Hogwarts Mafia - END

[nutella]

@nutella thoughts on MacD and Timmer? How familiar are you with their scum play?

ehh in terms of meta I'm not very good at remembering most people's subtle differences (I think luna is one of the exceptions but even that I think I'm overestimating my ability to tell) but I've seen an incredibly town game in general from Mac, timmer is harder to read but if Mac trusts him mechanically I'll believe it (but then I reread that interaction and it's somewhat unclear if it goes both ways, I think Timmer has said mac is cleared but not necessarily vice versa and timmer could be taking advantage of that maybe? [mention]MacDougall[/mention] can you guarantee timmer is town or is it not a two-way street?

[poutanko]

Are both of them vet players (oldfags)?
I know Mac is considered a big fish, some people mentioned it, what about Timmer?

It won't be as simple if a vet player/big fish involved in here and Jack acted so smug.

[nutella]

Yeah Timmer's been around a long time too

[timmer]

basically if there is a serious case against her, I'll need to seriously reread it because I'm not seeing it.

Someone mentioned this before:
She voted Glorf and stayed on him during LC v Glorf wagon near EoD3.
Voted me and stayed during Jack v me wagon EoD5.

Luna stayed on you but so did sloonei and Colin. And as for long con, didn't his team probably know he would survive? That allows people to vote in unexpected ways.

I suppose that's enough to bump Luna a smidge higher on my list, as in I'd add a small gap between her and dh but I'd need more than that to vote her at this time.

[timmer]

Are both of them vet players (oldfags)?
I know Mac is considered a big fish, some people mentioned it, what about Timmer?

It won't be as simple if a vet player/big fish involved in here and Jack acted so smug.

I've been around a long time, for sure. I've had huge gaps of time between playing, but I've played longer than this site's been around, let's put it that way. I'm often quite adrift with fast moving games because of how my head works, but there have been a few games where I've locked shit down (it's just been awhile, lol, witness my tantrum earlier in the game).

As for Mac, well someone did something nice for me at one point in the game, and this was after I spilled that I was a vig. I've been silently wondering who it was, and he posted earlier in this day phase in a way that basically told me it was him, so he gets my vouch from now until the game is over as there is no conceivable way a baddie would have done what he did. Also keep in mind that neither me or Mac, I'd say, were under any sort of heavy scrutiny earlier today, so there was no reason for some kind of random gambit.

[Jackofhearts2005]

@ColinIsCool @DharmaHelper @juliets @Lunalee @MacDougall @nutella @sprityo @timmer Any of you targeted Jay N3 and got a result? I wonder if Jay has Thestral resulting in me getting no result (instead of me getting blocked).

No, I used my one-time only Phoenix on N3 to razz TH and got INH instead

Lol appreciated.

[Jackofhearts2005]

I just asked you why you are willing to vote Colin after you copped him and got town. I'm not twisting your words, just trying to understand your though process a bit better. I didn't claim until I did because I was getting checks and didn't want to get lynched. If you'll notice, I used my town-firms to steer the conversation in the thread the best I could without revealing anything. The reason I didn't cop you was because your tone sounded very town, and there were other players I suspected more than you.

...I never vote him

Haha adorable.

[Jackofhearts2005]

I get that mac looks town, but who's bad then?

I'll try to rank (I generally hate rainbow lists etc.)

In order of badness

1. Sprityo
2. Colin

big gap

3. poutanko

gap

4. nutella
5. juliets 2.0

big gap

6. Luna
7. DH
8. Mac

Um you left me off your list.

[MacDougall]

Well sprityo what did you do?

ive done nothing except oh idk, lynch jack yesterday

anything specific you want to know?

I'm pretty sure the accurate statement would be that DH lynched Jack, lol, not you.

At night dildo

[Jackofhearts2005]

I still don't get why you think Sprit's vote on Jack is bad. He's not even a late voter.

A late Jack voter would be MORE civ, not less. Nutella's Jack vote, for instance, is significant, much more so than sprit's.

