Search found 56 matches

by Quin
Tue Jun 14, 2016 8:37 pm
Forum: Previous Heists
Topic: End Game: Attack on Titan Heist: The Battle of Trost
Replies: 1037
Views: 28606

Re: End Game: Attack on Titan Heist: The Battle of Trost

Gonna go with INH for MVP, since he was the only one to actually take out a baddie.
by Quin
Sun Jun 12, 2016 9:40 pm
Forum: Previous Heists
Topic: End Game: Attack on Titan Heist: The Battle of Trost
Replies: 1037
Views: 28606

Re: End Game: Attack on Titan Heist: The Battle of Trost

Bullzeye wrote:I cannot believe that actually worked! Wow! Well played everyone, this was a lot of fun.

Linki Quin - I wouldn't worry about it, we could just as easily have piled our votes onto you. We counted on being too quick for anyone to react
I noticed that. I still felt good about gleam until the very end but when I saw your vote change I was pretty confident you were bad :doh:
by Quin
Sun Jun 12, 2016 8:35 pm
Forum: Previous Heists
Topic: End Game: Attack on Titan Heist: The Battle of Trost
Replies: 1037
Views: 28606

Re: Day 6: Attack on Titan Heist: The Battle of Trost

Metalmarsh89 wrote:
Quin wrote:
Metalmarsh89 wrote:
Quin wrote:
Metalmarsh89 wrote:
Quin wrote:Without going into any particular detail, here's a rainbow list based entirely on my vibes on everyone as of right now. Why am I posting a rainbow list based entirely on vibes? Why not? Also, I intend to go through the thread and point out any discrepancies in how I perceive players and what actual evidence I can find.

Why am I disclosing this information?

Because I expect pure vibe rainbows lists from each of you as well. Thankies.

gleam

zebra

marmot
bullzeye
Speaking of Quin, how did you manage to list Bullzeye as your strongest baddie vibe, but than flip your read to civ in your ISO?
Because bullzeye was bad based entirely on vibes. Actual evidence puts him in a much better light. You'd know that if you were following along :rolleyes:
I checked your posts though. You hadn't mentioned Bullzeye the whole game before you listed him as your strongest baddie read on vibes. ;)
You know what a vibe is, right?
Nope. Do tell.
:|
by Quin
Sun Jun 12, 2016 8:09 pm
Forum: Previous Heists
Topic: End Game: Attack on Titan Heist: The Battle of Trost
Replies: 1037
Views: 28606

Re: Day 6: Attack on Titan Heist: The Battle of Trost

Metalmarsh89 wrote:
Quin wrote:
Metalmarsh89 wrote:
Quin wrote:Without going into any particular detail, here's a rainbow list based entirely on my vibes on everyone as of right now. Why am I posting a rainbow list based entirely on vibes? Why not? Also, I intend to go through the thread and point out any discrepancies in how I perceive players and what actual evidence I can find.

Why am I disclosing this information?

Because I expect pure vibe rainbows lists from each of you as well. Thankies.

gleam

zebra

marmot
bullzeye
Speaking of Quin, how did you manage to list Bullzeye as your strongest baddie vibe, but than flip your read to civ in your ISO?
Because bullzeye was bad based entirely on vibes. Actual evidence puts him in a much better light. You'd know that if you were following along :rolleyes:
I checked your posts though. You hadn't mentioned Bullzeye the whole game before you listed him as your strongest baddie read on vibes. ;)
You know what a vibe is, right?
by Quin
Sun Jun 12, 2016 6:59 pm
Forum: Previous Heists
Topic: End Game: Attack on Titan Heist: The Battle of Trost
Replies: 1037
Views: 28606

Re: Day 6: Attack on Titan Heist: The Battle of Trost

What's supposed to happen with that? The titan with the one-shot bulletproof ability is still active so if we lynch them today we'll be tied up 2:2 for the next day phase
by Quin
Sun Jun 12, 2016 6:52 pm
Forum: Previous Heists
Topic: End Game: Attack on Titan Heist: The Battle of Trost
Replies: 1037
Views: 28606

Re: Day 6: Attack on Titan Heist: The Battle of Trost

Didn't read the thing where you stress it being the last chance, which is true. So I take that much back. But I still don't like how easily you dropped your marmot suspicion.
by Quin
Sun Jun 12, 2016 6:51 pm
Forum: Previous Heists
Topic: End Game: Attack on Titan Heist: The Battle of Trost
Replies: 1037
Views: 28606

Re: Day 6: Attack on Titan Heist: The Battle of Trost

a2thezebra wrote:The reason I'm not voting for MM is because like you said, everyone else is on board with him. It shouldn't be everyone if he's actually bad.
Ding dong, you are wrong.

For everyone being on board with lynching marmot, I'm seeing a severe lack of votes that would suggest that. Even if there were, you've basically just said that you'd be willing to drop a suspicion you've had the entire game just because someone else voted for them, a vote which may just as easily be a bus attempt at this point than a mislynch.
by Quin
Sun Jun 12, 2016 6:48 pm
Forum: Previous Heists
Topic: End Game: Attack on Titan Heist: The Battle of Trost
Replies: 1037
Views: 28606

Re: Day 6: Attack on Titan Heist: The Battle of Trost

Metalmarsh89 wrote:
Quin wrote:Without going into any particular detail, here's a rainbow list based entirely on my vibes on everyone as of right now. Why am I posting a rainbow list based entirely on vibes? Why not? Also, I intend to go through the thread and point out any discrepancies in how I perceive players and what actual evidence I can find.

Why am I disclosing this information?

Because I expect pure vibe rainbows lists from each of you as well. Thankies.

gleam

zebra

marmot
bullzeye
Speaking of Quin, how did you manage to list Bullzeye as your strongest baddie vibe, but than flip your read to civ in your ISO?
Because bullzeye was bad based entirely on vibes. Actual evidence puts him in a much better light. You'd know that if you were following along :rolleyes:
by Quin
Sun Jun 12, 2016 8:21 am
Forum: Previous Heists
Topic: End Game: Attack on Titan Heist: The Battle of Trost
Replies: 1037
Views: 28606

Re: Day 6: Attack on Titan Heist: The Battle of Trost

Lastly, zebra.

