The Syndicate

tedxtr wrote: ↑Thu Sep 17, 2020 5:01 pm out every role cop thing, you said you had results on d1 and d2 that you wanted to out d3 or d4. It's d7.

Again you didn't and don't read my posts. Okay ugh lemme write it all again and I can tell you my conditions but it is on you when I can't use the role cop card ability no more.

tedxtr wrote: ↑Thu Sep 17, 2020 5:00 pm you have been hoarding info since d1, it's d7, what do you have

The only info I didn't talk about was my two conditions. I said everything other than those QUITE in details. Have you at all isoed me before making the wild assumption?

tedxtr wrote: ↑Thu Sep 17, 2020 4:59 pm poison talk about your entire info

Yo wtf at least read what I posted i wrote that with sleepy eyes and you don't even read it. RUDE. RUDE.

tedxtr wrote: ↑Thu Sep 17, 2020 8:14 am if we hit scum!dizzy here please yeet poison after, assuming game doesn't end

I have literally hard scum read him since day 1. Wdym?

tedxtr wrote: ↑Thu Sep 17, 2020 8:35 am It's hard to describe it, it's a way of messing up your entire built thought process in order to refute a single argument because you have TMI

She basically argued against her ability being town sided in order for me to drop my line that pushed a 3p angle on her. Does that make sense?

As a town, how could you possibly put yourself in a 3p's shoes like that? How could you, as a town, argue that your ability is not town sided?

tedxtr wrote: ↑Thu Sep 17, 2020 8:38 am actually - don't reply to that

@Poison Chan what did you mean with that question? "Does it work like that?" like what were you referring to?

tedxtr wrote: ↑Thu Sep 17, 2020 6:29 am I'm like...the most confident on Poison being 3p here.

Don't think she walks into toDay with a list of town reads and going "These are probably town because of some mechanic that I don't know, but I've seen it working a past time so it's gotta be right this time"

???

feel like she'd care about the game more as town here but I am not that convinced about that because of other stuff.

tedxtr wrote: ↑Thu Sep 17, 2020 6:30 am It's about pretending to care about the game but actually not caring at all.

something like that

tedxtr wrote: ↑Thu Sep 17, 2020 8:17 am
MacDougall wrote: ↑Thu Sep 17, 2020 8:15 am
tedxtr wrote: ↑Thu Sep 17, 2020 8:14 am if we hit scum!dizzy here please yeet poison after, assuming game doesn't end
You reckon poison has higher 3p chance than spf?
Yeah

what kinda town walks into D7, neglects all of their reads and goes

"Yeah magpie prolly town and everyone who said it was probably town"

poison should be more paranoid than that and have more complex reads, she doesn't care for the game

I guess it's not as solid because it's dependent on whether she actually cares about this game as a town but anecdotally speaking ; she should be more engaging here, whereas she's starting to become more and more detached, thinking it's because she's close to reaching her wincon

[mention]tedxtr[/mention] you realise exactly how weak your line of argument is here?

- first, talking about my activity/engagement - I'm generally More engaging as town. But did you see my recent games? Okay I'll link you up to my last 4 games. 4. 1 on WG, 1 on TB, 1 on our homesite [literally Nika called me the worst player she has ever seen cause I stopped caring about the game and barely posted the minimum required posts] , and the one I just played with you on MU. It's not something AI for me, the engagement and activity to guess my alignment. I'm just exhausted, I was planning to take a break for a while but couldn't. I have been playing multiple games at a time for some time now. Just exhausted.

It's day 7 for God's sake Ted!! With the thread open at night. Can you even think how much that is for me? Ughh.

- "Does it work that way"? "she won't put herself in the shoes of 3P as town"

First, I meant "Does it work that way" as in would a 3P do it like that at all? Okay, you don't have to trust me, do you have any idea what 3P experience I have? Have you seen me play a 3P before? You can boldly predict when I'm a scum or not and you can mess up this this bad?

Look ted, first, both as town or scum, 3p 4p or any other thing, I would always put my self in my opponent alignment's shoes cause that's how you can have an idea. Although the question was totally misunderstood by you cause I meant would 3P be doing that at all?

Morning Mr. Magpie, first, that's not my role, I have no mech regarding it either,that's simply a theory I came up with from previous experience. That's wrong? When I said specifically that I'm not 100% sure on it either but I still gave my views on it cause I would like to believe in it from what I have experienced before. This is not the first time I am presenting you theories which you won't buy but I strongly feel that way, if you really wanna see it with your own eyes just dig the Poison-SK arguments in each games you'll know.

