Guess Who? Mafia

[thellama73]

Back. Beer and dirt acquired.

More things I've noticed:

Probably Not Mafia
fingersplints
Missing Person
nijuukyugou
Roxy
G-Man
thellama73

This was after DDL got lynched, which nijuu happened to miss. Notice something funny about that list? Here:

Probably Not Mafia
fingersplints
Missing Person
nijuukyugou
Roxy
G-Man
thellama73

I searched llama's posts using "nijuu," "ninja," and "blooper," and the only mention or interaction whatsoever is this:

Catching up. Stand by.

You're the best, Blooper.

That's it.

thellama73 has no qualms voting off low-participators. He voted for Turnip Head. He voted for Missing Person. He wanted to lynch Hedgeowl. Yet no mention of nijuukyugou, who has 12 posts and one missing vote, and is the only living person in his green span (haha, that's an economics joke).

I'm not sure what your point is. I don't suspect Nijuu. I think she is fairly obviously civ. I also don't think she is that much of a non-participant compared to someone like Hedgeowl or Turnip Head.

[Marmot]

In between flights and no time. I'm voting llama. It is between him and Golden for me right now, but I haven't given Golden a proper look yet.

So llama gets my vote.

[Epignosis]

I'll vote either llama or nijuu. I predict they are the final two.

[Marmot]

I'll vote either llama or nijuu. I predict they are the final two.

You waiting to see how nijuu will vote?

[Epignosis]

I'll vote either llama or nijuu. I predict they are the final two.

You waiting to see how nijuu will vote?

Now that you have voted, I will vote for you, and complete my master plan!

[Marmot]

I'll vote either llama or nijuu. I predict they are the final two.

You waiting to see how nijuu will vote?

Now that you have voted, I will vote for you, and complete my master plan!

Just because I called timmer the sexiest player in this game?

[Epignosis]

I'll vote either llama or nijuu. I predict they are the final two.

You waiting to see how nijuu will vote?

Now that you have voted, I will vote for you, and complete my master plan!

Just because I called timmer the sexiest player in this game?

timmer has weird extremities. Don't let his face fool you.

[Epignosis]

Hey, where you flying?

I've never been on a plane in my life.

[Marmot]

Hey, where you flying?

I've never been on a plane in my life.

Florida --> Chicago --> San Fran --> Eugene. Though now I've got some down time because the flight is delayed.

I don't recommend flying. It's expensive and usually not fun. Oh and it's near impossible to find a good meal.

[Ricochet]

Hey, where you flying?

I've never been on a plane in my life.

Florida --> Chicago --> San Fran --> Eugene. Though now I've got some down time because the flight is delayed.

I don't recommend flying. It's expensive and usually not fun. Oh and it's near impossible to find a good meal.

Pretty much, although I only received "meals" (sandwiches, croissants or, worse, a bloody waffle!) and drinks when flying with Lufthansa; god forbid I get more than a smile with the low cost company. Not that I need meals much for one-two flight hours - you probably fly longer, though. As for fun, I usually entertain myself. Music, movie, tv episodes - I have more stuff stored on my tablet than money in my pocket.

As for recommending it, idk. I was shit scared of ever flying, then when I had no choice and got in my first plane (17 yrs, to Paris) I was all "weeeeeee" as soon as we took off. It only got bad one time was when my hearing shut down during a flight (err let's say i don't remember how old ) - of course I acted like a complete n00b and felt that I'm farked and my life is over.

[Epignosis]

I'm not afraid to fly. Just po.

[G-Man]

Dear Living Players,

With the growing number of residents around these parts, Ricochet and I have put our comedy skits on ice for a while. Last night we decided to do something a little different. We started a Dr. Who marathon. This was probably foolish because, with hundreds of episodes in existence, there is no way we'll ever finish watching them all before the rest of you are finished.

In the meantime, some of us have started making bets on which of you are the last two baddies. It's close but there's enough variety in suspicions to keep things interesting. We had to bar Dragon and Spacedaisy from joining the pool because that would kill the surprise factor. Needless to say, that made things a little chillier around here. Maybe if another of their peers joins them today, we can get back to being a little friendlier.

Gotta run- we're starting up another series.


-G

[Marmot]

My parents still like to fly me home for visits, so I take the free flights. And flying out of a small city, I always have at least one layover, and often two.

My current experience with United Airlines has been dreadful. Delta has been a better experience, amd they take better care of their customers.

The actual flying itself isn't bad at all. Waiting on the plane is much better than waiting in the airport.

[Ricochet]

Dear Living Players,

With the growing number of residents around these parts, Ricochet and I have put our comedy skits on ice for a while. Last night we decided to do something a little different. We started a Dr. Who marathon. This was probably foolish because, with hundreds of episodes in existence, there is no way we'll ever finish watching them all before the rest of you are finished.