I started off by having a look at the posts of who she replaced, Goldy. He only made two posts, with only one being game related.
Spoiler: show
Goldy wrote:Yo! I'm in front line.
Fighting in frontline is better than any other option I think if it really helps to kill a titan, while doing nothing is most scummy thing but on other side helping to evacuate people is much likely neutral thing.

I've slight scum read on insertnamehere but I don't know what's up with sig? Though this is my first time here so I don't know much about everyone play style or regular things.
I'll try to help as much I can.
I feel like he might have been reading way too much into the day 0 poll at the time, or maybe he felt like he needed to justify his vote somehow. He expresses a scum read for INH but doesn't back it up.
Spoiler: show
a2thezebra wrote:
MovingPictures07 wrote:With that said, I think we should consider a policy lynch of Dizzy by Day 3, if not for Day 2, if he doesn't show up or get replaced.
I will not consider that under any circumstances and if anyone else does I will actively fight it.
She opposes the idea of a policy lynch too. Makes me feel better, but I wish it came along with some sort of reasoning.
Spoiler: show
a2thezebra wrote:I'm voting Bullzeye. His vote for MP seems opportunistic.
Spoiler: show
a2thezebra wrote:Only the last sentence of this paragraph indicates a suspicion. The rest of it is a criticism of what MP is doing, as if he were a civilian that you simply disagree with. I think that you're trying to make MP's recent posts to be more alignment-indicative than you know them to actually be.
Bullzeye wrote:
MovingPictures07 wrote:I don't understand why I'm getting votes. How else do you all propose we figure out Dizzy's alignment then? Anyone?
It just seems counter-productive to be lynching no shows who might be civs when there are so few players overall. If this were a full game, then maybe. But if Dizzy is bad right now the only people he's hurting are his own team, who would probably be quite willing to throw him under the bus since he's a no show. So either we lynch a civ and go into day 3 with 8 of us left (assuming someone dies tonight) or we lynch a baddie who wasn't playing and whose teammates probably gain more from the civ cred of throwing him under the bus than they would have done from him just continuing to not play. I feel like you know and would have considered this.
It seems like she's reaching with this argument, though she's calling Bullzeye out for the same thing. I think it's clear that he's expressing a solid scum read for MP here. It kind of feels to me like zebra's trying to debate something for the sake of confusing people, because I'm pretty confused.
Spoiler: show
DrWilgy wrote:
a2thezebra wrote:I'll switch my vote to agleaminranks then, just for you.
Yay! Maybe Gleam will respond to me now.
I refer you back to what I said about her voting gleam for a really pointless reason while interrogating Bullzeye who would be much more deserving of her vote at the time.
Spoiler: show
a2thezebra wrote:That was a bad lynch. Bass did nothing to indicate that he was mafia and everyone who voted for him should've known that.
As a whole, zebra's approach to this game has been a lot of 'I'm right, you're wrong'. This is just one example of that. It's highly authoritative and it's given her a lot of steer power over the flow of the thread. I don't think she's used that power for town's benefit, either. She's been stuck on Bullzeye, sig and the marmot pretty much half the game and is direct in 'actively opposing anything else'
Spoiler: show
a2thezebra wrote:
leetic wrote:
a2thezebra wrote:
Bullzeye wrote:My comment was clearly a joke, yours just looks like you're directly criticising the people who voted Bass. You don't even frame it as an accusation, just that they should have known he wasn't bad.
Your joke served no purpose, my criticism did not. And the underlined is true, what is your objection exactly? I'd like to hear from the people that voted Bass because I don't understand why they suspected him. It's not a criticism of them, but their actions. Is that not cool or what?
I made an entire wallpost on the topic, so you can look at that if you wish.
Seems legit. I won't vote for you today. I will, however, vote for Metalmarsh89.
She'd just spent almost an entire phase doing almost nothing else but interrogating Bullzeye, and then voted metalmarsh the next day. I refer back to the fact that she was voting gleam before and didn't come back to that. Gleam, did that question thing with Wilgy ever get resolved?
Spoiler: show
a2thezebra wrote:I also think that sig is bad but I've been wrong about sig too many times to put my vote there...for now.
Don't like this one either. The opposition to the vote wasn't 'I don't think he's bad' it was 'I'm usually wrong about him so I'll take past game history and let that guide my vote'. Massive ping.
Spoiler: show
a2thezebra wrote:Wilgy is civ.
Well, uh.
Spoiler: show
a2thezebra wrote:
Bullzeye wrote:If you insist, I'll happily get behind an MM lynch tomorrow. Seems like he waited to vote until the timing was just right for him to save himself and be sure he'd be safe.
None of his votes have been contrived or disingenuous. You may dislike the reasons behind them or how he's played this game but that doesn't make him bad.

;)
Zebra's advocating a marmot lynch and when someone agrees she defends him against the accusation. Waddup?
Spoiler: show
a2thezebra wrote:The main thing people seem to be agreeing on is that MM is bad. I won't be voting for him today.
Spoiler: show
a2thezebra wrote:I'll place a vote on Bullzeye for now just in case I'm not free tomorrow but I'll be doing some independent research and that vote may change.
These are some massive contradictions. Early on it's Bullzeye, bullzeye, bullzeye! and she votes gleam/marmot. Now, it's marmot, marmot marmot! and she's finally putting the vote down on bullzeye I would've expected like, Day 2? Nah.


I think my vote's gonna stay where it is.
by Quin
Sun Jun 12, 2016 7:06 am
Forum: Previous Heists
Topic: End Game: Attack on Titan Heist: The Battle of Trost
Replies: 1037
Views: 28606

Re: Day 6: Attack on Titan Heist: The Battle of Trost

I'll do zebra later, since I've got all the time in the world because nobody else is awake hahahahahahahahahahahaha
by Quin
Sun Jun 12, 2016 7:01 am
Forum: Previous Heists
Topic: End Game: Attack on Titan Heist: The Battle of Trost
Replies: 1037
Views: 28606

Re: Day 6: Attack on Titan Heist: The Battle of Trost

Marmot!
Spoiler: show
Metalmarsh89 wrote:
ika wrote:ill thorw mtal to town pile too
Thanks. Lunch MP with me then, would you?

