The Syndicate

Forgot to reply to this due to EPIc posts. My problem with Epi right now is that MM's case was good. It showed how inconsistent he has been and his responses have done little to convince me he's good. His tone, deflated and dejected, has however. So I'm back and forth on him. Then we have Snowman. H...

Another question. What are the odds, in your opinion, that DH is Kira? This is where I'm struggling with both of them. I don't see either of them butting heads so radically if either was Kira. We can talk about egos, but they're clever enough to avoid this sort of thing if either is Kira. My worry ...

Woah :huh: I agree Epi's conclusion came first, but I can understand that because he probably set out to prove a point. DH has been one of his biggest critics. That said, I'm still on the fence with Epi. He's made some good points but it can also be read as the largest NO U in Mafia history. I'm gla...

I'd be onboard

My problem with Epi right now is that MM's case was good. It showed how inconsistent he has been and his responses have done little to convince me he's good. His tone, deflated and dejected, has however. So I'm back and forth on him. Then we have Snowman. His responses don't seem genuine to me and h...

Very convincing case, MM, I hadn't put together all those inconsistencies from Epi. Although I'm not sure on you, your points are persuasive. I may vote Epi if he convince me otherwise. I really don't know what to make of all the strange behaviour in this game tbh, feels like it's going to be quite ...

Turnip Head wrote:If my illegitimate discussion helps catch Kira I'll consider it a win

Turnip Head wrote:Not very, since I still think you might be bad and I think your reaction here is a little petty. But sorry enough in case you are genuinely upset for some reason.

A little petty? You're serious, aren't you?

Wow. This game is crazy. People are acting so crazy.

How sorry are you?

Really? That's all the two of you have to say? I suspect both of you, but I doubt it'd help to lynch either :stare: You sound pretty upset Zeek. That people don't have to give reasons and be open to discussion? Damn right. Clearly you're playing a different game to me and you don't need to do any th...

I am going nuts here? TH can have a go at my vote which I said myself wasn't strong, but other players can just say "I think he's bad" and vote immediately, without giving due discussion and time to consider their votes? Frankly, this is stupid. Especially from TH, who changed his mind on ...

Why did you guys vote so quickly? MM, you even said it was foolish, so how can you justify it?

Fairly happy with the results as well. Most of the big ones were pretty obvious and as I predicted, except for Best Actor. Glad Big Hero 6 won second place Animated Movie (cause first was Lego Movie!)

I've post a fair bit rebuffing TH's worries over my vote. I'm balancing a few things today - even thought it's my day off - but still reveiwing some posters.

linki - Jeez, this game is moving too fast for even me :P

Metalmarsh89 wrote:
zeek wrote:I've never played in a game in which votes are not changeable, so is it normal for such early votes?
Not really. It would be foolish to vote early when votes are not changeable.

Why did you vote so early then?

I've never played in a game in which votes are not changeable, so is it normal for such early votes? There are a few people I need to look at closer and hopefully form some opinions about. I don't have a read on a lot of people at this point and it's worrying tbh. On the one hand, he seems frustrate...

Matahari wrote:Zeke, no bashing STV here. I cut my mafia teeth there and I'm so grateful Roxy and LaD talked me into playing a game. I got hooked.

I am your mafia grandpa then, I talked Roxy into playing her first game :P

I don't believe that's what my post said

S~V~S wrote:I was thinking of it more in terms of Devils Advocate.

Considering how many times he brought up my vote I don't feel it was playing Devils Advocate.

I've just realised I was immune N1 and D2, not D2 and N2. Thanks for the talk, Turnip, always a pleasure drawing attention to myself

And I'm starting to understand yours. You're a troublemaker.

Wrong, I saw something that pinged me. You're projecting something into my word which isn't there, i.e. you're bullshitting. Also, I didn't compare it to Donner. I said it ISN'T Donner. There is no civilian team, which implies BTSC to me. You say I tried to make something out of nothing but I litera...

Below is Zeek's vote post. Tell me if I'm bullshitting, fellow players, but it looks like Zeek's reason for voting Snowman was because he called the civ roles a "team" and according to Zeek they are instead a "community". I don't feel good about voting for anybody, but I have to...

Need to catch up on the past few pages and look at the voting, but: Zeek voted Snowman for implying there was a civ team. What. That's bullshit. That's not what I said. Don't take my words out of context. I voted for him for saying he wants to help his team going into the future. I didn't like the l...

Nobody reads my posts

I don't feel good about voting for anybody, but I have to because I need to sleep. I've looked into most of the main players being talked about and this post pinged me harder than others. Buuuuuuuut, it is a social deduction game. Maybe good civvies behave differently, if this were live, I'd be look...

