The Syndicate

Also people weren't really accusing you of lurking? This is a weird response All I can really do for my last post is point out that this is a Mafia. I just said I don't have time to read through everything or even know what I'm being pushed on. And here you are trying to twist facts and say I have ...

I think the only thing I can really say since I just don't have time to read through the whole thread is to not execute me and hope a replacement can be found. There's really not much else to say. Bad timing with things is all, sorry that this game was pretty much a throw from me. But I believe you...

To be honest as far as I know the only argument is that I've not been posting. Which is fair since I'm normally a high poster. But like I said I got like 3 minutes, so I don't have time to really read up on anything this game. Gut saying Jack and Seanzie are probably not town though because they'd k...

I think the only thing I can really say since I just don't have time to read through the whole thread is to not execute me and hope a replacement can be found. There's really not much else to say. Bad timing with things is all, sorry that this game was pretty much a throw from me. But I believe you...

I think the only thing I can really say since I just don't have time to read through the whole thread is to not execute me and hope a replacement can be found. There's really not much else to say. Bad timing with things is all, sorry that this game was pretty much a throw from me. But I believe you ...

It's been a while since I forgot about this starting...But glad to see everyone is sprouting. Sad no one made a green bean or red bean joke about alignments though. Heck no one even made a vanilla bean joke, sad times indeed. At first glance I'm not really liking leetic that much. As a whole their p...

I decided to make a game with flavor akin to a rustic settlement vibe.
Of course this being Mafia there are people wanting to sabotage the new settlement.

Game Notes:

Closed setup.
48/24 day/night.
Majority votes with no early hammer.
Mafia have daychat.
Up to 15 players.

Good game. Yeah it was a tough one to work out.

I hate to inform you of this Guillotine, but Mafia 1-shot Vigilante is mechanically sound in a 10P setups. A vigilante if Town it gives an additional shot at possibly killing a Mafia and for Mafia it gives them a chance to kill a confirmed Power Role. The thing is with no additional kills at night a...

Granted I don't really see a world where I survive tonight because there is just no good argument for my role being Mafia. The only thing I could be is Mafia Doublevoter and there is just no world where that competes against Town Jailkeeper and Town Vigilante. So I guess I'll speak to you in 25 hour...

I think I need to sleep though. I'm not really feeling like I am effectively communicating my thoughts. I actually have too many and I really do just need to see Guillotine flip before really being able to clearly think through who is most likely to be their partner or who of Epignosis and Seanzie w...

And that's ignoring the fact that you continued to claim Parity Cop for a while into day 2, going so far as to suggest at one point Epignosis is a Town lying about being a Power Role to try and get you killed. Who is Guillotine's partner? Who is evil if Guillotine is not mafia? Well it kind of depe...

And that's ignoring the fact that you continued to claim Parity Cop for a while into day 2, going so far as to suggest at one point Epignosis is a Town lying about being a Power Role to try and get you killed.

I had a long day so only getting caught up EoD, but I'm just willing to let this ride and go from there. I just don't trust the Parity Cop as Vanilla to bait the Night Kill plan and gives off the opposite intent. There's a million and one things you could have claimed instead and as Seanzie pointed ...

Yeet me today if you must but don't expect apologies from me post game cause I will not, I played pro-town For what it's worth I do think it's a fair play for a town to do so. I just don't really believe you here. If you were trying to die night 1 as a Vanilla Townie, Parity Cop isn't the claim. Ma...

Whp would Guillotine's partner be if they were wolf? I was thinking it had to be Epignosis, but does anyone have meta on Epignosis to know if they tend to bus this hard day 2? He is obviously not jailkeeper, he is baiting the night kill. So you think Epignosis is Vanilla Town trying to bait a night...

I still do think Epi is just telling the truth over Guillotine though. Especially since Guillotine was so adamant that claiming day 1 meant that anyone who CCd them day 2 would be confirmed evil as though they were preparing for the counter claim beforehand. Then... why... won't... you... vote... G...

