dunya wrote: ↑Wed Sep 20, 2017 6:23 pm
well, it's past midnight here and i have work tomorrow early AM but I read through the entire thread. reading individual posts of the survivors doesnt really give much context or clues and I'd probably just be a burden (i did skip a bit of Epi and LC drama at the beginning).
It's extremely hard to read Serge and NewTraditionaluist due to the low post counts, but I don't get negative feelings from Dom or MP.
nutella....I feel a lot of posts and reactions were insincere. I am voting for them based on intuition mostly at this point, because I cant really go through and make a case for her.
I genuinely feel Dom's not likely to be the last scum, as much as I feel MP seems to be Town with his musings, and questioning and general emotions.
my list from bad to good goes something like this
nutella
NewTraditionalist
Serge
Dom
MP
me of course
i'll go get ready for bed then get on my phone and see if I can offer some more substance to my vote in time, but I wanted to offer SOME input before deadline. I'll be able to be more active now that I'm caught up in the future
Holy cow, you're a fast reader.
I appreciate your input, thanks.
Honestly, I've had my doubts about nutella off and on all game but she felt pretty sincere to me during the end of N1.
With that said, I do feel like many of us have been giving her too much credit for her suspicion of DDL. It's abundantly clear that sanmateo was bussing DDL hard, so why is it so hard to believe that nutella was bussing him as well? Furthermore, she was not the first person to suspect him and, as I pointed earlier, her suspicion of her was very vague and lacking detail. It was even lacking passion as well IMO, despite the fact that she labeled him a 'top suspect', which if I recall correctly Sloonei criticized her for earlier in the game as well.
Further, as the game has progressed the past couple of cycles, her posts have completely lacked any purpose or spark to them. Dom's have similarly been underwhelming but underlying them is this very consistent feeling of honesty, which is why I started interrogating Sloonei pretty heavily last cycle.
I am also increasingly reminded of other games I played and hosted, most notably Economics for the former and Parks and Recreation for the latter, where the low hanging fruit townie was specifically set up to be around for MYLO. And despite incredible efforts on the part of town to investigate everyone otherwise, that townie was still mislynched to end the game both times. In this game, I feel like Dom is that townie, and nutella is the only player remaining that I think would fit the profile of leaving him around for the express purpose of being mislynched. I previously thought that might have been Sloonei, to no avail. It also explains why I was left alive in favor of Daisy because I was jumping up and down wanting to lynch Dom before the Night concluded.
Lastly, I'm in part trusting your judgment. I still suspect Dom and I'm pretty torn between the two, but I think even before you said anything I was starting to come around to a nutella lynch. Let's do this.
I'd love to hear what nutella has to say to any of this. When putting Dom to the fire, at least he has been able to attempt
something. I've not seen anything from nutella in cycles.