STAR WARS Mafia [ENDGAME]

#3651

Metalmarsh89 wrote:Subject: STAR WARS Mafia [POLLS]

DharmaHelper wrote:
DharmaHelper wrote:
Spoiler: show
Hi there, here's the Day 6 poll.

Spoiler: show
Who went pew?

Poll ended at Sat Dec 05, 2015 5:26 pm

a2thezebra
0
No votes

Bass_the_Clever
0
No votes

Black Rock
0
No votes

Bubbles
0
No votes

Bullzeye
0
No votes

Canucklehead
0
No votes

DFaraday
1
Bubbles (11)
4%

Dom
0
No votes

DrWilgy
0
No votes

Elohcin
0
No votes

Glorfindel
1
a2thezebra (5)
4%

Golden
1
MacDougall (4)
4%

MacDougall
4
Golden (2), Glorfindel (6), Dom (10), Russtifinko (18)
17%

Matt
0
No votes

MovingPictures07
0
No votes

nijuukyugou
0
No votes

Roxy
10
Roxy (12), Matt (14), MovingPictures07 (15), Canucklehead (17), DrWilgy (19), DFaraday (20), Bullzeye (21), Sorsha (22), nijuukyugou (23), Elohcin (24)
42%

Russtifinko
0
No votes

sig
0
No votes

Sorsha
1
sig (16)
4%

thellama73
0
No votes

That thing in the Death Star's garbage disposal (The Host, the Non, the Dead)
6
Epignosis (1), DharmaHelper (3), Typhoony (7), Turnip Head (8), Metalmarsh89 (9), Black Rock (13)
25%

Total votes : 24

#3652

a2thezebra wrote:
MovingPictures07 wrote:Golden, how do you like those credits now?
They're fake, ask Sorsha. Golden won't have any new credits.

What are you talking about?

#3653

Sorsha wrote:
a2thezebra wrote:
MovingPictures07 wrote:Golden, how do you like those credits now?
They're fake, ask Sorsha. Golden won't have any new credits.
What are you talking about?

You're Salacious Crumb.

#3654

a2thezebra wrote:
Sorsha wrote:
a2thezebra wrote:
MovingPictures07 wrote:Golden, how do you like those credits now?
They're fake, ask Sorsha. Golden won't have any new credits.
What are you talking about?
You're Salacious Crumb.

No, I'm not

#3655

Sorsha wrote:
a2thezebra wrote:
Sorsha wrote:
a2thezebra wrote:
MovingPictures07 wrote:Golden, how do you like those credits now?
They're fake, ask Sorsha. Golden won't have any new credits.
What are you talking about?
You're Salacious Crumb.
No, I'm not

Then what's up with your criticism of the forced votes?

#3656

a2thezebra wrote:
Sorsha wrote:
a2thezebra wrote:
Sorsha wrote:
a2thezebra wrote:
MovingPictures07 wrote:Golden, how do you like those credits now?
They're fake, ask Sorsha. Golden won't have any new credits.
What are you talking about?
You're Salacious Crumb.
No, I'm not
Then what's up with your criticism of the forced votes?

The fact that I don't like forced votes, I think they are stupid. Especially when players can make it painfully obvious that they have been forced.

#3657

Mad that you didn't think to specify eh

#3658

I agree with Sorsha, forced votes are lame. They almost killed me!

#3659

Until you were saved/framed/whatever, mmmhmmm riiiiiiiiiiiight

#3660

Also how do you know the forced votes alone played such a vital part in your near-death? Apparently I was just acting.

#3661

Because you forced the votes on yourself, knowing you wouldn't be lynched.

#3662

a2thezebra wrote:Because you forced the votes on yourself, knowing you wouldn't be lynched.

#3663

a2thezebra wrote:Mad that you didn't think to specify eh

Specify what?

#3664

a2thezebra wrote:Mad that you didn't think to specify eh

Specify what?

#3665

Sorsha wrote:
a2thezebra wrote:Mad that you didn't think to specify eh
Specify what?

Tsk tsk

#3666

MovingPictures07 wrote:
a2thezebra wrote:Because you forced the votes on yourself, knowing you wouldn't be lynched.