He's proven to be dangerous mafiabaddyscummuffinsockface.
Not sure it's alignment indicative, but god damn, if this wasn't intentional I'll eat a titan.

I, uhm. I don't know. Unless he was voting someone, there's really not a lot to say. He really is the fluffiest titan you ever saw. The most notable posts of his are where he lays a vote down, but he doesn't justify any of them. Rather, I expect that he voted at a time where the state of the thread was justification enough, which makes evaluating it now a pain in the ass. Not a good sign. But as I said before, he looks less bad given the way Wilgy interacted with him.
by Quin
Sun Jun 12, 2016 6:46 am
Forum: Previous Heists
Topic: End Game: Attack on Titan Heist: The Battle of Trost
Replies: 1037
Views: 28606

Re: Day 6: Attack on Titan Heist: The Battle of Trost

Next up, Gleam.
Spoiler: show
agleaminranks wrote:Boku no Titan.
Yes.
Spoiler: show
agleaminranks wrote:I don't know if I feel comfortable voting Quin. I didn't feel incredibly pinged by what I could read of Silverwolf's defensiveness. It sounded more character oriented than role.

Voting leetic.
I'm pinged slightly in the last sentence of this post. This is in response to the silver/ika/mp fiasco, of course. I don't think it's realistic for him to put down behaviour as character indicative when he didn't know which character Silver was playing as. But then again, as a mafia he wouldn't have this information either. Either way, it was a weak argument.
Spoiler: show
agleaminranks wrote:leetic, if I can answer your response, you're right, I did not provide much justification for your vote. In all truthfulness, I placed my vote on you because you were the only other name with any votes on you by day-end. One of them was Epignosis, someone I mentioned I had good feelings about, and I'm sad to say the night period confirmed this. I also did not feel good about the vote against Quin/Silver, which I previously mentioned as well. Going off of that, and bearing in mind that people I felt decently good about putting votes against you, swayed me to place a hesitant last minute vote.
In context, gleam votes leetic because he didn't agree with the lynch of Quin 1.0. I think his defense is solid, he's previously expressed town reads for silver, ika, quin 1.0, epi, whoever, whatever.
Spoiler: show
agleaminranks wrote:
MovingPictures07 wrote:I don't understand why I'm getting votes. How else do you all propose we figure out Dizzy's alignment then? Anyone?
This just seems like a really scummy thing to do. I understand the no-shower isn't contributing atm, but just lynching him gung-ho sounds like a real mafia thing to do. Given that we're picking blindly because we have no interactions to go off of, the odds are much more likely they're civ. I could picture a baddie pushing this agenda and claiming it's just policy.
Similar to bullzeye, he's pretty actively opposing the policy lynch suggested by MP. I prefer the argument made by gleam to the one bullzeye made though. This is on the grounds of having no information that would justify lynching an inactive, bullzeye's is moreso expressing that there's no room to lynch inactives for the sake of lynching inactives.
Spoiler: show
agleaminranks wrote:
a2thezebra wrote:
agleaminranks wrote:Zeebs, I'm confused. Not being able to read a player makes them likelier to be civilian?
Where did I say that?
a2thezebra wrote:
leetic wrote:
a2thezebra wrote:I also think that sig is bad but I've been wrong about sig too many times to put my vote there...for now.
Why are you relying on meta reads? Keep this post in mind if sig flips scum.
I'm not relying on meta reads, I'm relying(?) on my failure to read a particular player.
This was also right after defending Wilgy as being good. Maybe I misread your intentions.

That being said, I don't feel great about Wilgy, and I don't see whatever patterns you are. I feel like he's more been skirting the outside for too long.

I have to go into work so I will vote Wilgy before I do so. I think I might be reading you two as teammates.
Out of all of us, gleam is the only one to ever put a vote down for Wilgy. The polls have gleam down as not having voted for Day 3 (when this post was made), though. I found myself nodding along to his comment about zebra and wilgy being teammates though. I'll get to him, but a lot of what I read while ISO'ing gleam helped me form a better view on zebra.

---

Another townie. I'm most confident about gleam being town than I am about pretty much anything else at this point. I'll cover my face with my hands and run away in shame if he ever flips bad
by Quin
Sun Jun 12, 2016 5:21 am
Forum: Previous Heists
Topic: End Game: Attack on Titan Heist: The Battle of Trost
Replies: 1037
Views: 28606

Re: Day 6: Attack on Titan Heist: The Battle of Trost

The first of the ISO's, starting with Bullzeye.
Spoiler: show
Bullzeye wrote:I'll also *Vote Quin*, at least for now. I might change my mind while I'm catching up. I definitely think there's a chance at least one of Silver and Ika were bad, and how Quin flips would colour my opinion of a few other people.
A vote for Quin 1.0, based on his opinions on Silverwolf. He was wrong, clearly, but I can appreciate his reasoning and expectations. Although, he never refers back to this lynch which was supposed to 'colour his opinions', which is something I'd expect at some point.
Spoiler: show
Bullzeye wrote:In fact, for now at least, I'm going to put a vote on *MP* for suggesting we spend either today or day 3 lynching people who aren't even playing the game. If the day ends when the poll does, I might change it. If day ends 48 hours after night ended, I likely won't get the chance.
Spoiler: show
Bullzeye wrote:
MovingPictures07 wrote:I don't understand why I'm getting votes. How else do you all propose we figure out Dizzy's alignment then? Anyone?
It just seems counter-productive to be lynching no shows who might be civs when there are so few players overall. If this were a full game, then maybe. But if Dizzy is bad right now the only people he's hurting are his own team, who would probably be quite willing to throw him under the bus since he's a no show. So either we lynch a civ and go into day 3 with 8 of us left (assuming someone dies tonight) or we lynch a baddie who wasn't playing and whose teammates probably gain more from the civ cred of throwing him under the bus than they would have done from him just continuing to not play. I feel like you know and would have considered this.
Serge wrote:
Bullzeye wrote:Serge, you missed the vote on day 1. Who would you have voted for and why?
leetic. I don't like how he flipped with his assessment on me.
So a NO U basically? Will you be voting Leetic today?
He votes to lynch the person suggesting a policy lynch on inactives. I feel good considering he's pretty forward in opposing the idea of lynching townies out of policy and even makes a point that there aren't enough players to justify wasting lynches on it.
Spoiler: show
Bullzeye wrote:
Serge wrote:Oh wait, I'm going to fulfill leetic's last goal, to lynch Metalmarsh. This one's for you, leetic!
Even better, put the blame for your vote on someone dead. That way if MM is civ and dies, it's Leetic who was wrong and not you.