Long Con wrote: ↑Thu Sep 17, 2020 12:41 am
Poison Chan wrote: ↑Thu Sep 17, 2020 12:15 am I would like to lock town the following who said Good Morning Mr. Magpie and I would not like them to get lynched.

Logic.
Odd.
Juliet.
Mac.

I think they are confirmed towns?!.
I don't have the same confidence that Magpie clears players. To me, that's 100% wild speculation... maybe those that hav said it have some insight, maybe YOU are Mr Magpie and have incredible insight that you can't share because host reasons. I don't know. I am not betting the game on Magpie at this point, and if you bwant to convince me that I'm missing something, then I'm all ears.

Why is Mac confirmed town?

Look, I'm not 100% sure on this either, but it resembled one of my earlier games.

I'm not Morning Mr. Magpie this was just a theory from my part.

Mac has been bugging me for not dying to be frank. I don't see why scum would leave them and kill others when they have so towny all game that the scum can never lynch him.

But, Mac has some mechs in his favor, like N1 where scum actions were on him. And he has been FAIRLY towny the whole game.

Also, because he said morning Mr. Magpie and as I think that's just a town thingy so I put him up there.

NANOOKTHEGREATANDFEARSOME wrote: ↑Thu Sep 17, 2020 12:25 am 3/5 people in your POE poison have been green checked.

One of them by you!

They are not in my PoE but those who are not confirmed town to me by the magpie thing. Although I'm not fully sure if I should be judging the situation with it at all.

I would like to lock town the following who said Good Morning Mr. Magpie and I would not like them to get lynched.

Logic.
Odd.
Juliet.
Mac.

I think they are confirmed towns?!.

That leaves 5 more people.

Spf
Ted
Nanook
LC
Dizzy

Among this, I do not like dizzy from the very beginning and I would probably be costing them If we are not sure whom to vote exactly.

Spf's play has been NAIs lately, I liked their play in the beginning am not a fan lately. Tbh, with all these mech, we stopped looking at the normal way of scum hunting I feel, but both are equally important though.

MacDougall wrote: ↑Wed Sep 16, 2020 11:04 pm Nobody really has any tracks left aside from Logic. So there's gonna be no more info here unless @Poison Chan has something to say. So town gonna have to root this last one out the old fashioned way.

I have only 1-shots left. I didn't use any last night.

[mention]tedxtr[/mention] have you seen my 3P plays?

tedxtr wrote: ↑Wed Sep 16, 2020 2:59 pm like what position do you have to be arguing from in order to make a comment like that

"Do my abilities really help the village? Hmmm"

No I'm not saying that I'm saying would a 3P be so careless as to reveal it like that just because they help the villagers?

tedxtr wrote: ↑Wed Sep 16, 2020 1:59 pm
Poison Chan wrote: ↑Wed Sep 16, 2020 1:27 pm I skimmed through a bit. @tedxtr why do you think I'm a 3P? Do you think if I was one and I have the wincon of matching songs, would I be ballsy enough to claim my role likr that instead of making something up?
You don't need to have balls to claim your role if you help the village with it.

Does it really work that way though?

tedxtr wrote: ↑Wed Sep 16, 2020 4:40 am Locked town (can't be 3p)

tedxtr

Locked not mafia

Alison
Mac

Nutella spew question mark ?

spf
juliets
dyachei

Soul read not wolf

Poison Chan

Alleged checks / heard there were shenanigans here that I didn't get into just yet

Nanook
LC

People we don't know anything about

Oddmerta
Dizzy

Tbh, I think odd, Dya, juliets are just confirmed town. Just a theory, whoever says "Good morning Mr. Magpie" they are either all town, or the person having this ability get a confirmation of their alignments or something. Had played a game with this mech few months ago.

I skimmed through a bit. [mention]tedxtr[/mention] why do you think I'm a 3P? Do you think if I was one and I have the wincon of matching songs, would I be ballsy enough to claim my role likr that instead of making something up?

tedxtr wrote: ↑Wed Sep 16, 2020 4:19 am
Poison Chan wrote: ↑Mon Aug 31, 2020 11:04 pm
Samusamu wrote: ↑Mon Aug 31, 2020 10:59 pm
ColinIsCool wrote: ↑Mon Aug 31, 2020 8:21 pm
Poison Chan wrote: ↑Mon Aug 31, 2020 2:05 pm I hope to see something from colin when I'm back. Too early to form a read but idk intuition says they might be scum?
How in the world could you possibly have “intuition” telling you anything about me with nearly zero posts
Poison scumming
Imagine calling poison a scum after playing with her in g9 and seeing the extremes of scumminess one can do. Lol. Anyways I see a lot of notifications from you, I'll be attending those. Oh btw!!!! Hello.. Also did you change your pfp to this one cause the other one never made others read you @Samusamu ? btw Herm is here as well ! And Master Radishes!! Hype!
idk man skimming her ISO and I just can't fathom scum her having the balls to do this type of thing

like in this game, if she played like this then huge props, I am like 60% confident she would've been the yeet over nutella d1 if she were to be scum here, simple as that.

