[TREE MAFIA] Spectator Chat

#51

Enrique wrote:what a load of bullshit

I think I would have voted FZ but I don't understand how wilgy can get away with anything!

#52

Sorry Enrique.

I did not see that coming at all.

#53

Ricochet wrote:Enrique just stated his intentions depend on Wilgy's flip, so a dead player would emerge before a possible substitution.

Idk I still feel the substitute (whether he actively spectated in here or happened to perouse the chatter) would go inside the game with a little extra mindset, even if begign tidbits. A sub civ could have in mind what spectators found fishy, not just what has been discussed in-game, and work the extra stuff into the game. A sub mafia would still have to adopt the team's tactics and goals, I suppose.

I had 0 intentions of subbing out because I knew there was no way he would get killed.

oh my god did that actually just happen. where did mp's flip even come from??

#54

Who do you think is bad, enrique?

#55

Golden wrote:Who do you think is bad, enrique?

Wilgy most of all.

Diiny and FZ are still very worth looking into.

I was counting on Diiny being lynched and I would've ID'd either FZ or motel room while the thread focused on DrWilgy being such a terrible liar.

#56

Well, this game has already eclipsed Pet Sounds in terms of post count.

Let's see if we can catch Talking Heads. Go team!

#57

What has town done?

#58

Turnip Head wrote:What has town done?

Eliminated two separate potential paradigms early. All part of the plan.

#59

Golden wrote:
Turnip Head wrote:What has town done?
Eliminated two separate potential paradigms early. All part of the plan.

#60

Hey guys, I think Enrique was the cop!

Hi Enrique. OMG the cop got btfo for a second consecutive game. Even worse, this time.

If Wilgy and JJJ aren't bad, then je ne sais quoi...

Also, dat "post once during the Night" rule fail... Hard time for our Marshy host.

Metalmarsh89 wrote:Well, this game has already eclipsed Pet Sounds in terms of post count.

Let's see if we can catch Talking Heads. Go team!

JJJ is only the 5th highest poster, even one place behind the late Enrique. Further proof of scummimninness.

#61

Ricochet wrote:Also, dat "post once during the Night" rule fail... Hard time for our Marshy host.

Ugh, lol. Mac wasn't really a fan of the rule, but I reminded him that mafia can't chat during the day, so it is fair in that respect.

Considering this "reaction to lynch post" thing was something I had never seen until I played at RYM, I'm surprised that it's the RYM folks who have trouble following it.

#62

So I guess Mac is confirmed town, lol.

#63

... I'm sorry Sorsha, I'm dumb.

#64

You did the right thing, Enrique. There may have been a doctor in the house, at least it creates wifom about whether or not that is the safe kill...

#65

Epig better be bad or I just don't get what he's looking to achieve by tunnelling this hard.

#66

tfw Marsh isn't writing TIMBER into his Posts every time a civ goes down

#67

Timmer isn't even playing.

#68

Enrique wrote:... I'm sorry Sorsha, I'm dumb.

No, you made the right call revealing Sorsha, I believe.

With Sorsha being a confirmed civilian, mafia is forced to make a choice for their nightkill with the possibility of a doctor in play. Do they kill the confirmed civ, or do they go elsewhere. I realize this makes the hypothetical doctor make a choice too, but the doctor has only two real options at this point, him/herself and the player you confirmed.

It doesn't hurt the civilians terribly if the doctor makes the wrong call (considering that the likelihood of their even being a doctor is only 50%), but it does hurt mafia if they make the wrong call, and nobody is killed. It tells everyone that there is a doctor, and it puts them behind from a numbers perspective, forcing an extra day phase.

Now of course mafia could choose to not kill, but clearly that didn't happen, and they would still put themselves behind by doing so. :P

#69

Marmot... taking 9 hours and 4 paragraphs to say what I said immediately in one line

#70

If Wilgy is not bad, then je ne sais encore quoi.

I don't think there's a doctor (role) in the game.

#71

I'm all good with a JJJ lynch.

I already told him if he wasn't signed up for 91 when I was ready, I would arrange for a marmot modkill.

#72

Prediction: Epi is bad.

Epi, Wilgy + one.

There is nothing anyone could say today to get me to vote for anyone but Wilgy. I would never be able to trust him.

#73

Golden wrote:Marmot... taking 9 hours and 4 paragraphs to say what I said immediately in one line

Sorry, busy getting Smashfest ready so I can kick your butt this season. :P

#74

You guys will understand if I feel bad Sorsha just died because of me

But yeah, I guess it was the right thing to do.

#75

Golden...taking 3 days and 14 hours to reach the same baddies I called out on page one.

#76

Ricochet wrote:Golden...taking 3 days and 14 hours to reach the same baddies I called out on page one.

#77

I think FZ is bad.

#78

Turnip Head wrote:I think FZ is bad.

