The Syndicate

Polo wrote:
Polo wrote:
sig wrote:and polo is helping a baddie to claim and not get ;lynched why?
Right now I don't think he's a baddie. You're the guy that just waited until 10 minutes before the poll closes and votes for a wagon on someone immune and you want to complain about me?
Your last post containing any material discussion whatsoever was 2 days ago. You could have contributed to the thread but you waited until now. You're sleazy.

I was busy with RL, I said that before signing up for the game it is a busy time of year for me, I skimmed over it was what I could do and I needed to vote.
So stop trying to use my activity agaisnt me, when I made it clear I'd be busy with school, especially considering the amount of posts.

Wilgy has been weird. So I voted for him.

These were okay results I knew LC was being weird. I'm glad our objectives are back to normal. HOWEVER, why did someone who was pushing non claimers to be lynched corrected him it makes no sense. I want to lynch Polo and Wilgy.

Also I wasn't going to mention this, but I think the failed night kill done awhile back was on me, for pursuing zebra/polo.

and polo is helping a baddie to claim and not get ;lynched why?

DrWilgy wrote:Sig, Koth, and BR. You all voted me after I had stated that I'm most likely a good toaster (meaning I still have a vote negation). What is the point of voting me? Also my bandwagon is alittle too easy for my liking. I guess it's one thing for me to say myself rather someone else, but I now have a 5 vote lead when compared to others. Does that happen to baddies unless the baddies wanted it to happen? I don't think so.

Linki - WHAT. Sig. How could you have been caught up and had any doubt to whether or not I was a cyclon?

I skimmed. I thought you were a baddie, but since you had refused to claim I was thinking maybe you weren't a bad cylon. However, I don't think you're a good cylon even if you are one I seem to remember Lorabsaying the same thing.

Epignosis wrote:To ask you the purpose of yours. Go.

It was me checking in and saying I was reviewing, I think that was pretty clear.

I knew I should've held my vote for a few more minutes however, if Wilgy claim is true it does kind of prove the we should pursue those who don't claim.

Okay so I'm more or less caught up the case on Wilgy isn't bad it has some good points so I'll put my vote there. I'd rather lynch Zebra today, but she's off the polls.

Dr.Wilgy

Epignosis wrote:
sig wrote:So Say We All

Just in case, so I see Wilgy is getting lynched, I'll review the case on him if there is one really quick.

His behavior right now is kind off strange though.
What was the purpose of this post?

What was the purpose of your post?

So Say We All

Just in case, so I see Wilgy is getting lynched, I'll review the case on him if there is one really quick.

His behavior right now is kind off strange though.

I'm a cylon

there ya go corrected. Still won't stop me a townie from getting lynched though if you do decided to go fourth with this tom foolery.

JaggedJimmyJay wrote:
sig wrote:So I get all this shit for not claiming, then when I do it is a scummy opportunistic move...............

Again someone look through Zebra's posts she has posted almost no content, Polo keeps asking people who they'd like to lynch and why not so and so that is a basic scum move. I use that all the time as mafia.
sig, I'm going to need you to acknowledge the reasons for that suspicion in a way that is not generalized and misrepresentative. Multiple people have been quite clear about why you're still suspicious, and what you just described is not an accurate depiction.

That is one of the reasons started by Scotty/Polo what are the others since I can't recall any real reasons besides the one i states and my push on Epi and other cylons. People just keep repeating I'm bad. And now you're saying I'm fusing myself to Glorf, which isn't true since it looks like it's coming down to him and me atm.

Polo I can't answer that either way it would be infodumping.

linki: Wait what polo? I'm rustled from your general behavior plus when did you say you wanted to vote for her? You've been pushing me and Glorfindel. It has nothing to do with Zebra who you're now saying you want lynched yet voted for someone else super early?

And Daisy is saying we should do the same thing that pushed Nero ahead of Lorab and what I wanted to do yesterday but on me. Both of which Polo thought was mafiash, but hasn't mentioned Daisy doing it.

If it comes down to me or Glorfindel you'll be choosing between two civs.