I cannot take this as a compliment, bubblegum.

juliets wrote: ↑Tue Sep 15, 2020 9:44 pm I can't deal with this anymore tonight. I'll be back in the morning.

Good night

juliets wrote: ↑Tue Sep 15, 2020 9:43 pm
Poison Chan wrote: ↑Tue Sep 15, 2020 9:40 pm What is LC's ability?
He claims to have a mutual vote cancel - he targets someone and they can't vote for him and he can't vote for them. Thats why he couldn't vote tutuu - he targeted her last night. Who knows what other powers he's got though.

I see

What is LC's ability?

I don't understand, LC you are voting yourself and not tutuu when you think her lynch is okay. Why?

Long Con wrote: ↑Tue Sep 15, 2020 9:26 pm Ho ho ho... now I could vote for tutuu by unvoting No one.

Sounds bad. Do you think tutuu is the 3P?

juliets wrote: ↑Tue Sep 15, 2020 9:22 pmWe're tied.

Would the host use RNG?

I don't really think tutuu is the 3P, I have voted no one.

juliets wrote: ↑Tue Sep 15, 2020 9:03 pm @Logic , @Dyslexicon , @Poison Chan please vote! EOD is in half an hour!

I thought we still had another 24 hours?

Just an observation,

Master Radishes
Dyachi / logic
Herm
Odd
juliets

Posted "Good morning Mr. Magpie" at Sods, I think they can all be town and the player asking them to post these is town as well. Could it be something which helps in distinguishing the scum/3P anyway? Maybe the player having this ability can distinguish?

Okay now I'm free, I will read the thread.

Ted didn't lie about his song.

[mention]juliets[/mention]

juliets wrote: ↑Mon Sep 14, 2020 1:05 pm So Poison Chan, if I understand you correctly you are lie detecting ted tonight? So you are talking about what you can do beyond tonight to hunt the 3P? If so, I guess I don't quite understand. You are given 3 songs and have to pick one to learn more about, but there is no guarantee one of the 3 songs is the 3P, have I got that right? I'm trying to figure out how you can specifically hunt the 3P if thats the way the role works. I'm probably misunderstanding something.

No, I cannot hunt for 3P specifically. But what I meant was that we can keep my shot for looking for those slot we think could be the 3p and ask them to claim later on the game. Cause I feel like we can get a 3P only by knowing their song, cause normal check comes civilian to them you know what I mean?

1. Let there be a world where we got rid off the scums, and it is just us and the 3p. We ask only a selected few players who are not mech cleared or things like that, we can make them claim their role. But only a few.

2. Let there be a world where we get the last scum and they spills out something about the 3P and we can check that with my ability to confirm whether or not that's true at all or not.

But these are just ugh assumptions that things gonna go this smoothly. Idk tbh. But uh basically I felt and still feel that, the only way checking the 3p would be getting the 3P Song and then asking a few suspects their role and check.

I'll go have dinner.

Alison wrote: ↑Mon Sep 14, 2020 1:26 am I guess we'll find out after the game. anyways I want to hear your thoughts on the way dizzy suddenly went "this is bullshit. alison is scum" the moment it became clear that he was gonna thunderdome ted who was going to get checked.

I find this a bit odd too.

MacDougall wrote: ↑Mon Sep 14, 2020 1:05 am
Alison wrote: ↑Mon Sep 14, 2020 1:04 am
MacDougall wrote: ↑Mon Sep 14, 2020 1:02 am
Alison wrote: ↑Mon Sep 14, 2020 1:01 am
MacDougall wrote: ↑Mon Sep 14, 2020 12:58 am
Alison wrote: ↑Mon Sep 14, 2020 12:56 am ted has claimed optimistic from Kid A and herm has verified there are 0 scum in Kid A. we know poison is town because she exposed the mafia role cop very early on. If poison confirms that ted is telling the truth, then ted has to be town.
And you're gonna check Poison Chan just to be sure right? Lol.
actually not too sure who to cop. could be dyachei since we have no info on that slot. could be SPF just to calm the tinfoil down but I really don't think she'll cop as anything but green so if I'm going for a gut shot I'll go for dyachei.

