its name. Lovely story.

In the 30th century, Florana was used by the Earth Empire as a toxic waste dumping ground.

In a comic, the Doctor 11 had a brunch on Florana before saving a star. The inhabitants held a parade in his honor.

Like Biblios, this planet is also a part of the Galactic Heritage.

Some other sort-of controversial things happened, but they don’t really seem too relevant. You can find them in the wiki below if you’re interested.

http://tardis.wikia.com/wiki/Florana

---------------------------------------------

Indigo 3

Image

Not much on this one. I’ll just quote the wiki directly.
http://tardis.wikia.com/wiki/Indigo_3 wrote: Indigo 3 was the location of the Blue Desert. The desert was perfectly symmetrical, but in the centre was the Sanctuary of Imperfect Symmetry, a religious retreat which existed to counterbalance the desert's perfection. (AUDIO: The Skull of Sobek)
http://tardis.wikia.com/wiki/The_Skull_of_Sobek wrote: On the isolated planet of Indigo 3, far out in the wastes of the Blue Desert, lies the Sanctuary of Imperfect Symmetry. It is a place of contemplation and reflection. It is also a place of death. Something from another time, from another world, has found its way inside the hallowed walls. Something with a leathery hide, a long snout and sharp pointy teeth. Tick Tock. Here comes the crocodile...
Doesn’t sound particularly pleasant.

http://tardis.wikia.com/wiki/Indigo_3

---------------------------------------------

Commentary

Collactin is famous for being destroyed. Let’s not go there.

Lots of good people died at Demons Run. Let’s not go there. (Only benefit is maybe something to do with Vastra/Strax/Jenny but I don’t really see that happening since so many other things happened there.)

Florana has Dalek connotations. Let’s not go there.

Don’t know much about Indigo 3, other than the fact that it has some sort of crocodile. I don’t like crocodiles. Let’s not go there.

Biblios sounds nice. No weapons. Lots of books might mean we get some info. I’m voting Biblios. Looks like most of you already have. Hooray. Let’s go there.
by Gotrees
Sun Oct 19, 2014 6:46 pm
Forum: Previous Jobs
Topic: Dr. Who Mafia - Night 12
Replies: 7359
Views: 189373

Re: Dr. Who Mafia - Night 8

Dom wrote:Gotrees, just curious, you say you aren't caught up, can you point me to where was the last time you read before you made that post?
Dom, embarrassingly, the last point I have thoroughly read up to is probably around here.

MM's LD post is what inspired me to look up the Cybermen some more and make this post. I then signed off.

Today I checked back to see if anybody said anything about that post, saw juliet's post about me just after it, and responded.

Haven't caught up much since then, other than reading the lynch posts and the night posts by the hosts, and some of the posts about me.
by Gotrees
Sun Oct 19, 2014 5:50 pm
Forum: Previous Jobs
Topic: Dr. Who Mafia - Night 12
Replies: 7359
Views: 189373

Re: Dr. Who Mafia - Night 8

juliets wrote:Gotrees, thank you for responding to my post.
No problem. I'll try to answer whatever is asked of me.
by Gotrees
Sun Oct 19, 2014 5:27 pm
Forum: Previous Jobs
Topic: Dr. Who Mafia - Night 12
Replies: 7359
Views: 189373

Re: Dr. Who Mafia - Day 7

Guys, I'm really sorry I have been so inactive lately, these past two weeks have really overwhelmed me with school work. Last week alone I've had tests or projects in almost all my classes, plus the PSAT on Wednesday (which is what I had that day instead of classes). I will try to become more active again now that most of that is hopefully out of the way. I haven't had the time to completely catch up yet, and I probably never will, but I've read through the host posts and the posts mentioning my name, and I think I have a basic understanding of the situation right now. To address Juliets' concerns:

juliets wrote: First, we can't deny that Gotrees has been super helpful on the night polls that involved planets from Dr. Who. Gathering all that material and publishing commentary at the end of each group must have taken a long time. He also has posted some videos that are interesting but not directly related to what is happening in the game. So I have to ask, why hasn't his posting been as complete? He talks about catching up which excuses him from posting thoughts or doing any baddie hunting. If he can post all that material about the planets why can't he keep up?
I don't think I really talked about catching up until this last Tuesday. Until then, I never used that as an excuse for anything (except in the very beginning of the game when I had a late start). Right now there's just been so much going on I haven't really had much time for Mafia between school and life. I'm sorry.

