Search found 60 matches

by HannaK
Wed Nov 12, 2014 2:00 pm
Forum: Previous Jobs
Topic: Monopoly Mafia [GAME OVER]
Replies: 2891
Views: 79773

Re: Monopoly Mafia [Day 3]

MovingPictures07 wrote:
HannaK wrote:Man i chose a bad day to be away from my computer yesterday
S~V~S wrote:
Boogs wrote:This changes my whole perception of the situation that LC could have been a color set, and that in fact he could have auto searched a Railroad if Llama was already found. I agree his behavior was iffy on Day 0 and I agree with MP on the total turnabout on Llama. He did a fake back and forth with Bullzeye in Monty where i didn't bite on it too much and they played me at the end when they were distancing teammates. I would NOT put past LC to do it here again with Llama. Not to mention Llama and him having fake arguments today on "don't ruin my game" and stuff to now them not after each other again and focusing lights on me and MM to get out of the radar.

So you want to lynch them whether they are baddies or LMS? LMS without a kill is better than a civvie, but i would still rather find a baddie. And even if we are to accept that they have BTS now, how do you know it is baddie BTS, not civvie BTS?

Did either LC or Llama land on a utility?
The whole Llama LC theory is interesting and I can definitely see the reasoning. They could as of this moment have a set of 3, it's not unlikely especially in light of the auto-find LC used (but then again that means that they had to have gotten lucky on night 1, what are the odds?). However, the biggest problem I have with the theory, is the conclusion of it. Like SVS says, I don't see how we should care *this much* if there are a set with hotel buying powers and such when you compare it to the money and power the baddies have right now. Sure, they could also be a baddie set, but again: what are the odds.
I'm just a little bit torn right now as I have no very firm suspicions of my own right now as to who are bad, I have been trying to follow the money (as I still think the money people spend can be the biggest clue as to who are bad and have too much money on their hands), but so far nothing super concrete stands out yet.
So maybe in the end it might be better to lynch someone from a suspected set rather than mistakingly lynching a civvie with no set...
I know you're new here, the posting is of high volume, and it's still early in the game. Nonetheless, I just want to confirm: You say you have absolutely no thoughts on anyone being bad right now? Nothing has stuck out to you at all? I know you mentioned thoughts on juliets earlier, but those were completely addressed, you feel?
So far I find it quite hard, since I normally often base my suspicions partly on gamestyles of players and since I an new here it's hard to read people's posts. So far juliets posts and defences seem genuine to me and I also don't think Boogs is bad. The case against BWT is interesting as well, I am gonna re-read some of that tonight if I find the time
Long Con wrote:
Hannah wrote:.
So maybe in the end it might be better to lynch someone from a suspected set rather than mistakingly lynching a civvie with no set...
That would not be better. I am not in a set, I am a Civvie with a Civvie BTSC partner. This game is designed so that the Civvies get an advantage through BTSC pairs. Don't look away from baddies and lynch me, please.
I know that's what you are claiming yes, that's why I say 'suspected set' and I fully see the benefit of obtaining a BTSC partner, the thing is though, I am inclined to believe you already found all of your teammates, as I have read llama's defence but don't neccessarily find it convincing.
by HannaK
Wed Nov 12, 2014 1:18 pm
Forum: Previous Jobs
Topic: Monopoly Mafia [GAME OVER]
Replies: 2891
Views: 79773

Re: Monopoly Mafia [Day 3]

Man i chose a bad day to be away from my computer yesterday
S~V~S wrote:
Boogs wrote:This changes my whole perception of the situation that LC could have been a color set, and that in fact he could have auto searched a Railroad if Llama was already found. I agree his behavior was iffy on Day 0 and I agree with MP on the total turnabout on Llama. He did a fake back and forth with Bullzeye in Monty where i didn't bite on it too much and they played me at the end when they were distancing teammates. I would NOT put past LC to do it here again with Llama. Not to mention Llama and him having fake arguments today on "don't ruin my game" and stuff to now them not after each other again and focusing lights on me and MM to get out of the radar.

So you want to lynch them whether they are baddies or LMS? LMS without a kill is better than a civvie, but i would still rather find a baddie. And even if we are to accept that they have BTS now, how do you know it is baddie BTS, not civvie BTS?