*Votes Serge*
He votes Serge, following the majority. Going off the poll history, he was the one who tied up the votes between Serge and the marmot.
Spoiler: show
Bullzeye wrote:I don't see MM being so detached if he was bad (he's been even less active than me), Sig and Wilgy I just don't see the cases on and feel relatively neutral toward. INH and Zebra I have reasonably good vibes on. Process of elimination leaves me with Gleam and Quin... Will see if I can find a reason not to vote for either of them.
Spoiler: show
Bullzeye wrote:Actually skimming over Quin and Gleam got me to look back at Sig, and I've changed my mind on him. *Votes Sig* Of particular interest to me was where he defends himself against Quin's claims that he hasn't done anything memorable with this post:
sig wrote:and neither have you? Also I did I built a case on Serge and true it was wrong, but I'm trying. Your'e tunneling on me since your salty I voted for you. :P

Ask me the questions and I'll answer I've made it no secret I've had RL things, but still have contributed more then some players and if I missed a question reask or requote it and I'll answer.
Sig's posts contain no such case. His vote for Serge was supposedly gut at the time. Just strikes me as odd he'd come out with something so false as well as trying to dismiss Quin's suspicion as just him being salty.
I like Bullzeye's uncertainty in these two posts. The time stamps are 12 minutes apart, and since he used the word 'skimming' makes me feel like he actually did read gleam and my posts to bring him to this conclusion. Were he mafia, I'm sure he would've left his train of thought going for gleam or I because he was setting himself up that way. There's no poll for Day 5 to check how the votes looked at EoD that I can find though, which makes evaluating his motivations a bit difficult.

---

Overall, factoring in my vibes from earlier and his interactions with Wilgy, I'm gonna put Bullzeye down as civ. I think he has a civ-minded attitude to the game, he's asking questions and he's not trying to avoid attention.
by Quin
Sun Jun 12, 2016 2:09 am
Forum: Previous Heists
Topic: End Game: Attack on Titan Heist: The Battle of Trost
Replies: 1037
Views: 28606

Re: Day 6: Attack on Titan Heist: The Battle of Trost

Alright, let's do a wall post. I'll point out any interactions that speak out to me between Wilgy and the living players in this one and then come back and ISO everyone individually after.

For the most part, it's fluff, especially between himself and the marmot.
Spoiler: show
DrWilgy wrote:
Metalmarsh89 wrote:
DrWilgy wrote:I'm fluffy...
Or you, in fact marshmallow?

I'm too full for marshmallow... :sigh:
"Plz eat me Marmot Senpai. I know you are full, but I believe!" - Stale Marshmallow
Spoiler: show
DrWilgy wrote:I'm like... 90% with Marmot friend.
Spoiler: show
DrWilgy wrote:Voted Gleam for 7 way tie memes, and for not acknowledging me. If it wouldn't break the tie and had 2 votes, I'd vote Leetic as well. If Marmot was my dad I'd be DrWarmot, most definitely a Marmot Doctor.
On to some semi-serious but still kinda fluffy post analysis, let's talk about this one conversation with zebra.
Spoiler: show
DrWilgy wrote:
a2thezebra wrote:
DrWilgy wrote:Voting Wilgy because he doesn't exist.

Zebra, would you ignore me?
What are you talking about? I don't understand any of this post.
Yay! Zebra doesn't hate me! *eyes sparkle as he leaps towards Zebra with open arms*

Gleam and Leetic hate me...
Spoiler: show
DrWilgy wrote:
a2thezebra wrote:I'll switch my vote to agleaminranks then, just for you.
Yay! Maybe Gleam will respond to me now.
Reading back for context, all I could find was this, which I've coloured:
Spoiler: show
DrWilgy wrote:Lalala~<3 hello everyone! My name is DrWilgy and I am most definitely a singer!

I have a question! Who is worried more about survivability mafia or civilian?

Next I want you to think based on your answer from above. Who would be more vocal regarding survival? WIFOM isn't an option.

INH can I please have a GTH on Silver, Ika, Rabbit and MP?
This isn't a game specific question, so I think it's odd that Wilgy would hold onto a vote at the time for it. Before this becomes me arguing the case for a proven scum, I'll get to my point. Well, two points, actually. One, is holding on to the fact that Gleam never responded to this question and taking it as far as to lay a vote for it some form of distancing between Gleam and himself? Two, it is definitely weird that zebra would abandon his vote for Bullzeye which he was so keen on at the time just to get on board with a vote for gleam founded on the idea that he wouldn't answer this question.

So Bullzeye doesn't feel left out, here's a little snippet of conversation betwe- uh. No. There's nothing. Well, not nothing, but what there is doesn't seem to do much for my train of thought. It does give me something more to talk about in regards to the marmot, though.
Spoiler: show
DrWilgy wrote:Who subbed in for Goldy?

Out of living players, Marmot interacted with me, possibly Goldy's sub, INH, Bullzeye and Zeebs. Because Marmot friend is a crafty turnip, I can't tell if they are teammate interactions or not.
Although this post actually existing might be justified by the context, I wasn't here for that. Right now it just seems unnecessary, as Wilgy *knows* the marmot is bad. Which, given his own alignment doesn't surprise me. Completely contradictory to what I just said about this post not helping, this could be spun to look like an attempt to set him up for a lynch. I'll elaborate more on this in his ISO.
Spoiler: show
DrWilgy wrote:Lol, both Bullzeye and MM missed the vote when the three way tie happened.
If this was an attempt to set these two up for a lynch, I don't know how well it would work. I don't think I'd be motivated enough to lynch someone because they missed a vote. I'd hope that they didn't skip votes as a mafia tactic, because I've got to have faith everyone's playing with integrity. If I were to take something out of this post, I'd put it down as a setup job. I don't think this post would exist if one of the two were bad, even if it was a bus.
---

With this, I guess my rainbow list isn't so much a rainbow list anymore, more like a big mix of orange. Except gleam, who's been bumped down to a disgusting earwaxy yellow colour.

