Pirate Mafia [END GAME]

#1001

Eyyy we just passed post #1000. We did it gang.

#1002

Oh Monday and Tuesday will also be mega busy to me so apology if I fail to catch up and vote. I'll be back on Day 4.

#1003

For the sake of posterity, here's yar Day 2 poll. Now back below decks with ye all. The sun be a league behind tonight, so we've got another hour to spare before we begin again. Arrrgh.

Day 2 poll:

Spoiler: show

#1004

On surface level, DDL, Quin, and Dunya don't look great on the lynch poll. If I have everything correct.

I might would put sig and DDL anti-aligned considering that.

I dunno. MP was such a suspect going into D2 that nobody looked good on the lynch poll. Hard to do vote analysis when there is no indecision around it. Could be that MP's death was the result of an enthyusiastic bus from LC, Spacedaisy... In my experience, it's around vote 4 that the scum start hopping on, but this might be the exception.

Remember, someone might die tonight. Get your thoughts into the thread in the next hour if you can.

#1005

I feel like my suspicions are mainly the same, and well-known enough. I'm really hoping that the Civ power role(s) can get some good info - we're off to a great start, nailing a baddie with no info.

#1006

You did Cap'n Sloonbeard proud yesterday. I thought I'd reward ye today, but instead I had a little fright this mornin'. Our dear buccaneer Long Con was found dangling from the mast, as lifeless as me wooden leg. There's no doubt those salty mutineers did this to get back at me and me crew. Arr. A gold doubloon to any lad who helps catch one of their lot today.

Long Con has been killed. He was...

Spoiler: show

It is Day 3. You will have 48 hours to make somebody walk the plank.

#1007

Attention crew: SpankGangsta was dropped off at the last port. His place has been filled by Jackofhearts2005.

#1008

Welcome Jack

#1009

My biggest supporter got night killed. Oh, woe is me.

#1010

hi jack

#1011

RIP LC.

Hi Jack

#1012

RIP LC, you will be avenged

#1013

Welcome Jack

Quin, who are your current suspects?

#1014

MP is still on the poll. I reckon we should lynch him again.

#1015

speedchuck wrote: ↑Mon Nov 06, 2017 11:20 am MP is still on the poll. I reckon we should lynch him again.

SQUAAAWWWK fix the poll fix the poll walk the plank hoist the sails scandalous scandalous

#1016

speedchuck wrote: ↑Mon Nov 06, 2017 11:20 am MP is still on the poll. I reckon we should lynch him again.

#1017

Whose timbers need shivering?

Internet Service Providers (host/dead/non)

Can I vote this option like 9001 times please? Too true.

#1018

I guess the main question of the day is, why didn't a baddie-motivated MP just vote to kill Quin so he could survive for himself and also his team?

#1019

MovingPictures07 wrote: ↑Mon Nov 06, 2017 11:58 am Whose timbers need shivering?

Internet Service Providers (host/dead/non)

Can I vote this option like 9001 times please? Too true.

Sure, blame it on your isp.

#1020

Kylemii wrote: ↑Mon Nov 06, 2017 4:14 pm I guess the main question of the day is, why didn't a baddie-motivated MP just vote to kill Quin so he could survive for himself and also his team?

Talking about D1 here, right?

I don't know. Even if it wouldn't have worked with his reads very well, voting for self-pres gives him at least another assured day. There's no reason D1 should have ended in a three way tie.

And he moved to Wilgy at the last second, not Quin.

I've got a town read on Quin, but that don't look good.

#1021

speedchuck wrote: ↑Mon Nov 06, 2017 4:54 pm
Kylemii wrote: ↑Mon Nov 06, 2017 4:14 pm I guess the main question of the day is, why didn't a baddie-motivated MP just vote to kill Quin so he could survive for himself and also his team?
Talking about D1 here, right?

I don't know. Even if it wouldn't have worked with his reads very well, voting for self-pres gives him at least another assured day. There's no reason D1 should have ended in a three way tie.

And he moved to Wilgy at the last second, not Quin.

I've got a town read on Quin, but that don't look good.

What are you referring to here?

#1022

Howdy.

26 pages? I better get to reading. I'll catch up sooner than later but I wouldn't say no to a summary of the game so far.

#1023

So far, I'm town reading LC and Doc and I'm almost certain Map is bad.

