The Syndicate

So, MM and Timmer are dead. It still makes more sense to lynch another member of the Circle first. SVS is a one-woman team at this point. Timmer had 3 teammates who helped him get off the poll. If he only had 2, another 3rd player would've gotten a PM asking them to take Timmer off the poll. I suspe...

Dom wrote:So... an SVS lynch?

How about we lynch one of the two remaining Circle members before giving them the Cabal NK?

lolwat

Yeah. 5x votes for MM and 6x votes for TH

Theme Park sounds fun.

Dom wrote:....some people have some explaining to do.

Who?

Read my posts, Dom. I said the Circle could NK MM, not NK SVS. Why didn't you reply to the question i asked here: http://www.mafiathesyndicate.com/viewtopic.php?f=60&t=744&start=4160#p204938 - The Circle could NK MM. Let's say they have no other targets other than MM, why wouldn't they NK hi...

Well, Timmer voted you on Day 10. Maybe we should test your theory by asking the Golem to NK Timmer tonight? :shrug: Testing the theory would require us to lynch neither MM or TH, so I'm not in support of that. Testing the theory wouldn't require TH to be alive. It was a joke anyway. I'm not quite ...

Well, Timmer voted you on Day 10. Maybe we should test your theory by asking the Golem to NK Timmer tonight?

Also i don't see how any of this Mac Secret Role stuff is relevant to today's lynch

- lynch a role nobody needs dead The only way you don't need his role dead is if you are Cabal. Wrong. Read the roles :P @ Hosts: Would the civvies need the Tarnished Golem dead if he chose a baddie as his watched over player? No, I think you need to read the roles. Having reread the roles, i stand...

Sorry - I haven't put very much eye on this thread recently, I've been too focussed on the other game. My bad. I'm going to try and get back into this one shortly. It's just that the other has been taking a lot of my energy. Jesus. Here i think we're in a possibly LYLO situation and you're off play...

@ MM: How realistic do you think the odds of a Sorsha lynch are today? I'd say pretty low, and i'm not even fully convinced she's bad atm. Vote TH if you want to lynch a Circle member. Which reminds me. Golden, did you learn anything from your backtracking of Sorsha? You keep telling me I can't win...

@ TH: Hmm. If the Golem is protecting you, then you shouldn't have any problem voting SVS today, right? :ponder: - lynch a role nobody needs dead The only way you don't need his role dead is if you are Cabal. Wrong. Read the roles :P @ Hosts: Would the civvies need the Tarnished Golem dead if he cho...

@ MM: How realistic do you think the odds of a Sorsha lynch are today? I'd say pretty low, and i'm not even fully convinced she's bad atm. Vote TH if you want to lynch a Circle member.

Which reminds me. Golden, did you learn anything from your backtracking of Sorsha?

Tranq, why do you trust that the Circle will do the civvie's job? I don't think we should trust them to do it either, but I don't know which team we would be better to lynch either. :shrug2: Cabal. Why? Because if we mislynch and vote SVS we're in a world of hurt. Explain this please. Dom, i'll ask...

@ Golden: No, i don't know Typhoony's role. @ LoRab: I don't have a role slotted for you. Only an alignment guess. Which may or may not be correct. Who do you think Timmer's 2-3 teammates are? But why would Circle kill them? I don't expect them to cooperate with us. I don't think we can depend on Ci...

TH ofcourse. I've already voted for him :p The SK is a SK without a K atm. Vanilla, basically. How are you getting a 3 v 3 scenario? Who's the extra Cabal? Who's the dead Circle? I had Typhoony down as a dead Circle for a while but now i doubt that's true. They might even have their full team intact...

I don't think anyone paying attention to the thread can be in doubt of MM's role.

Did you read the conversation i just had with Sorsha?

Golden wrote:If you believe SVS killed you today, I also think MM is the right choice for a lynch.

You can't be serious

We don't. But it beats the alternative

Aye, i agree. Once Timmer is on the poll again he should only have 1 teammate left. At that point we should consider the Cabal situation again.

Yes i can. We weren't on the same square anymore when the kill attempt happened

To ensure our safety after eliminating the Cabal, MM needs to go first. I don't see a way around it. And is there a way to remove a player from the poll in the hall of mirrors? If there is then maybe there are fewer circle than I thought. There are several ways around it. - Circle NKs MM - Circle N...

