The Syndicate

Well can you answer the question? You don't have to if you don't want. Am I one of the super posters? Because I think I'm town. I've also got a strong town read on Jay, as I've said, and a slightly weaker town read on MP. Turnip Head, if he's also in this group, is mostly a null read until further ...

my gut reaction is to stick with my Bass suspicion even after his participation in the gun-to-head exercise. It does change my view of him a little bit but it's not enough (yet) to shake my skepticism. why/how? It looks good that he was one of only a few players to participate in the exercise, and ...

Ok I would also like to hear what everyone else is thinking about the super posters. lol. Does anyone else feel like there could be mafia lurking among them? You seem to be implying that you think there's scum hiding out here. Which of us (I assume I'm being counter amomg the super posters, i dunno...

my gut reaction is to stick with my Bass suspicion even after his participation in the gun-to-head exercise. It does change my view of him a little bit but it's not enough (yet) to shake my skepticism. birdwithteeth's lack of participation shakes me a little bit, but again not enough to knock him do...

JaggedJimmyJay wrote:
MovingPictures07 wrote:Can we play the game now, Jay?
i'm game.

HEY Y'ALL: if you're here right now and will be for the next 10-20 minutes, say aye.

if we get enough people, i have an activity for you.

nay, i'm about to leave for like 30 minutes to an hour, but i'll he back after then

Dragon, fingersplints, Turnip Head, vomp, and Roxy all voted for someone other than Eloh. I am making nothing of this yet, just pointing out that it's a reality and something which may be worth pursuing later.
The people who voted for Eloh are in no way abovd suspicion for doing so, of course.

Ok I would also like to hear what everyone else is thinking about the super posters. lol. Does anyone else feel like there could be mafia lurking among them? You seem to be implying that you think there's scum hiding out here. Which of us (I assume I'm being counter amomg the super posters, i dunno...

WOOHOO

that vomp guy is being really secretive His meta is hands down the most bizarre of anyone at this forum, easily. I've really given up trying to understand him, but I can't help but try at times anyway. I've seen him say in more than a couple games blatantly that he's rooting for the mafia regardles...

Elohcin wrote:You are all making a big mistake.

Who do we look at as potential scums if you are good?

I feel so felt

approaching 10 minutes to go and i see no other option, so yeah, voting Elohcin. I apologize if we've all been wrong about you this game, but the case is probably the strongest one in the thread at this point.

i believe we only have 6 votes left in the field and currently the tally leader is up by 4. so i don't feel like i have many things i can do with mine. is anyone else who hasn't voted still around to talk about this? I decided I should vote for Elohcin, and now it seems my vote would put her over t...

Turnip Head: What do you think of the case against Bass? Have you already addressed it? If you have you can just direct me to that post and I'll have a look. If not, well... I'm afraid I haven't looked into the Bass case much yet. He was quiet today but I've felt good about him when he was posting....

I'm gonna go for a big long jog and probably decide my vote when I get back. Fitness mafia is where it's at.

Turnip Head: What do you think of the case against Bass? Have you already addressed it? If you have you can just direct me to that post and I'll have a look. If not, well...

MovingPictures: Supposing you had not already voted for Elohcin, who would you be considering for your vote right now? Elohcin is still an option, but let's pretend you still have a vote to cast. Who might it go to and why? Ooooh, good question. I'm glad you asked. Thinking on it, my vote would ine...

Elohcin - She's been a top suspect all day, and I've expressed some agreement with that suspicion without actually doing my own homework on the case. So here goes. I see that DDL thinks all those who've been posting tonight look like town. I disagree, but not only that, I highly doubt that none of ...

Elohcin, maybe once you've caught up, could you tell us what you think of any/all of the people who are voting for you right now? Do you find any of the votes suspicious? Which ones do you buy as sincere?

MovingPictures: Supposing you had not already voted for Elohcin, who would you be considering for your vote right now? Elohcin is still an option, but let's pretend you still have a vote to cast. Who might it go to and why?

On my phone. I may have less time tonight than anticipated. If anyone wants my take an a specific player i haven't covered yet or has any questions, lemme know now. You commented that you and I came to similar conclusions about fingersplints. Is there more you could add to that? Where does she fit ...

At this point I think aether would be my third suspect behind Bass and Elohcin, and I can get behind a vote of her right now, at least in spirit. I would want to hear more from her because most of my case against her has to do with her inactivity. But the longer it lasts, the worse it looks. Still n...

i'll try to respond to this in the most visibly pleasing an un-huge way possible :) I think I've been fairly clear about what caught my eye about BR: her defense of MP and then backtracking and saying she didn't defend him. This mafia game only has one mafia team, whereas others have more. So if BR ...

