The Syndicate

I'm considering this game a win for calling out @Scotty on D1 and almost calling out jack. (forgot to do it in thread, but like mentally I did)

LinearPoint wrote: ↑Wed Nov 17, 2021 9:17 pm Then on the other hand Sig says something like that and makes me think they are Mafia.

It's important to build game state.

Everyone is now assuming Survivor, Maybe SK (maybe not), and only 4 mafia with one gone. The wording immediately makes me think we have a lone mafia so I brought it up.

Also pretty sure everyone ignored my thoughts on a 2x voter for D1 so gonna look at that again. Technically wagon was tied with Scotty on SAA and MM was killed. But, if they had a 2x vote role it could work. All this to say I'd still be down for SAA vote. The issues ppl had with him D1 still are there and his claim is a bit dubious given how many other info claims are out there.

And did anyone catch the in a chat with 4 mafia members wording? I bet we've got a mafia member without chat wandering around alone. Probably not aware of there team OR they're aware of team but team isn't aware of them.

alexa wrote: ↑Wed Nov 17, 2021 2:23 pm i'm voting sig because Mac died voting them, presumably to scum, and Mac dying over both cop claims is weird
that feels like a bad reason but shrug there's not much else

maybe Jack stopped kills but that seems unlikely to have happened 2x at rand.

Seems like some good misdirect if you were the one to kill him.

Haven't read anything yet, assuming scotty is outted based off votes so 2 quick things.

1. DONT HAMMER! no talking during the night phases means hammering right now is going to hurt us more than help us. I say give it 24-36ish hours to continue to post and solve a bit before we hammer.

2. The vote wasn't tied right? I believe there was one more on SOA. That means we've got someone with either 2-3 votes or someone who can add. They're probably a mafia member so need to look at everyone on the counter wagon.

That's gonna be all for me tonight had a busy day with some unexpected stuff that came up and early work day tomorrow. Good news is I'll be working mainly from home in the afternoon so can catch up then.

LinearPoint wrote: ↑Fri Nov 12, 2021 10:58 pm Truth be told I am not actually opposed to a Paopon lynch today, I just have a stronger feeling about SoA than Paopon.
Its just a lot harder for me to want to vote inactivity over a scumread.

Meh, I personally hate to lynch a more inactive player (especially one new to the site) day 1.

Is your thoughts on Paopon mainly gut or any reasons?

Son of Anarch wrote: ↑Fri Nov 12, 2021 10:49 pm
LinearPoint wrote: ↑Fri Nov 12, 2021 10:47 pm I mean you asking me my thoughts on Scotty is sort of what Scotty was saying anyways. You mainly just ask surface level questions like an explanation for X read.
I think your post on Scotty jumping on your wagon was probably the most I have actually seen from you so far that wasn't what I considered lurking or fluff.
Up until now you've just kind of existed and it looks like you sort of flipped out when you got a 3rd vote. You didn't seem to care at all about my vote or Sigs vote on you so I don't see why Scottys is much different especially given that he posted a reason for it.
No. I'm sorry, but that's not a surface level question. There are plenty of slots that have simply "existed" within the game, that's not really a good enough reason to vote someone. Scotty's vote was different from your vote and Sig's vote because 1. It happened after two other people had already voted me and 2. His reasonin' for it was shallow and contradictory. He said I asked the same question twice, ignorin' all context on what had been said above me.

Nah that's wrong scotty voted after me. Don't like this false narrative you're trying to create around my vote. Also reasons weren't contradictory at all, based off my posts and really I'd like to see you point to anyone who so far has a non "shallow" vote. Since so far your votes would all fall in that category as well.

MacDougall wrote: ↑Fri Nov 12, 2021 9:06 pm [VOTE: sig] aubergine

I'm getting some negative vibes from SOA. Especially with the last post saying games too big. Could consider them, also not alot in ISO, more on fluffy not really providing info.

Thoughts?

Jackofhearts2005 wrote: ↑Fri Nov 12, 2021 6:48 pm
Scotty wrote: ↑Fri Nov 12, 2021 6:45 pm @Jackofhearts2005 thoughts on sig?
Wolflean.

Because he doesn't have much content.

good sir, I've got loads of content, infinite amounts of content! More then what I know what to do with. annnnnnnd def more than you so smh.

@Jackofhearts2005 thoughts on scotty?

Lime Coke wrote: ↑Fri Nov 12, 2021 4:20 pm Nothing really moving the needle in catching up.

I feel like there's 4 or 5 players that are literally just >rand which makes solving this significantly harder than it needs to be.

What do you mean by second line?

I did a very quick speed skim/catch up so here we go.

1)NotAnAxehole: I've played now two games with him, read him as mafia both times and was wrong. So meta wise I don't have the best track record. He's playing almost the same as those last two game(?) So I'd go with a light town read based off tone.

