The Syndicate

MacDougall wrote:No interest in helping me at all here Glorfindel?

If you're alluding to targeting someone (probably Glorfy based on your questions) and finding out they self targeted...

Glorfy being such a nice guy, I can definitely see him taking himself hostage. Derp.

Dom wrote:I'd like to hear actual thoughts from Matt, Enrique, and Dharmahelper too.

Sorry, I was writing out a response to your question about TH last night, got all into Paul Walker's "Running Scared", and fell asleep. Blah. Anyway, to answer you about TH...I simply think he's lying about being Riddlerfied and even yesterday, I won't say which post, but I'm pretty sure during the day phase he was blatantly laughing at me over something that was occurring.

Other thoughts...Why is Mac still alive? Is Glorfy Two-Face or Mafia, and should we lynch him either/or?

Enrique wrote:

Matt wrote:

Sorsha wrote:Thank you!

You're welcome.

Linki - I think I've changed my mind. Let's lynch Glorfy.

wait
what?

See, I'm mafia, and after killing Sorsha, I thought it would be funny to say "You're Welcome" to her "Thank you" in thread to act as if I had nothing to do with it. With the exception of you, it seems to have worked!

Turnip Head wrote:

DFaraday wrote:Linki: I'm kind of unclear about TH too. Everybody seems to be taking it for granted that he's civ and I feel like I missed why.

Maybe it's not being taken for granted. Maybe other players are critically thinking about my contributions and have concluded that I'm playing a strong game for the town. Have you read my posts DF? Have you looked into my contributions? Or are you just sort of skating by and not thinking deeply about what's happening?

j

Lulz.

Dom wrote:

Matt wrote:I'm tryin' to get things done, Dom. I'm tryin'.

You still like Turnips? I've never seen such a bad and/or indy player shove in my face how bad and/or indy they are, yet nobody wants to get behind a Turnips lynch. Does everyone still think he's Alfred or something?

Going back to another "confirmed civ", why isn't Mac dead? Sorry, but that doesn't make any sense for him to still be breathing. Derp.

Why do you think TH is bad and who thinks he is Alfred? The case was that he wasn't Alfred.

I assumed people thought he was Alfred and that's why literally nobody is sussing him.

As for why I think he's bad, not to pull a Zebra, but it's all over my ISO. Basically, he's a liar liar pants on fire.

I'm tryin' to get things done, Dom. I'm tryin'.

You still like Turnips? I've never seen such a bad and/or indy player shove in my face how bad and/or indy they are, yet nobody wants to get behind a Turnips lynch. Does everyone still think he's Alfred or something?

Going back to another "confirmed civ", why isn't Mac dead? Sorry, but that doesn't make any sense for him to still be breathing. Derp.

Chillin'. You?

Golden wrote:

Dom wrote:Golden maybe flown under the radar isn't the best way to put it. Do you mean avoided scrutiny? Because I don't feel like neither Matt nor myself have exactly flown under the radar.

Maybe avoided scrutiny is right. Not avoided suspicion, just... Avoided meaningful analysis, maybe.

Why you suss of me Golden? I thought we were two peas in a pod this game.

DharmaHelper wrote:As frustrating as it was to basically be told I am an affliction I don't like that Sorsha was NKed.

Seeing as how you and Sorsha seemed to have some kind of real off topic probs, I don't think you killed her btw. Unless you're just a total dick.

Sorsha wrote:Thank you!

You're welcome.

Linki - I think I've changed my mind. Let's lynch Glorfy.

DharmaHelper wrote:I wonder what Matt will be afflicted with today.

Nah I'm good.

Lol @ Mac still being alive.

Eh, at least I'm giving it my all. We've got several inactives, Sorsha who herself claims to be a barely functioning active, SVS who continuously votes for herself (but honestly for all I know she's been cursed to do that), D "This is my last game whatevs" H, and blah.

Anyway, my strongest suss remains Turnip. Everyone likes him as civ apparently.

Why you chasin' Golden?

So no go on Turnips again? Okey dokey. RIP Sprityo

And RIP MM, apologies for not offering condolences sooner.

Also I'm tellin' you peeps, Glorfy is Two-Face. Leave dat Glorf alone! Unless you're the cop who needs him dead. I suppose for your sake, he wouldn't be a bad lynch anyway.