I think poison is pretty likely to be just town since she exposed samu for no reason early on. also I don't really buy that 2/3 song cop claims are scum, and she has been pretty transparent about her role unlike samu who claimed he had roleclaim restrictions
PC has pretty high 3p equity imo.
PC has been townie on play, has cooperated fully with the town, and has no reason to randomly out the mafia rolecop D2 and then also randomly hard confirm radishes for no reason. what 3P townsides that hard in that situation?
Most 3ps townside hard in that situation, or any. To scumside as 3p here would be to get flipped by the town lol.

Okay, so basically, I, as a 3P would be so skilful and awesome that I won't even slip for once, okay you do not have to trust my meta cause people can really level up their games. But, if I was really 3P and survive till Day 5 without slipping or being the top wagon I would be patting myself cause looking at my other games where I just sit there being a potato this would be like a fantasy story.

Anyways, Lemme clear this once cause it seems like you really are set on me as 3P, I would not like to attend to this topic unless it becomes really essential cause it would be just getting diverted from the actual scum/3p hunt.

1. Even if I would agree that given the situation, the 3P would likely to be town sided, but don't you think they would like to be scum sided at the beginning at least? When they don't know where the game is going would they like to town side ?

If I was 3P, would I be outing scum role as early as D2 without having a proper grasp of the game flow or which alignment would be helpful for me or not to side with?

2. The 3p as you said, and which makes a lot sense to me as their role and I would agree that it's likely that wincom for them maybe? Cause haven't really seen anything which damaged town from the 3P iirc.

So if you go by the wincon like that, and think I have that wincon, would I be claiming my role in such details, when it clearly not towny enough as per this game, couldn't I claim something more meaningfully town instead?

3. Okay, let's say for your world, I'm 3P. How do you plan to catch me/confirm me? There must be some sort of ability to get the 3P right? Does any role apart from mine seems helpful in that field?

I think I elaborated enough.

Dyslexicon wrote: ↑Mon Sep 14, 2020 1:01 am Can't Poison check Oddmerta? He softed King of Limbs, so if he's a song from there, and that album has no scum according to Herm.

So we can check Oddmerta.
I can check Ted by tracking him.
Alison can check me if she wants.
Logic can check a fourth.

He has to claim his song name or I can't.

Dyslexicon wrote: ↑Mon Sep 14, 2020 12:56 am
MacDougall wrote: ↑Mon Sep 14, 2020 12:46 am The funny business from n1 with Tim roleblocking bs is you two. If Ted isn't mafia then you have to be imo. I don't see how you can both be town.
*intense fart noises*

I don't know how Tim got blocked or whatever, but I didn't claim that for fun, it's just what happened.

How does intense fart noise sounds like [mention]Dyslexicon[/mention]

Dyslexicon wrote: ↑Mon Sep 14, 2020 12:44 am
MacDougall wrote: ↑Mon Sep 14, 2020 12:43 am
Alison wrote: ↑Mon Sep 14, 2020 12:42 am i would turbo ted right now if there weren't a pending mech clear on him, given the way he tried to push us off the samu exe lol.
Yes I'd say

1. Tedxtr
2. Oddmerta
3. Dyslexicon

Is the likely POE for the last mafia.

The 3p ... well I'm afraid it's me so I'll be winning as 3p here.
Putting me on this list is a disgrace. What have I ever done to you? =(

You are just scummy dizzy, scummy.

tutuu wrote: ↑Mon Sep 14, 2020 12:33 am Im still offering that bet guys

That oddmerta is the final mafia and not wilgy

If that's true then wew my D1 gut reads gonna be GOAT.

MacDougall wrote: ↑Mon Sep 14, 2020 5:38 am 3p win con, each night submit a list that matches songs to names of living players. You win when you get em all correct? That'd be pretty cool. Maybe PC already hit the wincon too hence Sloonei speeding up the game?

Lmao you have just taken me as a confirmed 3p here it seems.

If that was my role or even my wincon would I be telling you my actual abilities? That doesn't make sense at all!?

MacDougall wrote: ↑Mon Sep 14, 2020 5:40 am I mean I'm not gonna yeet PC anyway.

