The Syndicate

read lsit so metalmarsh can be town sig is obvious scum right now MP i would lynch as well. to do list silver needs to eb sorted soon. figure out names meta, relookign its null For what reason? Nonsense. "Guts" you say. Unless you can back up any of your assertions with reasoning (such as...

insertnamehere wrote: Twas a bit of a jape, nothing serious meant by it. To be honest, I assumed all of your "early reads" were prime examples of tomfoolery and not 100% serious.

no they are real reads, they prob wont be like that for long

Wow..... everyone is gone....

ill thorw mtal to town pile too Who? metalmarsh i like his entrance Duh, should of known. Perhaps I should go read the game starting with the player list. :p I think it's too early to be giving out reads that quick but you do that so meh. I on the other hand, am dealing with a shitty fever and will...

Yes, and I don't even know what's going on yet? How about you? well vote with me and i think sig could eb scum right now along with insertname dunnow about everony else im gettin areal scum vib e from ika idk bout the rest of yous i will be exepcting your vote when the game begins. care to elaborat...

Silverwolf wrote:
ika wrote:ill thorw mtal to town pile too
Who?

metalmarsh i like his entrance

read lsit
so metalmarsh can be town
sig is obvious scum right now
MP i would lynch as well.

to do list
silver needs to eb sorted soon.
figure out names meta, relookign its null

ill thorw mtal to town pile too

Yes, and I don't even know what's going on yet? How about you? well vote with me and i think sig could eb scum right now along with insertname dunnow about everony else Elaborate please. I don't believe you could possibly have a read on either of those players so soon, so I'm inclined to think you'...

Silverwolf wrote:
Yes, and I don't even know what's going on yet? How about you?

well vote with me and i think sig could eb scum right now along with insertname

dunnow about everony else

Silverwolf wrote:
ika wrote:
Silverwolf wrote:Hi all!!

Why you say hi to everyone?
Hi ika!!

HI SILVER!!!!!

are you town? got any reads yet?

Silverwolf wrote:Hi all!!

Why you say hi to everyone?

oh fyi for the next 3-4 days my posting is going to be serverly limited due to work

sig wrote:Oh and Support the Front line of course
pray that I don't get eaten please.

No Ika, rabbit stole first. :P

nah you stole first before it got removed.

that being said im porb gonna afk first part of day 0

ok first vote goes to sig for stealing ym first

plz let me and silver roll scum together....

A Person wrote: I am mostly amusing myself by pointing out one of the problems one has as a civ player.

Well, if you want to be tecnical all maifa (outside of PR reulsts and mod info) is WIFOM in itself.

What if yours, or others, posts in this thread are a part of your meta game meant to influence future mafia games? Then we are not having a discussion and are going into a WIFOM argument. Ah, I predicted this, to call something a WIFOM argument is the oldest meta game of all! I edited my post to re...

What if yours, or others, posts in this thread are a part of your meta game meant to influence future mafia games? Then we are not having a discussion and are going into a WIFOM argument. I do think that the discussion will change how mafia games are designed overall (as JJJ pointed out with his si...

On the meta issue: i agree if people use it too much that they will get overtaken one game. Funny enough as much as i say i use meta, i only use it very little. If anything i use it as a baseline to start a read. Even with silver, i dont like to think when it comes ot reading her its not about meta...

On the meta issue: i agree if people use it too much that they will get overtaken one game. Funny enough as much as i say i use meta, i only use it very little. If anything i use it as a baseline to start a read. Even with silver, i dont like to think when it comes ot reading her its not about meta,...

I've pointed this out before, but (until Turf Wars), a mafia team of more than 4 players has never won on the Syndicate. The big teams always end up losing. It's the games where there's two mafia teams, or one mafia team and an Indy team, or several Indy roles and a mafia team, where the mafia usua...

I think a no info-dumping rule is a necessity in open setup games with a large number of special roles, especially when everyone has a special role. I don't think there's any way to arrange a game like that with roleclaiming and info-dumping without it being broken. That's a unique appeal to this c...

