The Syndicate

Zomberella12 wrote:- There are so many non-posters. We might all be civies.

Actually I just counted and there are less than I thought. Somebody here is a baddie! Where you at baddie?

MovingPictures07 wrote:Zomb, I have the following questions for you:

- How do you feel about Snowman this game? Any read on him yet (more likely civ or bad) or not sure?
- Same question regarding Epi
- Same question regarding trice (I had a good laugh when you called him PornStar)
- Regarding your point about Russ and FZ., could they not have baddie BTSC with the same argument? I'm not saying I suspect or don't suspect either of them, but I'm merely playing devil's advocate with your argument.

- Snowman's behavior is typical. He likes to do psychoanalysis and then sit back and watch the fight. I cannot read him. Ever. I know that if he is a baddie, we are all probably dead.
- I will now refer to PornStar - I mean trice - as PS JK PornStar, you know you're my favorite.
- It seems weird that players would collude to infodump. Plus, I think it was accidental. But, anyone in a baddie group would try to act like they were in a civie group.
- There are so many non-posters. We might all be civies.

Ricochet wrote:Actually, since they're both keen to infodump, shall we assume FZ and LC are actually in the same group and infodumping is their "mechanism"?

This feels like a weird assumption to me. It sounds a little protective. Maybe Rico, FZ, and LC are all in the same group?

thellama73 wrote:

Zomberella12 wrote: Llama seems pretty upset about posting who's in what BSCG with who. I get that it's against the rules but he seems overly upset about it. Perhaps that's his nature, but it seems to me that a civie wouldn't really worried about that kind of information getting out because it would be protective. However, who else would make such a brazen attack on Epig and MP via the message from Mrs. Donner? I'll wait to see how he reacts to this comment.

Yeah, because only baddies care about not cheating. He said, pretty sarcastically.

I figured someone would make that accusation when I posted what I did, but you can't lynch me today anyway, and by tomorrow, who knows what role I will have?

No, I don't think that only baddies care about cheating. I just haven't ever played a game with you before so I don't know. Some people have more of a sense of justice than others. Some people are fine with others cheating if I helps them. Oh yeah, I forgot that you can't get eaten. Anyway, I think that you might be able to influence Mrs. Donner in some way so I don't suspect you.

Zomberella12 wrote:

MovingPictures07 wrote: Russ and FZ, your comments don't give me info one way or another. I suspect that this may be because you are letting others in your group do all the talking...
[/ot]

Not a dig. I just mean that I think that you might actually be in a civie group.

PornStar, I wonder if you are maybe acting confused to earn sympathy? Things that make you go hmm.....

MovingPictures07 wrote: Linki w/ Zomb: I will admit that my hyper-analysis would occur likely regardless of alignment, so I wouldn't recommend trusting me just for that reason -- I've been a really active civilian-seeming baddie before (in fact, it's kind of my style). Nonetheless, I don't think it warrants automatic suspicion of me either. It just means I love mafia and it takes up almost all of my free me time.

Yeah, but this time you sound legit.

Llama seems pretty upset about posting who's in what BSCG with who. I get that it's against the rules but he seems overly upset about it. Perhaps that's his nature, but it seems to me that a civie wouldn't really worried about that kind of information getting out because it would be protective. However, who else would make such a brazen attack on Epig and MP via the message from Mrs. Donner? I'll wait to see how he reacts to this comment.

Russ and FZ, your comments don't give me info one way or another. I suspect that this may be because you are letting others in your group do all the talking...

Snowman, your post is all about civie strategy - none of them really favor the baddies. However, it is pretty benign and does divert our attention away from lunching you.

I feel like the game is designed to make the civies turn on each other - the way the real Donner party did. Bwahahaha.

In real life, Levina's mother in law was named Holly Ann Duke. She is my 5th(?) great grandmother and the namesake of my daughter: Holly Ann Cooper. Levina's husband's brother was named Emanuel Masters Murphy and he had like 50 wives.