Maybe I should just stop posting the deranged conspiracy theories in my head. Clearly is just confuses the sane people of this world.

So the problem I'm having in my head is that it feels like one of Guillotine and Epignosis are lying. Setupwise both being true seems highly unlikely. What reason do I have to lie, and what is my endgame scenario if I did? I mean if you are lying here the scenario would just be as follows. You fake...

So the problem I'm having in my head is that it feels like one of Guillotine and Epignosis are lying. Setupwise both being true seems highly unlikely. What reason do I have to lie, and what is my endgame scenario if I did? I mean if you are lying here the scenario would just be as follows. You fake...

So here's a thought. There is 7 people alive, 4 of which are claiming a Power Role. We could shoot into the 3 non-Power claims to try and kill a Mafia Goon (At least I highly doubt Mafia would get 2 Power Roles and there be only 2 Town-aligned Power Role). Although this does rely on at least 3 of t...

So the problem I'm having in my head is that it feels like one of Guillotine and Epignosis are lying. Setupwise both being true seems highly unlikely. What reason do I have to lie, and what is my endgame scenario if I did? I mean if you are lying here the scenario would just be as follows. You fake...

Oh dear lord. A power role doesn't mean you're a civilian. Claiming that doesn't mean anything. I claimed because I fucked up. I know that. I'm saying that I'm trying to think about role dynamics. Honestly the more I think about it the more Parity Cop does seem like the odd one out here. Vigilante ...

So here's a thought. There is 7 people alive, 4 of which are claiming a Power Role. We could shoot into the 3 non-Power claims to try and kill a Mafia Goon (At least I highly doubt Mafia would get 2 Power Roles and there be only 2 Town-aligned Power Role). Although this does rely on at least 3 of t...

I actually can see a world where MR votes Guillotine day 1 without going full bus mode making a hard accusation. Guillotine's push onto MR "perspective slipping" when all MR did was imply they Town read me and SVS did feel odd and could actually just be more distancing. The other option IM...

Whp would Guillotine's partner be if they were wolf? I was thinking it had to be Epignosis, but does anyone have meta on Epignosis to know if they tend to bus this hard day 2?

So here's a thought. There is 7 people alive, 4 of which are claiming a Power Role. We could shoot into the 3 non-Power claims to try and kill a Mafia Goon (At least I highly doubt Mafia would get 2 Power Roles and there be only 2 Town-aligned Power Role). Although this does rely on at least 3 of th...

And if Seanzie is town, it is obvious Seanzie is the vig, who is voting me because i cannot be a pr with him according to his beliefs. @Seanzie This is why i townread you yesterday but i dont care about keeping your secret no more! So why did you kill Wilgy if you scum read me yesterday? Well, look...

I will say a 2-shot Parity Cop (even though Guillotine never claimed their limitation) isn't completely unheard of and impossible. It'd be mostly as a just in case limitation not really because the host would ever expect them to be getting 3 checks off. But a Night 1 Jailkeeper is an interesting cla...

And if Seanzie is town, it is obvious Seanzie is the vig, who is voting me because i cannot be a pr with him according to his beliefs. @Seanzie This is why i townread you yesterday but i dont care about keeping your secret no more! So why did you kill Wilgy if you scum read me yesterday? Well, look...

I was not questioning cat getting yeeted organically but if you had something to do with it through mechanics, you must get killed even though cat was in my poe. Question. Why not use your Cop check on me then and out SVS? You were already putting SVS at the top of your wolf reads end of yesterday....

I was not questioning cat getting yeeted organically but if you had something to do with it through mechanics, you must get killed even though cat was in my poe. Question. Why not use your Cop check on me then and out SVS? You were already putting SVS at the top of your wolf reads end of yesterday....

We can argue all day that I should have just guessed one of the Mafia instead of guessing a Vanilla Townie. I don't think it's productive. What's done is done, I think solve from there is more productive than what could have been. If you actually believe me to be a Mafia Doublevoter though, I think ...

