The Syndicate

If she is bad that's exciting, because the "whoever has the most townies in the GTH reads exercise is most likely to be bad" theory would be supported. :nicenod: S~V~S: I'm not convinced you gave bea enough breathing room to have a fair chance of changing your mind. You had 17 civ reads v...

JaggedJimmyJay wrote:Polo, what degree of confidence do you have in your read on S~V~S?

High enough for me to say this: if she's lynched and she's not Cylon, then you can lynch me on the next day.

I am 100% sure she's mafia.

Oh, and you had too many civs on that list because you knew right from the start who was mafia

Do you still read Sig and Wilgy as mafia?

If I recall correctly, I got a bit of a scolding from JJJ for having too many civs on that list, but OK. You're on it :) It's funny that only 2 of the 7 people you read as bad are still alive. One of them is a confirmed Cylon who we believe is Civ (DrWilgy) and Sig. The other 5 were either lynched ...

S~V~S wrote:Persistent little devil aren't you? Um no. No teammates here. I also doubt OA is bad.

I've got my eyes on the people you read as good on the Day 4 GTH reads, and I'm certain your teammates are among those.

G'morning. *munches on blueberry muffin* We need to get you lynched tomorrow, by the way.

Are you teammates with ObscureAllure?

RIP, Dex.

You folks are looking at the wrong people.

And some more... Polo – Cylon The pusher. Polo was extremely intent on pushing the Claim back on Week 5 and oddly so. Yes to some this might look very “Good” but to me it screamed “bad”. Why? It was pretty over the top. The emotional outburst that came from this person was someone who was trying wa...

My suspicion of him has nothing to do with what he thinks about my post. That's good to know. What is your suspicion of me based on? Thank goodness for the Wills of the Dead Act because Epignosis is not who he appears to be! Living an unnaturally long life, the Great Deceiver will arise and vanquis...

S~V~S wrote:And publicly disagreeing with you is something only baddies do? Epi just did it and I see you think he is a baddie, too.

I speak my mind, son. Always.

My suspicion of him has nothing to do with what he thinks about my post.

ObscureAllure, how in the heavens is sig a confirmed Cylon? :eye: ____________________________________________________________________ Going back a bit: The Glorfindel/G-Man interaction smells artificial and fishy to me, and not like a red herring. I have to ISO G-Man because he appears to be tryin...

@Polo I voted Glorfindel, and I said repeatedly that I had no info on LC. I have been playing mafia with LC since 2009, though. So I just *knew* something was up with him before Cain was revealed, and once Cain was revealed, I knew what it was. Sorry if you disagreed with me that Cain was a priorit...

ObscureAllure, how in the heavens is sig a confirmed Cylon? :eye: ____________________________________________________________________ Going back a bit: The Glorfindel/G-Man interaction smells artificial and fishy to me, and not like a red herring. I have to ISO G-Man because he appears to be trying...

Vompatti has been shot for treason. May he rest in peace. [/color] So say we all. Do Polo next. Excuse me? I said So Say We All. "Christ, what an asshole". I hope he's either mafia or vanilla. Please don't say that, it is not nice :( https://web.archive.org/web/20070210090211/http://moder...

"Christ, what an asshole".

I hope he's either mafia or vanilla.

Ricochet wrote:
Polo wrote:I'm voting S~V~S because I think she's mafia. Post coming in the next hour.
Wait, didn't you do this thing on Day Seven, ie voting early, promising case l8er, as well? Tunnelling and punching the vote card early? Hmm.

Isolate me and you'll find out why I didn't post on day 7.

So say we all! I finally have some time to contribute. I've got a really sore throat and I coughed blood a few minutes ago, but I'm going to the doctor today to get that checked. First, I need to quote this again. Hello my lovely sortie finishers; GOOD LYNCH http://img.photobucket.com/albums/v508/M...

I suspect: 1. rabbit, because LC and zebra can't both be civs. 2. SVS, because she tried to prevent me from sinking the Klingon submarine. 3. myself, because I haven't been modkilled yet. Now you're getting modkilled because you didn't begin your post with So Say We All. Do you even care about this...

I'm voting S~V~S[b/] because I think she's mafia. Post coming in the next hour.

So say we all! I finally have some time to contribute. I've got a really sore throat and I coughed blood a few minutes ago, but I'm going to the doctor today to get that checked. First, I need to quote this again. Hello my lovely sortie finishers; GOOD LYNCH http://img.photobucket.com/albums/v508/MM...

Well, thanks, I guess. I still see you in here now, so no time like the present, but if you want to keep waiting, OK :shrug: Your last post was 6:24 AM, it is now 7:27. I would think an hour should be enough. That must be one hell of a dossier. I usually leave this browser tab open when I leave hom...

Well, thanks, I guess. I still see you in here now, so no time like the present, but if you want to keep waiting, OK :shrug: Your last post was 6:24 AM, it is now 7:27. I would think an hour should be enough. That must be one hell of a dossier. I usually leave this browser tab open when I leave hom...

So say we all. Just in case, Lol. The Defence of DrWilgy I'm going to try this one last time before the votes start to fall in earnest 1. I am as certain that Wilgs is a civ cylon as I was the LC was Cain. You'll recall that I pushed hard for an LC lynch. Now that Cain is dead, everyone's life is b...