I just spent like an hour catching up on all of y'alls posts. Good greif!

My analysis (for what it's worth):

LongCon was suspicious to me through the whole thread. It seemed like he latched on to other people's ideas/plans in a very convenient way. But now....he's posting like he all feels bad and stuff. I don't know if that is a typical manipulative post for him, and I don't think that his info dumping was that bad, but I still think he's suspicious.

I think that Mrs. Donner's accusation of MP and Epig was likely based on past history and not anything that she knows about either of them in this game,

I don't think that lynching your own civie teammates (that you know are civies) because you are afraid of role switching makes sense. If you are a civie, you should make the best decision in the moment to help that team (Snowman #3).

I am a civie. MP's hyper-analysis is over the top, but I can't see him spending that much time posting and planning if he wasn't a civie. Plus my civie group has latched on to his civie/baddie signaling idea. Epig seems to be willing to say whatever makes drama. Llama....I don't even know.

Metalmarsh89 wrote:

Zomberella12 wrote:

Metalmarsh89 wrote:

MovingPictures07 wrote:

Snowman wrote:Why indeed, and why is Epignosis trying so hard to stir the pot? Guilty much?

Haha, love it.

But I wouldn't say this is atypical of Epi; he and Llama are perhaps the most notorious for stirring up the pot early on in games, regardless of alignment.

What am I, chopped liver?

Chopped marmot liver...yum

Alex invited some strange people to play with us already strange folk.

I think we should sacrifice a newbie for the Day 1 lunch.

Yikes!

Metalmarsh89 wrote:

MovingPictures07 wrote:

Snowman wrote:Why indeed, and why is Epignosis trying so hard to stir the pot? Guilty much?

Haha, love it.

But I wouldn't say this is atypical of Epi; he and Llama are perhaps the most notorious for stirring up the pot early on in games, regardless of alignment.

What am I, chopped liver?

Chopped marmot liver...yum

Epignosis wrote:Are you bad? Then yes, I am accusing you.

Are you good? Then nope! Just passing by.

Sorry - I mean accusing me of infodumping.

Epignosis wrote:

Zomberella12 wrote:

Epignosis wrote:

Dom wrote:

Epignosis wrote:Since I can't die, I'm going to just say that Ricochet sounds like a newbie bad guy to me.

He's in another game too

Ah, so you're defending him then.

Got it.

Touches nose.

Moves on.

He who smelt it, dealt it.

Infodumping.

Hold up. Are you accusing me? Explain....explain....(since I'm new, not because I'm a dalek)

Epignosis wrote:

Dom wrote:

Epignosis wrote:Since I can't die, I'm going to just say that Ricochet sounds like a newbie bad guy to me.

He's in another game too

Ah, so you're defending him then.

Got it.

Touches nose.

Moves on.

He who smelt it, dealt it.

That does look like a pretty disgusting sock.

Long Con wrote:

Zomberella12 wrote:Do not worry. I am totally up to the challenge. As an actual direct descendent of the Lavinia Jackson Murphy family, I am especially equipped for the task. Let's eat!

Heh... the member of the Donner party that was secretly a zombie the whole time. "You know, I DO recall her casually bringing up eating people, even before our supplies ran out..."

Now give me your brain please.

Ooooh. I didn't do that quote right. Lemme try again.

Zomberella12 wrote:
Do not worry. I am totally up to the challenge. As an actual direct descendent of the Lavinia Jackson Murphy family, I am especially equipped for the task. Let's eat!

Heh... the member of the Donner party that was secretly a zombie the whole time. "You know, I DO recall her casually bringing up eating people, even before our supplies ran out..."

Supplies are for mortals! Me want braaaaainz!

Do not worry. I am totally up to the challenge. As an actual direct descendent of the Lavinia Jackson Murphy family, I am especially equipped for the task. Let's eat!

Okay - A it is. Bwahahahaha.