I don't understand if I'm the 3P like you think, then why wouldn't you yeet me?

MacDougall wrote: ↑Mon Sep 14, 2020 5:33 am If you are a town that is allowed to claim and you are Codex say so for insta clear if you are not already cleared

That was Radishes.!!?? I cleared him D3.

Bruh?

Spoiler: show

MacDougall wrote: ↑Mon Sep 14, 2020 5:32 am
juliets wrote: ↑Sun Sep 13, 2020 6:32 pm REVISED LIST FROM POST and #7670 and #8831

This was Alison's list that I updated for N3 and now N4. I think this is everyone. @Poison Chan, did you holster N4? Please let me know if you see any errors. Red is for dead.
-------------------------------------------------------------------------------
Alison - Cop (N1 TSP green, N2 nanook green, N3 LC green, N4 Wilgy delayed) Green does not mean they aren't 3P

TSP - X Shot Doctor, 1-Shot Vig (N2 shot JPIC, N3 holster)

Wilgy - Conditional Tracker/Random "Watcher" (N1 one person visited ted, N2 JPIC visited tutuu, N3 - TSP visited by info role, N4 SPF wasn't targeted)

dyachei - Tracker (N1 nanook visited Mac, N2 ted visited nanook, N3 Herm visited MR, N4 holstered)

Dizzy - X Shot Conditional Tracker (N1 ted visited Tim, N2 didn't meet the conditions, N3 Samu visited tutuu, N4 holstered (voted Oddmerta))

juliets - X Shot Non-Civillian, Non-Lethal Rolestopper (N1 Alison, N2 holster, N3 MR, N4 Alison)

Herm - "Song Cop" (N1 Amnesiac no result, N2 Kid A no result, N3 King of Limbs) [Knows mafia role cop is In Rainbows because of Poison]

Long Con - 3 Shot Mutual Voteblocker, N3 targeted Radishes, N4 holstered

MacDougal - ??? (Roleclaiming not allowed, but role "isn't strong")

Master Radishes - Universal Backup (N1 protected Alison with nutella's power, N2 checked nanook for vote manipulation with sprityo's power, N3 died)

nanook - Conditional Doublevoter (N1 visited Mac to fulfil his condition, N2 forgot to send in an action, N3 targeted Alison, N4 targeted Alison)

Oddmerta - ??? (Roleclaiming not allowed, but isn't a vigilante)

Poison Chan - Rolecard Investigative (not sure of the specifics, but gets given a role card with alignment and song that exists in the game every night, but isn't told who the role card belongs to)(N1 checked Nude =mafia role cop, N2 checked Codex=full role card, N3 lie detected Dr. Wilgys song claim = true, N4 holstered?)

Samusamu - Song Voyeur, can only infodump if you hit no result (N1 no result on Poison Chan, N2 has a result and isn't allowed to infodump it, N3 visits tutuu and sees 2 songs, 1 of which is a mafia song, N4 visits Alison sees 2 songs (3 visited Alison))

SPF - ??? [@staypositivefriend did you make a claim? You're locktown so you don't have to if you don't want to, but if you did let me know and I'll record it.]

tedxtr - Vote Manipulation Nullifier (N1 Tim, N2 nanook, corroborated by trackers, Dizzy N1 and dyachei N2, N3 Nanook, N4 Wilgy)

Timsup2nothin - Anti-Snowball Scaling PR (N1 roleblocked tedxtr, N2 gets a doublevote, Day 2 dead town)

tutuu - Jailkeeper/Rolestopper (N1 Alison, N2 Hally, N3 attempted Alison power did not go through, N4 Alison)
Hold up. Samu claimed he could only infodump if he got no result and then he claimed results on n3 and n4? Lol I totally missed that. That's hilarious.

If anyone is town and wants to claim Codex for a free clear go ahead.

Alison is town or suicide mafia because she was clearly targeted n1 and has hard townsided all game.

Wilgy/LC/Nanook are not mafia because cop check. Alison can't be faking on teammates because she would have none. So if she's mafia, they're still town. Ergo Wilgy, LC and Nanook are absolutely confirmed not mafia unless Godfather is in this game.

Dyachei accurately tracked Nook to me n1 (Hally confirmed this occurred) she can't know this unless she is actually a tracker. She heavily softed this result before Hally all but outed it. She is also confirmed through Ted not arguing that he targeted Nook as well as Herm confirmed as having visited MR. The amount of information she would need to have confirms she is absolutely a tracker. Mafia tracker (with other powers) is not off the table though. I'd put her a tier less likely than Ted/Dizzy on the lying scale though.