Yup win over town with attitude alone

#3667

You damn geniuses

#3668

I really have no idea what you're talking about but you're wrong, I didn't force anyone to do anything.

#3669

Buy buy buy

Deflector Shield - This shield will protect you from the next attempt on your life (be it a kill or a lynch).

PM both hosts with your bid tonight.

#3670

Stop stop stop...

Zebra, MP, Dom ... we're being had. We are all good guys just throwing shit at each other. The quiet players that aren't completely absent are the bad guys.

DrWilgy, sig, DFaraday. Quite possibly sorsha. They are the ones you want to kill.

By the way I never got paid when Roxy died so that was a lie.

#3671

#3672

Oh bother it clipped.

It says "the most obvious scum ever he's been last on so many wagons".

#3673

MacDougall wrote:Stop stop stop...

Zebra, MP, Dom ... we're being had. We are all good guys just throwing shit at each other. The quiet players that aren't completely absent are the bad guys.

DrWilgy, sig, DFaraday. Quite possibly sorsha. They are the ones you want to kill.

By the way I never got paid when Roxy died so that was a lie.

Nah... MP is bad.

#3674

Russtifinko
nijuukyugou
a2thezebra
MovingPictures07
Dom
Elohcin
thellama
Canucklehead
Matt
Sorsha
Bullzeye
Metalmarsh89
Spacedaisy
DFaraday
sig
DrWilgy

Please mod-kill these players:
Bass_the_Clever
Bubbles

#3675

Dom wrote:
MacDougall wrote:Stop stop stop...

Zebra, MP, Dom ... we're being had. We are all good guys just throwing shit at each other. The quiet players that aren't completely absent are the bad guys.

DrWilgy, sig, DFaraday. Quite possibly sorsha. They are the ones you want to kill.

By the way I never got paid when Roxy died so that was a lie.
Nah... MP is bad.

You reckon he was so calm and not stressful because he is bad guy part of the plot?

If so then sig is part of the plot. DrWilgy is part of the plot.

#3676

Does anyone have any reason to believe that any of our dead players are bad? I haven't seen any discussion about that? I know Luffy was getting suspected earlier. I wonder how many if any are. Surely by now at least one or two?

#3677

MacDougall wrote:
Dom wrote:
MacDougall wrote:Stop stop stop...

Zebra, MP, Dom ... we're being had. We are all good guys just throwing shit at each other. The quiet players that aren't completely absent are the bad guys.

DrWilgy, sig, DFaraday. Quite possibly sorsha. They are the ones you want to kill.

By the way I never got paid when Roxy died so that was a lie.
Nah... MP is bad.
You reckon he was so calm and not stressful because he is bad guy part of the plot?

If so then sig is part of the plot. DrWilgy is part of the plot.

Yes.

I don't think sig was in on it.

#3678

Dom wrote:
MacDougall wrote:
Dom wrote:
MacDougall wrote:Stop stop stop...

Zebra, MP, Dom ... we're being had. We are all good guys just throwing shit at each other. The quiet players that aren't completely absent are the bad guys.

DrWilgy, sig, DFaraday. Quite possibly sorsha. They are the ones you want to kill.

By the way I never got paid when Roxy died so that was a lie.
Nah... MP is bad.
You reckon he was so calm and not stressful because he is bad guy part of the plot?

If so then sig is part of the plot. DrWilgy is part of the plot.
Yes.

I don't think sig was in on it.

Why?

#3679

You know just saying "nah you're wrong" without explaining why is going to start me up again right?

#3680

MacDougall wrote:You know just saying "nah you're wrong" without explaining why is going to start me up again right?

...no.
I just don't read civ as bad right now. I genuinely think MP is bad.

#3681

Dom wrote:
MacDougall wrote:You know just saying "nah you're wrong" without explaining why is going to start me up again right?
...no.
I just don't read civ as bad right now. I genuinely think MP is bad.

Right. That's pretty black and white. If MP is a bad guy then it logically goes that the whole thing was orchestrated from the forced votes to the lynch swap. If he's a good guy it was still forced. So which votes on his wagon had the worst reasons?

Wilgy and sig.