As for my lack of baddie hunting: I don't really know how to baddie hunt. I'm new to the game, and although that is probably a garbage excuse, I don't really know all the ins and outs of it yet. My first vote led to Epi 1 getting lynched because I thought he was acting suspicious. In reality that's just how he plays the game. I don't want that to happen again. Until I play with you all a bit more, it will continue to be difficult to determine who and when people are lying. Right now, I just have to rely on other people's insight.
juliets wrote: Second, he indicates in this post he see's no connection between Enrique and Made, and says his own vote record is no better than Enriques, and finally he feels reluctant voting for made.
Gotrees wrote:Man, I'm not certain on either of them.

Epig does a better job arguing his case than Dom does, but Enri does a better job arguing his case than Made does.

Are people assuming Made is the Emperor Dalek and cant get lynched? Someone mentioned it earlier: if that were the case, there would be no need to save him last night. Also, I don't see any connection between Enrique and Made. Frankly, other people have come across as closer to each other.

The most suspicious thing on Enrique to me is his trend of unlucky votes, but it would be pretty hypocritical for me to criticize him for that, considering my record isn't too great either. His survival of last night is also a bit odd, but it seems pretty certain that it would be possible for him to potentially survive that night as a civ (eg. if the Master was blocked).

I feel reluctant voting for Made, though, too. I don't entirely understand the argument against him.

The thing I'm ultimately falling back on to base this vote on is my experiences with them outside of the game, since I mostly know them in that context. I mentioned on one of the first days that Made seemed a bit off to me. Enrique seems more like his usual self. It's entirely possible that he's just a better liar, but that's what I'm going on for now. I really hope I'm right.
I stand behind that, I don't know how that incriminates me. Everything I said there is what I believed at that point. I'm friends with Made and Enrique outside of Mafia, and I felt that was the best thing I could base my vote off of. I had stated earlier that I thought Made was acting a bit different from his real-life self, and many other players had also said that his game was different this time around. I didn't entirely understand the argument around him, but at that point I believe it was between Made and Enrique, and Made seemed to be the (slightly) more obvious choice for me.
juliets wrote: Third, Gotrees had this to say about Enrique (and MP) before the Enrique lynch. Note it begins with a soft complaint about how hard the game is to keep up with:
Gotrees wrote:Man, even without a lot of discussion this game is too much for me.

To be perfectly honest, MP and Enrique both seem equally bad to me. And by that, I mean they both seem civ. But so does everyone else. They just seem less civ than most people. I really need to improve my baddie-detector.

The case against Enrique is pretty much set in stone, I think. I agree that Made's actions seem suspicious, but can Enrique be entirely blamed for that? It is possible that Made just wanted to go out with a bang or something, or as someone mentioned a few posts up, wanted to save himself from being exposed as a baddie in an almost-tie. I don't know.
(I cut off the rest of this quote which was about MP)

First he says that he sees MP and Enrique as civ, just less civ than others. I guess that means he see's them as bad? He also says MP and Enrique seems equally bad which I disagree with. In my opinion MP never seemed as bad as Enrique seemed. He then defends Enrique against the accusation that Enrique is on Made's team as evidenced by Made voting for himself. Again, in my opinion it seemed pretty obvious why Made voted for himself - to try and help save Enrique.
The comment about how the game is "too much for me" was not about keeping up with the quantity of the posts, but rather about the contents of the posts. As I've said before, I'm having a hard time making sense of people's posts and deciding who's bad and who's good. To provide insight into my simple mind, I've quickly sketched up a graph in Paint:

Image

The yellow representing the confidence I had in Made, Enri, and MP around the time I made those posts. I wasn't yet convinced they were evil, but they were the best leads I could possibly have at that point. The green spot on the graph represents my confidence in my Epi 1.0 vote. Ideally I would like to achieve that amount of confidence before voting someone again, but at that point I was a naive, newborn babbie mafia player (even more babbie than I am now) and especially since he flipped civvie, it will probably take a while for me to get over my reluctance/PTSD following that situation.

juliets wrote: I know these issues don't feel meaty but like I said before, they've been stirring in the back of my mind. I'd like to hear from Gotrees and would especially like to know why he has a lot of time when he is putting something neutral in the thread (the info about the planets) but has not gotten more involved in some of our discussion except in that post where he talked about MP. I'd like responses to the other quotes but again, especially my first point.
The reason for the contrast between my informative night posts vs. my lack of "baddie hunting" posts, as I've hinted at above, is that I don't really know how to baddie hunt. What I do know is facts. It's much easier (and, admittedly, much safer--I understand your concerns) to pull cold hard facts from a wiki page than it is to throw out random accusations at your peers. I feel like, even if I did do that, my accusations wouldn't hold much merit. I don't really know what I'm doing, to be honest. I'm worried that if I were to start some bandwagon lynch campaign I would probably be wrong, and then that would probably come back to bite me in the ass sometime later. Ironically I guess it is my reluctance to pursue such a campaign that is getting me into trouble now.

