Zodiac Mafia - Discussion Thread

#81

Epignosis wrote:If I'm remotely right about the setup of this game, I think my best shot at surviving a lynch is to pretend I won't be lynched.

You see, it's true that I've only ever been lynched six times in my life (three good, three bad, if you were wondering). That's from years of active playing.

But I've been Night killed more times than I can count. I almost never make it to endgame.

G-Man freely cast aside his protection. I would not do so- I would attempt to save myself in order to keep from being night killed (which is what always happens to me).

So it may be best to frame it that way, and if enough civilians also have these protections, they might buy what I'm selling and leave me alone.

Long shot, but hell.

You may as well try. You're currently the top lynch priority from what I can tell so it's go big or go home.

#82

By the way, if there ever comes a point where you see a lynch bandwagon coming for me (especially if I still have my immunity) don't have reservations about jumping on it.

#83

If there's two bad teams who each kill each night will we inherit their kill if they are eliminated?

lol

I don't care who we NK btw

#84

Quin will kill sig.

I assume from last night's discussion, we're cool with that.

#85

Thanks. Your kill is noted.

#86

Epignosis wrote:Quin will kill sig.

I assume from last night's discussion, we're cool with that.

I don't mind.

#87

hey hosties

are you going to tell us if a team is eliminated, if there is more than one team?

#88

Sorsha wrote:hey hosties

are you going to tell us if a team is eliminated, if there is more than one team?

Sounds like a question for general consumption for everyone. I'll answer there if you ask it there

#89

Sorsha wrote:hey hosties

are you going to tell us if a team is eliminated, if there is more than one team?

i thought you posted this on the game thread for a second

linki: that would be a major giveaway imho

#90

Indeed. But I can't give anyone an advantage. So if you want an answer, you'll have to figure out how to get it in a non-suspicious way.

#91

Dafuq is this game

#92

As stated in the night post, Quin's protection has been used. He is equivalent to the rest of his teammates now.

#93

Do you think that there are three mafia teams? Could it be some sort of starsign compatibility thing?

Could hosts confirm whether our starsigns impact the game in any way?

#94

Whatever the setup, I think it may be wise to consider us all voting together since we have our numbers.

#95

Quin wrote:Do you think that there are three mafia teams? Could it be some sort of starsign compatibility thing?

Could hosts confirm whether our starsigns impact the game in any way?

Four teams of three each?

#96

Epignosis wrote:Whatever the setup, I think it may be wise to consider us all voting together since we have our numbers.

That's true. Who would you recommend?

#97

Sorsha wrote:
Quin wrote:Do you think that there are three mafia teams? Could it be some sort of starsign compatibility thing?

Could hosts confirm whether our starsigns impact the game in any way?
Four teams of three each?

Math doesn't check out. G-Man was a civilian. So they say.

#98

Sorsha wrote:
Quin wrote:Do you think that there are three mafia teams? Could it be some sort of starsign compatibility thing?

Could hosts confirm whether our starsigns impact the game in any way?
Four teams of three each?

It is completely unreasonable, but it explains three kills each night.

Both sloonei and G-Man had 1-time immunities, so we could assume the other 2 living civ's have the same ability. That, and having three teams killing eachother during night phases might balance that out. That's what I think, anyway.

#99

Quin wrote:
Epignosis wrote:Whatever the setup, I think it may be wise to consider us all voting together since we have our numbers.
That's true. Who would you recommend?

I agree too. There are only 7 players left, we'd only need to swing one of them assuming the votes all go to two players.

We might have to do some last minute switching again.

#100

Quin wrote:
Epignosis wrote:Whatever the setup, I think it may be wise to consider us all voting together since we have our numbers.
That's true. Who would you recommend?

Bullzeye or thellama73. sig gave them both a pass. Bullzeye doesn't like to tangle with me when he is bad and llama has been hounding me for poor reasons. Both of them could go in light of sig showing up bad.

I think this past night was a huge shove in the right direction for us.

I wish I could give a girl a huge shove with my pelvic region.

Or a huge shove down a flight of stairs.

#101

Llama might go after Nero or daisy today which we could just go with too.

#102

I don't think llama would be a good choice for me, since I've claimed I read him town quite a few times. It might be a bit sketchy.

#103

Quin wrote:I don't think llama would be a good choice for me, since I've claimed I read him town quite a few times. It might be a bit sketchy.

It's amazing that we are all in one piece. We could either go for one guy (Bullz) or set up a dichotomy between Bullz and Nero. I favor the first route, but am not averse to the second.

#104

I'm surprised I haven't screwed up yet. But we could do either, as long as it doesn't look like we're sheeping eachother so obviously.