So I get all this shit for not claiming, then when I do it is a scummy opportunistic move...............

Again someone look through Zebra's posts she has posted almost no content, Polo keeps asking people who they'd like to lynch and why not so and so that is a basic scum move. I use that all the time as mafia.

I bet you can't name more then 50 Epi.

So say we all.

shit,

linki: No there aren't.

Scotty was killed to frame me imo.

Either way I'm a cylon. There I claimed (even though I'm not)

I think whoever killed scotty is going to use it as a spring board to get a civ to push me I flip civ then they lynch the person who originally pushed my lynch.

Matt wrote:I know Polo posted a list, but just wanted to post my updated list... (they might be the same, probably are, derp)...

a2thezebra
DrWilgy
Epignosis
Glorfindel
OA
Ricotech
sig
Sokoth
Vompatti

9 players. Is that correct? Someone said 7 earlier, so I don't know if I'm missing something somewhere...

Of the names above, I am most curious of the red. Oh, and OA. She def not civ, right?

Daisy, Sokoth seems to be a friend of yours. What do you make of him seeing you claim Cylon but he won't do it himself? As a noob to Mafia, I'd assume he'd look to your lead in situations like this where the town is conflicted.

sig - I'm not down with anyone not claiming but I find you most curious because you have been legit asking others to claim but you won't do it yourself. Wtf?

Anyway, off to work. Peace

I said we should've made Epi claim in case our win cons won't change i didn't want anyone else to claim.

S~V~S wrote:
sig wrote:you know it is more likely that the baddies claimed first or came up with the idea. I know if I was mafia I'd have jumped on this claim thing right away AND THEN pushed a lynch on anyone who hadn't claimed. Which is what Polo is trying to do, he also last phase kept asking people what they thought of certain players and pushing a lynch, for these reasons I think he's mafia.

I'm also glad nobody addressed any of my points on zebra what does everyone think of her providing almost no content and just one liners throughout the game.

I'd rather live on my knees then die on my feet!...........hmmm that sounds like I messed up the quote.

@SVS why do you think I'm a cylon? Since I'm not.
Well, since we could not say "null" in the GTH, and I totally did not think you were good and I had disagreed with most of what I recalled you as having said, I said bad. But your reaction to realizing that pretty much everyone suspected you was to totally backpedal on everything you had said the entire game. That took you from null bad to probably bad for me.

I didn't backpedal on everything, I said I would claim if it stopped me from getting lynched and I saw sense in what Epi was saying. Of course that was the only two points ever put agaisnt me I guess. I still believe LC isn't helping the civs, I still think Zebra is mafia who isn't making many real posts. I have evolved on my views of Epi, but that was happening before people thought I was bad.

a2thezebra wrote:
Polo wrote:I'd be willing to bet money that you're Mafia, sig.
Same here.

Then your both going to loose. Zebra you can't read me worth damn anyway and the only time you're right about me is when you are the mafia member. Then you accuse me of being mafia and try to lynch me.

Again a case beyond sig is bad lynch him or he didn't say he was a cylon lynch him would be nice. But, I doubt it will happen.

Dex wrote:
Long Con wrote:I swear to God, S~V~S - give me a little time, and I can prove it to you. I can't do it if you guys just lynch me tomorrow for theories and suppositions about the role you think I am can do.
Why not do it now?

sig wrote:I'll claim tomorrow I said, since it seems it will lift peoples concerns about me.
Why not do it now?

Yeah it only counts during the day so I'll do so tomorrow.

you know it is more likely that the baddies claimed first or came up with the idea. I know if I was mafia I'd have jumped on this claim thing right away AND THEN pushed a lynch on anyone who hadn't claimed. Which is what Polo is trying to do, he also last phase kept asking people what they thought of certain players and pushing a lynch, for these reasons I think he's mafia.

I'm also glad nobody addressed any of my points on zebra what does everyone think of her providing almost no content and just one liners throughout the game.

I'd rather live on my knees then die on my feet!...........hmmm that sounds like I messed up the quote.