Sloonei wrote:spefically

I brought my A game to the thread today.

And I have one question for Sloonei: I noted your rainbow list and that you have Jay and I high on the list because we see eye to eye. However, I want to ask: Does agreeing with someone's points or their approach to the game make them more likely civilian? If not, then can you explain why you speci...

think of all these ISOs as a refernce source. No one actually has to look at them, but say you want to know what Player x has said about Player y. You can go and find Player x's ISO of Player y and there's everything they have to say for you to digest. They're not necessarily cases for suspicion. Th...

i'm seeing a lot of seeming confusion over these ISO posts. is this behavior a new thing here? It should be stressed that not everything we say in those big posts is meant to be interpreter as a scum read . In all of my ISOs I go in with a completely neutral pointnof view and just respond to a perso...

I am going to dip my toes in the rainbow game for the very first time now. I hope you're all as excited as I am for this. JaggedJimmyJay - I find myself agreed with much of what Jay is saying so far, which is usually a good sign. I could do a more thorough ISO later on if I feel it's necessary. Ever...

acrosstheaether wrote:Replace me please. No alignment reveal is too confusing.

if you had to guess at Epi's alignment, what would you say?

Roxy One of the lowest post totals in the game, but there's a fair amount of content in these individual posts. this one is an early one that's pretty substantive and contributes to a number of discussions going on early in the thread. Committing to slight civilian read on DDL. I believe him. Is th...

fingersplints Damn you guys are posting a lot. I'm only about half way through this Expresses early that this game is moving faster than she's used to. It's believable here, as that seems to be a genuine piece of culture shock for many people in this game. That does nothing to suggest an alignment,...

Looking through sanmateo's post history, if there's any one player who deserves to be frustrated for being overlooked this game, it's him. I feel like he's making a lot of posts that are going unheeded, as he seems to be suggesting himself a few times. He's had a big string about Turnip Head as a su...

I've been very aware of your posts in this game, sanmateo, but haven't looked closely and specifically at them, as is the case for lots of people. I still need to do a bunch of ISO stuff. This thread does have the feel of being dominated by a few names in general, and I think it would be ideal to fi...

I skipped the wombat. My read on him is as follows:

JaggedJimmyJay is the Mark!

I'll continue with fingersplints and everyone else later tonight or tomorrow morning. Don't want to overload on reads-making right now. I'll probably still be around the thread regardless.

Black Rock Just catching up here. You guys have been busy today. This post is where I'm at. I see that DDL thinks all those who've been posting tonight look like town. I disagree, but not only that, I highly doubt that none of the mafia are talking. I just can't see that being the case. Honestly, I...

Ok I have a bit of time so if anyone wants to ask me anythingg now is the time or if there are any questions I did answer please point them out. i have a few: 1.) how do you personally differentiate "keeping an eye on a player" and "suspecting a player"? 2.) who are your top sus...

birdwithteeth I've not been uneasy of birdwithteeth's presence at all this game, which is to say he's basically a gut town read for starters. And my eye was initially attracted to his name at the beginning of the game because is that an It's Always Sunny reference? MovingPictures07 , one might asse...

Bass_the_Clever My case against him from Day 1 is here and still stands, so I'll pick this up in his posts after that. Well I voted golden because I dont want to be lynched day one. Voted for Golden late in the day because, at that point, it was either Golden or Bass and self-preservation was on bo...

As a follow-up to that, I hope that a town aether would be able to give us some reads or at least general opinions about the thread. Who do you suspect? Who are your town reads? What do you think of the big cases that have been dominating the thread? Elohcin and Moving Pictures seem to be the two mo...

I'm going to start by looking at some of the low-content posters because that's not something I've really done yet. acrosstheaether - I have not really played a game with anyone since about December/January, and I know aether has played a lot in that time, so I don't know what her recent playstyle h...

JaggedJimmyJay wrote:Sloonei you should read things and then share some delicious perspectives. i'll feast.

I should. I am.

I like the false feeling of solitude tho

I'm voting for most people.

MovingPictures07 wrote:I'm here! Just hidden.

Lurking is v scummy imo

But those time stamps are all recent. Are we bragging about post counts? I think I topped 300 once.

Users browsing this forum: Sloonei and 0 guests

"In 9 hours" because i'm off to work now, l8r thread

hey Sloonei, tell me what you think about all the RYMers. In about 9 hours. I was just trying to recall whether i've ever played a game with scummateo, but i'm pretty sure he's always been town when I've played, so i can't really meta-case him. But that's not usually a very big part of my game anyw...

Search found 25709 matches