I'll do ISO's as well, but right now my vote goes to zebra because 1. I think he came out looking the worst from Wilgy's flip, and 2. I really hate clicking the view votes button every time I visit to make sure nothing's changed.
by Quin
Sat Jun 11, 2016 7:05 am
Forum: Previous Heists
Topic: End Game: Attack on Titan Heist: The Battle of Trost
Replies: 1037
Views: 28606

Re: Day 6: Attack on Titan Heist: The Battle of Trost

At some point I'll get all my in-thread evidence out and come up with a vote I can get behind, but I would very much like to get the insight of the other three before I do so. I think I'll keep it for tomorrow though. That is assuming we're still doing the 48 hour days after what Draconus said earlier about shortening it. I think I'll have time either way though.
by Quin
Sat Jun 11, 2016 6:55 am
Forum: Previous Heists
Topic: End Game: Attack on Titan Heist: The Battle of Trost
Replies: 1037
Views: 28606

Re: Day 6: Attack on Titan Heist: The Battle of Trost

Bullzeye wrote:So... INH may have just won us the game there. Good work!
Quin wrote:Without going into any particular detail, here's a rainbow list based entirely on my vibes on everyone as of right now. Why am I posting a rainbow list based entirely on vibes? Why not? Also, I intend to go through the thread and point out any discrepancies in how I perceive players and what actual evidence I can find.

Why am I disclosing this information?

Because I expect pure vibe rainbows lists from each of you as well. Thankies.

gleam

zebra

marmot
bullzeye
I can't understand why Gleam would be at the top of anyone's rainbow list. I can't think of a single thing he's done all game. Zebra is funnily enough the only person other than me that I actually believe to be a civ. At this point I'm sure MM is bad and that someone did vote Sig in a bid to save him early on. Here's why it wasn't me: Knowing what we know now about Wilgy, if I'd been a baddie during the previous lynch I latched on to INH's case for distancing purposes, safe in the knowledge that MM would show up to vote Sig and save himself. No saving necessary.
From your perspective then, are you saying that gleam and the marmot are our baddies?
by Quin
Sat Jun 11, 2016 1:58 am
Forum: Previous Heists
Topic: End Game: Attack on Titan Heist: The Battle of Trost
Replies: 1037
Views: 28606

Re: Day 6: Attack on Titan Heist: The Battle of Trost

Without going into any particular detail, here's a rainbow list based entirely on my vibes on everyone as of right now. Why am I posting a rainbow list based entirely on vibes? Why not? Also, I intend to go through the thread and point out any discrepancies in how I perceive players and what actual evidence I can find.

Why am I disclosing this information?

Because I expect pure vibe rainbows lists from each of you as well. Thankies.

gleam

zebra

marmot
bullzeye
by Quin
Sat Jun 11, 2016 1:40 am
Forum: Previous Heists
Topic: End Game: Attack on Titan Heist: The Battle of Trost
Replies: 1037
Views: 28606

Re: Day 6: Attack on Titan Heist: The Battle of Trost

wilgy is a deadie baddie guy guy and that means stuff that i will think about and do stuff with soonish i guess lol
by Quin
Fri Jun 10, 2016 12:12 am
Forum: Previous Heists
Topic: End Game: Attack on Titan Heist: The Battle of Trost
Replies: 1037
Views: 28606

Re: Night 5: Attack on Titan Heist: The Battle of Trost

I guess in hindsight the fact that the mafia actually allowed a three way tie to exist earlier should have meant that it was unlikely any of the three were bad. With that, I have my doubts about the marmot being bad.

Since the game's still not over I guess this means we have another day, unless there's a reason outside of the civ/maf ratio to warrant it to continue.
by Quin
Thu Jun 09, 2016 12:18 am
Forum: Previous Heists
Topic: End Game: Attack on Titan Heist: The Battle of Trost
Replies: 1037
Views: 28606

Re: Day 5: Attack on Titan Heist: The Battle of Trost

INH, considering this is our last chance to lynch a baddie, it's about time you stopped debating what would and wouldn't convince you to vote someone and started advocate for your biggest scum read.

Who dat? y?
by Quin
Wed Jun 08, 2016 1:00 am
Forum: Previous Heists
Topic: End Game: Attack on Titan Heist: The Battle of Trost
Replies: 1037
Views: 28606

Re: Day 5: Attack on Titan Heist: The Battle of Trost

a2thezebra wrote:I have just a tiny amount of doubt with my baddie read of sig, but that amount is still too big for me to not advocate Metalmarsh89 instead. That being said, I won't oppose a sig lynch or a Bullzeye lynch. Any other lynch I will strongly oppose.
I won't be changing my vote from sig, so I would recommend that that if you still think sig is bad that you vote with me on this. When he flips bad, which he inevitably will, I'll consider other options.
by Quin
Tue Jun 07, 2016 9:45 pm
Forum: Previous Heists
Topic: End Game: Attack on Titan Heist: The Battle of Trost
Replies: 1037
Views: 28606

Re: Day 5: Attack on Titan Heist: The Battle of Trost

So we have one more day to lynch a baddie.

Voting sig. He hasn't done anything memorable to address my or anybody else's suspicions of him to this point.
by Quin
Mon Jun 06, 2016 11:56 pm
Forum: Previous Heists
Topic: End Game: Attack on Titan Heist: The Battle of Trost
Replies: 1037
Views: 28606

Re: Night 4: Attack on Titan Heist: The Battle of Trost

this wouldn't have happened if we lynched sig
by Quin
Mon Jun 06, 2016 6:23 pm
Forum: Previous Heists
Topic: End Game: Attack on Titan Heist: The Battle of Trost
Replies: 1037
Views: 28606

Re: Day 4: Attack on Titan Heist: The Battle of Trost

insertnamehere wrote:incomprehensible.
If you were to describe DrWilgy in one word...
by Quin
Mon Jun 06, 2016 6:21 pm
Forum: Previous Heists
Topic: End Game: Attack on Titan Heist: The Battle of Trost
Replies: 1037
Views: 28606

Re: Day 4: Attack on Titan Heist: The Battle of Trost

Swapping my vote to Serge because

1. You all suck
2. This post:
Serge wrote:Scum will try and get me lynched tomorrow. Or sig, if he's town. We're the easiest choices. Just remember that yesterday was a very easy lynch and I couldn't believe it went through. 3 players didn't vote and I'd be willing to wager at least one of those 3 is scum.