Mac, why haven't you been killed? Unless them Mafia are like "We won't kill Mac and he will be suspicious for not being murderfied muhahahaha". But yes, I find it suspicious.

DharmaHelper wrote:Fuck that Ghostbusters trailer, btw. Fuck it so hard

Dom wrote:Matt, where you at?

Hey Dom, how're things? School goin' okay? If Glee were to make a comeback, would you call it "Glee: The Next Generation", "Glee: Voyager", or "Glee: Deep Space Nine" ?

Movin' on up...to the east side...

Dom wrote:It sounds like you could be wrong, Matt.

No.

From the impression I got, I very well should've been posting funny on Days 4, 5, and 6 as well, until I got the riddle correct. Suddenly though, nothin'.

But everyone's keen on Turnips, so what can I do? Guess I'll move on.

Typhoony wrote:Was anyone riddled last night?
I'm wondering if bea could have been the Riddler since I haven't heard anything at all

Nah pretty sure Zeebs or sig was the Riddler. Which means I have no clue what you and Turnips have been talkin' about. Especially Turnips.

Metalmarsh89 wrote:

Matt wrote:RIH Floyd.

I see Lorab's spirits seem to be up so I suppose I will not be voting Mac again tomorrow.

Funny tho, I'm pretty sure both Turnips and MP are liar liars but everyone seems to think they're civvie.

Is MM playing this game? I'm pretty sure he is. MM - What's up bud?

Yeah dude! I'm totally playing. That's why I'm posting on topic and voting in the polls (usually) and stuff.

Are you playing this game?

I'm trying.

I think you listed me as bad in your G2H reads. Why Marmot why?

RIH Floyd.

I see Lorab's spirits seem to be up so I suppose I will not be voting Mac again tomorrow.

Funny tho, I'm pretty sure both Turnips and MP are liar liars but everyone seems to think they're civvie.

Is MM playing this game? I'm pretty sure he is. MM - What's up bud?

Btw I'm not trying to be tricky. Since everyone thinks you're supatowning, guess I will conform and ask you about my latest suspect, he who isn't Robin.

Turnips, what do you think of MP?

MacDougall wrote:Cmon Matt. Why would you go do something like that?

Because you were making Lorab sad

Early on in the comics, Harvey Bullock was a crooked cop

Nah I'm kidding. He's really not Boomslanging you at all, but I wanted to use Boomslang as a verb, and I used it prematurely it seems.

MacDougall wrote:

DharmaHelper wrote:

MacDougall wrote:Let's lynch DharmaHelper.

Lets not.

Nah let's.

Mac's totally Boomslangin' DH right here. Classic.

Mac

Yo peeps. Just replaced into Llama's game and will be doing my best to catch up over there before work today.

I noticed Dom has me on his suss list. Not sure why, Dom, you ask me questions and I answer and then it's done. The latest time you actually realized you made a mistake when questioning me, lulzed it off, and done. Yet I'm still suss in your opinion.

Tonight when I get home from work I'll catch up here and see what you have to say for yourself, Mr. Dom.

Also, I guess everybody thinks MP is really Wonder Boy. Okey dokey.

Turnip Head wrote:

Matt wrote:

Turnip Head wrote:Matt... wtf

Lol. What? It's not like I gave anything away, I thought this was already heavily implied "knowledge" already in the thread?

So you think MP is good to go then?

I just don't know what your aim is. I think you'd be more successful if you didn't play solely on your own terms. We're all trying to figure out the game together and you're off in la la land.

Maybe I missed it, but why doesn't anyone think Wilgy could be Robin?

After the Day 1 lynch, Wilgy gave Scotty topsy civ honors in a rainbow list. I think a Wilgy who wasn't Robin would be smarter then that to auto assume Scotty was Robin, and realize that though it's nowhere stated in the roles, that it's possible a bad guy has a lynch stop somehow. Not only does he give Scotty top honor civ in his rainbow list, he makes him blue. Not the regular green, but blue, like "Yo this dude is civ for realz". If Golden is correct and Scotty was the Commish, perhaps Wilgy as Robin saw that.

Though it's also possible Wilgy was a bad dude and painted Scotty blue so he could buddy up to him. But still, I wonder.



