The Syndicate

Great game baddies! I think best-case I could say I suspected only two out of the eight of you, and those ones I only pressed shortly before getting myself killed, so most people played really well under the radar. Sorsha too of course.

And thanks, hosts!

Golden wrote:
Dom wrote:If wilgy and mac aren't baddies i s2g
Wilgy
Mac
Sorsha
DH?

I dunno, but when I did an iso of boomslang while in the game I realised he was civ.

Replace DH with Draconus and those would probably be my picks. Possibly Wilgy with juliets too.

All of my reads this game have been garbage.

Typhoony wrote:Who did you target last night HB?

EpiPen.

Although if golden's confidence was due to Jimmy being Park Place, then I guess there's just a bunch of protective roles in this game. I'd like to know why golden was so sold on Jimmy being good.

So it's looking like LoRab vs JJJ really could have been scum on scum, based on that role reveal, and since LoRab could have oriented things for Jimmy to have a no-lynch conceivably. Damn me for letting up on that. I hope Mac really pressures Jimmy over it. I'm leaning town-ish on Dharma now, probab...

My initial suspicion on Dom was built on a theory that he had BTSC day 0 either with llama (more likely) or conspirators plotting against llama (less likely), so I definitely agree with it. I think that if Dom flips scum, llama will be boosted far up on my suspects list.

What makes you put MetalMarsh immediately below Dom/Llama? I could agree with it in the "compatible but not indicative" sense of things but compared to people like Wilgy that have the supportive post history and the questionable voting records, I'd put MM towards the bottom of the lynch. O...

JaggedJimmyJay wrote:I think his leaning-town reads on LoRab were more the result of his distrust for the people going after her than her actual content, though he can correct me if I'm wrong about that.

Yep.

3. You men me voting around my work schedule? And voting for someone I think was bad? Well I don't know your work schedule, a quick glance over your posts does show a fairly consistent posting pattern, I don't think that is purely an excuse. E.g. Jan 15 the day before the 3.5 flip, you dropped a &q...

Oh, and one more thing, do you guys feel DharmaHelper would be the kind of guy to stick his neck out, defending a scummate and attacking the alternative so aggressively as he's done? In spite of the LoRab flip I'm still getting a civvie gutfeel from him, because at least I feel the mindset he's used...

New suspect/re-evaluation: Draconus. I realize I had just defended him earlier, but looking more closely at his day 1 actions/vote, I think he may look the worst out of it. He gave a very soft defense of LoRab (Long Con pointed this out earlier and I dismissed it, sorry) about accidentally getting h...

I didn't think the text would vary for different bad teams if there are any. That would be kind of weird. It'd give scum teams more info about each other than we're privy to. Is that normal here? ....for what reasons again? 1. Your stated intent as early as day 0 to vote llama, predicting that he w...

I'm super-duper down for Dom tomorrow.

What does the thread think of Bea and Juliets? I feel good-ish on both of them. juliets I was suspicious of because earlier I felt she looked like the same juliets I saw during A World Reborn, but more recently she started making pretty directed arguments. In retrospect she did jump on to vote JJJ ...

Why can't they be on opposite bad teams? Whoever cursed Boomslang is not on Zebra's team, unless it's normal here for scum teams to have two of the same role. LoRab and Zebra have the same red 'BADDIE' text, so I'm assuming they are on the same team. Jimmy wouldn't have built a big case against Boo...

Not sure why this would change whether you suspect JJJ or not. The biggest worry would be that JJJ and LoRab really were on the same team, that 3.0 was a proper lynch cancel, and JJJ's roleclaim a fake one to satisfy those of us trying to work out the motive for canceling the lynch. You have to adm...

I don't think that I started buddying you, just agreed with what you had to say more than the others. Out of what I've read, It made the most sense in my head I suppose. I was pinged by you early game, but realized later that was only because I had the context of the conversation backwards. Those w...

DrWilgy, why did you suddenly start buddying me these last couple of days when I was one of your bigger suspects earlier in the game?

I think it's worth considering that DrWilgy reformed the tie on accident, but realized the potential of it to make him look horrible considering golden's immediately preceding vote change. I also still think Black Rock was too LoRab-focused while also latching onto other people's cases in the early ...

Voted Whitney & Bobby because I don't know them.

re: golden, maybe you're right, I still think this narrow lynch will give a lot of info to look back on. I think a lot of it will make me look bad but oh well.

Welp.

Oh, I just remembered that during Frisky Dingo, niju made a last-minute tie vote that ended up lynching a scum "by chance". Or at least I think that's how it went down, too lazy to check right now.

Golden wrote:And the idea that mafia would blink in that scenario is equally daft.

I can't give an exact example off the top of my head, but I feel that it's happened before. With potentially two scum teams at play, that makes it especially favorable.