Dyslexicon targets Ted n1 and sees him visit Tim. Tim claims to have roleblocked Ted and has since flipped town. Holstered on a potential Tim shot n2 which may have actually ended up clearing Tim since we yeeted him later in the game. Bad Dizzy. Tracked Samu to Tutuu which kind of outed Samu as mafia I think (explain how @Dyslexicon this game is too complicated for me to remember everything). Holstered instead of tracking Oddmerta. Has also claimed to have another power but hasn't disclosed it and won't until they're dead. Question marks here but also has the Samu thing going for him.

Juliets - Claims would be weird if she was mafia. If they were outright lies then she'd run the risk of being caught by a tracker or Wilgy's random watch thing so they're probably real targets. If they are real targets then what the hell could she be targeting Alison with twice that Alison wouldn't know about? Her targets are all fine. Holstering on n2 was fine.

Long Con - Wanna talk about him for a second. Mutual roleblocker. Aside from the fact that I kinda town read him for the way he slanked he has the cop check going for him obviously. I would say that if there was a Godfather that he'd profile. He also heavily profiles as the 3p to me for reads reasons. Let's say he's in my 3p POE lol.

Oddmerta - Softed to Herm that he received one of Herm's notifications. I still don't think anyone else has claimed to have. Was pretty offensive towards old mate JPIC too. Probably just town but we kinda need some sort of mech confirmation.

Poison Chan - 100% not mafia. What kind of mafia fake claim decides to out one of the confirmed mafia roles n1? Nope. Has 3p equity though.

SPF - Has just hard townsided but has no real mech claims. I don't think anyone has tracked her or checked her at all. Need to clear her if the game doesn't end in a couple of phases.

Tedxtr - Is complicit in the n1 weirdburger shit. Has evidence that he didn't like about who he targeted n2. His claim is weak though. It's entirely possible his role is just a mafia one and he still decided to target everyone he's claimed to have. He also doesn't have double targeting limits and he targeted Wilgy n4 because apparently Wilgy is a good target for a vote manip nullifier for some reason. Clearly in the major 2 person POE.

Tutuu - Is cleared in a range of ways. Is town if Juliets is town. Is town for saving Alison n1 with no counter claim. Targeted Hally n2. Is also cleared via Dizzy seeing a mafia target her and also by Wilgy seeing a mafia target her. Just cleared not mafia. Probably not 3p either though could be hard townsiding 3p I suppose.

From where I sit it's like;

Tutuu/DrWilgy/Nook/LC are God mode cleared
Juliets/PC is only mafia in a purely ridiculous world
Alison is in this tier because she is a crazy busser nutcase player and might have just got herself cornered but like no
Oddmerta and SPF can be mafia but both helped town obliterate their team if so and Oddmerta has some claims in his favour
Dyachei's claims are better than Ted's and Dyslexicon
Dyslexicon's claim is fractionally better than Ted's when I look at them without either of them getting mad at me for daring to scumread them in a POE game where everyone else is near cleared

Obviously the existence of a Godfather would suck. So perhaps we need to keep PC alive so PC can go ahead and figure out whether there actually is one the same way she found the rolecop. We should have the albums narrowed down and if she has a list of all the songs which it appears as though she does then she should be able to narrow the last mafia role down to a very small list of songs here. So given that I'm rather tempted to have her do that instead of lie detect Tedxtr given Dyslexicon is already tracking him anyway. @Poison Chan does this actually stack up with how your role functions? Like from my perspective the last mafia kinda has to be on The Bends or Pablo Honey off top of my head but I'd like some other people's input here.

Sans a godfather being incorrectly cleared by Alison and us somehow never finding them mafia aren't winning this game.

Okay I'll be reading everything but before that lemme talk about these.

[mention]MacDougall[/mention] ,

Lemme clear my role first.

1. I have two abilities. Can use both in the same night but didn't do it cause X shots, so I think I should be using it carefully.

2. My role card checks need to satisfy 2 conditions. If I satisfy the first one then I get the name of 3 songs and I can select only one to get the gist of the role like my N1 = Nude.

If I satisfy the 2nd condition I get the full role. My N2 = Codex.

I used lie detector on Wilgy N3.

Didn't use any ability N4.

Now,

Something I thought about my role and how it should be helpful to the game at all :

-Alison if is truly a cop [since no one ever really showed any concern in the slightest to counterclaim that] can detect scum but not 3P.

-Herm (could he detect 3p?)