[thellama73]

I'll vote either llama or nijuu. I predict they are the final two.

You waiting to see how nijuu will vote?

Now that you have voted, I will vote for you, and complete my master plan!

This is a much better master plan than voting for me.

[nijuukyugou]

Been traveling all day and thankfully remembered to check this game! Back with a vote in a few.

[thellama73]

Been traveling all day and thankfully remembered to check this game! Back with a vote in a few.

Any idea who you are going to vote for? (hint: not me.)

[Epignosis]

I voted llama. I think I'm right.

[nijuukyugou]

I am amused people think I'm bad Interesting analyses, but like llama, I'm tickled that people think they have my gameplay pinned when I don't even have it down.

Been traveling all day and thankfully remembered to check this game! Back with a vote in a few.

Any idea who you are going to vote for? (hint: not me.)

Sorry, llama, but the points against you look pretty damning to me (except, of course, Epi's mention of your few interactions with me, with his assuming I'm mafia with you). It IS like you're playing the "I'm so bad I'm not a baddie" game, especially with the kills (but then again, I think I see that in your behavior in just about every game you play :P ). Something in my gut tells me your voters are right about you, and they know something.

[thellama73]

I'm just disappointed I never got to ask the host a question about the mafia. Where's the trust, guys?

Thanks, Eloh, for a really fun game! Good luck, civs!

[Dragon D. Luffy]

Hey, where you flying?

I've never been on a plane in my life.

Florida --> Chicago --> San Fran --> Eugene. Though now I've got some down time because the flight is delayed.

I don't recommend flying. It's expensive and usually not fun. Oh and it's near impossible to find a good meal.

I like flying, except for the turbulence. I always get dizzy when there's turbulence.

The thing I like the most is getting to the place I'm going to, though, not the trip :P

[Elohcin]

Llama has been put down today. He was a civilian. You have 23 hours to submit your PMs! Happy Night 5!

[Marmot]

I'm sorry llama. You looked bad to me. Sorry to put you down.

[Black Rock]

So much for my freaking gut.

So Golden, is Llama right about you or are you right about MM?

[Marmot]

Regardless, we have to get it right tomorrow. If we lynch the wrong player, mafia wins.

Also, lol at your question BR. How do you expect Golden to answer?

[Golden]

RIP llama.

Regardless, we have to get it right tomorrow. If we lynch the wrong player, mafia wins.

Also, lol at your question BR. How do you expect Golden to answer?

Yeah, this is exactly right, on both counts.

First, we have to get this right - so I'm not going to do my best not to go tunnel vision. I do think MM is bad, I really do, I think he has played a completely different game here to what I'm used to and I think so far I've only seen civvie MM, so this feels very different to me. BUT - I intend to take another look at everyone. Because there has to be two baddies out there, and yesterday I had narrowed my list to two. Now it's one, so... I need to figure out which pair could be a team.

Second - there really isn't any way to answer BR's question, other than to say that I know llama was wrong about me.

I wish I could also figure out who has had questions and who they have asked about. Because that could be really useful information right now, but I haven't really seen any sign of it at all this game (has anyone else? Am I just blind?)

[Marmot]

I think we're not allowed to talk about it the questions we ask.

[Marmot]

4. As you, the civilian, receive information about a player's avatar........ You may not use a player's avatar to discuss whether the player is civilian or mafia. Doing so will result in a mod-kill. If you are unsure about something you want to say, please PM the host before posting.

11. No posting the contents of PMs- period.

Snipped for relevance. This looks to me like a no go. I guess looking from signs from the players you have voted for (which we're also not allowed to talk about) is your best bet.

[Golden]

I think we're not allowed to talk about it the questions we ask.

Sure, but a sudden change in direction or something might signal that one was asked, it's worth looking for.

[Golden]

Oh yeah, you kind of just said that.

[Marmot]

Oh, and I still have an ISO of you to do Golden. I will get around to that tomorrow.

Linki: And there's always the good old-fashioned scum-hunting.

Linki 2:

[Black Rock]

Regardless, we have to get it right tomorrow. If we lynch the wrong player, mafia wins.

Also, lol at your question BR. How do you expect Golden to answer?

It would be very tricky wouldn't it? I did not expect a real answer. Just putting out my thoughts in questions.

[Elohcin]

As stated in my first post:
Night Action - Civilians vote for a player via PM (you may not vote yourself). The winning player gets to PM the host a yes or no question about a Mafia member. Once you've asked a question about the Mafia, anonymous votes for you will no longer count.
- Acceptable question example: Does a member of the Mafia have red hair?
- Unacceptable question example: Is so-and-so a Mafia member?

I never said you may not inform the thread that you have had or have not had the opportunity to ask a question or what that question was that you asked. But, you may not give the answer to the thread or use the information that you receive to build a case.

