LinearPoint wrote: ↑Tue Dec 21, 2021 9:12 pm
NANOOKTHEGREATANDFEARSOME wrote: ↑Tue Dec 21, 2021 9:05 pm
But we don't have to reevaluate after the TK
We can build worlds as soon as the red is outed
It's not at all the same as a normal day and idk why you keep insisting it is
It also isn't waiting for the potential of a red check, we already know there is one lol
I mean if someone flips Mafia it calls for reevaluation since you didn't know they were Mafia beforehand.
You can't know for certainty that a flip or vigilante shot will result red or green unless you are Mafia.
The same goes for red checks. Prior to the check you cannot be certain they are Town or Mafia.
I do not really see a fundamental difference between a lynch resulting in a Mafia death and a Watcher saying they saw someone kill.
And Dolby is ultimately correct. Town will just tunnel on the red check until they are dead and 9/10 ignore all other stimuli and overlook potentially scummy behavior.
Its also not like he's saying that he wont give it at all. The first half can be used to regular scum hunt and determine who is trying to distance from the killer and the second half is reevaluating the first and seeing what was missed.
That seems fairly logical and a good plan in my opinion.
I mean the difference is you can spend the day building worlds after a check*, before the TK. Not, you know, in public, but privately, if you're me. Or in public if you're you. Idc.
You can do what you want but I fundamentally disagree with the approach you're describing and your comparisons are inane at best or intentionally bad at worst, and I will not be making any reads now that could bias me later when I'm building worlds.
*yes there is technically the possibility that marmot could be faking a red as town (unlikely for him I think, with how he's gone about it) or as mafia (lol), but it's low in this case