I missed Russ. I'm worried about Russ because he's been a lot more quiet than usual and doesn't seem to be as engaged as civ Russ would be. The silent treatment always puts me on edge when you expect good discussion from certain players.

I have skimmed and gleamed what I can in the available time I have at the moment. I feel bad voting right now because I'm not where I should be with the thread but I don't want to abstain because I don't believe that helps anyone. llama - He does get called out early and sometimes lynched because of...

I need to catch up but the past two days have been terrible for me and I won't have a change until tomorrow night.

I feel horrible

I am sorry so, MP, cause I had bags of time before I replaced in. I promise I will give this game the time and respect it deserves when I get the chance!

I found myself agreeing with Epi over the D0 vote but since then he's lost me a bit. This little tiff with DH seems rather pointless to me, as it's not helping at all. We'll have to lynch one of these guys eventually if they can't let their egos cool off and cooperate. That said, maybe this is a ca...

I found myself agreeing with Epi over the D0 vote but since then he's lost me a bit. This little tiff with DH seems rather pointless to me, as it's not helping at all. We'll have to lynch one of these guys eventually if they can't let their egos cool off and cooperate. That said, maybe this is a cal...

I've been mostly following along, less so today as I had stuff to do but I should catch up tomorrow and have some thoughts.

As I haven't received my role yet

I'll be back in the morning

bea wrote:If I were a civ, I'd be VERY wary of anyone who seemed they were buddying up to me. Not that anyone does. I don't have ideas worth buddying up to - but yea. If I were svs or dh or lc or someone - I'd look for that.

Affirmative, bea. That's a very nice assessment, bea.

The game is afoot.

bea wrote:
zeek wrote:
bea wrote:I'm currently entertaining Chettey and 'Brella.
I like Chet and Ella
How are you not playing this game??? wtf zeeky????

Having a break

I am regretting not signing up.

bea wrote:I'm currently entertaining Chettey and 'Brella.

I like Chet and Ella

If you decide to expand this into a full game I can give you some more robots to include

Who is your favourite 17th century English lyric poet?

They won't know which it came from, cause reasons. The confessions won't be hard to understand, so superhero knowledge isn't essential.

I've put a few things in the game that fans might enjoy though

Events and such.

linki - Yes.

What does this mean? Each Night, he may choose three players to confess their sins. He will be given a Host-created confession of one. Probably not well worded. It means he can pick three players' names to submit via PM. At the end of the night he'll get a confession based on a role one of those th...

Thought I'd try to limit the information. Even Iron Man's investigations get unreliable as he gets drunk

Epi doesn't get angry, he gets even

I'm serious though

Galactus may take Apocalypse's place.

Any thought on the setup?

Mystique was a seemer. Apocalypse chose four players to be his horsemen on Day 0. If these four died, so would Apocalypse. Each time one of the four died, Apocalypse could kill. Apocalypse also had one resurrection to use. He had to eliminate the others to win with his horsemen. Similar then. Apoca...

What were Apoc's and Mystique's powers?

It was easier to put in the Blob with a block role than think up a Pyro power :P

Mystique Her shape-shifting abilities allow her to go undetected. If lynched, she will appear to be the role of her choice. She will learn the role of any player her team kills. Blob Every Night, he may use his enormous size to block a player. Apocalypse He will choose four Horsemen at the beginnin...

Epignosis wrote:I don't like comics or superheroes, sorry.

Mar vel Maf ia: Infi nity A battle for the universe, for 30 players. http://i1368.photobucket.com/albums/ag187/zeek97/marvel-banner_zpsa6caabb1.jpg Heroes (18) Avengers Assemble! Must defeat the Would-Be Rulers, Hydra and certain Independents to win. http://i1368.photobucket.com/albums/ag187/zeek97...

Did you know you are one of my favorite people on this forum? :D Oh you :hug: What do you do to pay the bills? (I'm pretty sure I asked this and somehow missed the answer) I'm an AM at a supermarket (not one of the big evil ones tho.) Do you have a mafia nemisis? if so, who is it? MP :feb: Who do yo...

With the beginning of this new participation rating system, it could be a good idea to turn it into a reputation rating. Info-dumping could lose points as well as inactivity, with a standard amount of points being deducted for various crimes. It may be easier to track as well, as the mods wouldn't h...

N8: zeek Were you informed this failed? At this point I was Marla and unrecruitable. Oh, really? That would have been nice to know. I thought he said you were recruited, but maybe Epi can confirm or deny. Maybe he decided it would make it obvious I might be a problem for you if he told you it failed.

MovingPictures07 wrote:N8: zeek

Were you informed this failed? At this point I was Marla and unrecruitable.

Search found 1450 matches