Rolling Stones Mafia Game Over!

#351

Epignosis wrote:
Mongoose wrote:
Epignosis wrote:The Lizzy votes came in BOOM BOOM BOOM BOOM 1-2-3-4 like a band getting ready to play. They came in right when llama voted for MovingPictures.

That's the first thing that sticks out to me.
Indeed, indeed. I don't know exactly how to connect the dots though. Do you have any interpretation(s)?
That's the thing- it's all so circumstantial. One or two in that crew have to be rotten. That's when I look through the posts and am like the bear that went over the mountain.

Epi, are you saying here that you think the Lizzy vote were intended to nip any push for MP in the bud? And I know saying "it's gut" doesn't give you much chance at defense, so I'm sorry for that. I'm still not set on voting you, if that makes you feel any better.

MP, to answer your question, I really can't peg any one thing in Epi's posts that makes me blame him. There's his A Person vote, which I have a hard time criticizing him for, and then it seems to me that he was the one pushing most strongly to look at Lizzy voters, which is a place I said I wouldn't be looking too hard. Lizzy voters comprise nearly half of those of us left, and I think it'd be easy for a baddie to say "let's get those bad Lizzy voters; they killed a civ!" and then subtly point us to the civs in that group. Admittedly, it's not damning evidence. It just still makes me nervous.

I am sure about 2 things: 1) there are baddies among us. 2) There are 3 of them.

Linki with Roxy--I also am curious about your thoughts, Big D!

#352

I shall spam with Isis!

#353

Russtifinko wrote:
Epignosis wrote:
Mongoose wrote:
Epignosis wrote:The Lizzy votes came in BOOM BOOM BOOM BOOM 1-2-3-4 like a band getting ready to play. They came in right when llama voted for MovingPictures.

That's the first thing that sticks out to me.
Indeed, indeed. I don't know exactly how to connect the dots though. Do you have any interpretation(s)?
That's the thing- it's all so circumstantial. One or two in that crew have to be rotten. That's when I look through the posts and am like the bear that went over the mountain.
Epi, are you saying here that you think the Lizzy vote were intended to nip any push for MP in the bud? And I know saying "it's gut" doesn't give you much chance at defense, so I'm sorry for that. I'm still not set on voting you, if that makes you feel any better.

MP, to answer your question, I really can't peg any one thing in Epi's posts that makes me blame him. There's his A Person vote, which I have a hard time criticizing him for, and then it seems to me that he was the one pushing most strongly to look at Lizzy voters, which is a place I said I wouldn't be looking too hard. Lizzy voters comprise nearly half of those of us left, and I think it'd be easy for a baddie to say "let's get those bad Lizzy voters; they killed a civ!" and then subtly point us to the civs in that group. Admittedly, it's not damning evidence. It just still makes me nervous.

I am sure about 2 things: 1) there are baddies among us. 2) There are 3 of them.

Linki with Roxy--I also am curious about your thoughts, Big D!

I made an observation- that was all. I drew no conclusion from it.

juliets voted for A Person day one when DP was in trouble, and then voted for Lizzy when MP may have been in trouble. Again, an observation, not a conclusion.

Unfortunately, I don't have much time to draw conclusions, but I'm trying while my dough rises. Making pizza.

Also, you're sure there's three evildoers? Do you know something about the mystery in green?

#354

MovingPictures07 wrote:Alright, just got home from work. Going to be out of town this weekend, but will still have my laptop and internet access. I am getting ready and multitasking, but I'll hold off on my vote until a bit later because I'm still unsure.

I find it sort of convenient that Hedgeowl is insanified, the night after S~V~S was killed, especially given how strongly S~V~S felt about her.

Sure, DP is acting illogically and isn't really around and is being blendy, but he plays that way a lot. I frankly can never read him. That said, I may still vote him. I don't know. I feel like it is kind of a cop out vote right now though.

I'll likely vote for Hedge, Llama, or DP currently. Hedge because of what I've said about her, Llama because I think it's also possible he wanted to shut up an opponent and I was starting to think one of the two might be baddie, and DP given his blendiness.

Juliets has made me feel better, but I always read her intentions as civvie, so my paranoia in that regard remains.

Ugh, can I have some discussion here? I feel like this vote could end badly with people just popping in like Day 2; I'd rather it not.

