From what I understand, the idea is, should a PR get killed before having a chance to claim and clearly state results, they can simply sneak them out as part of a fake claim-fest, and when they die, all the other town players need to do is look back at their posts and see what info they left. Such a tactic should only be left to info roles like Cop or Tracker/Watcher, and only in a environment where it's the standard and people can be expected to carry it out, however. And as I said before, I'm against it here, without any experience in those tactics, it will probably just lead to a confused mess for town.Long Con wrote:What good does it do for every player to claim every role? How does it benefit the Power Roles to be able to "naturally" throw their real results in?Marco wrote:That works best when people are used to hypo claiming. We could go that route but doesn't look to me like everyone is used to hypo on their home boards. I don't mind PR cover either but it's hard to pull off with complete strangers. I'd have to have a really strong town-read on someone (or say an innocent report).Zexy wrote:So, sig: what is TS? What do you think of Sloonei’s push on you? You defended, but what does that mean in regards to his alignment?
I disagree on the fake claiming part because in MU there actually a power role cover system where everybody claims all the roles so that the real ones get to “naturally” throw their real results in without standing out too much. And others fakeclaim to draw NKs.
Search found 2 matches
Return to “Mafia Championship Scrimmage [END]”
- Fri Apr 15, 2016 2:03 pm
- Forum: Previous Sit Downs
- Topic: Mafia Championship Scrimmage [END]
- Replies: 3675
- Views: 72464
Re: Mafia Championship Scrimmage
- Fri Apr 15, 2016 1:51 pm
- Forum: Previous Sit Downs
- Topic: Mafia Championship Scrimmage [END]
- Replies: 3675
- Views: 72464
Re: Mafia Championship Scrimmage
Hello~
On that note, I'm not, you won't hear from me unless I feel I have something worth saying.
Ok, and what's your point?
...And I feel this "new posts" feature is lovely, helps keep me up to date, again and again and-
Second addendum: OH GOD I CAN'T POST STOP HELP
Thanks for the welcome! Cookie jar? What cookies, vanilla? Because I have a vanilla here, not a cookie, however. :PMetalmarsh89 wrote:
Psittacitform caught my eye. VOTE PSITTACITFORM. I see you there with your hand in the cookie jar. What have you to say for yourself!
I'll just note on this that Zexy is also prone to analyze anything he can and try to set himself up as a town leader, which can (at least partly) explain why he's going to Sig's defense here over that.Zexy wrote:I don't think you are the kind of person who would base a read only on that anyway when so much more is going to happen.Sloonei wrote:What I didn't like about your posts is that they seemed like an easy opportunistic set of early observations when there wasn't a whole lot of content to analyze. It's a good and easy way to establish yourself early on as a town leader.
I'd like to believe same goes for sig.
On that note, I'm not, you won't hear from me unless I feel I have something worth saying.
Cognitive dissonance? And no, I don't think I would, and I wouldn't recommend anyone else be that eager to, either. Unless you have a clear goal and plan to get something out of your fake claim/counter-claim, it only stands to spread confusion, and potentially cause a mislynch or two.Frog wrote: I've JUST finished a C12 match on MU where many vanillagers were fake claiming TPRs, and fake counter claiming TPRs all over the place. Some of them worked, some of them didn't. Those that didn't work were because of a cognitive dissonance between players. With this in mind, if you are town reading a player, and they fake claim a power role, would you counter claim them?
Furthermore, with respect to claims, I'm planning on following this format every day:
If I'm X role, I did this N1, N2, N3, etc.
If I'm Y role, I did this N1, N2, N3, etc.
If I'm Z role, I did this N1, N2, N3, etc.
Ok, and what's your point?
...And I feel this "new posts" feature is lovely, helps keep me up to date, again and again and-
Second addendum: OH GOD I CAN'T POST STOP HELP