The Syndicate

I know there are mixed feeling about multiball, but if only for this being my first game in years, it allowed me to have the best of both worlds: being scum while actively genuinely scumhunting. I just wish my scumdar wasn't so [censored]ing broken :sad:

Also I wanted to be here actively posting by EOD, but my guitar student had to push his lesson up exactly to EOD time for me. Sorry I was low-posting the last couple days.

Everyone, thank you so much for a really fun, brain-breaking game. By D7, I was like, 'I don't care if I wind up getting my ass handed to me; this game is a lot of fun.' :beer: novaselinenever , great game design. I've always been fascinated by role madness, which didn't happen too terribly often in...

Question : @Strawhenge if you didn't play with a miller role before, how come you claimed miller in your defence for my peek, instead explaining with your words what your role says? This is what i remember, i didn't reread, but is a thing that bothers me since yday and i forgot to ask Hey, sorry, w...

and don’t say she self-targeted because i refuse to entertain that That's my only plausible explanation. Unless someone has a hitherto unclaimed superkill-proof ability, the only explanation is that you, Michelle, or I tried to kill Esooa. I know that I didn't, and we both agree that Michelle didn'...

Hally wrote: ↑Sun May 02, 2021 2:05 pmclearly the wolves are not making optimal decisions here

Kind of indicative of someone who doesn't care about the game, imo.

Because you were suspicious of her the previous night. so she let herself get redchecked????? makes no sense Well, look at the way she responded to it, that Michelle pointed out. She could just say, 'So is Straw.' She could've also simply said, 'I'm unchoppable, so I don't care,' and then stopped p...

Because you were suspicious of her the previous night.

That's what I'm saying. I never doubted she was a cop, especially after she red-peeked my miller card. okay but if michelle isn’t a wolf and esooa was targeted for the kill then the only one left who can be the wolf is you I'm telling you, I don't think it's outlandish that Esooa self-targeted. If ...

Hally wrote: ↑Sun May 02, 2021 1:56 pm [VOTE: straw] aubergine

It's not me, Hally.

And no I didn't send a typewriter last night. Honestly didn't think it mattered after one finally got through to you, and you posted through nova.

That's what I'm saying. I never doubted she was a cop, especially after she red-peeked my miller card.

the key to this game imo is figuring out what happened with the kill Per my post (which is long, I know), the easiest answer is that the NK was aimed at Esooa. If Esooa is scum, it means she self-targeted to make it look like someone other than her is the last scum. And if she's town, that just mea...

Michelle wrote: ↑Sun May 02, 2021 12:48 pm Straw, I as Esl i am admiring how good you put the Esooa activity report in words, better than i could ever do it.

Thank you

I'm glad it came off clearly. I often worry my writer brain makes things too complicated, especially in mafia games.

[VOTE: Esooa] aubergine

Maybe it's the fatigue talking, but this is the most baffling day so far in this game. 1. The Failed Super-Kill Occam's Razor is that Esooa's tree stump claim is true, and scum tested that, meaning that the final scum is Hally or Michelle. A tinfoily-but-not-impossible alternative is that Esooa targ...

I swear this post is almost done, Michelle. It's a long one.

Sorry I wasn't around yesterday, it was a busy one.

Michelle wrote: ↑Sun May 02, 2021 11:28 am I need someone to talk.

Good morning, I'm working on a post.

You made Isos on 3 villagers and a mafia from the other team. :suspish: I said i will tell you what other wolfy things you did. What the fuck, seriously? So it's either supertown Hally, supertown Michelle, or unchoppable Esooa?! The fuck kind of choice is that?! If it's either Hally or Michelle, co...

Esooa wrote: ↑Sat May 01, 2021 9:29 am I'm pretty sure we just lose tonight

I'm pretty sure that if town would lose the game during a night phase, the game would end at the preceding EOD.

(snip) Can you link me your cases please? I am only phone posting today and I can only play sporadically Sure: Oddmerta fingersplints NANOOK Long Con Sadly there are only a few full ISOs, and most of them were on D2 with only Odd on D7. Part of the reason was real-life time constraints. I had to do...

(snip) Did you Iso a flipped scum to search for interactions with living players? Not in the same way that Sloonei did, for instance, but with each player I ISO’d, I looked for their interactions with flipped scum. (snip) I understand that Esooa was convincing in making you stop asking questions. W...

Ever since my red-check, yeah, I've been defending myself because there was something to defend. And if I didn't engage enough with Esooa and Oddmerta, it's because they've both seemed disinterested in engaging in conversation. Esooa even got cross with me and told me to stop asking her questions, s...

(snip) You couldn't town case yourself, that's one of them. Wolves don't have the ability to explain why are they villagers because they are not. No matter what villa game I am playing, I know in every single moment of the game what I did villagery and I can explain why am I villager with quotes an...