Thats what I was thinking from very early. Could still be true.

#79

#80

lol Sorsha

FZ and JJJ are baddies 2gether 4ever

#81

Sorsha wrote:

I love it!

#82

Sorry. I'm on Team "we need more pianos in this world".

#83

MP's step-by-step replies ugh. him not doing wall-o-text syntheses might be a sign he's a baddie.

Golden has more posts that DFaraday in the game.

#84

He has fewer posts than me in this thread, though.

Also, how the heck did nobody use the barking up the wrong tree expression so far? Didn't anyone learn, since THM, that putting in-theme lines in your rebuttals is the key to your success in a game? (...assuming you also survive up to three lynch ties in the process, of course...)

#85

lol rico. I always try to do terrible in-theme puns.

#86

Ricochet wrote:He has fewer posts than me in this thread, though.

Also, how the heck did nobody use the barking up the wrong tree expression so far? Didn't anyone learn, since THM, that putting in-theme lines in your rebuttals is the key to your success in a game? (...assuming you also survive up to three lynch ties in the process, of course...)

I've firgotten to make more terrible puns myself.

#87

I bet I could still beech you in terrible tree puns though. :P

#88

Four hours till EoD = nope

Brace yourselves for 7pm ET deadlines, tops, when I'll be hosting, btw.

Or else brace yourselves for me falling asleep on the job.

Actually, just combine both of those in the expectations category.

#89

I know for a fact that yew can consistantly stay up late for mafia. :P

#90

Metalmarsh89 wrote:I know for a fact that yew can consistantly stay up late for mafia. :P

Doesn't mean I axed for it.

#91

RIP DrWilgy, who is most definitely a doctor with a hint of vanilla.

#92

Rip me! Hello ghosts and friends! It seems y'all thought I was bad!

#93

Wilgy, how is it possible that you are civilian! Lol!

Oh my, so many people around here do fake doctor gambits that get the doctor killed

#94

This is a common occurrence? Why? Do cops not trust their team that much?

#95

DrWilgy wrote:This is a common occurrence? Why? Do cops not trust their team that much?

No, it's just the way the gambit plays out ends up with the doctor dead. It is really a dig at MP's suicidal moron gambit lol. He'll see this later

I could see your move from a civ perspective, it made sense, but the bit where I thought you were bad was when Enrique got lynched afterwards. Then I thought your gambit was to draw out the real cop and kill em, and I thought you must be bad.

#96

Nah, it was just as I said. I expected cop to chill till they had some reads, and found Enrique who was obviously hiding something. Not knowing whether or not cop was even an active role made me think he was hiding scummiphoonies

#97

I didn't think you were bad Wilgyboy

My money's on JJJ an FZ, and maybe Sock.

#98

DrWilgy wrote:Nah, it was just as I said. I expected cop to chill till they had some reads, and found Enrique who was obviously hiding something. Not knowing whether or not cop was even an active role made me think he was hiding scummiphoonies

That... is a very good point.

I wondered why you went hard after him when he turned on you. I forgot that not everyone knew that a cop was in the game.

Nub host.

#99

Hey guys, I think Wilgy was not bad after all...

#100

Hi.

Uhm...

What's shakin'?

Bye.

Full Games	Civilian: Mafia: Independent:
Speed Games	Civilian: Fiddler on the Roof Mafia:
Heists	Civilian: MVP: RED vs BLUE
Burglaries	Independent: The Theme Is Literally a Burglary
Special Games	Civilian: Independent:

Full Games	Civilian: Mafia: Independent:
Speed Games	Civilian: Fiddler on the Roof Mafia:
Heists	Civilian: MVP: RED vs BLUE
Burglaries	Independent: The Theme Is Literally a Burglary
Special Games	Civilian: Independent:

Full Games	Civilian: Mafia: Independent:
Speed Games	Civilian: Fiddler on the Roof Mafia:
Heists	Civilian: MVP: RED vs BLUE
Burglaries	Independent: The Theme Is Literally a Burglary
Special Games	Civilian: Independent:

Full Games	Civilian: Mafia: Independent:
Speed Games	Civilian: Fiddler on the Roof Mafia:
Heists	Civilian: MVP: RED vs BLUE
Burglaries	Independent: The Theme Is Literally a Burglary
Special Games	Civilian: Independent:

Full Games	Civilian: Mafia: Independent:
Speed Games	Civilian: Fiddler on the Roof Mafia:
Heists	Civilian: MVP: RED vs BLUE
Burglaries	Independent: The Theme Is Literally a Burglary
Special Games	Civilian: Independent:

2014 Sockys
2015 Sockys
Miscellaneous

2014 Sockys
2015 Sockys
Miscellaneous

2014 Sockys
2015 Sockys
Miscellaneous

2014 Sockys
2015 Sockys
Miscellaneous