Did either LC or Llama land on a utility?
The whole Llama LC theory is interesting and I can definitely see the reasoning. They could as of this moment have a set of 3, it's not unlikely especially in light of the auto-find LC used (but then again that means that they had to have gotten lucky on night 1, what are the odds?). However, the biggest problem I have with the theory, is the conclusion of it. Like SVS says, I don't see how we should care *this much* if there are a set with hotel buying powers and such when you compare it to the money and power the baddies have right now. Sure, they could also be a baddie set, but again: what are the odds.
I'm just a little bit torn right now as I have no very firm suspicions of my own right now as to who are bad, I have been trying to follow the money (as I still think the money people spend can be the biggest clue as to who are bad and have too much money on their hands), but so far nothing super concrete stands out yet.
So maybe in the end it might be better to lynch someone from a suspected set rather than mistakingly lynching a civvie with no set...
by HannaK
Mon Nov 10, 2014 9:05 am
Forum: Previous Jobs
Topic: Monopoly Mafia [GAME OVER]
Replies: 2891
Views: 79773

Re: Monopoly Mafia [Day 2]

juliets wrote:
HannaK wrote:I am inclined to believe FZ because back in the day I sorta played the pity card when I was civvie as well when I felt overwhelmed with the game and everything, plus it is also an indicator FZ doenst have BTSC.
The person I am mostly looking to right now is juliets, now I am nor familair with the style juliets normally plays, but looking through the posts I find it weird that most of them are either questions directed at other players who they find suspicous without really contributing anything substantial or info about votes and/or money. To me this feels like a good baddie tactic, posting without revealing too much about yourself so I am gonna go ahead and vote juliets. I'm not 100% convinced but so far this has spiked my baddie-sensor the most.
HannaK, my mafia style is to ask questions. Also, I got lynched once for being too nice. These two things are hallmarks of my style, i.e., regardless of my alignment I ask a lot of questions - that's how I process information - and I am normally polite when playing. You can ask the people who play with me often and I'm pretty sure they will say the same. I'm not sure what you mean about revealing anything about myself - did you read the post I just posted about who I am thinking about right now?

Speaking of that TH, TH there is one other person who has caught my eye depending on how he answers my question and that is llama. I forgot to include that in my last post.
Since everyone seems to confirm this is your playstyle I guess I should say my bad then :)

I am kinda worried about how everyone jumps onto a bandwagon of someone who only received like 2 votes (FZ), just for the reason to have the 200$ added, I mean, I get why you would do that if there is still a few minutes left to vote and it is clear that he or she is going to be lynched, but I could easily see us voting out civvies very easily just because he or she received 2 or 3 votes at the beginning of the day and everyone just tagging along with it because money
by HannaK
Sun Nov 09, 2014 8:18 pm
Forum: Previous Jobs
Topic: Monopoly Mafia [GAME OVER]
Replies: 2891
Views: 79773

Re: Monopoly Mafia [Day 2]

I am inclined to believe FZ because back in the day I sorta played the pity card when I was civvie as well when I felt overwhelmed with the game and everything, plus it is also an indicator FZ doenst have BTSC.
The person I am mostly looking to right now is juliets, now I am nor familair with the style juliets normally plays, but looking through the posts I find it weird that most of them are either questions directed at other players who they find suspicous without really contributing anything substantial or info about votes and/or money. To me this feels like a good baddie tactic, posting without revealing too much about yourself so I am gonna go ahead and vote juliets. I'm not 100% convinced but so far this has spiked my baddie-sensor the most.
by HannaK
Sat Nov 08, 2014 4:19 pm
Forum: Previous Jobs
Topic: Monopoly Mafia [GAME OVER]
Replies: 2891
Views: 79773

Re: Monopoly Mafia [Day 2]

Hedgeowl wrote:
FZ. wrote:Asking again:

What happens if no one bids on a property?
Because if we decide we don't bid and baddies do, we know they're baddies, and if they're too scared to bid on them too, they don't get them?
I cant imagine any baddie actaully doing that though. Its a good thought not bidding, but what baddie would out themselves that way. Another thought would be to bid last minute so you cant be nkd for the card that night and then sell it as LC said he would do.
RIP SVS :(
Honestly, I don't really see why people are *that* afraid of bidding, I mean, like LC said, I can imagine there are a lot of people who would gladly take the card off your hands if it is anonymous anyway and that way you earn a nice amount of money.
by HannaK
Fri Nov 07, 2014 1:03 pm
Forum: Previous Jobs
Topic: Monopoly Mafia [GAME OVER]
Replies: 2891
Views: 79773

