The Syndicate

November

Frank - I've agreed with Frank on some occasions. They've been some of the few posts I've actually made! But I agreed on the wrong things, such as his Puddy comment. The vote record isn't great, except that last one getting Jackie. But then again, I suppose I could say that of anyone, considering w...

November

I voted for Peterman and the poll's not even up yet.

November

Frank - I've agreed with Frank on some occasions. They've been some of the few posts I've actually made! But I agreed on the wrong things, such as his Puddy comment. The vote record isn't great, except that last one getting Jackie. But then again, I suppose I could say that of anyone, considering w...

November

Just to be clear, I misunderstood Jerry's question about Frank, but left the thread last night before I saw my mistake until now. I was well aware of the Frank check, but the question in context was right after Frank had posted an opinion, so I responded as such. Whoopsie. I don't care about this. ...

November

Frank and Tim Alright, I'm back, SERENITY NOW'ed, and ready to vote for George now that Jerry has also seen the light. Will look at Whately just to be fair. He looks to me like a civilian being thrown into the game and wanting to engage with the main posters, make sure they didn't escape suspicion. ...

November

A look at Tim Whatley's treatment of all players still in my POE pool: Do you think it would be unwise for power roles to claim at this point in the game? Depends really. There are too many variables in play still. @George Costanza Where are you and where is your head at? Why did you vote the Soup N...

November

My gut right now is leaning toward Peterman, but I could easily change my mind. I'll figure this out later. Good work today, y'all. Mr. Steinbrenner is proud of your efforts.

November

It looks like nobody else is going on George, so I'll switch to Whatley. I can see the argument for him being bad, even though my gut says he's not. And obviously my gut has been wrong on several different occasions this game. Is this the kind of thing a teammate would say before contributing to th...

November

I voted Uncle Leo. It's the only vote I feel good about placing right now. This post makes me feel good about Leo. I don't think mafia where in a position where they wanted to bus each other today. If they're going to push a lynch, they're pushing a mislynch unless a bus can't be avoided. This feel...

November

The fact Peterman isn't even aware of the civ read on Frank is as interesting as Whatley not knowing that Steinbrenner is the "cop" It might be interesting. Tell me why you think it's interesting. Well, mafia team communicates to each other, this sort of information would have been made c...

November

The fact Peterman isn't even aware of the civ read on Frank is as interesting as Whatley not knowing that Steinbrenner is the "cop" I just had this thought as well and I may now be coming into agreement with Elaine. Between the two of them, Peterman and Whatley did not seem to have a comp...

November

Alright, I'm back, SERENITY NOW'ed, and ready to vote for George now that Jerry has also seen the light. Will look at Whately just to be fair. He looks to me like a civilian being thrown into the game and wanting to engage with the main posters, make sure they didn't escape suspicion. That both of ...

November

Lynch frank tomorrow

November

@Frank Costanza @Elaine Benes @George Steinbrenner Your votes are critical now. I think Leo is the best vote presently. Whatley remains in my 3-player POE, but I do agree with George that his voting behavior in this late phase hasn't been pro-mafia. That's a good thing. Why Leo? I don't have time t...

November

Voting whatley. I'm probably not going to be here for EOD, but I'll try my best to make it. If I need to move a vote, I should at least be able to do that. But at this very moment I feel good about where it is.

November

If we can reach a consensus on Whatley then he'd be my preferred lynch today for the reasons Leo laid out. It's safer to lynch a player who does not have a town ID on them.

November

[mention]Uncle Leo[/mention], when you return, my most pressing concern about you is your treatment of J. Peterman in this game. You've been a vocal supporter of his bandwagon without actually supplying any of your own input on the player. I'm sure you can understand why this might look bad from my ...

November

Frank/Whatley is currently looking like the most plausible team to me, but I'm not yet at a point where I'm comfortable removing anyone else from my POE.

November

I could vote for Whatley. What stands out to me most about his posts right now is three similar instances of him giving unsatisfying answers for his questionable behavior: Do you think it would be unwise for power roles to claim at this point in the game? Depends really. There are too many variables...

November

My ID is the one reason I have not to vote for Frank. Even if he does turn out to be the godfather, it would be preferable today to find his teammate. I'd feel a hell of a lot better about lynching Frank if we had two confirmed vanilla mafias. I've been ignoring Peterman today. I see him now as low ...

November

It's a vote I could support. Lynching a civilian who has been ID'd civilian with a godfather still alive would be a gut punch, but that's only relevant if he's a civilian. I think he looks bad. A nagging feeling in the back of my mind tells me the two cop IDs were put to the worst possible use, tar...

November

Jackie consistently named Frank as a suspect without ever actually applying pressure to him.

November

ASSMAN! I'LL GIVE HIM ASSMAN! *votes Kramer* Now where did this vote come from? You criticize George, Elaine, Estelle... but then vote Kramer with no real explanation! Not to mention that this is a follower vote on someone I'm feeling pretty good about. Highly questionable behavior. On another not,...

November

here, hear. whatever.

November

I think Big Stein's analysis of the lawyer has a lot of merit. And not just because he's black. I mean, not because he's black at all! But one thing you missed, Steinbrenner: he did mention Estelle before challenging Jerry. On another not, rereading Estelle's three posts, I find it satisfying to re...

November

Frank hasn't commented on me IDing him at all. Frank hascn't commented on a lot of things and it makes him difficult to read. I am leaning toward voting for him today. I am unlikely to be here for the EOD.