#105

Quin wrote:I'm surprised I haven't screwed up yet. But we could do either, as long as it doesn't look like we're sheeping eachother so obviously.

I'm going to pound Bullz and Nero to make it look like the "town" (whatever that is now

) has only those two options.

#106

Also, setting up Bullz and Nero would likely force the two of them to have to vote each other. Tactic as old as the hills.

#107

As long as llama doesn't stick to you like he has been. I don't even remember what it was that started it.

#108

Quin wrote:As long as llama doesn't stick to you like he has been. I don't even remember what it was that started it.

With Wilgy and sig flipping bad, he's going to have no chance of getting me lynched now without looking bad.

I'm trying to set up the Bullz / Nero dilemma. thellama73 has added spacedaisy to the mix, which is fine too. I'm liking the opening of this day.

#109

Llama has been wording things like there is more than one Mafia team. Not sure if that's significant or if I should bring it up.

If you were a civ in this game would you be thinking two Mafia teams or that it's one team with more than 3 players at this point?

#110

Sorsha wrote:Llama has been wording things like there is more than one Mafia team. Not sure if that's significant or if I should bring it up.

If you were a civ in this game would you be thinking two Mafia teams or that it's one team with more than 3 players at this point?

I couldn't say for sure but I'd know that there is something 'weird' going on. I would've ruled out a single large mafia team because it doesn't explain all the night kills.

I legitimately think llama is town at this point.

#111

If we assume there are two mafia teams of 3 and a serial killer then at this point we've eliminated the second mafia team. It should be that only two people die tonight following that. It's likely I'll be killed tonight because my protection is definitely gone. It could also be Nero, unless he's the one with the killing ability.

I would suggest killing bullzeye tonight. The bandwagon is leaving on him and it might become hard to lynch him later on. It really depends.

#112

Bullz or llama. I know llama says he'd survive once but if the SK targets him too tonight he'd die. Plus it would put him a step closer to being likable. Or maybe he is the SK

#113

I never had a mafia read on llama but he is my top candidate for who I think the last killer is. Whether that be serial killer or ninja is still TBD.

#114

What do you think about Nero's claim of ignorance as to why he didn't die? I don't see any reason why he would lie about it.

#115

I don't know why he would lie about it either, but it's weird he doesn't know why. Unless there is a power for a lynch save out there.

#116

I think bullzeye might be helpful in getting nero lynched, so I think we should leave him alone.

Should we risk killing llama and either getting rid of his defence or getting rid of him?

#117

I agree. I think it's got to be llama or spacedaisy.

#118

I don't think anybody is ever going to want llama lynched. Whether you want to keep him until the end or kill him, I don't mind. At this point I doubt there's a tracker mixed in but I'll still do the kill, whoever our target may be.

#119

I vote for a shot at llama

#120

Quin kills thellama73.

#121

Epignosis wrote:Quin kills thellama73.

#122

Confirmed! Thank you guys. And gals!

#123

In case I die I figured I'd provide my thoughts on roles and stuff. They're not really based on anything major. Just a fun guess.
Quin, Epi, Sorscha [Mafia Team #1]
llama, Nero, Bullz [Civ]
Daisy [Rogue]

#124

Bullzeye or spacedaisy. You call it Quin.

#125

Quin will kill Bullzeye

#126

Quin wrote:Quin will kill Bullzeye

Confirmed! Thank you.

#127

I think that there's 3 mafia teams after all.

inb4 night killed

#128

No I don't, ignore that.

#129

If there were that many teams, I'd be dead. I should be dead now. Why has no one killed me?

#130

I'm confused again since Nero actually was mafia. If there's two teams of 3 there's one extra that I can't explain. Maybe there was just one extra mafia on their team or something.

Full Games	Civilian: Mafia: Independent:
Speed Games	Civilian: Fiddler on the Roof Mafia:
Heists	Civilian: MVP: RED vs BLUE
Burglaries	Independent: The Theme Is Literally a Burglary
Special Games	Civilian: Independent:

Full Games	Civilian: Mafia: Independent:
Speed Games	Civilian: Fiddler on the Roof Mafia:
Heists	Civilian: MVP: RED vs BLUE
Burglaries	Independent: The Theme Is Literally a Burglary
Special Games	Civilian: Independent:

Full Games	Civilian: Mafia: Independent:
Speed Games	Civilian: Fiddler on the Roof Mafia:
Heists	Civilian: MVP: RED vs BLUE
Burglaries	Independent: The Theme Is Literally a Burglary
Special Games	Civilian: Independent:

2014 Sockys
2015 Sockys
Miscellaneous

2014 Sockys
2015 Sockys
Miscellaneous

2014 Sockys
2015 Sockys
Miscellaneous