#1024

#1025

Complaints:
People not calling their votes since polls aren't in order anymore.

Epi said a bad word.

#1026

Jackofhearts2005 wrote: ↑Mon Nov 06, 2017 6:03 pm Complaints:
People not calling their votes since polls aren't in order anymore.

Epi said a bad word.

Fucking right??????

#1027

It's kind of hard to summarize.... A lot of stuff happened day 1 which resulted in about 3 different ties that eventually resolved in DrWilgy being lynched 'because he talked weird'. We lynched MP day 2 and he was a mutineer. There's a lot more nuance to it than that though and I'd be curious to hear your input, Jack.

I think the general consensus is that we'll probably be able to find a teammate of MP's by analyzing the day 1 and day 2 lynches cus that's how the game mafia works.

#1028

or at least that's what I think, maybe others disagree

#1029

Kylemii wrote: ↑Mon Nov 06, 2017 5:12 pm
speedchuck wrote: ↑Mon Nov 06, 2017 4:54 pm
Kylemii wrote: ↑Mon Nov 06, 2017 4:14 pm I guess the main question of the day is, why didn't a baddie-motivated MP just vote to kill Quin so he could survive for himself and also his team?
Talking about D1 here, right?

I don't know. Even if it wouldn't have worked with his reads very well, voting for self-pres gives him at least another assured day. There's no reason D1 should have ended in a three way tie.

And he moved to Wilgy at the last second, not Quin.

I've got a town read on Quin, but that don't look good.
What are you referring to here?

3 way lynch tie on D1.

After the deadline (but before the mod post), MP moved to vote Wilgy.

#1030

speedchuck wrote: ↑Mon Nov 06, 2017 6:41 pm
Kylemii wrote: ↑Mon Nov 06, 2017 5:12 pm
speedchuck wrote: ↑Mon Nov 06, 2017 4:54 pm
Kylemii wrote: ↑Mon Nov 06, 2017 4:14 pm I guess the main question of the day is, why didn't a baddie-motivated MP just vote to kill Quin so he could survive for himself and also his team?
Talking about D1 here, right?

I don't know. Even if it wouldn't have worked with his reads very well, voting for self-pres gives him at least another assured day. There's no reason D1 should have ended in a three way tie.

And he moved to Wilgy at the last second, not Quin.

I've got a town read on Quin, but that don't look good.
What are you referring to here?
3 way lynch tie on D1.

After the deadline (but before the mod post), MP moved to vote Wilgy.

I was talking about earlier when the lynch was a 3 way tie between quin, MP, and.... Spankgansta I think? before you suggested Dr.Wilgy.

#1031

[mention]Spacedaisy[/mention] Do you think MP was so busy he didn't have time to submit the night kill?

If MP didn't submit the kill at all, I think its possible the other two team members are/were inactive. However, for now I'll most likely be voting for Quin. I always found it a bit odd neither voted for the other when they were tied. Especially since MP did a whole ISO of Quin yet somehow redirected the lynch away from him altogether. However, the other thing that's really bothering me is why didn't MP switch his vote off of DDL? He could've switched to Wilgy and yes it would've been wrong but he wouldn't have risked being lynched. I wouldn't put it outside of the realm of possibility for DDL and MP to be a team, but that would also require a large amount of risk on their part so I'll shelf that for a bit.

I'm a little lost on the third potential mafia member, perhaps speed or someone on the MP wagon, but I feel like with such a small mafia team they'd try to avoid voting for each other, which is why i think it is possible for one of the two inactive players to be mafia. However, I'd rather hold off on lynching them and go for Quin right now.

#1032

immediate self-preservation can kiss my ass, sig.
MP didn't redirect the lynch; it takes two to tango, sig.
Top suspects don't get to redirect lynches, sig.
You should look into who fell in with MP's chaos, sig.
He did move his vote, it just wasn't in time, sig.
you suck, sig.

#1033

Kylemii wrote: ↑Mon Nov 06, 2017 6:44 pm
speedchuck wrote: ↑Mon Nov 06, 2017 6:41 pm
Kylemii wrote: ↑Mon Nov 06, 2017 5:12 pm
speedchuck wrote: ↑Mon Nov 06, 2017 4:54 pm
Kylemii wrote: ↑Mon Nov 06, 2017 4:14 pm I guess the main question of the day is, why didn't a baddie-motivated MP just vote to kill Quin so he could survive for himself and also his team?
Talking about D1 here, right?

