The Syndicate

JaggedJimmyJay wrote: ↑Wed Aug 07, 2019 2:45 pm Hey players! Let's get some feedback.

1. How did you feel about playing in a game with a posting limit like this?

2. Did you feel 45 posts was a decent limit, or would you make it more/less restrictive?

3. If [Light Game] became a unique game type, could you see yourself signing up for those games consistently?

I think 45 is generous considering most people didn’t post too much

I think 30 would be more of a hindrance to people if that’s the goal

Overall though I liked it, didn’t ever feel like I was so far behind it wasn’t worth catching up

Does this mean I’m Warden Golden forever now?

juliets wrote: ↑Tue Aug 06, 2019 8:50 pm Also bad guys why did you kill me? There was still suspicion that Jack had created.

You’re a formidable player

Quin wrote: ↑Tue Aug 06, 2019 7:59 pm i can't believe you killed me on night 1

That was all rej lol

Jack replaced in day2 and I didn’t start reading until day3

We did a huge gambit on day 5 lol, so glad it paid off

Good game town, Bette truck next time

MacDougall wrote: ↑Tue Aug 06, 2019 6:02 pm

Jackofhearts2005 wrote: ↑Tue Aug 06, 2019 5:26 pm Thanks @MacDougall for pointing out Dom’s role so we knew we didn’t have to block or shoot him.

Someone else already had.

I had assumed dom was the cop lol. Was obvious

It’s 4 am and I have a PT test in an hour. Hope we got the mafia, gang

Hm. [VOTE: mac] aubergine

but like if nova has all this interest in me in his poe pool, then why am i not being voted for?

that's the thing. he's still voting sabie after this whole kerfuffle today. sabie being someone who has barely spoken a word. it's either a bus attempt, or a mislynch attempt imo

@nova I won’t be voting Sabie over you unless you have something more convincing to offer. A theory of something easy for me to follow. I already expressed my summary of sabies iso and how I see it and while it’s lacking in all content, you have more content that I don’t like.

I’m avoiding saying mac is a “confirmed” mason because it’s physically impossible to do. Dom obviously thinks so too. So what if Dom is the mason and wants to lynch Mac who is riding on that free gravy train?

[mention]Dom[/mention] is there a conflicting view with the general populace that you have towards Mac that no one else has? Do you not believe he is the other mason?

novaselinenever wrote: ↑Sun Aug 04, 2019 1:26 pm @Sig @Sprityo Stop wasting your time and solve that PoE I gave you. Lend me your power and we shall come back and win.

Sprit you're in it. Sig you're not in it courtesy of Oreki.

More dismissal tsk tsk

You guys are tickling my vote-tie bone

Re: your post- I GUESS Mac could’ve just gotten lucky but there’s still another mason alive and no one disputed that they don’t think he’s town, except for Dom. And of course yourself

I mean, Mac and dom probably next in line for town leader, Mac especially due to his “clear”

Dom really wants mac dead and everyone else either doesn’t want him dead or just doesn’t care because they don’t think he’s gonna get lynched imo.

If you look at end of day 3 and then day 4. You’ll see juliets explain it and jack will follow up and explain why

Well there’s the fact that claiming is not allowed

Not even hinting


Also 45 posts is a lot more than you’d think.

Most people have been averaging 7-12 posts per phase

sig wrote: ↑Sun Aug 04, 2019 9:39 am

MacDougall wrote: ↑Sun Aug 04, 2019 1:03 am Mmm

And sig still not posted.

Tell me why you're not mafia.

@Dom tell me why he is mafia

It’s under everyone’s assumption that mac is the other mason

Dom, Mac, Jack. As my top 3 could you guys maybe consider voting elsewhere?

Mac
Dom
Jack
Sig
Sabie
Rej
Nova

Hm, yeah I like this list. Fine with lynching any of the bottom three, but I’m prioritizing nova.

Jacks ISO has a lot of memes and joking, but when he is playing he’s clear with what he’s thinking and what he’s trying to accomplish. I like that and it makes him one of the easier players to understand (when he has relevant things to say)

Nova‘s day 1 is full of sarcasm and dismissal, all for the express purpose of pushing Rej’s buttons it would appear. I can’t tell if he ever seriously wanted to lynch rej (or whoever we was referring to) the whole of day 1. Day 2 he spends the first half referring to his own gth, the second half about the Mac/juliets wagon. With one or two mentions of drago, and of course he votes drago. Looking at his iso for day 4 it looks like
Nova almost exclusively talked to/about juliets. Coming to say he thinks she’s town. oh man, then juliets died.
Finally he clears mac because of something unrelated to why everyone else thinks mac is town.

Time to make a list!