@SVS why do you think I'm a cylon? Since I'm not.

JaggedJimmyJay wrote:
Polo wrote:Funny that two of my suspects are clearing the image of the one person that's pretty high on my list of shady people.
I think Glorfindel is one of the easiest players to suspect in this game right now if not the easiest -- he strikes me as a major scapegoating effort and not a truly suspicious player. I might follow this angle later and see who is trying to capitalize on him.

See I don't know if I like this Polo, you seem to be pushing the low hanging fruits quite a bit, plus the way you keep feeling out other peoples opinions is pingy. Should I not give any reads or clear anyone since I'm being suspected or what? I think he's a civ so I said so. I'd say I'm quite good at reading him and I do have more experience with his meta then most people so I don't see why I wouldn't defend him if I thought he was a civvie.

I'll claim tomorrow I said, since it seems it will lift peoples concerns about me.

@Scotty/Matt I've explained throughout the thread not just when pressured what I thought, and yes at first I wanted to lynch all cylons, I don't see how that is scummy, if you ask me questions I'll answer or build a case, but neither of you want to do that you like zebra just keep repeating that I'm bad and should be lynched. This is just like every game where I get mislynched I hold an unpopular view and get lynched for it. In this case it was lynching all cylon's at the beginning.

linki: Agreed JJJ, I'd be very very shocked if he was mafia this game.

Scotty if I was a baddie with Glorfindel I'd have killed him for such an obvious link. :P

I think he's a civ this game. Though I do believe he could be wrong about zebra.

Scotty wrote:
sig wrote:Aww I messed up my own joke by bolding and not underlining.

Also this was the first GTH that everyone read me as bad.
You'd be wrong, but if it will help your concerns I'll claim cylon tomorrow. Since I'd rather not be lynched.
Why are you waiting? Your hesitance to say it before and your willingness to do so because you'd "rather not be lynched" is quite telling.
sig wrote:Oh and Epi makes some good points about my points on him. I'd be happy to leave him alive with his immunity.
Well that was a quick turn around. What made you change your mind?

Can we lynch this bad guy tomorrow please? Or at least let him claim so we can lynch him the day after?

Well it is night phase so it wouldn't count.

Also lol no i changed my mind awhile ago maybe read my posts and you'll see that. Today I reverted back and said we should lynch him to get rid of the immunity, but Epi gave a good reason not to so yes I did switch, but it wasn't a quick turn around.

So how about you stop being so tunnely.

It is just it seems some of the or most of the votes for me comes from the fact I wouldn't claim cylon and was pushing Epi correct?

Polo doesn't like that I didn't vote for LoRab but I saw no point since she had immunity, and day 2 I didn't think LC was going to get lynched even with my vote so I went with Epi who I thought (wrongly) was mafia.

However, I do disagree with Rico that if LC flips mafia it looks bad for me, I think it makes me look better since I did push him for quite awhile.

JaggedJimmyJay wrote:
sig wrote:You'd be wrong, but if it will help your concerns I'll claim cylon tomorrow. Since I'd rather not be lynched.
Is that to imply that claiming cylon would prevent you from being lynched?

No.

Oh and Epi makes some good points about my points on him. I'd be happy to leave him alive with his immunity.

Aww I messed up my own joke by bolding and not underlining.

Also this was the first GTH that everyone read me as bad.

You'd be wrong, but if it will help your concerns I'll claim cylon tomorrow. Since I'd rather not be lynched.

Polo wrote:
Dex wrote:
ObscureAllure wrote:After all, we are out to get all cylons now, not just the *good* ones, right? :eyeroll: Tomorrow will be mighty interesting.
I don't think we should just calmly accept having to pull off (now) twelve successful lynches in order to win the game. What do you think our chances are of winning in those circumstances? To my mind, a better idea is to overthrow Cain (a Cain mutiny, as it were), and bring that number down to a more realistic number. And who knows how these potentially allied cylons might help us in that endeavor?
I know that lynching 12 people sucks butts, but I believe we should go after Cavil before attempting a coup d'état. Or an impeachment process; as a Brazilian dude I'll be glad to provide y'all with my hands-on experience.