...I don't get it

I saved you bish

Lol I know you saved me. Have to question you since your block on Colin (and someone mentioning the possibility of you being Jack's team mate trying to look good by voting him knowing he couldn't be lynched)

Nutella would never pretend lynch me if we were real teammates.

[Jackofhearts2005]

Are both of them vet players (oldfags)?
I know Mac is considered a big fish, some people mentioned it, what about Timmer?

It won't be as simple if a vet player/big fish involved in here and Jack acted so smug.

[MacDougall]

@nutella thoughts on MacD and Timmer? How familiar are you with their scum play?

ehh in terms of meta I'm not very good at remembering most people's subtle differences (I think luna is one of the exceptions but even that I think I'm overestimating my ability to tell) but I've seen an incredibly town game in general from Mac, timmer is harder to read but if Mac trusts him mechanically I'll believe it (but then I reread that interaction and it's somewhat unclear if it goes both ways, I think Timmer has said mac is cleared but not necessarily vice versa and timmer could be taking advantage of that maybe? @MacDougall can you guarantee timmer is town or is it not a two-way street?

95 percent.

[MacDougall]

Sprityo it's you v Col today pal and Col has given us his night actions.

So far we have ... wait you roleblocked JAY on night 3?

Why?

[Lunalee]

I just can't with this game. Moving my vote back to sprit.

[Long Con]

@ColinIsCool @DharmaHelper @juliets @Lunalee @MacDougall @nutella @sprityo @timmer Any of you targeted Jay N3 and got a result? I wonder if Jay has Thestral resulting in me getting no result (instead of me getting blocked).

No, I used my one-time only Phoenix on N3 to razz TH and got INH instead

Lol appreciated.

I thought this was very cool.

[poutanko]

6000 posts

[poutanko]

Oh..wait wrong

[juliets]

Ok, I'm about to leave and won't be back until after EOD. I'm just going to leave my vote where it is and if something happens and everyone decides t move their vote mine won't do any harm where it is. I'll be back on tonight.

[sprityo]

Sprityo it's you v Col today pal and Col has given us his night actions.

So far we have ... wait you roleblocked JAY on night 3?

Why?

I barely paid attention to the thread and wanted a good chuckle

You want to know all my night actions?

[sprityo]

There’s no pleasing everyone because they’re so damn ignorant

It’s okay I’ll be the one who’s right and laughing


So I replaced in night 2 I believe?

N2 made +1 vote potion
N3 roleblocked jay
N4 Thunderbird
N5 used potion

Yknow why I used my potion? cause I knew some fucked up shit like everyone dogpiling me was gonna happen for no discernible reason

Maybe I could’ve had a chance if everyone wanted to be fair but no that doesn’t seem to be the case

I’ll go fuck myself I guess because it’s apparently too hard for people to use their brains

[Jackofhearts2005]

Ugh you are giving the mafia a road map.

[Lunalee]

[mention]sprityo[/mention] The only problem I have with voting Colin is his town-firm from Pout. I don't believe Pout could have gotten two false checks, and if I believe she's town, then I have to believe she's not lying. How have you justified this with your colin vote?

[sprityo]

@sprityo The only problem I have with voting Colin is his town-firm from Pout. I don't believe Pout could have gotten two false checks, and if I believe she's town, then I have to believe she's not lying. How have you justified this with your colin vote?

with what mac has said about the night actions
i believe mac to be town, and henceforth pout already had one bad check so i dont see it as impossible to have it happen a second time

[nutella]

Luna given the insane amount of redirects and stuff on this game why do you find it unlikely? Makes sense to me that scum would diricawl themselves with townies as much as possible, plus there's imperio

My vote is staying on sprityo anyway, I just think that if that's your only reason for hesitating to vote Colin it's not the strongest one.

[Lunalee]

I may switch back to voting Colin then. I'm still hesitant about the sprityo lynch just because sprityo's reaction to it looks very town. BUT we may be better off to go ahead and remove the sprityo option today, since he is so heavily suspected, so we can move on with other suspicions. It would be nice to hear from everyone voting sprityo what it would mean for the other players if sprityo flips town. His death, even if he is civ, can stil help us win the game.