Dom’s commentary at the least has been relevant and helping move the game forward. Though anything past day 1 it would appear he gets really tunnel visioned with the person he think is bad (see drago, mac) I’m giving him benefit of the doubt and assuming he’s one of the cops and not the sane one

Sig is of course not here

Mac “is town”

Looking through sabie’s ISO it’s quite minimal, but more so there’s minimal interaction. The most she has is for everyone who is already dead. Not a lot of talk between people still alive.

Rej’s ISO is mostly day 1, all I have to work with outside of that is the couple posts after. He expresses his suspicion of dom and throws shade about the people who Lynched creature. That’s what I got out of it.

juliets wrote: ↑Fri Aug 02, 2019 1:32 pm @Dom and @sprityo -

Dom now that LC has spelled it out do you see what we are talking about with Mac?

sprityo, I appreciate you believing in me but I think you should move your vote from Mac given we have figured out he's a civ. I'm not sure where my vote will end up, there's plenty of time for us to find someone else that looks bad.

I looked back to confirm for myself, and I think I see where you might be thinking that.

I’ll believe mac is town for now. I don’t have any time right now to re assess because I’m on shift tonight


But certainly if I can check in before eod I’ll see what I can do

I’m [VOTE: mac] aubergine again until further notice

Jackofhearts2005 wrote: ↑Thu Aug 01, 2019 6:53 pm LC and Juliets can’t both be mafia. Same for Juliets and Dom.

What’s your argument for this?

I’m sticking by Lc and juliets being more likely town than most any other player.

My opinion of you will change depending on how you answer

MacDougall wrote: ↑Tue Jul 30, 2019 5:42 pm Sprityo... your reread had me civ and then you made up some thing about voting for voting lurkers in order to justify tossing a vote on me in the hopes it'd just run away right?

Why do you want me dead? Do you think I am a bad townie?

Addressed previously, but I don’t see you in a positive light, nor do i see you as town. To EVER assume the Macdougal would just run away is a preposterous statement.

I’m not sure what you mean though by, “on form”

MacDougall wrote: ↑Tue Jul 30, 2019 5:36 pm Oh wait sprityo actually is voting me. That's odd given his reread had me quite high...

But still it's on form.

I don’t remember scoring you “high” anywhere. I had two pools of no particular order I had made during my day 1 read through. You also failed to see:

sprityo wrote: ↑Tue Jul 30, 2019 1:18 pm I still think juliets is town, so I will be voting to save her

Which is why I voted for you, mac

MacDougall wrote: ↑Thu Aug 01, 2019 12:14 am

Dom wrote: ↑Wed Jul 31, 2019 10:24 pm[VOTE: mac] aubergine

novaselinenever wrote: ↑Tue Jul 30, 2019 1:20 pm Can we like lynch Rej?

If you can give me a convincing argument as well as doesn’t conflict with my current objective, then sure I’ll consider it

And to close my little jam session:

The quin N1 kill could have been anyone, I think quin came out with strong town vibes early. Epi was a given night kill due to home he operates. That being said, looking at people he had legitimate suspicions on is another course of action we can take.

I haven’t looked through the votes from the past two phases yet.

I still think juliets is town, so I will be voting to save her

Some other thoughts:

People shouldn’t be worried about the post limit at all unless you are literally up to 30+ posts before halfway through day phase

Lynching lurkers will help us. Lynching lurkers who also vote is a good idea.

Would love to see some more vote analysis and night kill analysis from everyone. Since personally I’m bad at just straight up reading posts and making an vague opinion

So day 2 is just creature and dom

Nothing important in my eyes to be gained from reading day 2

This day phase, I like jack. Though if there were indies in this game i’d Bet my money that he’d be it. He’s giving me the fallout mafia vibes

I also like sabie a little more this phase

Dom wrote: ↑Mon Jul 29, 2019 7:39 am Dude-- you're posting at 3AM and asking why people aren't responding and it's quite sad. : (


And you don't think it's willfully naive to delude yourself to say that all the baddies are non-voters? Come on.

Actually in a game with such little activity as yesterday, that’s a theory I can support.

MacDougall wrote: ↑Sun Jul 28, 2019 8:29 pm Okay well two of my four were town that means the other two have to be Mafia because I can't be entirely wrong.

Do you remember assassination classroom? I’m sure Jay does

Dom wrote: ↑Fri Jul 26, 2019 7:18 pm LOL @ Creature flipping out and actually producing content once he receives a shit ton of votes.

This happened last game too

also, wonderful to see you again Dom!

Juliets
Long Con
Oreki

Macdougall
nova
Rej
sabie
Drago
Dom

Jack
TSP

———————

So finishing up day one, of the people alive I’ve split it as such from top to bottom as good, bad, and ugly no content.

In more colloquial terms. The players at the top posted either in a way I found to be in line with a towny or their town meta(ish) while everyone else performed at a sub par level in the day discussion, or was heavily involved in nova’s kerfuffle that I think was a waste of time for most everyone involved.

8 pages to read? No problem


Let’s do this