Polo please some of us are under age.

:P

Oh and since Lorab is going to get lynched anyway I'm voting for zebra.

Vote a2zebra.

Yes Scotty I won't do it right now it wasn't a slip it was a purposeful word choose, I won't do it for a few reasons. One I don't agree with it in fact it seems to be pushing role/info claiming and I'm surprised Golden allowed it. Two if people are going to vote for me they will whether I claim or not a portion of players have already decided I'm mafia and plan to lynch me.The fact nobody is batting an eye at people for setting up tomorrows lynches so early though isn't good.
If you will lynch me based on little to nothing except tunnely people fine I won't fight it since I don't feel like getting yelled at or having to deal with people who won't build a case. Espaiclly since I said pre game I'd be busy and people are now trying to use my activity against me. You're tunneling with no reason or case behind it. The other main pusher of my lynch is zebra who has like 200 posts of nothings.

@MM these posts by zebra aren't about tomorrow it is about this phase.

a2thezebra wrote:If there's going to be a counterwagon, it's got to be sig. Vompatti would be nice too but no one is going to get behind that.

a2thezebra wrote:I absolutely support a sig lynch. The other three I'm not so sure.

a2thezebra wrote:
Scotty wrote:
a2thezebra wrote:Who should we lynch today, OA?
You wanna help me make a secondary lynch on sig? Last I checked he was in the bottom of your rainbow list.
Ooooh yes please!

Do a quick read through of Zebra's posts she has 212 posts most of which are one liners devoid of any real content what so ever. She has given out very few reads and have done very little this game. Lots of posts that give us nothing to work with, which makes it seem like she's active while she really isn't

I don't feel like claiming cylon right now, and I'm not going to be pressured into it when the people attempting to pressure me into it don't care if Epi an outted cylon doesn't do it.

Ricochet wrote:
Scotty wrote: You had all day to contemplate your answer to my push against you and why you're not claiming cylon while still pushing for Epi to do it. So let's do this:

vote sig

Remind me why you're not invested in the slightest to lynch LoRab. Your Day Three vote was also parked on sig.

Yeah he is being super tunnely since I at one point wanted to lycnh Epi and all cylons no other reason.
Wilgy's votes are just if not more absurd, two phases ago he voted with me this phase he voted for me, he like zebra is coasting through the game not doing much.

Also there is a difference from me not claiming and stopping Epi from having an immunity when our win con says we need to lynch all cylons, if we can change it then that is great, but if we can't and we leave him with immunity we could be screwed when we get to EOD. I don't want to for all purposes win then loose since we didn't put him on an even level. AND why is it that everyone who wants everyone else to claim immunity don't want to make Epi do the same? It makes no sense.

The chances of finding Cain is so small IT IS A WASTE OF TIME TO ACTIVELY HUNT THEM. It'll result in the death of civs and an excuse for the mafia to mislynch civs over and over again while the mafia keeps on killing us every night. It is a foolish thing to try to do right now.

Metalmarsh89 wrote:
sig wrote:So nobody is going to follow my Epi plan fine. However, the fact that y'all are starting other wagons on people when we have an outed most likely bad cylon is stupid, especially considering our win cons. I mean I see no case for DF yet he has two votes? Zebra wants to start a counter wagon on me yet is now saying she wants lorab lynched, ect.
I think any attempt to counter lorab is being done by her teammates.
In terms of alignment, why is Epignosis most likely a bad Cylon?

I don't know if he is or not, I'm leaning towards him not being a bad cylon however, that doesn't matter right now. Since we at this time need them all dead and even if we do kill Cain the win cons might not change. So we must operate under the assumption that they don't, continue to hunt the bad cylons, and as a plus take Epi's immunity ince we know he is a cylon.

sig wrote:
Silverwolf wrote:
sig wrote: I think any attempt to counter lorab is being done by her teammates.
Yes, because I'm an idiot.
No need to get nasty and defensive.