Straw, it's you for reasons i will write down in the morning, is a general pattern of wolfy activity, but is 1 am and I don't have now the mood to explain you what wolfy things you did. You get some rest, don't tire yourself out for the likes of this game. But I do honestly look forward to your rea...

I think you should check Hally tonight. I know it'd be insane if there was a v/w mason team, but I think we should be sure.

Michelle wrote: ↑Fri Apr 30, 2021 6:14 pm
Strawhenge wrote: ↑Fri Apr 30, 2021 6:09 pm If it's either Hally or Michelle, congratulations on an amazing scum game.
Why not congratulations for Esooa? I am curious

Because being an unchoppable scum wouldn't take any work. You and Hally, if one of you are scum, both put in an incredible amount of work.

Yeah, because it's not really useful. I'll give you a typewriter tonight, and you can see if you can make use of it.

I know how that feels. I used to feel it every time I survived this long in a game.

It sure as hell isn't me. I wish I had the ability to prove it to you, but all I have is a typewriter.

If it's either Hally or Michelle, congratulations on an amazing scum game.

What the fuck, seriously?

So it's either supertown Hally, supertown Michelle, or unchoppable Esooa?! The fuck kind of choice is that?!

I'm here. I just feel like I have nothing more to add to my current thoughts, so I'm just biting my nails waiting for EOD.

Esooa wrote: ↑Fri Apr 30, 2021 4:19 pm I don't really think it's odd

Why?

@Hally @Oddmerta

I know it's been a long and exhausting game, y'all, but we only have 2.5 hours left, then it's over. At least come in and give your thoughts. I'd hate for this monthlong mafiathon to end on a whimper.

(snip) What from your text helped the village, can you link them? I'm afraid I don't know what you're asking here. What do you mean? If Odd is scum that means he is enjoying tormenting villagers, because imo if he was Gerhard mafia he wouldn't let me have any peek and he would kill me long ago. Bo ...

(snip) The thing is Bo didn't interact very much with you in the first days, and I don't remember from JPIC any stance regarding you, but i have to check. I see your post count in this site is not so big, how much mafia experience do you have? Can you link me a scum game and a town game no matter h...

In addition to his, I mean.

@Michelle, have you read my posts about my concerns about Odd? Nobody has directly addressed them. My most recent reasons I think he's scum (including vote) and my ISO of him . Yes, i read your posts. Imo, it's Odd who should answer at your case. @Oddmerta can you do this? I was hoping he would as ...

@Michelle, have you read my posts about my concerns about Odd? Nobody has directly addressed them.

My most recent reasons I think he's scum (including vote) and my ISO of him.

(snip) The thing is Bo didn't interact very much with you in the first days, and I don't remember from JPIC any stance regarding you, but i have to check. I see your post count in this site is not so big, how much mafia experience do you have? Can you link me a scum game and a town game no matter h...

Strawhenge wrote: ↑Thu Apr 29, 2021 12:14 pmVoting proof was fueling the wagon on JPIC, then fighting against BoKnows when he limply tried to make a case that he was town after you red-checked him.

I forgot a word that makes this clearer.

And @Michelle, I could've claimed 'shenanigans' when you red-checked me. There's been enough redirecting and bus-driving and all manner of wackadoo mech bullpiss in this game, I could've started spouting off anything to save my hyde. But I didn't. I did the risky thing and told you the truth with a...

Esooa wrote: ↑Thu Apr 29, 2021 12:26 am
Strawhenge wrote: ↑Thu Apr 29, 2021 12:18 am Also @Esooa, do you have parity or not? Why's your vote on me if it doesn't count?
why does it matter lol

Utterly daft of me to expect any other kind of response; my apologies.

Also @Esooa, do you have parity or not? Why's your vote on me if it doesn't count?

And Michelle , I could've claimed 'shenanigans' when you red-checked me. There's been enough redirecting and bus-driving and all manner of wackadoo mech bullpiss in this game, I could've started spouting off anything to save my hyde. But I didn't. I did the risky thing and told you the truth with an...

And Hally , maybe I'm old-fashioned but there was never a time when no-chops were ever a good idea. Maybe that's something that was discovered since the last time I played, but how I see it, we're just handing scum an NK if we sleep. And if I'm right, and Odd is scum, he'd probably kill you (Hally),...

Seen any typewriters lately? i got one a couple of nights ago iirc and used it to post the mashed potatoes pasta (brilliant, i know) dunno who he targeted since SPF the night she was killed, Michelle last night when we were swapped. Also, solid rebuttal, Odd. Care to maybe address any of the things...

Aside from everything else I've pointed out about Oddmerta, here's a list of things I don't like: I don't like that he never tried to stop a night kill by meat-shielding with Esooa. If I were a busdriver, I'd be doing that left and right. It's insane to me that a busdriver exists in a game with a tr...

Search found 955 matches