Linki: Russ. Can you elaborate any more about Epig per chance?

thellama73 wrote:I reread hedge, and DP (I do not think juliets is bad) and I'm not seeing enough in either of them to deter my intentions. Hope you enjoy my vote, MP!
Hope you enjoy being wrong!

#355

Time to get caught up and vote in 15 minutes!

Yay!

#356

I was in trouble last day period? I wasn't aware of that.

#357

BWT, look forward to your thoughts when you're finished.

#358

Russtifinko wrote:
Epignosis wrote:
Mongoose wrote:
Epignosis wrote:The Lizzy votes came in BOOM BOOM BOOM BOOM 1-2-3-4 like a band getting ready to play. They came in right when llama voted for MovingPictures.

That's the first thing that sticks out to me.
Indeed, indeed. I don't know exactly how to connect the dots though. Do you have any interpretation(s)?
That's the thing- it's all so circumstantial. One or two in that crew have to be rotten. That's when I look through the posts and am like the bear that went over the mountain.
Epi, are you saying here that you think the Lizzy vote were intended to nip any push for MP in the bud? And I know saying "it's gut" doesn't give you much chance at defense, so I'm sorry for that. I'm still not set on voting you, if that makes you feel any better.

MP, to answer your question, I really can't peg any one thing in Epi's posts that makes me blame him. There's his A Person vote, which I have a hard time criticizing him for, and then it seems to me that he was the one pushing most strongly to look at Lizzy voters, which is a place I said I wouldn't be looking too hard. Lizzy voters comprise nearly half of those of us left, and I think it'd be easy for a baddie to say "let's get those bad Lizzy voters; they killed a civ!" and then subtly point us to the civs in that group. Admittedly, it's not damning evidence. It just still makes me nervous.

I am sure about 2 things: 1) there are baddies among us. 2) There are 3 of them.

Linki with Roxy--I also am curious about your thoughts, Big D!

#359

MovingPictures07 wrote:I was in trouble last day period? I wasn't aware of that.

Precision in language. I said, "may have been in trouble."

#360

I'm sorry, I had to just vote in a hurry my games post is coming up. DP was the only one who pinged me so thats where I voted.

#361

Epignosis wrote:
MovingPictures07 wrote:I was in trouble last day period? I wasn't aware of that.
Precision in language. I said, "may have been in trouble."

Oh, got it! My bad, didn't see that distinction.

#362

Ugh, I feel like a DP vote is such a cop out, feels like Lizzy all over again. But he could definitely be a baddie... it just bothers me because it seems we might very well have a repeat of Day 2 and he plays like this really often.

#363

juliets wrote:I'm sorry, I had to just vote in a hurry my games post is coming up. DP was the only one who pinged me so thats where I voted.

Now that's interesting right there.

#364

Epignosis wrote:
juliets wrote:I'm sorry, I had to just vote in a hurry my games post is coming up. DP was the only one who pinged me so thats where I voted.
Now that's interesting right there.

I agree, that vote really bothers me for some reason.

#365

I'm going with juliets. 0-2 is starting to look like Tampa Bay to me.

#366

juliets's behavior and voting history do seem pretty bad, especially if DP flips civvie. But she's been reading civvie to me overall... And I keep wondering who is directing this thread nefariously, so I'm hesitant to jump any which way.

I may follow you with that, Epig, but I'm going to wait this out. I may not.

#367

Voting juliets partially to save me, partially because I'm getting not fuzzy vibes, and partially due to the fact she suspects me for a reason that would have occurred had I voted anyone at all at the time which I find is just strange.

#368

Oh man, 2 votes for DP and 2 for juliets. I feel like there's something going on here, I just don't know what.

Not sure I want to be the deciding factor here. Surely I can't be the only one wanting to discuss this out?

#369

I'm in between either llama, juliets, and Hedge. Llama because I could see him being ballsy enough to try and take S~V~S out already. Juliets because I could see some attempts to save teammates in there. But I think I will be voting for Hedge today. S~V~S mentioning her and then getting killed off pretty much ended any discussion of her. And for some reason that really freaks me out.

Votes Hedge

Lots of linki.