Bullzeye
Gleam
Metalmarsh

I'll be voting Metalmarsh tomorrow
Pretty big preemptive NO U as someone said. I regret not making that point when I first replied to it because it most definitely crossed my mind but, whadderyagonado. Add that he was one of ?two? people who lynched leetic, I guess.
by Quin
Mon Jun 06, 2016 1:05 am
Forum: Previous Heists
Topic: End Game: Attack on Titan Heist: The Battle of Trost
Replies: 1037
Views: 28606

Re: Day 4: Attack on Titan Heist: The Battle of Trost

DrWilgy wrote:I feel that a Quin or INH lynch would reflect heavily on the other.
I feel that a shut up
by Quin
Sun Jun 05, 2016 9:18 pm
Forum: Previous Heists
Topic: End Game: Attack on Titan Heist: The Battle of Trost
Replies: 1037
Views: 28606

Re: Day 4: Attack on Titan Heist: The Battle of Trost

DrWilgy wrote:
Quin wrote:
insertnamehere wrote:
a2thezebra wrote:Let's lynch Metalmarsh89 already.
This is exactly what I mean when I said this:
insertnamehere wrote:aaaand we've learned nothing
We need to actually get back into the habit of discussing who we want to vote for instead of just tunnel-vision'ing one specific person. This shit is how scum wins games.
I'm all for that. Let's discuss things. Tell me who you think is bad and why. You're saying a lot of 'everyone stop the tunnel vision and analyse things!' but frankly, it feels to me like you're calling tunnel vision just because we aren't voting who you want us to vote for. :suspish:

I'd like to contribute the idea that sig didn't vote yesterday and didn't address that when he returned. Kind of seems to me like he just didn't want the attention at EoD. He's got some pretty detailed scum reads on Serge, which I think is going to reflect on one another's alignment depending on who flips first.
So you think these two are on opposing teams?
At this moment in time, yes. And given that I would prefer to lynch sig over Serge, I'd say sig is the baddie.
by Quin
Sun Jun 05, 2016 8:54 pm
Forum: Previous Heists
Topic: End Game: Attack on Titan Heist: The Battle of Trost
Replies: 1037
Views: 28606

Re: Day 4: Attack on Titan Heist: The Battle of Trost

insertnamehere wrote:
a2thezebra wrote:Let's lynch Metalmarsh89 already.
This is exactly what I mean when I said this:
insertnamehere wrote:aaaand we've learned nothing
We need to actually get back into the habit of discussing who we want to vote for instead of just tunnel-vision'ing one specific person. This shit is how scum wins games.
I'm all for that. Let's discuss things. Tell me who you think is bad and why. You're saying a lot of 'everyone stop the tunnel vision and analyse things!' but frankly, it feels to me like you're calling tunnel vision just because we aren't voting who you want us to vote for. :suspish:

I'd like to contribute the idea that sig didn't vote yesterday and didn't address that when he returned. Kind of seems to me like he just didn't want the attention at EoD. He's got some pretty detailed scum reads on Serge, which I think is going to reflect on one another's alignment depending on who flips first.
by Quin
Sat Jun 04, 2016 10:47 pm
Forum: Previous Heists
Topic: End Game: Attack on Titan Heist: The Battle of Trost
Replies: 1037
Views: 28606

Re: Day 4: Attack on Titan Heist: The Battle of Trost

So that was either because of eren's secret ability or overall inactivity of the mafia.What are the odds of three baddies all forgetting to do a kill? Or is this is a ploy to make us think baddies are inactive? Find out next time on Attack on Titan Z!
by Quin
Sat Jun 04, 2016 5:53 pm
Forum: Previous Heists
Topic: End Game: Attack on Titan Heist: The Battle of Trost
Replies: 1037
Views: 28606

Re: Night 3: Attack on Titan Heist: The Battle of Trost

insertnamehere wrote:
Quin wrote:
Serge wrote:Scum will try and get me lynched tomorrow. Or sig, if he's town. We're the easiest choices. Just remember that yesterday was a very easy lynch and I couldn't believe it went through. 3 players didn't vote and I'd be willing to wager at least one of those 3 is scum.

Bullzeye
Gleam
Metalmarsh

I'll be voting Metalmarsh tomorrow
I'll be voting sig tomorrow :nicenod:
aaaand we've learned nothing
What makes you think that?
by Quin
Sat Jun 04, 2016 8:48 am
Forum: Previous Heists
Topic: End Game: Attack on Titan Heist: The Battle of Trost
Replies: 1037
Views: 28606

Re: Night 3: Attack on Titan Heist: The Battle of Trost

Serge wrote:Scum will try and get me lynched tomorrow. Or sig, if he's town. We're the easiest choices. Just remember that yesterday was a very easy lynch and I couldn't believe it went through. 3 players didn't vote and I'd be willing to wager at least one of those 3 is scum.

Bullzeye
Gleam
Metalmarsh

I'll be voting Metalmarsh tomorrow
I'll be voting sig tomorrow :nicenod:
by Quin
Sat Jun 04, 2016 1:41 am
Forum: Previous Heists
Topic: End Game: Attack on Titan Heist: The Battle of Trost
Replies: 1037
Views: 28606

Re: Night 3: Attack on Titan Heist: The Battle of Trost

[insert aggravated groaning]
by Quin
Fri Jun 03, 2016 7:28 pm
Forum: Previous Heists
Topic: End Game: Attack on Titan Heist: The Battle of Trost
Replies: 1037
Views: 28606

Re: Day 3: Attack on Titan Heist: The Battle of Trost

I feel like I should apologise for sub-par activity since replacing again. I've got a report due in 2 days, but if I'm still alive by the time I submit it I'll definitely pick up my socks. plz 4giv.