"Under the radar?" Possibly.

Baddie? Definitely not.

Linki: Looks like you guys are pretty active right now. I'll try to answer any questions you might have before starting up on my work.
by Gotrees
Wed Oct 15, 2014 3:12 pm
Forum: Previous Jobs
Topic: Dr. Who Mafia - Night 12
Replies: 7359
Views: 189373

Re: Dr. Who Mafia - Day 7

Not caught up yet, but I'd just like to point out that the phrase "I am not a robot" might still reply as true even if it were said by a Cyberman.

From Wikipedia:
It is presumed (and often implied) that there are still organic components beneath their suits, meaning they are actually cyborgs, not robots: in The Tenth Planet, a Cyberman tells a group of humans that "our brains are just like yours", although by the time of Attack of the Cybermen (1985), their brains seem to have been replaced with electronics.
http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Cyberman
by Gotrees
Tue Oct 14, 2014 5:58 pm
Forum: Previous Jobs
Topic: Dr. Who Mafia - Night 12
Replies: 7359
Views: 189373

Re: Dr. Who Mafia - Day 7

Hey guys, sorry I've missed a bunch of posts these past few days. :( I don't have classes tomorrow, so I'll try to devote the next 24 hours or so to catching up with mafia.

I'll let you all know when I've finished catching up.

Sorry for my absence!
by Gotrees
Thu Oct 09, 2014 9:51 am
Forum: Previous Jobs
Topic: Dr. Who Mafia - Night 12
Replies: 7359
Views: 189373

Re: Dr. Who Mafia - Night 5

Darillium

Image
This picture is fanart because the planet was never actually pictured in the show. Credit to mikazukirisa.deviantart.com

PSA: River Song plot spoilers for this planet.

Darillium was the last place the eleventh Doctor took River Song before she would go on to "die" with the Tenth doctor in The Library.

As quoted from the wiki:
Darillium was the location of the Singing Towers. The Eleventh Doctor took River Song to see these towers the last time she saw him before she went to the Library and met the Tenth Doctor. She told the Doctor in the Library that "the last time I saw you - the real you, the future you, I mean - you turned up on my doorstep with a new haircut and a suit. You took me to Darillium to see the Singing Towers. What a night that was. The towers sang and you cried. You wouldn't tell me why, but I suppose you knew it was time. My time. Time to come to the Library.
Sounds rather romantic.

http://tardis.wikia.com/wiki/Darillium

---------------------------------------------

Midnight

Image

Midnight was a resort planet, made up almost entirely of diamonds. It was colonized by humans, but the planet had no air, so the humans had to live in airtight structures which were dropped onto the planet from space. When the Doctor visited this planet with Donna Noble, he discovered that some other creature was capable of living on the barren planet. This creature "infected" one of the passengers on the Doctor's tour bus. When the Doctor tried to talk to her, she would just repeat whatever he said. As he spoke more and more, she started repeating things faster and faster until eventually, she was saying them before the Doctor was. The Doctor was now infected. He could only repeat things said by others. All hell basically broke loose, and people wanted to throw the Doctor off the shuttle bus and to his death, but eventually the original infected lady was thrown out by a nice hostess, and the problem was solved.

Interesting note: this was the episode in which the Doctor first learned about the lost moon of Poosh (see below). Rose Tyler also briefly appears on a tv screen, but the Doctor does not notice. Both Rose and the moon of Poosh would make an appearance later in the series.

http://tardis.wikia.com/wiki/Midnight

---------------------------------------------

New Savannah

Image

Not much to say here, other than that this planet was the home of a species of cat-people that came to distrust (and in extreme cases, kill) humans:
Circa 4,999,999,740, Catkind lived on the planet New Savannah. They were a primitive people at the time, and their natural resources were running low. The New Earth Empire came to New Savannah, and brought it and Catkind into the empire. They agreed to give the Cats autonomy until the year 5,000,000,000, when control would be given to the New Earth Empire. Within fifty years, Catkind had reached the same level of technology as the humans, and Catkind grew to distrust them. In order to avert a potential war, they left the Earth empire cities, which were then covered by empathic force fields, stopping any Cats from returning. Myths would spring up about these Cats, specifically about them being angry spirits.