My roots are different than yours. In any case, we did not allow it where I started, and the wins were balanced, so it is probably a combination of factors. I don't disagree either, i think where i have that point is from my roots and a little bit of devil's advocate where on an objective view and ...

I've been caught out by a guilty as scum when I was playing an excellent scum game and went down. The problem with not being able to claim is the cop could be lynched with several clears and no one would know. The reason for claiming is exactly this. It gives an advantage to town in a situation whe...

I think case building is better play than info dumping, and as Epi says, better sportsmanship. Baddies are not vermin to be caught; they are respected adversaries to be outwitted. Still disagree overall but i'm not going to argue it that much cus its just an opinion and i'm not to say what i think ...

One thing that is a major reason is that, traditionally here, civilians only won if they were alive and eliminated the Mafia. If civilians won dead or alive, I would have a lot more banners down there. However, the prevailing mindset among many has been, "As long as the lynch isn't me, everyth...

Well, perhaps some of us feel such is NOT the game. I have played with people who really actually seemed to think the baddies were actually bad, like they got RL mad and such. That's why I like that we use a silly name, baddies, rather than "scum". It's harder to get mad about being manip...

I think our culture is some of it. It tends to be viewed as inherently unfair for a baddie who has played a flawless game to get outed because someone got a PM :shrug: We had this culture at our core communities, and the win ratio was pretty even, so I don't think that is all of it, though. On the ...

Civilians have been dominating the Heists here on the Syndicate though. That makes for an interesting counter-study. I think with hesit, it is more straightforward and counteracts one of the most important things on the site, claiming and info dumping. As it was seen in the one that just finished, ...

Honestly i would pick all of them except role usage. Mafia at its core is literally citizen/vanilla vs mafia. Role usages is just an added benefit to it all. If a game is dependent on role usage that's another thing but towns biggest power is its voice and its vote. Which could fall under game desig...

are hydras allowed?

i say silver for scum MVP and the cop for town MVP

gleam gets best rp

MP did anyone else guess socks outside of me?

if thats the case i dont think there should be anything cus i knew silvers picks before the game began

(FTR i was not going to sign up and i acutaly sugested one of the picks)

TBH this game shows how important a cop is in hindsight, nibbler could of waled the entire game but couldnt only due to POE as i has said in rico hesit game.

cop will outbeat it all

like i said, if cop didnt out...... she would ofbeen able to pull it off

wow a night 3 frame was sucessful? what is that? liek 2% chance that both of them target the same person?

silver did very well

i do have to say if the cop didnt claim and silver continued her silence idea she might of made endgame

man MP ruined it, i was txting silver saying dont post yet pretend i was scum in the game.....

she told me the moment MP agreed to the conceeding

Spacedaisy wrote:I play how I play Ika, hopefully you will learn how to read me better in the future as a result. I believe your signature is lacking something now that the game is over and my civ alignment has been proven.

im not missing anything dasiy, the condition was that you got lynched, you got nked

zebra how come you voted black rock? last time you were against lurker lynched and how it seems to have played out BR would be a lurker no?

a2thezebra wrote:If you're defining who your allies and who your enemies are by their win condition exclusively, you're in deep shit. End of discussion.

well consdiering how golden has not stated any wincons, why should we not define it by wincons?

a2thezebra wrote:lmao these poor newcomers

for real, they should of seen us fighing in heist

i aleady offered others to make a new dicussion and it would porb be moved on but nobody is saying anything so......

idgt?

I'm pretty sure you started it because you realized that you were contradicting yourself so you had to improvise a new definition for the term "scum" as it is normally used in this game just so you could keep arguing without admitting defeat. im not at all. scum and mafia are two differen...

I'm pretty sure you started it because you realized that you were contradicting yourself so you had to improvise a new definition for the term "scum" as it is normally used in this game just so you could keep arguing without admitting defeat. im not at all. scum and mafia are two differen...

a2thezebra wrote:I don't know whether to laugh or cry at that. You're literally pretending to not know the definition of the term to try and save your argument.

im not, i know the term of a mafia and the term of a scum

zebra if you dont belive me you can easly go see the downtown abbey game as well, even thought the doc was aligned to eb town-sided i called him scum still

Search found 1377 matches