[Jackofhearts2005]

*checks watch*

*sneers*

[speedchuck]

*checks watch*

*sneers*

And to think I was once your housemate, in another life

[nutella]

I may switch back to voting Colin then. I'm still hesitant about the sprityo lynch just because sprityo's reaction to it looks very town. BUT we may be better off to go ahead and remove the sprityo option today, since he is so heavily suspected, so we can move on with other suspicions. It would be nice to hear from everyone voting sprityo what it would mean for the other players if sprityo flips town. His death, even if he is civ, can stil help us win the game.

I would go to Colin next and failing that you or poutanko

[sprityo]

[nutella]

Damn straight. You have any productive final words? Legacy reads?

[DharmaHelper]

Woo boy.

[ColinIsCool]

I may switch back to voting Colin then. I'm still hesitant about the sprityo lynch just because sprityo's reaction to it looks very town. BUT we may be better off to go ahead and remove the sprityo option today, since he is so heavily suspected, so we can move on with other suspicions. It would be nice to hear from everyone voting sprityo what it would mean for the other players if sprityo flips town. His death, even if he is civ, can stil help us win the game.

I would go to Colin next and failing that you or poutanko

I think it’s Luna and not pout, if not sprit.

[DharmaHelper]

I feel like Luna is a civ

[Jackofhearts2005]

Let’s lynch Mac.

[Jackofhearts2005]

Cfd?

[Lunalee]

so you aren't allowed to vote then, Jack?

[nutella]

Thought maybe he'd vote at the last minute but looks like no

[sprityo]

[Dragon D. Luffy]

Day 6

Who just made a bloodbath in the Forbidden Forest?

Poll ended at Fri Nov 16, 2018 5:54 pmPlease note that if you vote, your vote will be visible.

ColinIsCool
3
17%

Voters: MacDougall, sprityo, Lunalee

DharmaHelper
0

juliets
0

poutanko
0

Lunalee
1
6%

Voters: poutanko

MacDougall
0

nutella
0

Jackofhearts2005
0

sprityo
5
28%

Voters: ColinIsCool, juliets, nutella, timmer, DharmaHelper

timmer
0

Aragog (Host/Mod/NP/Dead)
9
50%

Voters: speedchuck, dunya, Owner of a Lonely Heart, JaggedJimmyJay, Turnip Head, Epignosis, Sloonei, Dragon D. Luffy, Soneji

[Dragon D. Luffy]

Scrying Pool of Elimination

The situation was getting desperate. The majority of innocent students over guilty ones was starting to feel small. And the teachers were very uncooperative and ineffective. Some believed they might be under the effect of Imperius curses.

The students started reviewing who had cooperated the most with the previous successes in finding the New Death Eaters, who had alibis, among other things. Some people even tried to use divination to find out who was guilty, but nobody was sure if they could rely on divination.

Eventually two names came up. Some people sided with a name, some sided with the other, but eventually the name of sprityo became the loudest.

Yet again, a student from Slytherin gets unfairly mistaken for an evil wizard.

sprityo (Hogwarts Student) was lynched.

Abilities:

Wit-Sharpening Potion
Expelliarmus
Thunderbird (Even Nights)

Night 6 Begins!

[nutella]

Fffffff

[DharmaHelper]

Fffffff

Lol I bet mafia chat is so lit

[sprityo]

Why do i even bother sometimes

[DharmaHelper]

Lol remember when nutella said out loud in the thread that she blocked the guy who was going to block the outted mafia lol what a wild fuckin game man I swear it's crazy

[nutella]

Lol remember when nutella said out loud in the thread that she blocked the guy who was going to block the outted mafia lol what a wild fuckin game man I swear it's crazy

And it's looking more like I made the right call haha absolutely wild

[DharmaHelper]

Is it tho

[Jackofhearts2005]

Wait...Sprityo was town?

[Jackofhearts2005]

Is it tho

Kill Nutella tonight plz. Thanks.

[nutella]

If I die tonight, the mafia are fucking idiots.

[ColinIsCool]

If you are a town vig you should vig me tonight. This is not a trick. Don’t waste the lynch on me.