In the intervening centuries, a cult sprang up to to oppose human influence. With the help of Bubastion, they destroyed the headquarters of Vedela Defense Systems, which controlled the force fields around the city. At the stroke of midnight at the start of 5,000,000,000, the forcefields were shut down and gigantic robots, disguised as undead Catkind, entered to the city. Unfortunately, Bubastion had programmed them to attack everyone, intending to use New Savannah for his own purposes. When Garrard Townsend, a member of the cult, learned they were being used, he turned the force fields back on and deactivated the robots.
Most of that story comes from comics (which I haven't read).

http://tardis.wikia.com/wiki/New_Savannah

---------------------------------------------

Poosh

Image

A planet which has nice swimming pools. The Doctor would like to retire either on Poosh or in Paris.

At some point, one of its moons disappeared. This came to be known as the lost moon of Poosh. Turns out it was taken by the Daleks, and they planned to blow it up, along with 26 other planets (along with Colm, one of the options of a previous night poll). Luckily the Doctor saved the day before that could happen.

http://tardis.wikia.com/wiki/Poosh

---------------------------------------------

Stormcage (Stormcage Containment Facility)

Image

PSA: River Song plot spoilers for this planet.
Stormcage Containment Facility was a prison in the 52nd century of the highest security. River Song was a prisoner there and a frequent escapee, but always returned as her part of the charade to make the Silence think she actually killed the Doctor at Lake Silencio.

Though the staff were able to keep most of the prisoners in their cells, they failed endlessly with River Song. However, as she always returned after a breakout, they might have eventually given up on trying to stop her and left her to her own agenda.
It is located on a planet which is in a constant storm, and high-tech facial recognition cameras and trained guards help to keep the facility secure. Although not specifically confirmed in canon, it is believed by some that this entire planet is just a massive, unpleasant prison.

http://tardis.wikia.com/wiki/Stormcage_ ... t_Facility

---------------------------------------------

Vulcan (not the Spock one)

Image

Planet colonized by humans for resources. Some guy found Daleks on it. The Daleks tried to kill the humans but barely failed. The Daleks who survived were deemed insane by the other Daleks and were sent to the Asylum of the Daleks.

http://tardis.wikia.com/wiki/Vulcan_(Th ... he_Daleks)

---------------------------------------------

Commentary

Pardon the short descriptions for the last few, I really must sleep. I think I summed up the important stuff though.

For the same reasons my commentary will be sort of brief:

Both Darillium and Stormcage are definitely linked with River. Don't know if she'd get some sort of benefit or power for going there or what. Between the two, Stormcage might be a better choice. I was thinking that Stormcage represents "hellos" while Darillium represents "goodbye." Idk about you guys but I don't want to say goodbye to River Song just yet.

I would avoid Poosh and Vulcan entirely because of the Dalek connotations. Even if Poosh is allegedly a nice place to retire.

Midnight was a pretty scary episode because the mind parasite thing turned the good humans against each other--scaring them into making baseless accusations and ultimately almost killing the Doctor. Sounds like most of this game so far. Don't want to go there.

New Savannah would be a nice place for cat lovers. (Dana, bea: looking at you). I think cats are pretty cool so I think I'll stick my vote there for now. Hopefully it's not a trap. Only the radical cat cultists resorted to killing humans, and even then they stopped once they realized they were also killing their fellow cats. Might change it to one of the River Song options when I can think more clearly.

It's 2AM my time, but my internet died just after I loaded the Vulcan wiki page, so I guess I'll save this all to Word and try to post it in the morning.
by Gotrees
Wed Oct 08, 2014 11:56 pm
Forum: Previous Jobs
Topic: Dr. Who Mafia - Night 12
Replies: 7359
Views: 189373

Re: Dr. Who Mafia - Day 5

Metalmarsh89 wrote:I voted Vulcan until I do some research.
I'll get to work on my nightly planet summaries as soon as I finish my RL work.
by Gotrees
Wed Oct 08, 2014 11:48 pm
Forum: Previous Jobs
Topic: Dr. Who Mafia - Night 12
Replies: 7359
Views: 189373

Re: Dr. Who Mafia - Day 5

Woo hoo! :fiesta:

Finally a lynch result I can celebrate.
by Gotrees
Wed Oct 08, 2014 9:58 pm
Forum: Previous Jobs
Topic: Dr. Who Mafia - Night 12
Replies: 7359
Views: 189373

Re: Dr. Who Mafia - Day 5

Man, even without a lot of discussion this game is too much for me.