Meanwhile, I don't intend to move my vote. sig's reasoning and overall behaviour came off the worst among those who lynched that Quin 1.0 guy, and I, Quin 2.0, firmly believe he is a bad.
by Quin
Wed Jun 01, 2016 10:08 pm
Forum: Previous Heists
Topic: End Game: Attack on Titan Heist: The Battle of Trost
Replies: 1037
Views: 28606

Re: Day 3: Attack on Titan Heist: The Battle of Trost

Quin 2.0 votes sig, because sig is a bad dude. Of course, this vote has nothing to do with Quin 1.0, owing simply to the fact that I am not Quin 1.0, I am Quin 2.0.
by Quin
Sun May 29, 2016 5:36 pm
Forum: Previous Heists
Topic: End Game: Attack on Titan Heist: The Battle of Trost
Replies: 1037
Views: 28606

Re: Day 2: Attack on Titan Heist: The Battle of Trost

I didn't and don't expect an apology. Draconus told me it'd be a crappy situation to replace into in the first place and I did it anyway. For mafia! Or town, I guess it depends on your thing.
by Quin
Sun May 29, 2016 7:32 am
Forum: Previous Heists
Topic: End Game: Attack on Titan Heist: The Battle of Trost
Replies: 1037
Views: 28606

Re: Day 2: Attack on Titan Heist: The Battle of Trost

Yo, this was not what I meant when I said to make this a good'un.
by Quin
Thu May 26, 2016 9:56 pm
Forum: Previous Heists
Topic: End Game: Attack on Titan Heist: The Battle of Trost
Replies: 1037
Views: 28606

Re: Day 1: Attack on Titan Heist: The Battle of Trost

Hooray, progress!

Whoop whoop whoop whoop whoop!

Wait, wrong game.
by Quin
Thu May 26, 2016 8:56 pm
Forum: Previous Heists
Topic: End Game: Attack on Titan Heist: The Battle of Trost
Replies: 1037
Views: 28606

Re: Day 1: Attack on Titan Heist: The Battle of Trost

I guess I'll just wait for someone to defend sig so I can accuse them of being scum by accessory \_(:T)_/
by Quin
Thu May 26, 2016 8:38 pm
Forum: Previous Heists
Topic: End Game: Attack on Titan Heist: The Battle of Trost
Replies: 1037
Views: 28606

Re: Day 1: Attack on Titan Heist: The Battle of Trost

rabbit8 wrote:
sig wrote:
rabbit8 wrote:
sig wrote:
Quin wrote:Points of interest - pardon me for not drawing quotes, I can't be assed with that right now.

There's some fluff conversation between sig and wilgy early on. Wilgy joking about being scum isn't surprising, but I haven't seen that sort of thing from sig before. ika (Epi) picked up on sig too, but his reasoning just comes down to guts so it's credibility is something to be desired. Although, if sig ever flipped bad I think that would favour Epi somewhat.


Placing a resting vote on sig, because why not.

This all goes up to about page 5, but I've got to stop for a minute. I'll come back.
NO U
Quin :mad:

On a more serious note, I've joked around about being bad before. It was very early day 0 fluff there was no meaning behind it what so ever. I find it strange you're trying to give it a meaning when it was clearly fluffyness. :ponder:
Is this a serious accusation? Or just bullshit NO U voted me, I'm voting you?

It's hard to tell since you guys, girls (some gender neutral nonsense here) just throw your votes around like their meaningless.
Semi serious, I doubt I'll leave it on Quin, but him picking at my fluff is pingy.

This never happened?
I mentioned that his and Wilgy's interaction on Day 0 was pretty much fluff, and that it was uncharacteristic of sig to participate in it.
by Quin
Thu May 26, 2016 8:36 pm
Forum: Previous Heists
Topic: End Game: Attack on Titan Heist: The Battle of Trost
Replies: 1037
Views: 28606

Re: Day 1: Attack on Titan Heist: The Battle of Trost

sig wrote:
rabbit8 wrote:I'm voting sig. I didn't like her no u post.
I'd have moved my vote if Quin had answered my point, but he hasn't yet. Why though are you voting for me based on that, but never reneged me or mentioned me until this post? :eye:
I didn't realise you wanted me to comment on it. There's not much to say in response. I did do the thing you find suspicious. And uh, chopsticks!
by Quin
Thu May 26, 2016 6:34 pm
Forum: Previous Heists
Topic: End Game: Attack on Titan Heist: The Battle of Trost
Replies: 1037
Views: 28606

Re: Day 1: Attack on Titan Heist: The Battle of Trost

I change my mind. If it comes down to self-preservation i'll vote for Serge. Everybody wins! Well, except Serge :shrug2:
by Quin
Thu May 26, 2016 6:22 pm
Forum: Previous Heists
Topic: End Game: Attack on Titan Heist: The Battle of Trost
Replies: 1037
Views: 28606

Re: Day 1: Attack on Titan Heist: The Battle of Trost

Epignosis wrote:Vote leetic with me, Silver's replacement.
Should it come down to a matter of self preservation, I might; however I'm currently feeling more confident with my vote for sig given his response and follow up to my vote.
by Quin
Thu May 26, 2016 6:16 pm
Forum: Previous Heists
Topic: End Game: Attack on Titan Heist: The Battle of Trost
Replies: 1037
Views: 28606

Re: Day 1: Attack on Titan Heist: The Battle of Trost

leetic wrote:
insertnamehere wrote:leetic, do you have a specific active player that you want to lynch today, or do you just disagree with Epig on theory alone?
Not really a specific one. I currently have a vote on Silver's replacement, and Silver was not only scummy but if she flipped town there would be a lot of goodies to go off of since everyone (well, except for Serge that is) talked about her. If a better lynch arises, I'd be willing to go for it, but for now I think Silver is a decent lynch.
I'm Quin, damn it!
by Quin
Thu May 26, 2016 6:13 pm
Forum: Previous Heists
Topic: End Game: Attack on Titan Heist: The Battle of Trost
Replies: 1037
Views: 28606

Re: Day 1: Attack on Titan Heist: The Battle of Trost

MovingPictures07 wrote:I'm currently really busy, so I'll be back to generate some juicy content either late tonight or sometime tomorrow before EoD.