I do recall Typh asking folks "how did Wilgy switch if he wasn't here?" and though Wilgy does have his settings set so we can see him, who's to say he didn't go dark for awhile and stop the lynch, then switch himself back on again?

Also, no worries Turnip, I play weird I know. I just like to get opinions sometimes before I fully state my thought process derp. Anyway, you're still totally sketch so I'm not taking anything you say personally.

Turnip Head wrote:Matt... wtf

Lol. What? It's not like I gave anything away, I thought this was already heavily implied "knowledge" already in the thread?

So you think MP is good to go then?

RIP Scotty

Question for anyone/everyone - Are you personally under the impression that MP is Wonder Boy?

Typhoony wrote:I've always wanted to be the target of Matts crazy theories. I finally did it!

It's simple.

One of us is not being truthful. Either way, lynch me or lynch you, we find out you're the dishonest one here. Not so crazy, really.

But I will admit I chuckled at your response there.

Okay, here's a crazy theory since you asked about motivation...

I was up Turnip's ass asking him questions about the Riddler. Let's assume you and Turnip are partners, so you come swinging in saying "Nope my experience is in line with Turnips" to make me look bad. There's your motivation.

Anyway, Golden, thanks for the advice. Really. But when something doesn't add up to me, I think it's a benefit to discuss it, even if I'm literally the only one in thread who thinks town benefits from me talking. :P

Whatevs, though. I don't know how the Riddler works exactly, maybe different things are done. But one thing I do think would remain the same, is the time frame.

Anyway, have to get ready for work, I'll be back tonight. Oh, and I suppose I'll go to Fish Mooneys.

I'm fine with my lynching. My flip will guarantee that I'm not lying, and though the civs would take a hit, it would just be losing a body (a body nobody listens to anyway), so whatevs.

I'm going to go out on a limb and guess that Epi would not tell one player "You have one try per night" and tell another player "No time frame", so Typh will most likely be getting my vote tomorrow.

Typhoony wrote:I escaped. I'm just visiting some lifelong friends may or may not exist.

Also, I was not given a time limit Matt

Okay, now I think you are lying.

And seeing as how it's definitely open for discussion, seeing as how you've seemed to have "gotten the okay" from Epig...

I was specifically told I had one try per night. Which is also why I assumed the Riddler was dead after I wasn't posting funny three days straight, because my second try was definitely not the right answer, I even told the hosts while answering "Lulz I dunno but..."

Are you saying Epi didn't give you a deadline to answer the Riddler by end of night phase?

Typhoony wrote:Because Epi told me I can't really say much.

Linki: thanks.

Turnip has said he had no time frame, and I did have one. What about you? I know Epi hasn't warned me via PM to stop chattering about this and I assume the same for TH, so I think you can answer that question at least.

Linki - Hmm.

Typhoony wrote:Can you describe your experience Matt? I'm on phone, hard to find stuff for me atm

Absolutely. As soon as Turnip answers my three questions.

But even w/o, my experience was pretty much the same as Turnips with an exception or two...

1) I did have a time frame in which to answer the riddle.

and

2) I was given a mission on my second day. Turnip didn't seem to (noticeably) have one. I have no idea though because he refuses to answer.

Typhoony wrote:Yes because me and TH are both lying about being riddled.

Why not just elaborate on what you mean that your experience is like his? And I never accused you of lying, I asked you to please expand on what you are talking about.

Dom wrote:Matt, I clearly misunderstood your point. I thought you were saying Equivocate and Floyd etc hadn't interacted with her.

Sorry, missed your post somehow.

Okay, cuz I was like "I have no idea what Dom is trying to say there"

Typhoony wrote:Ths experience is (so far) in line with my experience with the Riddler Matt.

Elaborate, please. What is your experience with the Riddler and how does it compare to Turnips? And just for fun, how does it compare to mine?

Turnip Head wrote:

Matt wrote:Turnip, a few questions

1) A few days ago, I believe you answered someone's question about the Riddler, saying there was no time frame in which to answer the riddle. Can you expand on this please?

2) How many times have you attempted to answer the riddle?

3) During your most recent day experience, did you have a certain goal to accomplish along with the curse?

Thank you

I'm not going to answer your questions Matthew, and I'll tell you why. I can already tell you won't like my answers, based on prior discussions on the matter. But I can't change my answers because everything I've said is true. Even if I were bad, I can think of no logical reason that I would lie about something like this.