To be perfectly honest, MP and Enrique both seem equally bad to me. And by that, I mean they both seem civ. But so does everyone else. They just seem less civ than most people. I really need to improve my baddie-detector.

The case against Enrique is pretty much set in stone, I think. I agree that Made's actions seem suspicious, but can Enrique be entirely blamed for that? It is possible that Made just wanted to go out with a bang or something, or as someone mentioned a few posts up, wanted to save himself from being exposed as a baddie in an almost-tie. I don't know.

MP was barely on my radar as a baddie until the last lynch. The main reason MP sets me off is his sudden desire to be lynched. He never showed any signs of giving up like that until Enrique finally brought up (what seemed to me like) the first good evidence against him. Naturally, a large group of people took MP's sudden suicidal plea as a reason NOT to vote for him, which I think would be the logical response. If he's really a civ, why should we vote for him? If he's a baddie, he must have something up his sleeve.

Again, I see not voting MP as the natural response to this situation. Yesterday even I completely brushed it off, but today I had a long walk home so I thought about it some more, and it just made me even more suspicious. If the natural response to a suicidal player is to not kill them, then why was MP's response to Made's suicidal vote to vote with him? I know MP addressed this, saying it was a knee-jerk reaction, but I sort of don't buy it.

MP, I know you're going through some stressful times, and your responses seem genuine, but Enrique's responses seem genuine too. Maybe I'm just bad at detecting lies, but today I'm probably going to put myself on a lot of people's radars by voting for you. Looks like Enrique is going to win anyway, but I suppose it's better to vote with your gut than to vote with the herd.

Sorry if this post was incoherent, I'm a bit drowsy atm.

Which reminds me: yesterday I had a dream that Epi was getting all angry at me for using the wrong version of the word "its" vs "it's." I woke up trying to come up with a defense and it took a few hours for me to realize it was all a dream after all. (At least I think it was...)
by Gotrees
Tue Oct 07, 2014 1:41 am
Forum: Previous Jobs
Topic: Dr. Who Mafia - Night 12
Replies: 7359
Views: 189373

Re: Dr. Who Mafia - Day 5

Enrique (and other non-Whovians), I found this vid starring Captain Jack Harkness. It's pretty much an intro to the Cybermen. Worth a watch.



And another one for the Daleks:



Here's more, if anyone's interested:

http://www.bbc.co.uk/doctorwho/s4/misc/ ... iles.shtml

The quality might be better than on the youtube videos, but they're not loading for me right now. Not sure if that's a problem with the site or if it's just because I'm behind my school's web filter at the moment.
by Gotrees
Tue Oct 07, 2014 1:08 am
Forum: Previous Jobs
Topic: Dr. Who Mafia - Night 12
Replies: 7359
Views: 189373

Re: Dr. Who Mafia - Day 5

...although who knows what their "alternative solution" is, and if it's related to recruiting him.
by Gotrees
Tue Oct 07, 2014 1:05 am
Forum: Previous Jobs
Topic: Dr. Who Mafia - Night 12
Replies: 7359
Views: 189373

Re: Dr. Who Mafia - Day 5

bea wrote:and Gotrees has special new person love in my world too.
<3
Enrique wrote:Dylan, you might be able to answer this. "The upgrade had failed" before the Cybermen killed zeek? What does that mean?
You mean in the context of the show?

The Cybermen basically try to "upgrade" all living things. To them, being converted into a Cyberman is considered an upgrade. So it looks like zeek died, but was not recruited to the Cyberman team.
by Gotrees
Tue Oct 07, 2014 12:06 am
Forum: Previous Jobs
Topic: Dr. Who Mafia - Night 12
Replies: 7359
Views: 189373

Re: Dr. Who Mafia - Day 5

Just read the night post.

RIP Zeek, a truly upstanding citizen. You will be missed.