Guillotine wrote: ↑Thu Aug 24, 2023 11:40 pm PoE

SvS
Cat
Wilgy
LP

If chopping through does not win the game we are fucked

I have a bit of tinfoil that LP is something like a double-voter rather than just controlling the elim, but the way they were telegraphing at EoD yesterday doesn't fit super well with that. In a mafia!LP world though, the fact that they went for Cat strongly suggests one of SVS or Guillo would be t...

If linearpoint is a double voter and went against the concensus, they must be eliminated. They went against the will of the majority No real offense or anything, but if you actually believe I am Mafia why would you suddenly be Town reading SVS today? Heck by your logic we might as well execute the ...

*waiting for everyone to realize there is no way we have a pairity cop, a vig, and someone who controls the D1 elim in a 10er* The conclusion I've reached is that I think Vigilante could realistically be either alignment in a 10P game. Without a Vigilante the game goes to 4v2 naturally if Town does...

I have a bit of tinfoil that LP is something like a double-voter rather than just controlling the elim, but the way they were telegraphing at EoD yesterday doesn't fit super well with that. In a mafia!LP world though, the fact that they went for Cat strongly suggests one of SVS or Guillo would be t...

I just don't know if I really think that wolves would just allow their partner to die that early and without a fight when it was not that hard of a lift form their perspective. Heck SVS even was willing to die in place of a Parity Cop claim. It's really just the fact that there is no realistic partn...

Going back to this for a moment, Cat : LinearPoint, S~V~S, falconca45 Guilltione: Cat , DrWilgy , Seanzie S~V~S: Michelle , Master Radishes, Guillotine, Epignosis I cannot for the life of me find a valid partner for S~V~S, so I don't think they are a wolf. Falcon and Guillotine were both active EoD...

To be honest I was debating for a long time if outing was a better play, but in the end I decided to wait and see how EoD wagon dynamics played out and just stuck to my gut choice. I ended up just hinting at it, but did have a little fun with a few of the lines. It was very hard to not say "I'm...

Which the fact that Guillotine both openly claimed that they missed my claim and are trying to push me when (imo) my role can't ever be Mafia in a 10p setup they are probably just Mafia who didn't realize they made a horrible choice in push target for day 2.

Granted I was expecting to die in the night since I see no real world where Mafia can successfully argue that a Mafia was given the ability to dictate the D1 execution.

But I am thinking they missed the telegraphed kill and shot in the dark.

1) It's painfully obvious how Cat died. I wasn't very present for D1 and was sleep deprived when I was, so I don't know what happened either. Feel free to explain, if it's painfully obvious enough that everyone else knows. I telegraphed quite heavily that I was going to be executing Cat day 1 in ho...

Those two kills point at me as having motivation to kill them as they both pushed me together. Which means scum went for WIFOM route. This is gonna be my assumption if the vig shot is not claimed. In my opinion Linear is scum with TMI and I don't think Linear comes here saying all wagons are were t...

Cat : LinearPoint, S~V~S, falconca45 Guilltione: Cat , DrWilgy , Seanzie S~V~S: Michelle , Master Radishes, Guillotine, Epignosis I cannot for the life of me find a valid partner for S~V~S, so I don't think they are a wolf. Falcon and Guillotine were both active EoD and neither made any effort to t...

Epignosis wrote: ↑Thu Aug 24, 2023 11:57 pm Y'all saw Michelle in here bullying me. Just sayin'.

Aw, don't worry about it Epignosis.

I'm content with my choice for today's execution.

It's times like these I sit back and think to myself that I'd make for a terrible dayvig who's contemplating shoting one of the 3 top wagons in the last 30 minutes.

Michelle wrote: ↑Thu Aug 24, 2023 11:20 pm 3 tied wagons of 3 players, one cop claim, one low active and our dear SVS.

Is this dead air dead villager?

I doubt it.

Search found 1875 matches