I don't know. Even if it wouldn't have worked with his reads very well, voting for self-pres gives him at least another assured day. There's no reason D1 should have ended in a three way tie.

And he moved to Wilgy at the last second, not Quin.

I've got a town read on Quin, but that don't look good.
What are you referring to here?
3 way lynch tie on D1.

After the deadline (but before the mod post), MP moved to vote Wilgy.
I was talking about earlier when the lynch was a 3 way tie between quin, MP, and.... Spankgansta I think? before you suggested Dr.Wilgy.

Oh.

Well I'm talking about a later time when he still didn't vote Quin.

#1034

sig wrote: ↑Mon Nov 06, 2017 6:56 pm @Spacedaisy Do you think MP was so busy he didn't have time to submit the night kill?

If MP didn't submit the kill at all, I think its possible the other two team members are/were inactive. However, for now I'll most likely be voting for Quin. I always found it a bit odd neither voted for the other when they were tied. Especially since MP did a whole ISO of Quin yet somehow redirected the lynch away from him altogether. However, the other thing that's really bothering me is why didn't MP switch his vote off of DDL? He could've switched to Wilgy and yes it would've been wrong but he wouldn't have risked being lynched. I wouldn't put it outside of the realm of possibility for DDL and MP to be a team, but that would also require a large amount of risk on their part so I'll shelf that for a bit.

I'm a little lost on the third potential mafia member, perhaps speed or someone on the MP wagon, but I feel like with such a small mafia team they'd try to avoid voting for each other, which is why i think it is possible for one of the two inactive players to be mafia. However, I'd rather hold off on lynching them and go for Quin right now.

I doubt the highlighted very much. And I find it suspect for you to be suggesting it honestly.

As far as MP and Quin, my immediate reaction after the lynch was I could see them as teammates. I'm torn right now frankly. I can see it two ways. MP never hesitates to bus his teammates when it's needed. So the fact he was so hesitant to vote Quin is weird. It could be that he was trying to actually substantiate it somehow to make a case against Quin. Or it could have been that Quin is his teammate and he wanted to have a better case than just a self preservation vote because it would make MP look even better if Quin was lynched and flipped bad. Or because he wanted his hesitance to be read as Quin being his teammate.

In the end the 3 way tie was between DDL, MP and Wilgy. Frankly, the Day 1 action now knowing MPs alignment makes me feel more like I was wrong about DDL. I think he is civ now.

I apologize for being quieter but I have had a very rough few days that had me extremely anxious. And bwt is visiting now, Sokoth is coming in tonight, my sister is coming in Friday. My activity right now will be a little low, but I am following around and going to do my best to still be somewhat active.

#1035

Quin wrote: ↑Sun Oct 29, 2017 9:02 pm
sig wrote: ↑Sun Oct 29, 2017 7:50 pm Tequila really sucks 4/10 wouldn't recommend.

Second Hey! Lets get this lynch train started.

I think we should eye people who are to heavy on the role play, it could be used to avoid scumhunting/be left alive out of amusement. However, that shouldn't be the only reason to lynch someone.
I think you should have said that after the people worth eyeing had already shown themselves

^What means this, Quin?

#1036

Dah One

MP: Sig said we should lynch heavy roleplayers because roleplaying could be an excuse to avoid scumhunting and nightkills. Therefore, good first look for Sig.

MP: I'm gonna take LC's no lynch joke too seriously and vote for him. (Of course, we know LC was good.)

MP: Agree with Quin (whatever Quin meant) but Wuin doesn't use that to develop a Sig read. (Stops short of using that to develop a Quin read.)

MP: Votes Quin asking what is on his mind but reiterates need for LC to answer.

Speed: Cause math, going no lynch is okay. (Aha! But you should go no lynch late in the game in this scenario, not early. That's a ping. Speedchuck and I mindmeld on strategery so he should know better if he's town.)

Quin: I tend to tunnel Sig so no read off one post. (Fair.) Also, no lynch is a good strategy. (noooope)

Kyle: Blah blah dags (Unhelpful imo but I don't know Kyle enough to say if this is alignment indicative.

DDL: No lynch is bad! (As expected. DDL is another player that would have pinged me if he disagreed with me early on this.)