Made, on the other hand: hopefully Strax was right in killing you.
by Gotrees
Mon Oct 06, 2014 11:51 pm
Forum: Previous Jobs
Topic: Dr. Who Mafia - Night 12
Replies: 7359
Views: 189373

Re: Dr. Who Mafia - Day 5

Man, I can feel the aggression in this thread right now. :eek:
by Gotrees
Mon Oct 06, 2014 6:46 pm
Forum: Previous Jobs
Topic: Dr. Who Mafia - Night 12
Replies: 7359
Views: 189373

Re: Dr. Who Mafia - Night 4

Made: Why not vote for Enrique? If you had a chance to survive, wouldn't you have had the same chance if you had voted for Enrique and still ended up getting the most votes? Just doesn't make sense that you wouldn't vote for Enrique, even if you did have the chance to survive your lynch. Personally, if it were me, I would want to avoid that coin-flip as much as possible.
Elohcin wrote:I am going with Red Rocket.
Why? I don't really understand why anyone would go for RRR with it's very high potential Dalek presence. I mean, they intentionally crashed an entire asteroid into the planet to try to kill everyone! Seems like the most-obviously-bad choice out of the four to me.
by Gotrees
Mon Oct 06, 2014 4:28 am
Forum: Previous Jobs
Topic: Dr. Who Mafia - Night 12
Replies: 7359
Views: 189373

Re: Dr. Who Mafia - Night 4

Quotes taken from the wiki. Again, I've bolded parts that may be of interest.

--------------------------------------------------------------------

Raxacoricofallapatorius

Image

Home of the Slitheen, the big fat green farting aliens that everyone hates.

Sister planet of Colm, mentioned in the last planet vote.

Notable quote from the wiki, referring to a plot from one of the comics:
In an alternate timeline in which the Cybermen conquered the Borg, Raxacoricofallapatorius was among the many worlds the Cybermen conquered, the natives all cyber-converted.
http://tardis.wikia.com/wiki/Raxacoricofallapatorius

--------------------------------------------------------------------

Red Rocket Rising

Image
Red Rocket Rising was a planet colonised by humans.
This planet is from one of the audio episodes called (innocently enough) Blood of the Daleks.

The planet itself was much like Earth, but with multiple suns. The people living there had almost no records of the outside universe.

One day, a Dalek ship crashed into the planet, and some scientist (Professor Martez) guessed that the Daleks must be the future of humanity. He began working on creating Daleks out of humans both living and dead. While he was doing these experiments, he figured he'd contact the real Daleks, assuming they'd love his new plan, but when they heard of it, they basically freaked out and sent an asteroid hurtling into the planet, with the intent to kill all inhabitants. Some of the humans tried to escape, but the Daleks just exploded their ship. Then they came down to exterminate the ones who stayed behind. There was a big battle between the humans, the mutants, and the Daleks. Somehow all the Daleks (mutant and original) were destroyed.

Reminds me of Dalek Sec's story. Doesn't sound like a fun place to be.

http://tardis.wikia.com/wiki/Red_Rocket_Rising

--------------------------------------------------------------------

Rexel IV

Image

The wiki doesn't mention much about this planet, other than that it is the home of the Carrionites. These were the "witches" that "ensnared male victims" in Tennant's Shakespeare episode (The Shakespeare Code). They pretty much had all the powers one would expect a witch to have, but the show explains it all as being more science-y rather than witchcraft-y. Basically, they used the power of words to mathematically manipulate the universe.

Long ago, their entire species was banished into the Deep Darkness because of a violent war they were waging against another species.

Eventually, Shakespeare came along, and his words were so powerful that he accidentally and unknowingly let three of them out of the Deep Darkness. The three Carrionites then manipulated Shakespeare into hypnotically changing the last lines of his play into some words that would let the rest of their species out of the Darkness. The Doctor, Shakespeare, and Martha stopped the play before anything terrible could happen. The three escaped Carrionites now live trapped in a hidden crystal ball in the TARDIS.

http://tardis.wikia.com/wiki/Rexel_IV

--------------------------------------------------------------------

Riftan 5

Image
Riften 5 was a satellite of Vita 15. On Riften 5, the Fifth Doctor visited the vid-archives and saw genetic tests that were run on Daleks after the War of Sharpened Hearts.
It was also the birthplace of Gustave Lytton, who has quite an interesting story when it comes to his interactions with the Daleks and Cybermen. When the Doctor first met Lytton, he was working as a paid mercenary for the Daleks. When Davros started a fight with the Dalek Supreme, Lytton and a few of his men were among the handful of people who were able to flee for safety.

