It depends.Dragon D. Luffy wrote: ↑Sat Feb 09, 2019 8:19 pm Oh thanks!
One of the reasons I made this is that there was a certain "stigma" against role madness in my other site. Like, "real" games are vanilla roles and role madness is the silly stuff that is not real mafia.
Hogwarts was role madness, and it was real mafia.
A World Asunder was role madness, and mostly balanced IMO, but it ended up not being 'real mafia' in the same way an INH game might not be real mafia. Only at the end, though, where teams were exposed and hunting went out the window for a bit.
I love role madness games, personally, because I like not being vanilla.