The Syndicate

I'm actually a bit weirded out by the fact that trice hasn't voted for MM, yet. I was painting a new lid for my composter up until about 2 minutes ago. I am willing to vote MM to save myself, but will not be surprised if he is good. He is in fact on the golden suspect list which is a point against ...

MP, the important part is that vompatti was moya List of other people Golden voiced suspicions of within a day or two of his death: A Person , Dom, Lorab, MM, Sig List of people Sloonei voiced suspicions of before getting silenced by Sleep: Lorab, Scotty, Dom, INH, DrWilgy List of people dom has def...

MovingPictures07 wrote:Trice still seems genuine to me. What am I missing?

nothing

How is it awful? It's 100% true, in the past day or two JJJ has only chosen to write about people who have first targeted him. Offer an alternative or rebuttal if you think it's not true. It isn't true in that you've incorrectly stated who I have suspected and also who suspects me (I don't suspect ...

Even if you lynch me today, remaining civvies can still easily win if they listen to me. I'm sort of resigned to the fact that I die every game I ever play (it's why all my victories are as mafia or indy, being alive isn't typically a win condition for them) and even if you don't lynch me, Dom or JJ...

It was only in response to the one example possibility you listed

Hey BWT, are you able to produce some summarized/quick reads for me (whether rainbow or not)? I'm curious where your head is at right now. Linki: Same question to Trice. Confident civ: the late Golden, Sloonei, you, me tentative/probably civ: epignosis, Timmer, MM, sig Mafia 1: was vompatti Mafia 2...

If he was an information role as you believe I don't think he would have lynched 3 civs and been so far off in his reads this game I mean, I have too. It's really hard to nail 4 baddies in a game of 19 players. What's your point here? Timmer suggested JJJ was a civvie role with an info gathering ab...

That's because it ties to my previous several posts, which you don't appear to have read I'll help you out, though: the point is pattern recognition, figuring out which names constantly appear in leads worth following. "Once is happenstance. Twice is coincidence. Three times is enemy action&qu...

I don't think he has made stupid posts at all. I think you want to delegitimize a player who has been right because it is hard to lynch him and obvious to night kill him. You haven't read most of the last 2 pages have you? Dom posting the same way I'm criticizing JJJ and epignosis for - deliberatel...

So far 2 bad players have voted for me, and the other two haven't been in the thread since I made my case

nothing to do but wait it out

Who has JJJ suspected today? Me, when I suspect him Marmot, who suspects him ( 1 , 2 ) MP, who posted suspicions of him ( 1 , 2 ) Scotty, who suspects him Lorab, who posted suspicions of him ( 1 , 2 ) Epignosis, who posted suspicions of him ( 1 , 2 ) Didn't you criticize Lorab for doing basically wh...

@Trice (and thus to JJJ who asked my opinion earlier), I feel like you are a strong possibility to be bad, tbh. I'm not following your reasoning on things, and it feels like you are trying to manufacture a JJJ lynch out of very little. That said, your insistence about him being the SK is so specifi...

It's alarming that I'm the only person who has even bothered to cross-check suspicions of dead civvies especially somebody who supposedly has a giant spreadsheet of every game and tries to perform statistical analysis should be doing this... if he was good but JJJ has instead been thrilled to just ...

It's alarming that I'm the only person who has even bothered to cross-check suspicions of dead civvies

I would talk about them if there was meaningful content - almost 3000 words to say "marmot plays a bit goofy and changes his mind a lot" isn't worth dissecting

Percentage who are actually bad is pretty significant , it's impossible to generate meaningful stats without that number. huh this is interesting Once in a while. Most of the time I don't get into hyper-analysis mode until a scum is dead. It's a great way to fit the profile people expect of a generi...

I'm tilting for writing out my entire train of thought, including civ reads and analysis of known civvie's suspicions

JJJ isn't tilting for repeating the same lie about me over and over again

noted

That was because I had said and quoted and repeated my reasons for suspecting him many many times before that. If it concerned you why didn't you comment on it at the time? Because you don't care about lynching civs The data revealed that 56% of them were not good. This is a game with multiple baddi...

JJJ that was one of the very last things I ever said about A Person, immediately after he was actually posting in the thread (so it seemed, he posted once and left. I doubt he even knows he's dead yet) and NOT one of my stated reasons. I would like somebody who isn't bad to comment on my posts pleas...

Trice, we seem to have 3 people posting in some form of curse. Do you think all 3 are legit? If not, which do you think is lying, and why? I'm pretty sure when roles are finally revealed at the end of the game, Mladic will be rather complication mechanics for cursing people and I don't really know ...

2) I didn't vote for A Person for the "exact same reasons" you did. I did not give him an ultimatum he would never meet, and I did not lambaste him for his gripe with the high posters. These were my reasons: I preferred him over a Marmot lynch which was the alternative presented to me as ...

Timmer, because he got the idea after epignosis threw out the idea that vomps was Moya. It didn't originate with him. List of people dom has defended or said he thinks are good: Timmer, JJJ, Scotty, BWT, Boomslang, MP, epi He also defended BWT from JJJ accusations, so you can cross the latter off th...

