I've compiled all the final votes placed in this game by players who are still alive. The information is presented as follows:
[total number of votes received by] Player X: living players who voted for him/her
Civilian
Deceased with unknown alignment
Independent
Day 1:
[3] Epignosis: Scotty
[6] insertnamehere: JJJ, MP/G-Man, timmer, Sloonei/Quin, sig
[2] timmer: MM
[1] trice: Epignosis
Day 2:
[2] A Person: LoRab
[4] Boomslang: MM, BWT, sig
[5] DrWilgy: JJJ, Epignosis, Dom, MP/G-Man
[1] LoRab: Scotty
Day 3:
[6] A Person: LoRab, BWT, timmer, JJJ, MM
[1] BWT: Dom
[1] Dom: sig
[1] LoRab: Sloonei/Quin
[4] MM: MP/G-Man
Day 4:
[6] MM: timmer, Scotty, BWT, MP/G-Man
[1] Sloonei/Quin - sig
[6] trice: Epignosis, JJJ, Dom, LoRab, MM
Day 5:
[3] BWT: MM, Scotty
[1] Scotty: Sloonei/Quin
[5] trice: LoRab, JJJ, timmer, Dom, Epignosis
A few statistical extractions...
Votes cast for players who were lynched the same day phase (nobody is being counted here for Day 4 because it was a tie and nobody died):
BWT: 1
Dom: 2
Epignosis: 2
MP/G-Man: 2
JJJ: 4
LoRab: 2
MM: 1
Sloonei/Quin: 1
Scotty: 0
sig: 1
timmer: 3
I'd say the standout here is Scotty with that goose egg. His votes leave him untraceable by the alignments of each lynched player, none of whom have been on the mafia team. That's not a great look. The exception for him is on Day 4 when he contributed to the tie, but the [non]-result leaves us unable to draw much from that.
Votes cast for confirmed non-members of the mafia team (including trice):
BWT: 1
Dom: 3
Epignosis: 4
MP/G-Man: 2
JJJ: 5
LoRab: 4
MM: 2
Sloonei/Quin: 1
Scotty: 0
sig: 1
timmer: 3
It occurs to me having counted these that the numbers are very similar to the previous tally plus Day 4 (not exactly that, but close). So the insight may be limited. Scotty's zero is the same zero, so there's nothing to add on him.
At the moment I feel okay with LoRab's 4 non-mafia votes. She has gotten her fair share of crap for most of the game but has still been willing to stick her votes on people whose flips did not reflect beautifully on her at face value. It's very easy for mafia to stay out of trouble in this regard since they already know with 94% certainty everyone's alignment from the beginning (and 100% certainty who's not on their own team). I get the impression a baddie LoRab would have been more evasive in her voting pattern than this.
MM's 2 may as well be a 1 since one of them was a self-preservation vote. It should be stated though that in two cases his votes ended days on multi-vote wagons which were at least somewhat relevant. Boomslang especially was quite close to being lynched on Day 2. In that regard I am not super troubled by his voting record. I am less thrilled with his record of uninspiring vote rationales.
Votes cast which did not have a meaningful impact upon the development of EOD discussion and the final tally:
BWT: 0
Dom: 1
Epignosis: 1
MP/G-Man: 0
JJJ: 0
LoRab: 1 (D2 A Person vote is debatable)
MM: 1 (D1 timmer vote is debatable)
Sloonei/Quin: 2
Scotty: 1
sig: 2
timmer: 0
It's unlike Sloonei to have any of these. I think he typically views off-wagon flier votes with as much suspicion as I do. Unfortunately he can't talk about that now, and I am willing to chalk it up to his having been too busy to be involved. Quin had the second one and he is much more known for those. sig's couple of whatever votes aren't my favorite things. He's had difficulty keeping up, but that hasn't stopped him from stating opinions. Also, on Day 2 he was eager to involve himself in the more dramatic EOD proceedings. It was that Boomslang vote that got him into some trouble after all, so that he abandoned any effort to involve himself similarly after that point is not great.
~~~
The voting records which thrill me the least here are Scotty's and sig's.