I don't think anyone is being nasty in this post.

sig wrote:I already said before I started playing I'd be busier forgive me if I didn't build big enough cases and just made posts and weighed in when I could. To much toxicity of this game at times and post counts didn't help. I'm on a tight schedule right now with school and I don't want to post WHEN PEOPLE ARE CAPING EACH OTHER TO DEATH, or when I have ten pages of nonsense to catch up on. The posts I do make have been either ignored or discounted.
Also if you looked at my baddie meta you'd see i usually post more and do build cases. But, go ahead if you want to lynch me without building a case or doing critical thinking about how to win go ahead.

Zebra I'm not trying to actively get you lynched while you are activity trying to get me lynched over a cylon and the way you keep brushing suspicion off and not actually doing anything is scummy. You're not even trying to game solve and you're just coasting.

linki: I wasn't even addressing SW at first she just made a weird response to my post which I believe was uncalled for. I said any attempt to make a counterwagon which would mean lynching the counter over lorab is scummy. I see no world in which a good townie player would attempt to lynch someone with nothing then Lorab who is a confirmed cylon who is most likely bad. I could see leaving Epi alive, I'm fine with that atm, but it makes no sense to not lynch Lorab and instead lynch me, Df, or even LC.
Calling people nasty when they're being perfectly civil (if just with some sarcasm) isn't going to help with toxicity.

To bad it was my turn to throw a fit like almost half the other players so I did.

The point isn't to lynch another person. The point it to eliminate amnesty and fall back on Lorab.

Zebra even said she wants to lynch you tomorrow, not today.

No she was pushing my lynch today then changed her mind to lynch me tomorrow, she was still pushing for me to be lynched based on nothing like she did last game in which she was mafia.

Epignosis wrote:
Metalmarsh89 wrote:I proposed a plan yesterday, and you've refused to follow it OA. You've also already voted despite warnings against it from myself and sig.

Did you have a plan in mind?
You don't need a PLAN.

I need a BEER!

I already said before I started playing I'd be busier forgive me if I didn't build big enough cases and just made posts and weighed in when I could. To much toxicity of this game at times and post counts didn't help. I'm on a tight schedule right now with school and I don't want to post WHEN PEOPLE ARE CAPING EACH OTHER TO DEATH, or when I have ten pages of nonsense to catch up on. The posts I do make have been either ignored or discounted.
Also if you looked at my baddie meta you'd see i usually post more and do build cases. But, go ahead if you want to lynch me without building a case or doing critical thinking about how to win go ahead.

Zebra I'm not trying to actively get you lynched while you are activity trying to get me lynched over a cylon and the way you keep brushing suspicion off and not actually doing anything is scummy. You're not even trying to game solve and you're just coasting.

linki: I wasn't even addressing SW at first she just made a weird response to my post which I believe was uncalled for. I said any attempt to make a counterwagon which would mean lynching the counter over lorab is scummy. I see no world in which a good townie player would attempt to lynch someone with nothing then Lorab who is a confirmed cylon who is most likely bad. I could see leaving Epi alive, I'm fine with that atm, but it makes no sense to not lynch Lorab and instead lynch me, Df, or even LC.

Silverwolf wrote:
sig wrote: I think any attempt to counter lorab is being done by her teammates.
Yes, because I'm an idiot.

No need to get nasty and defensive.

a2thezebra wrote:Okay so every time I try to lynch sig it's because I'm bad. Okay.

Actually zebra yes in recent days you have been. Star wars, Llama's gam, this game. Plus you're not doing any real game solving this time just civ confirming people, if you aren't a baddie this game then you're just lacking common sense.

Build a case which you haven't done or give a reasoning. Which you aren't doing.

a2thezebra wrote:If there's going to be a counterwagon, it's got to be sig. Vompatti would be nice too but no one is going to get behind that.

lol

a2thezebra wrote:Also, please don't lynch me because I'm not bad.

Yes you are.

Zebra just like in the last game we played in which she was bad, is trying to lynch me for no reason just like in last game, Zebra is a baddie this game.