Re: Monopoly Mafia [Day 1]

Elohcin wrote:
HannaK wrote:(I can already tell that the end vote times won't be to my advantage, no way I am staying up till 3 am to see who is getting a lot of votes so I can change mine last minute as well)
Anyway, day 1 votes are always hard and I hate to vote random. So far I don't really see any of the big BTSC debaters as bad per se, so I am gonna vote for Made for bidding quite a lot of money on a special power but backing out when Elochin bid 250, if I were a baddie I wouldn't want people to think I had too much money on my hands either. It's not a very good reason, but it's day 1 and it is a reason nonetheless.
Where do you live?
Leeds, UK

And wow I voted for Made before the slip-up for a minor reason but I guess my reasoning was solid enough then. And yeah I like FZ's plan in theory, but I am definitely not trusting anyone enough yet to make the plan a reality
by HannaK
Thu Nov 06, 2014 3:13 pm
Forum: Previous Jobs
Topic: Monopoly Mafia [GAME OVER]
Replies: 2891
Views: 79773

Re: Monopoly Mafia [Day 1]

(I can already tell that the end vote times won't be to my advantage, no way I am staying up till 3 am to see who is getting a lot of votes so I can change mine last minute as well)
Anyway, day 1 votes are always hard and I hate to vote random. So far I don't really see any of the big BTSC debaters as bad per se, so I am gonna vote for Made for bidding quite a lot of money on a special power but backing out when Elochin bid 250, if I were a baddie I wouldn't want people to think I had too much money on my hands either. It's not a very good reason, but it's day 1 and it is a reason nonetheless.
by HannaK
Thu Nov 06, 2014 7:36 am
Forum: Previous Jobs
Topic: Monopoly Mafia [GAME OVER]
Replies: 2891
Views: 79773

Re: Monopoly Mafia [Day 1]

S~V~S wrote:
The thing that is confusing me, I guess, is all the worrying people are doing about what MIGHT happen if civs form monopolies and become indies rather than worrying about two actual baddie teams that have kills. And I just reread the Utilities, those guys are super powerful. They know roles, plus they have a bidding advantage if those known cards come up for sale.
Are you talking about those cards that come up for sale because of their kill? Because I sorta agree with you but like i wondered previously, wouldnt it become too obvious if one or two people keep winning the bid of cards of people who were killed on even nights?

also question off topic: the time stated for the voting deadline, is that adjusted to the timezone I put in my board preferences (UK)? Or do I need to count like a few hours back because it is based on an American timezone?
by HannaK
Wed Nov 05, 2014 5:40 pm
Forum: Previous Jobs
Topic: Monopoly Mafia [GAME OVER]
Replies: 2891
Views: 79773

Re: Monopoly Mafia [Day 1]

Okay so I have caught up (sort of anyway) and I have a question/concern/thought
boo wrote:

Team 2: Utilities (2)
This team starts the game with BTSC. Kills even nights. Cannot be NKed by the Railroads. Any player who lands on a utility will have their property learned by the utilities, and if they are ever lynched, the utilities will have $300 applied to a bid on the property.
I am slightly confused, doesn't this give the baddies away more easily as they are more likely to 'win' the bet, or does this simply mean that the baddies need to be careful in terms of what they are bidding so as not to give themselves away? (or, which can also be the case: am I just not getting it)


Also, I am quite a conservative player in any board game so no bidding for me yet :) About the whole teaming up question and which cards to buy, it's kinda tricky I mean I can easily see this game becoming about trying to stop (assumed) BTSC teams from aquiring certain properties rather than focusing on lynching bad guys, but then again, if you think certain people have BTSC then they become baddies for you as well since they are out to kill you as well eventually :ponder:
The only thing to really go on right now is 'following the money' as it is more likely baddies spend more money on powers/bids since they have more than other players
by HannaK
Tue Nov 04, 2014 10:57 am
Forum: Previous Jobs
Topic: Monopoly Mafia [GAME OVER]
Replies: 2891
Views: 79773

Re: Monopoly Mafia [Day 0]

I'm checking in! The game looks complicated but not overly so. Excited to get this show on the road

Return to “Monopoly Mafia [GAME OVER]”