#3682

Ackbar was the civvie lynch switch, and I find it unlikely that there would be two civvies who could do that. Therefore, I believe this was more likely to be the work of baddies (Palpatine?), and I don't see why a baddie team would use a lynch switch to save someone not on their team, just to frame that same person. The obvious explanation is that MP is bad and his team saved him.

I still suspect Daisy, but I think she was right about this, at least.

#3683

RIP Golden.

Good call, DF.

#3684

Matt wrote:RIP Golden.

#3685

DFaraday wrote:Ackbar was the civvie lynch switch, and I find it unlikely that there would be two civvies who could do that. Therefore, I believe this was more likely to be the work of baddies (Palpatine?), and I don't see why a baddie team would use a lynch switch to save someone not on their team, just to frame that same person. The obvious explanation is that MP is bad and his team saved him.

I still suspect Daisy, but I think she was right about this, at least.

"Having experienced many political, martial, and interpersonal scenarios, Leia Organa can use any non-secret Rebel Alliance action once."

Come to think of it, if Leia is alive then it's getting to the point where she'd have to start using the more random roles.

Tbh it's more likely it was was Leia than the bad guys. At least we know for sure that Leia can do that.

#3686

MacDougall wrote:
DFaraday wrote:Ackbar was the civvie lynch switch, and I find it unlikely that there would be two civvies who could do that. Therefore, I believe this was more likely to be the work of baddies (Palpatine?), and I don't see why a baddie team would use a lynch switch to save someone not on their team, just to frame that same person. The obvious explanation is that MP is bad and his team saved him.

I still suspect Daisy, but I think she was right about this, at least.
"Having experienced many political, martial, and interpersonal scenarios, Leia Organa can use any non-secret Rebel Alliance action once."

Come to think of it, if Leia is alive then it's getting to the point where she'd have to start using the more random roles.

Tbh it's more likely it was was Leia than the bad guys. At least we know for sure that Leia can do that.

Hmm, you're right, I totally missed that. It doesn't necessarily clear MP, though, it would just mean Leia thinks he's civ.

#3687

DFaraday wrote:
MacDougall wrote:
DFaraday wrote:Ackbar was the civvie lynch switch, and I find it unlikely that there would be two civvies who could do that. Therefore, I believe this was more likely to be the work of baddies (Palpatine?), and I don't see why a baddie team would use a lynch switch to save someone not on their team, just to frame that same person. The obvious explanation is that MP is bad and his team saved him.

I still suspect Daisy, but I think she was right about this, at least.
"Having experienced many political, martial, and interpersonal scenarios, Leia Organa can use any non-secret Rebel Alliance action once."

Come to think of it, if Leia is alive then it's getting to the point where she'd have to start using the more random roles.

Tbh it's more likely it was was Leia than the bad guys. At least we know for sure that Leia can do that.
Hmm, you're right, I totally missed that. It doesn't necessarily clear MP, though, it would just mean Leia thinks he's civ.

Or the target was the other way round and they didn't expect MP to get lynched.

#3688

So Mac, what are your opinions post Golden flip? Not a civ, but not necessarily bad. My guess is Golden just had to survive until the end. How does his flip make you feel in light of his calling you out a few days back?

Been ISOing Golden for the last 20 minutes (over 400 posts, really Golden?

).

#3689

I realised Golden was a Jawa already and 90% sure I who his teammates are. I assume anyone half observant can tell who they are.

Golden said himself his flip would reveal nothing about my alignment. His read on me had nothing do with his alignment, said it himself. His read on me was wrong, and I'm not happy that he's dead considering I realised that he was probably benign on literally his last day of play.

I don't think he believed I was bad by the end either.

Tell me Matt, do you actually have anything tangible to suspect me for or are you just lining up to the be the next person I get into a pissing match with over suspecting me for reasons I think are bogus?

#3690

So far I have about 5 suspects as Golden's 2 Jawa partners, one of them being dead lol.

One of them I'm sure about, though. Of course that doesn't mean jack but oh boy I'm sure

Mac - Golden wasn't Mafia, he was a pretty harmless indy as far as I can tell, so for all intents he was a civ IMO. He suspected you and went so far as to 1 v 1 you. I'm not trying to start a pissing match, but by Golden's ghost I don't think it's something we should just ignore.