Other than these two people I don't think we really have anything which helps in 3p hunt much unless the right tracker/watcher is used when 3p does something. Now, the 3P hasn't been doing much which comes out as a night result I think or rather I can assume they are from scum/mostly from scum. If 3P does not have KP or any damaging role [which would be a bit weird cause it said VS Rogue] then I think tracker/watcher won't be of much help either.

My role can be helpful here. To hunt 3P I think. Cause I cannot go for both mafia and 3P given that I have only X shots. Secondly, it depends a lot on my luck or on my guess.

So what do you guys think I should do? [I'm checking ted's song though] [mention]MacDougall[/mention] [mention]Alison[/mention] [mention]juliets[/mention]

Alison wrote: ↑Mon Sep 14, 2020 12:55 am @Poison Chan please check if tedxtr is the song Optimistic from the album Kid A tonight, thanks.

Okay. I'll be catching up now. I'll look into ted tonight.

I see thanks.

tedxtr wrote: ↑Sun Sep 13, 2020 9:42 am Like I’m either getting red peeked tomorrow or green peeked by Poison, talking about me is useless.

Talk about other slots.

But my role only confirms whether you have lied about your song or not.

juliets wrote: ↑Sun Sep 13, 2020 6:32 pm REVISED LIST FROM POST and #7670 and #8831

This was Alison's list that I updated for N3 and now N4. I think this is everyone. @Poison Chan, did you holster N4? Please let me know if you see any errors. Red is for dead.
-------------------------------------------------------------------------------
Alison - Cop (N1 TSP green, N2 nanook green, N3 LC green, N4 Wilgy delayed) Green does not mean they aren't 3P

TSP - X Shot Doctor, 1-Shot Vig (N2 shot JPIC, N3 holster)

Wilgy - Conditional Tracker/Random "Watcher" (N1 one person visited ted, N2 JPIC visited tutuu, N3 - TSP visited by info role, N4 SPF wasn't targeted)

dyachei - Tracker (N1 nanook visited Mac, N2 ted visited nanook, N3 Herm visited MR, N4 holstered)

Dizzy - X Shot Conditional Tracker (N1 ted visited Tim, N2 didn't meet the conditions, N3 Samu visited tutuu, N4 holstered (voted Oddmerta))

juliets - X Shot Non-Civillian, Non-Lethal Rolestopper (N1 Alison, N2 holster, N3 MR, N4 Alison)

Herm - "Song Cop" (N1 Amnesiac no result, N2 Kid A no result, N3 King of Limbs) [Knows mafia role cop is In Rainbows because of Poison]

Long Con - 3 Shot Mutual Voteblocker, N3 targeted Radishes, N4 holstered

MacDougal - ??? (Roleclaiming not allowed, but role "isn't strong")

Master Radishes - Universal Backup (N1 protected Alison with nutella's power, N2 checked nanook for vote manipulation with sprityo's power, N3 died)

nanook - Conditional Doublevoter (N1 visited Mac to fulfil his condition, N2 forgot to send in an action, N3 targeted Alison, N4 targeted Alison)

Oddmerta - ??? (Roleclaiming not allowed, but isn't a vigilante)

Poison Chan - Rolecard Investigative (not sure of the specifics, but gets given a role card with alignment and song that exists in the game every night, but isn't told who the role card belongs to)(N1 checked Nude =mafia role cop, N2 checked Codex=full role card, N3 lie detected Dr. Wilgys song claim = true, N4 holstered?)

Samusamu - Song Voyeur, can only infodump if you hit no result (N1 no result on Poison Chan, N2 has a result and isn't allowed to infodump it, N3 visits tutuu and sees 2 songs, 1 of which is a mafia song, N4 visits Alison sees 2 songs (3 visited Alison))

SPF - ??? [@staypositivefriend did you make a claim? You're locktown so you don't have to if you don't want to, but if you did let me know and I'll record it.]

tedxtr - Vote Manipulation Nullifier (N1 Tim, N2 nanook, corroborated by trackers, Dizzy N1 and dyachei N2, N3 Nanook, N4 Wilgy)

Timsup2nothin - Anti-Snowball Scaling PR (N1 roleblocked tedxtr, N2 gets a doublevote, Day 2 dead town)

tutuu - Jailkeeper/Rolestopper (N1 Alison, N2 Hally, N3 attempted Alison power did not go through, N4 Alison)

What does holstering mean? I didn't use any last night.