For example,

- "I think Llama is bad (I know I pick on llama a lot) b/c I asked the host if a member of the mafia has a mustache and llama has one." That is a no no.
- Or, "Hey guys....I really think that Roxy is bad b/c she has glasses on." That is a no no.
- Also, "I really think a member of the mafia may be someone who has a necklace on." No no.

If you get info on a member of the mafia...keep it to yourself and use it to help build a real case on the person you believe to be mafia.

[Ricochet]

I asked Eloh if I can has a rezz pls and said no no

[Roxy]

I asked Eloh if I can has a rezz pls and said no no

That is bc she gave it to me!

[timmer]

I'm back! I just got in the door and needless to say, there was no wifi anywhere to be found on my camping trip. I have a son barfing periodically now as well, so i will catch up tonight when things are relatively back to normal.

[thellama73]

- "I think Llama is bad (I know I pick on llama a lot) b/c I asked the host if a member of the mafia has a mustache and llama has one." That is a no no.

[Elohcin]

Black Rock has been put down by the mafia. It is now Day 6! Everyone should vote!

[Marmot]

Oh crap, I switched time zones and forgot to adjust my mental clock. RIP Black Rock.

[Epignosis]

My essay pairing llama and nijuukyugou together was unsatisfactory.

Needs improvement.

Please see the teacher.

Is partial credit allowed? Because I think the "silent partner" section of my paper is A+.

If anybody complains about my vote going for an inactive, I'll see you after school.

That's the bell.

[Marmot]

My essay pairing llama and nijuukyugou together was unsatisfactory.

Needs improvement.

Please see the teacher.

Is partial credit allowed? Because I think the "silent partner" section of my paper is A+.

If anybody complains about my vote going for an inactive, I'll see you after school.

That's the bell.

What about timmer?

[Epignosis]

What about timmer?

This was his last on-topic post:

Timmer, what is your view on llama?

I'm curious about his vows on Hedge. I could see a situation possible where Llama got to ask a question of the host, asked something like "is a baddie wearing a tiara?" And gor a yes. I could see that. Because all I see from hedges three posts is an absent player.

Apart from that I don't really have much in the way of thoughts.

He expressed Interest in whether or not llama got a question against Hedgeowl, but llama said he didn't get a question.

In hindsight, that post strikes me as paranoid. llama always goes after "Hedgebaddie." It's a thing of his.

[Marmot]

Epignosis, remember when nijuu voted for Missing Person because of timmer's case on MP? You came in and pointed out your more original case on MP.

I think there's a connection there, and feel more strongly about it now than I did the other day.

Here, nijuu follows timmer's reasons that Missing Person could be a baddie, and later acknowledges Epignosis's case. My gut feeling here is that nijuu and timmer are baddie partners, and nijuu followed his read of Missing Person because of this, but I could be reading to far into it. Personally, I say bad look for nijuu, but you be the judge.

That was easy. I like this:

Reading back further, the case that was brought out about DDL specifically mentioning that there would be a potential modkill of MP just adds to that. And Daisy suggested that MP should be given at least a day to get settled in, as well, so both of our baddies didn't seem to like the idea of people voting for MP. This may be enough for me to vote him today.

as well as the other supporting points about MP (basically I'm seeing the same thing being said regarding defense of inactives and MP being inactive, etc.). I'll go ahead and vote that way, too.

Epi's post is adequate. It'll do.

[Epignosis]

I don't believe nijuukyugou is bad.

[Marmot]

Did I misunderstand your previous post where you asked for amnesty for potentially being partially correct about a llama/nijuukyugou duo?

[Epignosis]

Did I misunderstand your previous post where you asked for amnesty for potentially being partially correct about a llama/nijuukyugou duo?

Maybe you didn't see that I voted Hedgeowl?

[Marmot]

I take it this lynch does not mean that much to you?

[Epignosis]

I take it this lynch does not mean that much to you?

If that's what you take, then that's what you take.

I am good with my vote.

[Marmot]

I take it this lynch does not mean that much to you?

If that's what you take, then that's what you take.

I am good with my vote.

You took the time to make a case on llama yesterday to justify your vote, even bringing up the fact that he never interacted with nijuukyugou until his late baddie list. You even voted late to observe other voters.

But today you vote Hedgeowl early, with nary a previous suspicion of her.

[Epignosis]

I take it this lynch does not mean that much to you?

If that's what you take, then that's what you take.

I am good with my vote.

You took the time to make a case on llama yesterday to justify your vote, even bringing up the fact that he never interacted with nijuukyugou until his late baddie list. You even voted late to observe other voters.

But today you vote Hedgeowl early, with nary a previous suspicion of her.

You have summed up the situation admirably.