So nobody is going to follow my Epi plan fine. However, the fact that y'all are starting other wagons on people when we have an outed most likely bad cylon is stupid, especially considering our win cons. I mean I see no case for DF yet he has two votes? Zebra wants to start a counter wagon on me yet is now saying she wants lorab lynched, ect.
I think any attempt to counter lorab is being done by her teammates.

Epignosis wrote:
sig wrote:WHY are we discussing NOT lynching Lorab and my plan to put Epi in number one right now. Like the fact people want to either hunt a civ or do a crap shoot and target someone else is foolish.

@BR what do you think of my plan to put Epi over lorab so he'll be forced to use his amnesty?

Long Con wrote:
sig wrote:Okay LC I see your point, but what happens if they're civs who end up getting lynched over a cylon?
That doesn't have to happen. All they have to do is speak the words "I am a Cylon", and that possibility goes away forever.
But, if they aren't a cylon they'll get lynched.
Why do you think you can force me to do anything?

Why are you not interested in finding and lynching people who can kill you? I cannot kill anyone. Lynching me to "force" me to do anything means you are okay burning a lynch and not putting pressure on killers.

We wouldn't lynch you though since you'd claim so you'd be lynch proof and then Lorab would be lynched if we believe she is a bad cylon. So we will end up lynching someone who can kill us.

@Scotty I'm playing to fulfill my win cons, which right now says we need to kill all cylons. We have two outed cylons one with immunity so it makes sense to make him loose his immunity IN CASE we can't reverse the new win conditions, since even if we beat the bad cylons we could still loose. Just like the civs in Turf War they were to focused on one thing.

So I think we should have Epi number 1 not to lynch him today, but to stop him from getting out of a lynch in case we need to lynch him in the future.Yes before I wanted to lynch him since I thought all cylons where bad, I've changed my view on that though. However, I'll point out the player who pushed the not all cylons are evil and we don't need to lynch Epi was nutella a baddie.

DrWilgy wrote:Holy crap guys it shoulda been obvious Triple J is a baddie.

since when has JJJ allowed Rico to have the highest amount of posts in a game?

Scotty wrote:
a2thezebra wrote:Who should we lynch today, OA?
You wanna help me make a secondary lynch on sig? Last I checked he was in the bottom of your rainbow list.

bullshit.
Though if you wanna try and lynch someone over an outed baddie cylon then go ahead. It just confirms that Zebra is a baddie. Just like in Llama's recent game she's playing the same way.

Scotty wrote:
sig wrote:So Say we All!

Okay so I still need to catch up but I saw the night results,

STOP VOTING FOR LORAB!

Why you may ask the answer is simply, right now we need to kill all the cylons the cylon amnesty law is still in play. We should make Epi the number 1 wagon and Lorab the number 2 wagon, So Epi will need to claim he's a cylon so he won't have the amnesty and then Lorab will still be lynched. We need to make sure everyone is on board with this though and we don't have what happened yesterday where Lorab had fewer votes then the counterwagon.

@HOST was no kill submitted or was the nightkill blocked? Also when did the Marmot law start working? Would it have blocked last nights kill?

Almost done school for the year so bear with me here.
LoRab has all but confirmed herself as a cylon. "Right now we need to kill all the cylons"

I'm not convinced this win condition will stick around. And even if it does, we have Epi, who is for all intents and purposes, our strongest civ-leaning cylon. So we have him in our back pocket for a future lynch if we need, and even if he doesn't claim cylon with this law until that said, we'll cross that bridge.

We have no idea about LoRab. She's definitely vulnerable. I know I just entertained it, but relying on some weird last minute vote manipulation to get one player in the lead so they'll claim cylon is a strategy that didn't work yesterday. Just ask Nero.

We already know Epi is a cylon though so he'd be forced to claim thus ending his immunity save. I see nothing wrong there. ALSO I find it funny as you say this you're trying to set up my lynch.

WHY are we discussing NOT lynching Lorab and my plan to put Epi in number one right now. Like the fact people want to either hunt a civ or do a crap shoot and target someone else is foolish.