For now, I have the following brief thoughts:

- I'm willing to tentatively throw out slight town reads of insertnamehere, leetic, and Epignosis/ika. I don't want to vote for any of them today due to their contributions, which all thus far seem genuine to me with respect to solving the game.

- I was going to slightly mafia read Silverwolf, but then she flew off the rails and I'm not sure what to make of all of that. Unfortunately for Quin, I still think Silverwolf was suspicious for latching onto the suspicion of me after ika started going after me as well as for her insistence of things that just weren't true (like that I was trying to get people to not form reads on ika, wtf?). It didn't read genuine to me, like instead she doubled down on aggressively pursuing me instead of recognizing she made a faulty point. I don't believe a town Silverwolf would fail to recognize when she was mistaken, but I'm not sure how confidently I believe that. I'd like to give Quin a chance, but... I don't currently have any other slight mafia reads and I'm torn between voting for him due to his predecessor's actions and going the route of a low poster policy lynch (as Epi suggested).

So... I'd like to see more from Quin (and many others), in an attempt to better direct this Day 1 lynch if at all possible. I always feel torn on low poster policy lynches; I can pick up what Epi is putting down but I can also pick up what leetic is putting down, and I'd ideally rather lynch someone I'm legitimately suspicious of than someone who just isn't here, at least on Day 1. But I've also seen too many games here in which town was too hesitant to pursue low posters not only Day 1 but throughout the game, to their demise.
Don't lynch me and you will, lynch me and you won't :shrug:

I'll most definitely talk about things when I come across them but from experience it's hard to get the ball rolling until day 2. I realise your perception of Silver doesn't reflect that greatly on me right now, but as I said about Epi, GIVE ME A CHANCE, MAN!!!!!
by Quin
Thu May 26, 2016 2:21 am
Forum: Previous Heists
Topic: End Game: Attack on Titan Heist: The Battle of Trost
Replies: 1037
Views: 28606

Re: Attack on Titan Heist: The Battle of Trost

Hey, Marmot!
Metalmarsh89 wrote:
ika wrote:ill thorw mtal to town pile too
Thanks. Lunch MP with me then, would you?

He's proven to be dangerous mafiabaddyscummuffinsockface.
Are you hungry, Marmot? You eatin' the peoples?
by Quin
Thu May 26, 2016 2:09 am
Forum: Previous Heists
Topic: End Game: Attack on Titan Heist: The Battle of Trost
Replies: 1037
Views: 28606

Re: Day 1: Attack on Titan Heist: The Battle of Trost

Points of interest - pardon me for not drawing quotes, I can't be assed with that right now.

There's some fluff conversation between sig and wilgy early on. Wilgy joking about being scum isn't surprising, but I haven't seen that sort of thing from sig before. ika (Epi) picked up on sig too, but his reasoning just comes down to guts so it's credibility is something to be desired. Although, if sig ever flipped bad I think that would favour Epi somewhat.

MP pushes ika (Epi) to elaborated more on his reads, which I like to see. I didn't see his retaliation as suspicious either. I agree with the principle of what he was trying to say too - you need more than guts for your speculations to be considered credible. He does say that there's no reason to be throwing out reads, although i can think of about 10 reasons why throwing out reads is a good thing. I think it's interesting that he defended ika from the new players before anybody had actually expressed a read of him either way though. Interesting meaning, it's definitely indicative of an alignment, but I have no idea which one. I don't really interpret what rabbit and insertnamehere have said up to that point as expressing a read, personally. Irregardless, I'll definitely be comparing this degree of helpfulness against his further actions and i recommend others do so as well. Right now, i'd say that I think MP cares too much about preserving townies to be bad though.

ika himself was a bit of a flipflop while he was here. I personally can't get on board with straight gut reads that aren't backed up by some form of evidence, because i can't differentiate it from a baddie throwing a name in the air and hoping it sticks and a casually playing townie. Either way, he runs with the 'discredit' argument pretty quickly which reflects on my perception of epi right now. He used the 'silver is the only person who understands my game' argument, which I don't like either. Without sparking up this whole argument again, I'll just say that I think this is nonsensical, considering ika has been here about as long as I have and has most definitely played more games. We've all gotten used to his play style and meta by now and I'm sure he knows that. Of course, I don't want to put a vote on Epi just because of how I've perceived ika, because he's got no counter argument and ika can't defend himself now. I'd rather wait and see what I think of Epi's contributions first, or it'd be ironic and unfair on him since the exact same thing could happen to me since I replaced Silver.

Placing a resting vote on sig, because why not.

This all goes up to about page 5, but I've got to stop for a minute. I'll come back.
by Quin
Thu May 26, 2016 1:25 am
Forum: Previous Heists
Topic: End Game: Attack on Titan Heist: The Battle of Trost
Replies: 1037
Views: 28606

Re: Day 1: Attack on Titan Heist: The Battle of Trost

I'm home. I'll see if I can give you something substantial now that I'm in front of a computer screen.
by Quin
Thu May 26, 2016 1:24 am
Forum: Previous Heists
Topic: End Game: Attack on Titan Heist: The Battle of Trost
Replies: 1037
Views: 28606

Re: Day 1: Attack on Titan Heist: The Battle of Trost

Metalmarsh89 wrote:
Quin wrote:
Metalmarsh89 wrote:
Quin wrote:
Metalmarsh89 wrote:
Quin wrote:
MovingPictures07 wrote:Oh, and glad to be playing with new folks (Goldy, leetic) too! Definitely don't want to leave that out.
I forgot about this too. There's a few people in this game I haven't played with yet, so lets make this a good'un.

Uhh, ill be home in an hour or so. Stay tuned. Or don't. Either way, checking the thread so far hasn't really brought anything significant to my attention but I'll have another go when I'm at a computer and can actually read the screen properly.
Here, have a vote.

Vote Quin.
I don't want it!
What else am I supposed to do with it?
You could eat it?
I just ate three (3) grilled cheeses, I don't think I can eat any more.
I thought titans were able to vomit at will? Make room!

Return to “End Game: Attack on Titan Heist: The Battle of Trost”