Sorry guys I returned home after midnight and couldn't play after that.

juliets wrote: ↑Sun Sep 13, 2020 9:59 am REVISED LIST FROM POST and #7670 and #7743

This was Alison's list that I updated for N3 and now N4. I am missing some people - @Long Con, @Poison Chan, and @tedxtr I couldn't find yours could you please tell me your N4 action? Please let me know if you see any errors. Red is for dead.
-------------------------------------------------------------------------------
Alison - Cop (N1 TSP green, N2 nanook green, N3 LC green, N4 Wilgy delayed) Green does not mean they aren't 3P

TSP - X Shot Doctor, 1-Shot Vig (N2 shot JPIC, N3 holster)

Wilgy - Conditional Tracker/Random "Watcher" (N1 one person visited ted, N2 JPIC visited tutuu, N3 - TSP visited by info role, N4 SPF wasn't targeted)

dyachei - Tracker (N1 nanook visited Mac, N2 ted visited nanook, N3 Herm visited MR, N4 holstered)

Dizzy - X Shot Conditional Tracker (N1 ted visited Tim, N2 didn't meet the conditions, N3 Samu visited tutuu, N4 holstered (voted Oddmerta))

juliets - X Shot Non-Civillian, Non-Lethal Rolestopper (N1 Alison, N2 holster, N3 MR, N4 Alison)

Herm - "Song Cop" (N1 Amnesiac no result, N2 Kid A no result, N3 King of Limbs) [Knows mafia role cop is In Rainbows because of Poison]

Long Con - 3 Shot Mutual Voteblocker, N3 targeted Radishes, N4

MacDougal - ??? (Roleclaiming not allowed, but role "isn't strong")

Master Radishes - Universal Backup (N1 protected Alison with nutella's power, N2 checked nanook for vote manipulation with sprityo's power, N3 died)

nanook - Conditional Doublevoter (N1 visited Mac to fulfil his condition, N2 forgot to send in an action, N3 targeted Alison, N4 targeted Alison)

Oddmerta - ??? (Roleclaiming not allowed, but isn't a vigilante)

Poison Chan - Rolecard Investigative (not sure of the specifics, but gets given a role card with alignment and song that exists in the game every night, but isn't told who the role card belongs to)(N1 checked Nude =mafia role cop, N2 checked Codex=full role card, N3 lie detected Dr. Wilgys song claim = true, N4 )

Samusamu - Song Voyeur, can only infodump if you hit no result (N1 no result on Poison Chan, N2 has a result and isn't allowed to infodump it, N3 visits tutuu and sees 2 songs, 1 of which is a mafia song, N4 visits Alison sees 2 songs (3 visited Alison))

SPF - ??? [@staypositivefriend did you make a claim? You're locktown so you don't have to if you don't want to, but if you did let me know and I'll record it.]

tedxtr - Vote Manipulation Nullifier (N1 Tim, N2 nanook, corroborated by trackers, Dizzy N1 and dyachei N2, N3 Nanook, N4 )

Timsup2nothin - Anti-Snowball Scaling PR (N1 roleblocked tedxtr, N2 gets a doublevote, Day 2 dead town)

tutuu - Jailkeeper/Rolestopper (N1 Alison, N2 Hally, N3 attempted Alison power did not go through, N4 Alison)

I have no N4 results. I didn't use any.

NANOOKTHEGREATANDFEARSOME wrote: ↑Sat Sep 12, 2020 4:08 am Look idk what ted is but I also don’t know how he’s a better kill than wilgy so

“Kill all liars” is the stupidest shit ever too tbh

LYNCH ALL LIARS!!

tedxtr wrote: ↑Sat Sep 12, 2020 9:31 am @Poison Chan how does your role work? Do people actually have to claim songs / albums in thread?

Can't you just random scan for albums? Like choose me and check for King of The Limbs even if I didn't claim I was that?

The player needs to claim. I don't have the albums and I get to role card cop from selected songs given every night if I satisfy conditions.

tutuu wrote: ↑Sat Sep 12, 2020 5:13 am @Poison Chan pls lie detect ted's claim baby

Few posts above

Sure.

Sorry guys I was a little busy today cause I have an exam tomorrow, I'll catch up to the current page and hopefully be there before EoD cause it would take me sometime to return home after the exam. Sorry for the inconvenience. I'll read now. But I'll answer to the notifications first

[mention]dyachei[/mention] [mention]Oddmerta[/mention] and someone else posted "Good Mr. Magpie" on three consecutive days. Is there a particular reason behind this?

Search found 587 matches