I thought just dovel and cavil? By Dovel you mean Doral? And isn't Conoy mafia? Yes - doral - I'm sorry - it's the very end of a very long and and emotionally stressful day. By conoy I assume you mean Cavil? Yes. Evil and mafia are the same thing to me. Are they not to you? OK - I'm going to bed if...

bea wrote:I thought just dovel and cavil?

By Dovel you mean Doral?

And isn't Conoy mafia?

Polo wrote:So, only 3 Cylons alive, right? Gaius, please check S~V~S!

EBWOP: 3 evil cylons, according to lore.

So, only 3 Cylons alive, right? Gaius, please check S~V~S!

EBWOP:

- Glorfindel is good;
- DrWilgy is good

I had a brainfart. Sorry.

If Glorfindel is a good Cylon, he'd probably has to be good along with Wilgy. I believe the civ-aligned Cylons would have BTSC with each other, and Glorf stated that he highly suspected me being mafia for correcting Wilgy's orthographically incorrect claim. I believe these propositions... - Glorfind...

What distinguishes a bad Cylon from a good one, and how do you determine that? A bad Cylon is a Cylon whose win conditions should be incompatible with those of the good Humans, who need Cavil's faction dead. A good Cylon is a Cylon who shares win conditions with humans and/or who need Cavil's facti...

What distinguishes a bad Cylon from a good one, and how do you determine that? A bad Cylon is a Cylon whose win conditions should be incompatible with those of the good Humans, who need Cavil's faction dead. A good Cylon is a Cylon who shares win conditions with humans and/or who need Cavil's facti...

All that being said, I'm gonna have a hard time not voting for Glorfindel today. Yes, I think there's a very good chance he's Caprica Six, but there's still some definite ambiguity as to her motives, and I have some doubts that they line up with the civilian ones. Also, I think that lynching Glorfi...

I don't believe Polo reasonably thinks he's getting S~V~S lynched today, which makes me question the sincerity of his vote and his "I'll talk about it later" business. I also don't believe this: Dex - again. Explain it to me like I'm dumb Cuz I really . Why Wilgy civ and not glor? What am...

Rabbit8 and Rico, you're both civ. Why waste time arguing with each other?

I am standing by my word and I'm going to vote now: vote S~V~S . I I'm perfectly fine with a Glorfindel lynch and I endorse it too, but I'll try to convince you all to vote for S~V~S. I have to say wait wot?? You just mention that you find her evol at the start of the day - you give NO reason for t...

Ricochet wrote:You've voted very early throughout a number of cycles, Polo. Is it in your nature or is there any other impulse for you to do so?

Sometimes I'm very certain of who I believe needs to be lynched. S~V~S is mafia and we need her gone.

I am standing by my word and I'm going to vote now: vote S~V~S.

I'll write a big post when I get home.

I'm perfectly fine with a Glorfindel lynch and I endorse it too, but I'll try to convince you all to vote for S~V~S.

Dex - again. Explain it to me like I'm dumb Cuz I really . Why Wilgy civ and not glor? What am I missing? My Wilgy case is here. My case against Glorfindel has three legs. 1) His repetitive but generally contentless posts. 2) He was the last non-declarer to declare before the law was repealed, and ...

Folks, Glorfindel's survival by claiming last day is enough to warrant his lynch. There is no plausible way he's not a Cylon.

S~V~S is mafia Cylon and we need her lynched ASAP.

Epignosis - Town
DrWilgy - Town
Glorfindel - MAFIA

SO say we all!!! I'm off to the ballpark to catch a game and won't be back before game-dawn, so I just wanted to make an if-I-die-before-I-wake post. My intention is to look to players particularly hostile and aggressive towards anti-Cavil cylons, Epi, LoRab and Wilgy. It looks to me like the Cavil ...

You keep saying anti-Cavil -- do you literally mean "not aligned with Cavil" or "on Cavil's team"? You called Glorfindel anti-Cavil too. I'm trying to come up with replacement terms for civ and mafia, which I think are murky in this game. We have two sets of cylons, though; the ...

https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=iMUezhpuEoE What are you seeing? We already have two potential Cylons playing the good game card. Begin your sentence with "I think" and then lay it out for us. I see sig and Glorfy town reading the eff out of each other when looking through their ISO's. Wi...

Glorf won 6 to 5. Silverwolf was replaced.

So what are you waiting for in this whole claim drama, Rico? In the drama that was? For the plan to be fulfilled and everyone (relevant i.e. besides Epignosis, I guess) to have claimed. In the drama that is? Nothing, seems irrelevant now. :shrug: What the frak, man? Just claim tomorrow :disappoint:...

So what are you waiting for in this whole claim drama, Rico? In the drama that was? For the plan to be fulfilled and everyone (relevant i.e. besides Epignosis, I guess) to have claimed. In the drama that is? Nothing, seems irrelevant now. :shrug: What the frak, man? Just claim tomorrow :disappoint:

I get your point; at the moment, removing Cavil from the game was contextually optimal. But imagine this: wouldn't it be better to kill the mafia (Cavil's faction), who nightkills civs and has other maleficial powers, and then go after Cain in order to eliminate martial law in order to restore winc...

If Glorfindel knew he would have been immune for non-claim reasons, he would not have wasted his Cylon claim.

It is quite hilarious how Glorfindel spent the entire game avoiding the claim and did not hesitate to do it today at the most critical moment. Why didn't you stick to your moral compass, Glorf? Is it because it is pointing towards "evil"? You asked me the same question and I gave you the s...

Search found 572 matches