#3691

Matt wrote:So far I have about 5 suspects as Golden's 2 Jawa partners, one of them being dead lol.

One of them I'm sure about, though. Of course that doesn't mean jack but oh boy I'm sure

Mac - Golden wasn't Mafia, he was a pretty harmless indy as far as I can tell, so for all intents he was a civ IMO. He suspected you and went so far as to 1 v 1 you. I'm not trying to start a pissing match, but by Golden's ghost I don't think it's something we should just ignore.

Golden said that his flip would reveal nothing. Using his role as a basis for suspecting me goes against his requests. He always attained his read on me as bad was findable in my ISO. So if you want to scum read me look at my ISO.

You won't find anything, but don't misrepresent the dead.

He also cooled hard on me as a bad guy by the end, and had other suspects.

If he gets me lynched posthumously because of you, he's going to be a very sad panda.

#3692

MacDougall wrote:
Matt wrote:So far I have about 5 suspects as Golden's 2 Jawa partners, one of them being dead lol.

One of them I'm sure about, though. Of course that doesn't mean jack but oh boy I'm sure

Mac - Golden wasn't Mafia, he was a pretty harmless indy as far as I can tell, so for all intents he was a civ IMO. He suspected you and went so far as to 1 v 1 you. I'm not trying to start a pissing match, but by Golden's ghost I don't think it's something we should just ignore.
Golden said that his flip would reveal nothing. Using his role as a basis for suspecting me goes against his requests. He always attained his read on me as bad was findable in my ISO. So if you want to scum read me look at my ISO.

You won't find anything, but don't misrepresent the dead.

He also cooled hard on me as a bad guy by the end, and had other suspects.

If he gets me lynched posthumously because of you, he's going to be a very sad panda.

Lol. I think you severely overestimate my ability to control the direction of the thread, but for using the saaaaad panda reference, I will consider your request. That being said, my point wasn't that his role reveal somehow dictated your alignment, just that Golden seemed pretty effin' sure you were bad. I've been workin' a lot the last few days, though, so I'll have to review his most recent thoughts on you.

#3693

WILD SPECULATIVE THEORY

Soooo

At the beginning of the game in Day 0, I recall DH saying a secret event had been triggered.

Within minutes, both sig and Golden posted descriptions of each planet from the Day 0 poll. About 20 minutes later, Sorsha did the same.

Is it possible the secret event was for these three players to post their descriptions of each planet? Furthermore, is it possible each player is from a different faction? Golden being indy, sig/sorsha one being good, the other bad. Perhaps DH picked the winner and that faction won a prize of some sort?

Hmmm

One problem with this theory is that sig and Golden both posted their descriptions exactly 4 minutes after the event had been triggered, but it's possible DH let them know ahead of time they would be involved in this contest.

Anyway, probably wrong. But I just thought of it and wanted to share haha.

#3694

RIP Golden. I'm glad MP didn't die though.

#3695

MacDougall wrote:Stop stop stop...

Zebra, MP, Dom ... we're being had. We are all good guys just throwing shit at each other. The quiet players that aren't completely absent are the bad guys.

DrWilgy, sig, DFaraday. Quite possibly sorsha. They are the ones you want to kill.

By the way I never got paid when Roxy died so that was a lie.

What makes you so sure of this all of a sudden?

#3696

It's quiet.

Someone tell me how bad my theory is. Go!

#3697

Your theory sucks harder than String Theory. Just kidding, I don't know.

#3698

Matt wrote:It's quiet.

Someone tell me how bad my theory is. Go!

Well it's a Mr F theory so I assumed you wouldn't need telling.

Kidding, of course :P I'm sure it's lovely.

#3699

Bullzeye wrote:
Matt wrote:It's quiet.

Someone tell me how bad my theory is. Go!
Well it's a Mr F theory so I assumed you wouldn't need telling.

Kidding, of course :P I'm sure it's lovely.

Hi Bullzeye.

#3700

thellama73 wrote:
Bullzeye wrote:
Matt wrote:It's quiet.

Someone tell me how bad my theory is. Go!
Well it's a Mr F theory so I assumed you wouldn't need telling.

Kidding, of course :P I'm sure it's lovely.
Hi Bullzeye.

Hi Llama.

Who Dies Next?