Later, Lytton joined the cause of the Cryons, helping to defend them against the Cybermen. He wanted to go to London to pretend to befriend the Cybermen, planning to betray them later. When the Doctor met him again, he immediately disliked Lytton because of their previous encounter with the Daleks, but soon, both the Doctor and Lytton were being captured by the Cybermen and it became clear that Lytton was on the Doctor's side.

When the Cyber-Controler learned of Lytton's plans of betrayal, he ordered him to be converted into a Cyberman. Lytton died fighting the Cyber-Controler as the Doctor was trying to save him from this conversion (pictured).

This planet also doesn't have any pubs, apparently, so if you like drinking, maybe it's not the planet for you.

http://tardis.wikia.com/wiki/Riften_5

--------------------------------------------------------------------

Commentary/TL;DR

Raxacoricofallapatorius sounds potentially pro-Cyberman. At the very least, it will have gross, fat, farting green things.

Red Rocket Rising sounds like it's very likely to be Dalek-related.

Rexel 4 is the only planet that doesn't seem to have any obvious Cyberman or Dalek connections. But there are witches there.

If going off of the Lytton connection, Riften 5 sounds like it could be pro-Dalek, anti-Cyberman. I expect it could be something like we'll meet Lytton, and he'll be like "if you lynch a baddie, I'll help you against the Cybermen, but if you lynch a civ, I'll join the Daleks and do something bad."

--------------------------------------------------------------------

Right now, I'm going to vote for Raxacoricofallapatorious because the Cyberman connection there is pretty vague, coming from an alternate universe from a comic. I imagine the green things shouldn't be too hard to battle, considering their biggest weakness is that if they touch vinegar they explode into goo.

Rexel IV would be my next choice, if someone can convince me to switch over to that. The lack of any baddie connection sounds appealing, but the witches do not.

I also find it strange that keys was so quick to jump on board RRR with it's obviously Dalek-heavy connotations. I'll give him the benefit of the doubt for now, but I would like to hear an explanation if he has one.

Hope this helps, and as always, feel free to add any info I might've missed. (I'm sure I don't need to tell you guys that, though.) :p
by Gotrees
Sun Oct 05, 2014 11:47 pm
Forum: Previous Jobs
Topic: Dr. Who Mafia - Night 12
Replies: 7359
Views: 189373

Re: Dr. Who Mafia - Night 4

MovingPictures07 wrote:
Gotrees wrote:I'll get to work on another planet summary thing in a bit if no one else does it first.
Go for it.
Alright, cool. Might be an hour or two though--grandma's birthday party right now.

If anyone wants to have a crack at it before then, go right ahead.

I'll get on it as soon as I can.
by Gotrees
Sun Oct 05, 2014 11:43 pm
Forum: Previous Jobs
Topic: Dr. Who Mafia - Night 12
Replies: 7359
Views: 189373

Re: Dr. Who Mafia - Night 4

I'll get to work on another planet summary thing in a bit if no one else does it first.
by Gotrees
Sun Oct 05, 2014 11:40 pm
Forum: Previous Jobs
Topic: Dr. Who Mafia - Night 12
Replies: 7359
Views: 189373

Re: Dr. Who Mafia - Night 4

Gotrees wrote:So...

Made is Dalek king?

Also, I love that vid.
Or he's someone else and has a secret power?
by Gotrees
Sun Oct 05, 2014 11:39 pm
Forum: Previous Jobs
Topic: Dr. Who Mafia - Night 12
Replies: 7359
Views: 189373

Re: Dr. Who Mafia - Night 4

So...

Made is Dalek king?

Also, I love that vid.
by Gotrees
Sun Oct 05, 2014 11:36 pm
Forum: Previous Jobs
Topic: Dr. Who Mafia - Night 12
Replies: 7359
Views: 189373

Re: Dr. Who Mafia - Day 4

Epignosis wrote: "This will be an interesting vote."

The word "certainly" isn't necessary. See? :)
:huh: I have been enlightened. :biggrin:
by Gotrees
Sun Oct 05, 2014 11:32 pm
Forum: Previous Jobs
Topic: Dr. Who Mafia - Night 12
Replies: 7359
Views: 189373

Re: Dr. Who Mafia - Day 4

This will certainly be an interesting vote.