@BR what do you think of my plan to put Epi over lorab so he'll be forced to use his amnesty?

Long Con wrote:
sig wrote:Okay LC I see your point, but what happens if they're civs who end up getting lynched over a cylon?
That doesn't have to happen. All they have to do is speak the words "I am a Cylon", and that possibility goes away forever.

But, if they aren't a cylon they'll get lynched.

Polo wrote:ObscureAllure, Epignosis, juliets, sig, Glorfindel, bea, DrWilgy, Drumbeats, Metalmarsh89

These are the people who voted for the Nerolunar counter bandwagon. Be wary of them. Counter bandwagons are a no-no in my (limited) book when a civ is lynched (or in this case a presumed civ, seeing that Nero was human).
Of those mentioned right above, juliets, Drumbeats, and ObscureAllure helped lynch Nutella.
Removing Epig and Marmot from the list of suspicious people, we're left with sig, Glorfindel, bea and DrWilgy.
Please look into those people.

Marmot is probably civilian, unless there's a scenario in which he claims to have witnessed a Cylon attack but is actually mafia/Cylon himself.
Of course, such thing would only be possible if Cavil or any of the really bad guys had insanely strong hidden powers, but I'm inclined to consider Marmot a civ, for the time being.

I read up on the lore a bit and apparently Caprica Six kills Admiral Cain in one point of the show. We should try to find and lynch Six, then.

I'm going to vote LoRab now.

Why wouldn't I vote for Nero? Lorba couldn't have been lynched at that point and Nero was the second best thing espacilly since there was a chance he was a cylon. This makes no sense neither does the fact that you keep asking people about me.

Wanting to hunt for a town PR role and ignore the baddie cylons how is that not pingy? Basically SVS is suggesting we hunt for a member of the town instead of lynching Lorab ect

Also since I forgot to say this SVS wanting to not lynch an outed most likely bad cylon (lorab) and wanting to lynch the admiral is pingy.

@LC
I've been flipfloppy on SW, sometimes she seems very civve sometimes not so much. Right now I think she is town. I'm unsure of you, the SW/LC thing could be civ vs civ, but I've had enough experience with LC setting me up for lynches as mafia for me to be wary of him pushing SW. He also did ping me early on so I don't know,

Though I do think they're both trying to annoy each other and not helping game solve.

linki: lol SVS, maybe. However, would it be worth it to hunt a civ (assuming the admiral is a civ) just to stop us from having to lynch the cylons? We would be wasting a phase. I'd suggest for the time we focus on hunting the bad cylons like Cavil the number 1 cylon (no not the Number 1 from kids next door) :P
Though I say this about Epi since then he won't have amnesty.

linki 2: Okay LC I see your point, but what happens if they're civs who end up getting lynched over a cylon?

@SW cool, this is mainly to get Epi on an even playing field just in case our win cons don't change it is kind off like Matt's idea, but it makes more sense. :P
So I don't want to lynch him today just remove his get out of jail free card.

I'll respond to some quotes soon, I see what Bea is saying, but I'm worried she is a cylon using that excuse. I disagree with wasting our time hunting Cain.
Basically we should try to hunt the admiral in hopes that we don't need to kill all the cylons? This seems like a waste of time and lynches which will only help the mafia/cylons. Also we can't assume our win cons will change with his/her death.

linki: LC how do we know OA is a cylon though? We could waste a phase lynching her and miss Lorab. Unless we very carefully plan it out so we can push Lorab ahead of OA, however if there is voter manipulation or even cylons voting for one person say OA over Lorab we would be screwed. If we did this it would need to be very close, very carefully planned.

So I'd disagree with pushing OA to the top of the ticket. I'd have to think about Bea, but for the time I believe that she's telling the truth about her reasons for not claiming. So I'd like to just do the Epi then Lorab thing since we know Epi is a cylon. Then we can leave him alive for awhile and see if we can change the win con back.

So Say we All!

Okay so I still need to catch up but I saw the night results,

STOP VOTING FOR LORAB!