Cabal? Yes.
MM's role? No. The game can perfectly end with a civ win and with MM still being alive. MM wouldn't win, but the game would end

lol @ the random votes already. Timmer is off the poll again. Again, was anyone asked if they wanted to take him off the poll? He has to have 2 or 3 teammates helping him out. We need a landslide Circle lynch today or the game will be over soon. TH is our best bet at that, let's just hope he isn't ...

lol @ the random votes already. Timmer is off the poll again. Again, was anyone asked if they wanted to take him off the poll? He has to have 2 or 3 teammates helping him out. We need a landslide Circle lynch today or the game will be over soon. TH is our best bet at that, let's just hope he isn't S...

@Draconus - I don't know, but for me it would avoid the necessity for two lynches, so it would be a pretty big swing. Plus, you know what I mean when I say I could double back and get the Master Thief in other ways. With the trickster, I feel blind. Maybe you could double back on the Master Thief, ...

@ Golden: I don't blame you. I'm also considering all options at this moment

Do you think Timmer-TH-LoRab is a possibility, with Dom being civ and SVS being Cabal?

I trust Draco fwiw.

The thing is, i think Dom and LoRab are linked together. I think they're either civvie together, or baddies together. If they're civvie together or Cabal, i'm at a loss as to Timmer's final teammate. Which is making me consider Master Thief as being one of them. I mean, i doubt it, but i don't like ...

I could easily see the Circle NK'ing Dom, knowing he'd survive, if they had no other targets in range. Especially since last time they had a kill, they apparently chose not to kill.

Draconus wrote:I'm pretty sure the Soul Shade is dead.

Which team do you think the Soul Shade was on?

I'm thinking this could be a pretty straightforward poll. 1 civvie, 1 cabal, 1 circle

Atleast 2 players have to be helping him. Possibly 3. If Timmer only has 2 teammates left, someone else should've gotten a vote in taking him off the poll.

@ Everyone: Was anyone asked if they agreed to taking Timmer off the poll?

@Sorsha: You've mostly been focussing on the Cabal recently. I don't think your theory is wrong as i have either SVS or Dom down as Cabal. What are your thoughts on the Circle? How sure are you about Dom? How many teammates do you think Timmer has left and who do you think they are?

@Golden: How sure are you about Dom? I have him as a possibility for both teams.

I just said a bunch of words out loud that I would not be comfortable posting on any website. That aside :rip: Matt. I'm sorry. I don't know who to trust anymore, and it's giving me very mixed emotions. I'm voting with MM for the Thief. No offense meant to any player in particular. I just have to k...

You know nothing, Draconus!

Well i'm off to sleep. Sticking with my original thought and voting TH

How far away is it from the poll square? Assuming you know where that is, ofcourse

Well yes, he wouldn't be anywhere near Timmer's location if that's true.

Do you think Matt was being truthful when he said he was on the south side of the map atm?

I have Typhoony down as civ or indy due to him being NKd by the Cabal and his interactions with TH who i think is Circle.

Yeah that makes sense

LoRab wrote:I'd think he'd only need 2. At any rate, the question becomes, what happens if he stays put? What can we do about that? And given Golden's message, is there a greater risk in that? I think it's in our best interest for

I just looked it up. He'd need three. I don't think i'm reading that wrong

I'm pretty sure timmer is a baddie, and he must be on a team of at least three. So circle. This is my implication from him being missing from the poll two days in a row. Teammates - TH, Matt, Typhoony (dead) is my best guess. The Matt/Dom fight has me also thinking Dom is a chance, but I don't real...

Even to the extent that I'm beginning to think that the fight with Dom could be a sign of Dom and Matt being on the same team, trying to make Dom look bad so that Matt can survive longer term. Today has felt like a gambit to secure Matt's survival. I agree with Tranq, in that I'm coming out of this...

I think all three of you could be bad tbh. I'm still thinking TH > Matt > Dom atm but i haven't voted yet. I'm willing to consider all options. Do any of you think Timmer isn't a baddie? Do you think he's Cabal or Circle? Assuming he's Circle, who do you think his teammates are? He has to have atlea...

I know of a space that gets you off the poll to, but it requires some people be asked... which actually meshes with timmer starting on the poll then vanishing. Has anyone been asked if they agree to timmer being off the poll? I know I haven't. I've been to that square early in the game. The number ...

@ LoRab & Matt: Can you look at that list of items and tell me if there are Trickster-type items on there? Items that look like they can take you off the poll?

Voted Dom + the three musketeers.

Search found 717 matches