Take it or leave it, I don't much care what you do.

Per the underline, that's kinda weird because the post I made directly before the post quoted above, I said I slightly feel better about you. But okay.

Based on what I've seen from you, I can conclude one of two things...

a) The Riddler has different ways to go about his targeting, with different effects

or

b) You're lying.

What I won't do is waste my vote on you each day if nobody else is seeing a baddie Turnip, but based on your refusal to answer my questions, if you get suspected later down the line and start catching votes, I will definitely add on then.

In the mean time, carry on "not caring". Derp.

Linki - Dom, I don't get what you're saying there. sabie didn't have a high post count either. And which one of "those players" are you referring to, all the ones I mentioned plus the ones not directly mentioned from "the list goes on" ?

Linki - Dom, Mac said I hadn't had any interaction with sabie, who was a low poster, so I brought up the names of other players who are low posters as well and were not at all on my radar. And those aren't the only players that I have not had any interaction with either. Would you like me to ISO myself and give you a comprehensive list of every player I haven't interacted with?

Btw, in case you hadn't noticed, my first two or three day day phases here were pretty "busy", and I was concerned with other happenings in the thread.

Turnip, a few questions

1) A few days ago, I believe you answered someone's question about the Riddler, saying there was no time frame in which to answer the riddle. Can you expand on this please?

2) How many times have you attempted to answer the riddle?

3) During your most recent day experience, did you have a certain goal to accomplish along with the curse?

Thank you

Nice job on sabie peeps.

Mac, you're right that I hadn't interacted with sabie, but the same could be said about me and Bass, Floyd, Bubbles, Equivocate, the list goes on.

Also, my vote wasn't a "drive by", I've been suss of Mac for days. I believe I voted for him two day phases ago and last day phase I voted MP because nobody seemed to be interested in a Mac lynch and at the time, I preferred an MP lynch over a Glorfy lynch. Now that I know better about Mac, I'll stop looking that way obviously. Btw, icing Zebra two games in a row? Hardcore dude :P

In light of Mac's hint, I'm feeling slightly better on Turnip. Slightly.

I think Turnip is super sketch and want to vote for him today, but I don't think anyone else in the game is even looking at him. So I'll add one more to the Mac vote.

Off to work, good luck town!

Turnip Head wrote:Chrysanthemums warming radiated.

Interesting, my second day posting funny also enabled me a way to try and find a certain inmate.

Your second day doesn't appear to do that.

I still think you could be faking.

Scotty wrote:

Matt wrote:

Scotty wrote:This also isn't damning or anything because it was two different teams, but I found slightly coincidental: the last person both bea and sig addressed was Glorfindel.

Oh, a theory!

Harvey "Glorfy" Dent held bea hostage last night, and someone targeted Glorfy for a NK.

you solved it Matt. Good work everyone. We can go home

Scotty wrote:This also isn't damning or anything because it was two different teams, but I found slightly coincidental: the last person both bea and sig addressed was Glorfindel.

Oh, a theory!

Harvey "Glorfy" Dent held bea hostage last night, and someone targeted Glorfy for a NK.

RIP bea

That's pretty hardcore to nuke bea the same night she was up for the Spirit Award @ #sockyawards

To Scotty and others who haven't played with 2-Face, he is always this polite. Always.

Bullzeye wrote:

Matt wrote:

Bullzeye wrote:Actually I just realised you spent a significant portion of day 2 repeating the word knock twice in every post. Matt = Two Face confirmed.

That's not at all the same thing I found from Glor's posts and you know it.

I just don't understand why someone would put so much effort into dropping a ton of hints that they're a role who wins with the baddies 50% of the time. Nor do I see why someone would go to that much effort to role hint full stop. It's just ridiculous. If Glorfindel really is Two-Face and really did decide to drop a ton of 'two' related hints then I wish I had his amount of motivation, dedication, and spare time.

I'm not claiming to give you the "why", but I don't think it's just coincidence that 5 out of his first 10 posts include a "hint", then later he quotes someone simply saying "Seconded", and even later still makes another "hint" with the coin flip thing.

Could be coincidence, maybe it is.

Linki - But Two Face can essentially win with anyone, and is not LMS, so it's not the same thing.