Lynching civvies just to see the game "move" is such a counter civ thing to want. It's so easy to enjoy this when you're not among those on the lynch trains. Scum, if I don't die, please NK me. This is the shittiest game ever. linki: I think Golden is playing a more civ game than any of y...

Does it bother anyone else that Epi seems to be reading the thread a lot but not posting?

666.

I don't believe it. We actually went to a four way tie. Officially the stupidest lynch I have ever seen. I'm actually with fz. Considering asking for a replacement. Are the civs even trying to win? I feel alone. I don't get it, what's wrong with a four way tie? For you, someone basically convinced ...

DrWilgy wrote:I'm feeling my life spiral out of control

I swapped to MM to break the tie... I figured as long as it wasn't JJJ or FZ.

Nah, I think you dun gud, even if you are bad.

Golden wrote:Ties are stupid.

Depending on your confidence. I'd be a little relieved to see any of the four be lynched just to see things really start to move.

Great job resettling that tie Wilgy.

HamburgerBoy wrote:hand's

I'm actually thinking of leaving the votes like that instead of saving myself. There are so many people I wish would just shut up. Will it do it? Lol I will move my vote off you at the last second on to a random candidate and leave it as a 3 way tie. How bout that? Yes, because no foreseeable vote ...

Golden wrote:This is ridiculous. The fz bandwagon is as contrived as the jay one. So many people seeing her as a top town read.

I'm certainly not.

5-5-5-5, now THAT'S what I love to see.

Ricochet wrote:or makes me think of a certain old character...

Is there a role that has to vote the same person until that person dies?

:sigh: I can't wait until you finally find out you're wrong about me this game. Chalk up another player who can't read me. Considering how the Jay/LoRab lynch played out yesterday, are you really surprised it isn't repeating itself exactly the same today? The reasons behind that rapidly building ba...

Bold statement time: FZ. is the serial killer. Votes going with the breeze, snappy rebuttals not to catch too much heat, somehow gets genuine marks from several people, unciv "I would let a dormant baddie be the last baddie standing, so I can then laugh at his so-called victory, if he achieves...

Bold statement time: FZ. is the serial killer. Votes going with the breeze, snappy rebuttals not to catch too much heat, somehow gets genuine marks from several people, unciv "I would let a dormant baddie be the last baddie standing, so I can then laugh at his so-called victory, if he achieves...

:sigh: I can't wait until you finally find out you're wrong about me this game. Chalk up another player who can't read me. Considering how the Jay/LoRab lynch played out yesterday, are you really surprised it isn't repeating itself exactly the same today? The reasons behind that rapidly building ba...

I realize I just posted my rainbow with MM in light green, but that was me getting lazy with rotating people around based on my previous rainbow. He's more of a solid/bordering-orange yellow for me, haven't seen anything compelling either way regarding him, but the fact that he's been around makes h...

re whoever is wondering why lots of people voted lorab yesterday but not today... It's because yesterday, lots of us were finding a consensus candidate to save jj. I'll vote lorab to the same end of it comes to it, but I think mm is a good bet. He really is playing like dune mm. Don't you find it i...

Sup Wilgy, who are your three biggest suspects right now?

Even if that's true, I think that as bad as my words can sound, jumping on that for a vote is a whole lot more suspicious than what I said. Not to mention that as I said before, the fact I said that if JJJ is bad we should look at his voters didn't diminish the need to look at Lorab's voters in any...

New rainbow time!

Ricochet

golden
Draconus

Matt
MetalMarsh
SpaceDaisy/Bea
Boomslang
LoRab

juliets
Epignosis
Bass_the_Clever/motel room
nijuukyugou
thellama73

Long Con
Elohcin/FZ
DharmaHelper
DrWilgy
MacDougall
Black Rock
Tranq

JaggedJimmyJay
Sorsha

Dom

If he doesn't think JJJ is bad, than why would I be covering all bases? His post has more to do with you than him. That it was JJJ mentioned seems irrelevant to his point; he's accusing you of making a safe post where you defend a player, and then simultaneously distance yourself by saying if he fl...

FZ, you've mentioned no suspicion of Draconus up until a few posts ago saying "you'd vote for him or MM". Am I missing something? Day 2, in fact, you've eyeballed Matt for claiming Draco faked his curse. FIrst off, I'm allowed to change my mind. Second, I don't buy his vote. If he thinks ...

I'd be happy to vote for Dom. While even Sorsha I can partially excuse for kick-starting the LoRab run yesterday (golden said it would be her or LoRab to save Jimmy; Sorsha's response was only natural self-preservation), Dom's been coasting and others more familiar with him than I have suspected him...

idgi, what's the case on Draco? That he had relatively weaker cases on day 0 (duh, everyone does) and has been relatively inactive these last couple days?

In A World Reborn, timmer had his vote on SVS for only a couple minutes, but it allowed MM to nightkill him.

Search found 448 matches