November

You raise an interesting point about the night kill, George. Someone had to have been here to submit it. However, the target of the kill might suggest that it was done by someone (or a pair of someones) who aren't paying close attention. Off the top of my head, Peterman and Uncle Leo best fit that b...

November

George Costanza wrote: ↑Tue Oct 17, 2017 3:43 pm And I got nothing to hide, so throw all the work you got my way, I'll give you answers. I'll give you solutions.

I am most interested in hearing your thoughts on those other folks right now. Keep doing that.

November

Nitpicking words is what Mr. Steinbrenner pays me to do.

November

@George Costanza, why are you voting for No Lynch? I wanted to see how the votes were split. I will not be voting No Lynch. I will most likely be voting for Uncle Leo. I want to stop defending myself and concentrate on lower post count people who I haven't really looked into or analyzed yet. I enco...

November

George Costanza wrote: ↑Tue Oct 17, 2017 3:27 pm
My Day 1 vote was not a heavily built up case; I was going by role play and did not feel Newman's outcries were insincere so I couldn't jump on the bandwagon, even though it would probably have made me seem less suspicious in some ways.

why are you concerned with appearing unsuspicious?

November

Another angle which can be immensely helpful for Day 4 that we really ought to work with: living-teammate analysis. We have a relatively small suspect pool, and two names to isolate. We already have an idea who we trust. If we can manage a suspect pool of four or five, then we can check every singl...

November

[mention]George Costanza[/mention], why are you voting for No Lynch?

November

George Costanza It was my understanding that George Costanza poisoned his fiancée with envelope glue. Despicable, degenerate, deplorable! He'll get my vote. Oh come on! Be sensible. and since when did we ever trust an attorney :rolleyes: George entered with a handful of fluff posts. This is the fir...

November

As a low-ranking member of the Yankees' social media outreach team, I have no idea what any of you mean when you talk about roleplay.

November

George is playing with heavy WIFOM in that big defense post. It's entirely possible that Jackie incriminated one of his teammates with his dying breath. It's entirely possible he incriminated an innocent townie. Either way, he did it so that we would be left scratching our heads at it. That George i...

November

Frank Costanza Hi, I'm George. I'm unemployed and I live with my parents. As if we needed any more proof you're a good-for-nothing bum! Didn't bother showing up at all to the Mafia for the first day of it. Hiding? I've been serving soup behind a counter for nine hours already today. Except for you....

November

Voting Uncle Leo.

November

Jerry Seinfeld wrote: ↑Tue Oct 17, 2017 2:12 pm I forgot about Peterman. Meh. I really would like to think a mafioso under constant pressure would naturally end up with more than 9 posts.

Leo's post history has me considering that Peterman is town more than anything else I've seen in this game. It looks like scum bandwagoning 101.

November

Uncle Leo HELLO! I was with Jerry’s cousin Jeffrey. You know Jeffrey, he works for the parks department? He would have this whole thing figured out quick. How many times do I have to tell you all that my past is not who I am these days. It was a crime of passion! I never knew this Susan. Now if you...

November

I don't see anything strikingly different about the Soup Nazi's reads and my own. I was perhaps a bit more favorable to Whatley and less so to Peterman, but that's about it. Peterman and Elaine were my top two suspects much of the day and I didn't have any clear distinctions between everyone else. I...

November

I'm not going to bother ISOing Jerry and Elaine. If anyone wants me to elaborate on them, I will but I think my reasons are self-evident. Tim Whatley/Kenny Bania The only thought Bania contributed toward the game was a soft suggestion for less roleplay, whatever that is. So I've just about read ever...

November

A rainbow list with thoughts prior to me doing any digging today: Elaine Benes - Claimed tracker. This claim lines up with my own role in the matrix, has not been countered, and netted us a scum lynch. Elaine is as close to confirmed as can be. Leaving her alive for Day 4 was a silly move. Jerry Sei...

November

George Costanza wrote: ↑Tue Oct 17, 2017 12:13 pm you're basing your entire votes on Jackie's interactions with me, jerry/elaine? that's really lazy scum hunting. Terrible in fact.

Be the change you want to see in the world, Georgie boy!

November

Frank Costanza wrote: ↑Sun Oct 15, 2017 5:16 pm
I think Big Stein's analysis of the lawyer has a lot of merit. And not just because he's black. I mean, not because he's black at all! But one thing you missed, Steinbrenner: he did mention Estelle before challenging Jerry.

Frank, which parts of my analysis on Jackie had merit?

November

Mr. Steinbrenner needs to relieve himself from some of the pressures of scum hunting while his beloved Yankees battle for an American League pennant. He's entrusted me, some intern or something, with a portion of his responsibilities here.

November

ESTELLLLLLLLLLLLLLLLLLLLLLLLLLLLEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEE?!?!?!?!?!?!? No! It can't be! My wife is dead because of you animals! She would drive me up a wall, but she was being quiet around you people, and now someone thought it was worth shutting her up even more. Only people she mentione...

November

Voting for Peterman because we can't all lump our votes in the same place.

November

Sure I'll do a George vote. You announced towards the end of Day 3 that you would not be voting for George. I assume that your interactive read between George and Jackie has a lot to do with your change of heart. What are the key points at the root of your George suspicion. Why is he your preferred...

November

I wanted to do an interactive read between Jackie and Peterman, but in its entirety it amounts to this single post: Mr Puddy, I find your comments about me to be slanderous, unsupported, offensive! Seems to me like you were put on the spot by Mr Seinfeld and filled in the gaps by scanning the player...

Search found 498 matches