#370

birdwithteeth11 wrote:I'm in between either llama, juliets, and Hedge. Llama because I could see him being ballsy enough to try and take S~V~S out already. Juliets because I could see some attempts to save teammates in there. But I think I will be voting for Hedge today. S~V~S mentioning her and then getting killed off pretty much ended any discussion of her. And for some reason that really freaks me out.

Votes Hedge

Lots of linki.

#371

Epi, are there not 3 baddies? I thought Roxy said so. I'll have to recheck.

I'm surprised that you guys are surprised that juliets voted DP, she's been talking about it all day.

I could see the baddies being MP, DP, and juliets. I could also see them being Epi and the Lizzy voters who weren't DP and juliets. I could see juliets and DP not being on the same team, and there are lots of other possibilities too. Hopefully this lynch will be super informative.

#372

NOOOO! Just missed the poll. That's what I get for being indecisive.

#373

#374

Shit. That sucks so bad. It still says 6:52 on my computer. Grrrrr.

Well, I honestly don't know who I would have voted, still.

#375

Oh, god. I hate myself. I got trapped in linkitis and my vote didn't go through.....I meant to vote DP. Epi was my first choice, but he clearly wasn't being lynched. Ugh....I am so horrible. Sorry to everyone and to Rox, yet again.

#376

Well, whatever. Guess there's nothing I can do. Sorry Rox for missing it. I even stuck around here longer so I could make it.

I guess I'm leaving now, be back whenever I'm done driving and such. Hopefully we'll have a good result.

#377

MovingPictures07 wrote:Shit. That sucks so bad. It still says 6:52 on my computer. Grrrrr.

Well, I honestly don't know who I would have voted, still.

Sounds like someone needs to change their settings to show the seconds in the time for each post. It's helped keep me from missing votes.

#378

Crossin the fingers.

#379

birdwithteeth11 wrote:
MovingPictures07 wrote:Shit. That sucks so bad. It still says 6:52 on my computer. Grrrrr.

Well, I honestly don't know who I would have voted, still.
Sounds like someone needs to change their settings to show the seconds in the time for each post. It's helped keep me from missing votes.

I definitely we be doing that now. me----->:derp:

#380

Who hates the color black?

Poll ended at Fri Oct 25, 2013 6:52:03 pm

birdwithteeth11
0
No votes
DisgruntledPorcupine
2
Mongoose (4), juliets (5) 25%
Epignosis
0
No votes
Hedgeowl
1
birdwithteeth11 (8) 13%
Juliets
2
Epignosis (6), DisgruntledPorcupine (7) 25%
Mongoose
0
No votes
Russtifinko
0
No votes
Sockout
1
thellama73 (3) 13%
Thellama73
0
No votes
Not me/Mr D/Nons
2
Roxy (1), S~V~S (2) 25%
Total votes : 8

#381

Ya'll got cocaine eyes...

Juliets has been lynched! Thanks for playing Juliets <3

It is now Night 3 the Bomb is still out there soooo...yeah.

#382

RIP juliets.

#383

She had a lynch switch too.

#384

RIP Juliets!

I guess she left her lynch switch on the table then. :/

#385

birdwithteeth11 wrote:RIP Juliets!

I guess she left her lynch switch on the table then. :/

Ditto, very very interesting.

#386

RIP juliets.

#387

bye ya'll happy game! get 'em civvs!

#388

Mr. D- should I stay up or go to bed?

#389

While I'm waiting on Mr. D's answer, I'm going to go ahead and say this in case I am kaput on Night 3.

I think Russtifinko benefits from missing votes.

Could be the beer talking, but I think it's me talking. Who the hell signs up for a 12-person thing and misses three in a row like that?

"Oops! Not Again!"

After all that talking. After this:

Russtifinko wrote: I'm not as sure as I'd like to be about any of the 3 of you, but I am absolutely committed to voting for someone in this poll, and no other names have truly caught my eye so far.

(I wanted to make a joke about him voting for someone not on the poll, but decided against it) But he's "absolutely committed" and yet did not vote.

This also made me wonder:

Russtifinko wrote:Epi, are there not 3 baddies? I thought Roxy said so. I'll have to recheck.

I'm surprised that you guys are surprised that juliets voted DP, she's been talking about it all day.