Why you may ask the answer is simply, right now we need to kill all the cylons the cylon amnesty law is still in play. We should make Epi the number 1 wagon and Lorab the number 2 wagon, So Epi will need to claim he's a cylon so he won't have the amnesty and then Lorab will still be lynched. We need to make sure everyone is on board with this though and we don't have what happened yesterday where Lorab had fewer votes then the counterwagon.

@HOST was no kill submitted or was the nightkill blocked? Also when did the Marmot law start working? Would it have blocked last nights kill?

Almost done school for the year so bear with me here.

OA why do you think LC and I are on a team? Or are you suspicious of us independently.

Zebra I've been suspicious of you for awhile, saying what your saying isn't helping my read of you.

weeee I caught up, I'm not liking Zebra or LC right now.

Silverwolf wrote:
DrWilgy wrote:
ObscureAllure wrote:
DrWilgy wrote:
ObscureAllure wrote:
DrWilgy wrote:Sometimes silencing a common civ read can save them from NK and bring other players out of lurking. Perhaps forcing activity from others was the intention. Speaking of which, I'm pretty sure you are bad. ISO incoming.
If you think you're going to head down this road, I suggest you bring an army, pops. There are a couple of players that I'll see lynched over my dead body and she's one of them. Emotional or not, I'd bet my life that that girl flies the civilian flag.
So are you Cavil and shes one of your btsc buddies? Pr is it the other way around?
HA! Not even remotely. (And wtf, if I was do you think I'd slip and out myself right there? lol) I don't know for sure whether or not she's a human or civilian. But, I highly doubt she's a mafia. If she was, her mafia team would have either A) reigned her in with her outbursts or B) thrown her under the buss to gain civvie cred while she was silenced. The fact that neither has happened an she is still very much playing a hugely emotional game says to me there's no way she's a mafia. She's a civvie.

Why do you suddenly think she's a mafia out of the blue? Hmm?

Linki: golden already answered. Claiming cylon negates their votes. So The person with the most votes would simply no longer exist as an option which would roll it down the the next most.
1. Only a baddie can slip.
2. What brought that possibility to mind if it was impossible? Thinking of slipping is something only a baddie would naturally do.
3. I think you just did.

We found our Cavil everyone!
Nope, She was giving a hypothetical scenario and I've said things like that as town before. "If I was mafia, you think I'd be so dumb as to.......whatever it it." If you look at motivation, there's things Mafia would not do if they were smart. Openly defending each other like that is definitely one of them. There's a lot more subtle ways to protect a scumbuddy than that. And OA was instrumental in the nutella lynch and calling out Lorab as a BTSC partner. I think you are barking up the wrong tree.

I disagree any if I was mafia thing can be used by mafia. And mafia can openly defend their teammates smart mafia do it, the winners of GoC did it and I've done it multiply times and have never gotten lynched in the past. So saying smart mafia wouldn't do this is WIFOM ridden and inaccurate.

Long Con wrote:
ObscureAllure wrote:
Long Con wrote:
Metalmarsh89 wrote:I'm a boneheaded idiot when I'm civilian and I talk out of my ass when I'm mafia.
Does this apply to today's lynch?
What are your thoughts on what happened today, LC?
My thoughts on Metalmarsh's part are already quite clear. It's really sucky that Nero got lynched, and the real fault lies with the President for making that law. Without that law, Lorab would have been lynched today.

Yeah stupid president lets impeach them. :P

ObscureAllure wrote:
Epignosis wrote:Lorab tomorrow. No questions.
This.

And then I think that Sig, Long Con, Juliet and Bea are the most likely mafia at this point.

Why me and then LC? That makes no sense/. I don't like how you're setting up lynches days in advance.

Silverwolf wrote:Also, I'm guessing you picked ika N1 since he was killed and no one was silenced. That almost makes me feel like you have a personal vendetta this game but that could just me being irritated right now thinking that. I am NOT a happy camper.

Don't be mean to Nero he's going to be my future sugar daddy. :P
Right Nero.

Search found 287 matches