(Sorry for adverbs, Epig.)
by Gotrees
Sun Oct 05, 2014 11:30 pm
Forum: Previous Jobs
Topic: Dr. Who Mafia - Night 12
Replies: 7359
Views: 189373

Re: Dr. Who Mafia - Day 4

:ponder: Odd.
by Gotrees
Sun Oct 05, 2014 10:39 pm
Forum: Previous Jobs
Topic: Dr. Who Mafia - Night 12
Replies: 7359
Views: 189373

Re: Dr. Who Mafia - Day 4

Long Con wrote:I would think Made, if he were Emperor Dalek, would still not want to be lynched, and thus exposed as that role to the more suspicious of us. A save of him to keep his cover makes sense.
Good point. I suppose in that sense a save could still potentially make sense.
by Gotrees
Sun Oct 05, 2014 10:38 pm
Forum: Previous Jobs
Topic: Dr. Who Mafia - Night 12
Replies: 7359
Views: 189373

Re: Dr. Who Mafia - Day 4

Man, I'm not certain on either of them.

Epig does a better job arguing his case than Dom does, but Enri does a better job arguing his case than Made does.

Are people assuming Made is the Emperor Dalek and cant get lynched? Someone mentioned it earlier: if that were the case, there would be no need to save him last night. Also, I don't see any connection between Enrique and Made. Frankly, other people have come across as closer to each other.

The most suspicious thing on Enrique to me is his trend of unlucky votes, but it would be pretty hypocritical for me to criticize him for that, considering my record isn't too great either. His survival of last night is also a bit odd, but it seems pretty certain that it would be possible for him to potentially survive that night as a civ (eg. if the Master was blocked).

I feel reluctant voting for Made, though, too. I don't entirely understand the argument against him.

The thing I'm ultimately falling back on to base this vote on is my experiences with them outside of the game, since I mostly know them in that context. I mentioned on one of the first days that Made seemed a bit off to me. Enrique seems more like his usual self. It's entirely possible that he's just a better liar, but that's what I'm going on for now. I really hope I'm right.
by Gotrees
Fri Oct 03, 2014 12:58 am
Forum: Previous Jobs
Topic: Dr. Who Mafia - Night 12
Replies: 7359
Views: 189373

Re: Dr. Who Mafia - Night 3

( :offtobed: for me too)
by Gotrees
Fri Oct 03, 2014 12:57 am
Forum: Previous Jobs
Topic: Dr. Who Mafia - Night 12
Replies: 7359
Views: 189373

Re: Dr. Who Mafia - Night 3

In case anyone confronts me about it later: Voted for the 4th option because I used to have the #4 jersey in little league in like 1st grade so it's become my go-to number for this type of thing.

linki to mp regarding uncertainty after a coin-toss: yeeessss, I think you're right, actually. :( Guess I didn't think that through well enough. I assume the hosts probably wouldn't say if it went to a flip or not.

So it becomes a 33% chance at revealing two baddies vs a 66% chance at killing one civ.

Sounds like it still might be worth it, but I guess I've never been the best at numbers. It would be a real risky move for sure, and actually considering that so far we've gotten a total of zero baddies, the hope of achieving option #3 is slowly fading away in my head as I type...

Shame, for a second there I thought I had actually come up with a move that would be both bold and useful :(
by Gotrees
Fri Oct 03, 2014 12:42 am
Forum: Previous Jobs
Topic: Dr. Who Mafia - Night 12
Replies: 7359
Views: 189373

Re: Dr. Who Mafia - Night 3

zeek wrote:If we aim for a tie between a civ and a baddie, the civ will be lynched. No tie. I think its necessary to have a clear choice of 2 votes so its free from manipulation in that sense at least.
Potential outcomes:

CIV + CIV tie = One civ lynched, no baddies revealed, one person confirmed as civ. (worst-case)

CIV + BAD tie = One civ lynched, one baddie revealed.

BAD + BAD tie = One baddie lynched, one baddie revealed. (best-case)

So it's pretty much a gamble, but at least all of the options are better than just lynching a civ like we've been doing these past few nights. Even with option one, we lose a civ but one person is also confirmed as definitely a civ, unless I'm missing some way the baddies can manipulate that. (I suppose they would probably just lynch that confirmed civ the next night, but who knows.)

Anyway, judging by this last poll, I doubt we're all organized enough to go through with that, but if there's any possibility of it happening, I'd be willing to get behind the idea.

Return to “Dr. Who Mafia - Night 12”