OK my first spoiler is completely unreadable, it's just a copy paste of the Motherfucker=Redeemer role description

Dom posting the same way I'm criticizing JJJ and epignosis for - deliberately misleading when not outright lies in their accusations. Wouldn't be surprised if all three are bad, civvies can and do play honest the way virtually everybody else has been "lies" I don't know your alignment. I'...

triceratopzeuhl wrote:BWT, boomslang, lorab, nijuukyugou all haven't checked in day 4 yet, there might not be any silence target though

one off the list, thank you lorab

Some players view this differently so it's not the sole point I'm considering, but I do think baddies are more obsessed with answering every accusation than townies are in general . I have gotten into trouble as a bad guy myself for this before. oh here's why, it's because he thinks that's how you ...

Sig: rico was brought over from progarchives (not a mafia website) a few years ago by MP, same as me, epignosis, BWT, and A Person Golden targeted by mafia twice in 3 nights, seems they didn't like what he's been saying. This Fellow [JJJ -ed] is Not a Civilian I did not like his reasons for being a...

Crooked Epignosis thinks he can keep throwing whoppers after a civvie insanified him, sad!

Dom posting the same way I'm criticizing JJJ and epignosis for - deliberately misleading when not outright lies in their accusations. Wouldn't be surprised if all three are bad, civvies can and do play honest the way virtually everybody else has been

Why are we criticizing the approach Epi is taking to the game when MP initially took the very same approach? I can only speak for myself, but I am not criticizing Epi for playing POE. I think POE can be a very effective method. My concern with Epi is that his conduct late in lynches and immediately...

and even if I hadn't, you assume every other person is familiar with his play but me, very disingenuous

every mafia game I've ever played iirc

trice -- He wasn't as hard on Vompatti for perceived irrelevant content as he was on others (Epi and A Person). He called him a spambot and left it at that. That's not ideal. The people who didn't mention Vompatti while he was alive -- I'm not inclined to read into this. Generally speaking, there's...

Sig: rico was brought over from progarchives (not a mafia website) a few years ago by MP, same as me, epignosis, BWT, and A Person Golden targeted by mafia twice in 3 nights, seems they didn't like what he's been saying. This Fellow [JJJ -ed] is Not a Civilian I did not like his reasons for being a...

triceratopzeuhl wrote:BWT, boomslang, lorab, nijuukyugou all haven't checked in day 4 yet, there might not be any silence target though

these people pls post tia

trice -- He wasn't as hard on Vompatti for perceived irrelevant content as he was on others (Epi and A Person). He called him a spambot and left it at that. That's not ideal. That's because that's how vompatti has always been on every website as long as I can remember knowing now that rico is putti...

BWT, boomslang, lorab, nijuukyugou all haven't checked in day 4 yet, there might not be any silence target though If Sleep kills, he cannot use his regular power during the same Night if somebody IS silenced, it probably means some power or role secret faked the cause of death somehow. If all 4 of t...

I'm putting a vote on Scotty . What is your reason for this? Is it that he hasn't answered this post? I'm going to restate my primary Scotty beefs for Scotty himself whenever he is available. ~ Scotty's efforts to communicate with Golden and facilitate his involvement in the continuing dialogue was...

The other game has ended so I'm putting more focus here. Not surprised to find JJJ, who I called bad with my 1st post of the game, as voting for me. I assume it's because I haven't been around to answer. Or he's just bad. Can't tell yet. Are you caught up now? Any insights to share from day 3 and n...

JaggedJimmyJay wrote:I'm putting a vote on Scotty.

What is your reason for this?

Dom wrote:
triceratopzeuhl wrote:
Epignosis wrote:Good or Helpful = Lynching Civilians and Threatening to Vote Another One for Not Being Good or Helpful
see he even admits it
.....?
?!!?!

Imagine reading this and thinking it was a serious post

biggest change in Golden's theories over the course of day 3 was JJJ from Moderate Town & less likely than sloonei to be bad, to worried about JJJ

Sig: rico was brought over from progarchives (not a mafia website) a few years ago by MP, same as me, epignosis, BWT, and A Person Golden targeted by mafia twice in 3 nights, seems they didn't like what he's been saying. Recent noteworthy posts from Golden: A PERSON BWT BOOMSLANG DOM Slight bad Mod...

Why was golden killed by sleep and alfothad instead of by moya and alfothad? any theories? Do you mean you don't read MP as civilian at all, or you don't have a clear read on him at all? clear I also said this when I voted for AP: I'm voting for him until I see at least an attempt at finding mafia m...

Epignosis wrote:Good or Helpful = Lynching Civilians and Threatening to Vote Another One for Not Being Good or Helpful

see he even admits it

I think we have plenty in common yes, I just don't like how he's playing this game Object of the Game: Vote Out the People Who Are Playing in a Way You Don't Like by "I don't like the way you're playing the game" I mean "I'm pretty sure you are bad and are constantly making idiotic p...

I also said this when I voted for AP: I'm voting for him until I see at least an attempt at finding mafia members would have been easily correctable if he was playing the game Did you feel this was a demand A Person was ever likely to meet either way? He posted on day 3 shortly before I made this p...

I wasn't thrilled with the Epi wagon of Day 1, but trice was the exception. To suspect Epi purely for his posting gimmick does not evidence a thorough hunting mindset, in my opinion, in people who know the guy. That's where trice is a bit different: he hasn't been around here in a long time, and I ...

Good or Helpful = Lynching Civilians and Threatening to Vote Another One for Not Being Good or Helpful You've contributed to lynching just as many civs as I have I'd like to know what others think of Scotty right now. Each time I look at the player list his name stands out loudly to me. Well he's b...

Search found 702 matches