2)DrWilgy: Don't like this wagon for the sole reason that he commonly gets mischopped early on. The reasoning for the vote seems weak as well an easy D1 place to hide and write off.

3)Ruri: NA?

4)MafiaMenace: Either super town based off there catch up or a very committed mafia member. I'd appreciate some meta on how they play as mafia vs civ. BUT, without that i'm going with a civ lean.

5)falcon45ca: Prior grudge recommend lynching.

6)Jackofhearts2005: Doesn't seem to have much content, but remember jack posting. Null with a slight mafia lean I guess

7)LinearPoint: New player to me so no meta knowledge. Posts are a bit of a gut ping so will be doing an iso later. Right now Null, but I'll have more later.

8)Michelle: Town read. Like the tone, her entrance, and wilgy defense.

9)LimeCoke: Think I might be confusing our two L named player so need to review them both. Since i"ve got no read for lc, but I know they've posted?

10)Marmot: Doing marmot things so Null.

11)Paopan: I'm not sure how i feel about their first post, but right now just need more content.

12)MightyQ: Same thing as above, can't recall any real posts, need some content/might iso if have the time.

13)Scotty: Mafia read

I don't think I've ever seen scotty be so engaged and active as a civ so instant red flag with that. He"s also still maintaining the normal light hearted jokey side, but either way is a player to watch that I'd not put in the town core when ppl make one.

14)sig: god among the player, 100% a civ, shouldn't be voted off, night killed, or asked to elaborate on any reads/posts as he probably won't respond.

15)MacDougall: I'll have a good read on Mac by day threeish. I don't believe the cop claim at all and even if it is real with a fake cop isn't really the best claim. I guess we could in theory test it on a sketchy player and determine if he's insane or not, but seems risky to maybe risk a civ? It's probably something to discuss D2.

16)Alexa: Comes in pretty towny, another player I'm not familiar with though. @alexa who are the three players you know/what's there general meta?

17)Son of Anarch: Withholding judgement, haven't really seen enough to form an opinion one way or another. So also on my iso list.

Michelle wrote: ↑Fri Nov 12, 2021 1:21 am
Marmot wrote: ↑Fri Nov 12, 2021 1:14 am Why are you defending Wilgy, Michelle? I don't think Wilgy's done enough to warrant any defense.
Exactly because of that. And because he is the most mischopped player at Syndicate.
Why would a player like Alexa vote so lazy a low poster?

Mac did NOTHING, so he can die imo
I am calling his vote on Alexa distancing because he didn't vote in the poll. Also her vote for Mac wasn't good and their interaction is wolfy.

NO, NOPE, NOT AT ALL!!!!!!!!!!

Wilgy coming for my title as most mischopped how dare he, I am the most mischopped player here tyvm.

Scotty wrote: ↑Thu Nov 11, 2021 4:00 pm Never met 5 of you.

Putting placeholder on sig for now. We go way back

I rescind my lol from above.

Scotty wrote: ↑Thu Nov 11, 2021 2:55 pm NAA invented a new game:

lol

alexa wrote: ↑Thu Nov 11, 2021 12:48 pm sup

i don't trust this setup and i'm going to crumb my role at some point to avoid shenanigans gl mafia

alexa wrote: ↑Thu Nov 11, 2021 12:57 pm anyways there's like 3 people in this game i can read and i know no one else

Who are these three?
Would role crumbling be helpful when we have bastard type roles?

alexa wrote: ↑Thu Nov 11, 2021 12:48 pm sup

i don't trust this setup and i'm going to crumb my role at some point to avoid shenanigans gl mafia

Having said that, let's vote Mac

I'm here, gonna be doing some catch up today. and should have more posts about general thoughts later today. I believe the day ends tomorrow right not today?

Also as always in catch up mode if anyone wants to give a quick tldr and explanation of current votes I'd appreciate it.

The Syndicate

Search found 20 matches

Re: Fortune of Lies [Gameover Mafia Win)

Re: Fortune of Lies [Day 3]

Re: Fortune of Lies [Day 3]

Re: Fortune of Lies [Day 3]

Re: Fortune of Lies [Day 2]

Re: Fortune of Lies [Day 1]

Re: Fortune of Lies [Day 1]

Re: Fortune of Lies [Day 1]

Re: Fortune of Lies [Day 1]

Re: Fortune of Lies [Day 1]

Re: Fortune of Lies [Day 1]

Re: Fortune of Lies [Day 1]

Re: Fortune of Lies [Day 1]

Re: Fortune of Lies [Day 1]

Re: Fortune of Lies [Day 1]

Re: Fortune of Lies [Day 1]

Re: Fortune of Lies [Day 1]

Re: Fortune of Lies [Day 1]

Re: Fortune of Lies [Day 1]

Re: Fortune of Lies [Day 1]