I could see the baddies being MP, DP, and juliets. I could also see them being Epi and the Lizzy voters who weren't DP and juliets. I could see juliets and DP not being on the same team, and there are lots of other possibilities too. Hopefully this lynch will be super informative.

There are four non-civilians. Three are bad.

Considering the spread out "I could see X Y Z and A B C being bad" (how helpful) I think Russ is the Independent. And I do think he benefits from missing the polls.

Nicol Bolas · #390

i would have voted bwt... or maybe DP. anyways I'd say don't sleep ever!

#391

Wow. That SUCKS. RIP juliets, was great to play with you again, and sorry to see you go.

From a numbers standpoint, this is terrible. 3 players have died, all civvies. Assuming 3 baddies and 1 independent, that's 5 civvies, and BEFORE tonight, which means we might be down to 4 after this night period. Which means we cannot afford to lynch a civvie tomorrow... Can everyone please name who they are most eyeing currently in light of the most recent development?

As to your theory about Russ, Epig, I find it very intriguing. It's a possibility.

birdwithteeth11 wrote:
MovingPictures07 wrote:Shit. That sucks so bad. It still says 6:52 on my computer. Grrrrr.

Well, I honestly don't know who I would have voted, still.
Sounds like someone needs to change their settings to show the seconds in the time for each post. It's helped keep me from missing votes.

Lol, yes, I am doing that now... Didn't think I'd need to, ironically, haha.

#392

voted car

#393

Last post for now, I swear.

I, for one, heavily anticipate voting for Hedgeowl tomorrow, though I want to hear what she has to say.

#394

He don't go in the light of the morning...

Teeth was starving someone had set a package at his door he heard a strange noise coming from it so he put it in front of someone else's door on his way to the elevator. He had to get out of here and get some Twinkies and A & W Root Beer. Damn it was so quiet.

But someone seen him. They were following him quietly at the last minute they stepped onto the elevator with Teeth.

"Oh hey" Teeth said "I am going for some snacks want anything?"

"Indeed" the cold dark voice said it was the last thing Teeth heard as someone who needed an Emotional Rescue sliced his throat. "Damn that felt good" the voice now sounding sweet and sing songy.

"Oh Fuck" a man said as he found a box ticking at his door.
***************Kablooey**********splat*******

Emotional stepped from the elevator just in time to be slapped in the face with someones brain tissue!

"Well I did feel better for a second..."

Teeth is dead. Llama has been exploded and dead.

It is now Day 4.

Had a little trouble with my poll and didn't set the time - twice.
So Lynch ends -
Sunday October 27, 6:30:00 PM EDT.

#395

RIPIYWG BWT and llama.

#396

Oh wow! RIPiywg llama and bwt. I am going to hope one of you was bad.

#397

So the way I read that night post, it looks like Teeth was NKed by a baddie, and llama was a baddie who got exploded? Please let me know if you guys agree with that assessment. RIP Teeth, in any case. I'll be looking for links to llama today (assuming I didn't completely misread the post or something).

#398

Yikes!!

RIPIYWG BWT and Llama.

Russ, I definitely agree BWT was killed by the mafia, but it seems llama was exploded, but I can't tell whether it was by civvie, baddie, or whatever. Can you elaborate why you think llama was bad? I must be reading it differently.

I'm definitely voting for DP or Hedge. What do others think?

#399

Lest we forget BWT voted Hedge last poll...

And Hedge clearly had a chance to elaborate there with her previous post yet chose not to do so.

I am so tempted to just vote her right now. I can't imagine a scenario where she's good.

#400

In fact, let's think about this:

Hedgeowl CLEARLY contradicted herself when it came to Lizzy, then voted Lizzy.

Then S~V~S, who called her out on it and voted for her, dies.

Hedgeowl is then insanified for the next day, with absolutely convenient timing if you ask me, and she only gets one vote: from BWT. Then BWT dies, along with llama in some weird explosion, and now we're down to 6 players and it could be that we still even have 3 baddies left. Maybe 2. It would make the most sense to kill those who oppose you, especially in such a small setting.

Then, the kicker, Hedgeowl refuses to address the points brought against her.

Seems like enough to me. Since I'm not sure what the rest of my day holds and there's no way I'm missing this poll, I'll vote now. Would have preferred to hear from others first though...

votes Hedgeowl

Who is going to play The Donner Party Mafia?