#1037

Dah One Par Two

Quin: Speedchuck is town for suggesting no lynch. (Hmm. I don't think Quin and Speed are teammates.)

Dunya: Rwar rwar MP (possible distancing. Call it a quarter ping) Also misinterprets LC's no lynch joke.

Quin: You could assume I badish read Sig

Dunya: Can't read yer mind, Quin

Kyle: Asks about Quin's meta

Dunya: Waffles on no lynch but mostly against.

Speed: Sorta walks back his initial pro no lynch stance, reiterating a potential doc/block save (this looks better) Further clarifies to totally against a no lynch. (Hmm)

Dunya/Quin: LC is good because we didn't get that he was joking.

#1038

Back to work.

Next time on "Jack finds the bad guys"

LC's big post on page 3

#1039

Work is stupid. Lazy people need to be fired.

#1040

Jackofhearts2005 wrote: ↑Tue Nov 07, 2017 11:32 amKyle: Blah blah dags (Unhelpful imo but I don't know Kyle enough to say if this is alignment indicative.

Hurtful.

#1041

#1042

LC: Speed is probably bad cause he's trying to hard. DDL is bad cause buddying LC (tend to disagree). Quin is maaaybe bad cause ??? DDL is extra bad for saying don't go no lynch (disagree, that's a DDLish thing to say), blah blah Quin and Dunya. Vote DDL

Sig: Blah blah null (like the rest of the Sig posts so far. Could be worse.)

Kyle: I want reads from xyz (good look)

MP: I agree with Future Jack about Quin not wanting to tunnel Sig is fair (this should not be forgotten when trying to tie or untie Quin to/from MP later but doesn't do much in isolation) blah blah I like Quin. Dunya, why is LC good?

Wilgy: And now for my best Rico impersonation! Wolves is MP and Speed.

MP: Don't be Rico

Wilgy: You aren't my supervisor (Wilgy is town. Sorry if that gets you killed again.)

MP: I disagree with the "trying too hard" case on Speed and can't even the case on DDL

Sig: Let's lynch somebody else other than Speed....LC, why do you think Speed is bad? (lolwut?)

#1043

MP: Kyle, Wilgy, Sig, Speed are town. Probably Dunya (leaves out Quin) Vote Daisy (lolwut?)

Kyle: Speed seems authentic

@Quin You are 8 FFs ahead of me.

DDL: Vote Sig for asking the cop to claim (potential distraction but this could also be legit. Blah blah normal DDL blah.

LC: Sig is supabad cause meta and not bad with Speed cause veiled accusation

Wilgy: DDL voted Sig....

Sig: LC is bad (no) and asking cop who finds baddies to claim is fair (yes) (feels like he's softclaiming cop tbh)

Speed: Too many scumreads from MP. LC is no fear contributing so he's good. (Agree on both counts)

Wilgy: Town is me, LC, Sig, Dunya. Wolves is MP, Speed. Quin and DDL are null.

Kyle: Busdrive reads, please. (Townie here)

#1044

Reads so far:
Kyle, Wilgy supatown
Would eat my hat if Speed, Sig, DDL, Quin all townies. Generally read that list as bad to good with some no w/w in the middle

#1045

Dunya: Kyle bad for reasons

Speed: Wolves are Sig, Kyle or DDL....jk DDL is good. Vote Siiiiiig. (Sig/DDL probably not W/W)

DDL: Trading cop for goon is a bad idea (disagree)

Dunya: rwar

#1046

Is this a play?

#1047

Kylemii wrote: ↑Tue Nov 07, 2017 1:05 pm
Jackofhearts2005 wrote: ↑Tue Nov 07, 2017 11:32 amKyle: Blah blah dags (Unhelpful imo but I don't know Kyle enough to say if this is alignment indicative.
Hurtful.

agreed. Another dog basher like MP and look how MP flipped.

#1048

tentative vote on Quin since he was #3 of my suspect list while I catch up.

#1049

I'm here but I'm mega tired after traveling 800 km in two days.

I'll refrain from voting unless I need to vote to avoid being lynched. I don't trust my head to make hard decisions now.

#1050

Actually you know what, I was suspecting Quin after the lynch and I see people wanna lynch him so I'll just sheep on that.

Later.

Arrrrrrrrrrr and stuff