LoRab wrote:insertnamehere wrote:LoRab wrote:I actually had already given my input on this, not that long before you said something similar, but no one seemed to read it.
Here's what Lorab said:
LoRab wrote:And you each eat 1 of your fish. And give the other of your fish to someone else: Golden, DH, and Chuck makes the most sense. I believe Elo can feed herself--she's at least implied that in the thread. If I'm wrong, then she should get one of the fish instead of Chuck.
Here's what I said:
insertnamehere wrote:Who all's sick? Me, DH, Golden, Wilgy, and Elo?
Wilgy and I both got fish for ourselves, so we're good. I think it's a given that DH, Golden, and Elo should get the extra food due to their stat decrease, but that's just my thoughts. Open to anyone else's input.
I feel like these two posts are different enough in content to warrant them both needing to exist in the thread.
It was more that you didn't acknowledge that there had been another idea proposed. Or that I had spoken.
"I think it's a given," implies that everyone thinks that. I clearly had a slightly different opinion. And you didn't acknowledge the parts of it that were exactly the same.
Alright, let's analyze this.
I was sharing my view, and my opinion on what me, Wilgy, and Opt should do with our extra fish.
I wasn't responding to you, DH, or anyone else. I was just offering up my views.
Also, if you had said something to the effect of "DH, Elo, and Golden should get the fish because they are sick," than yes, we'd be saying the same thing. Instead, you said that Golden, DH, Chuck, and maybe Elo should get the fish while declining to mention the sickness itself or really any reasoning at all.
And even if my opinion was exactly similar to yours, I still had the right to give it in the thread, as I'm one of the people with the fish that started this whole shebang in the first place.
I wasn't specifically snubbing you in particular either, Lorab, and I had read your post. I just chose to give my own POV without citing anyone else. It wasn't a directed snipe or me ignoring you. It was me speaking my mind.
You also seem to think your statement is both too similar and directly contradictory to mine. They both can't be true.