A Gentleman's Guide to Love and Murder - Day 8

#521

Scotty wrote:Bye Golden!

I mean I was kind of hoping that I could see what Golden's alignment was, since it was partly influencing my decisions over llama and sorsha. Oh well.

However.

Sorsha being saved again is leading me to believe that she is very much good. No tomfoolery there.

I think both MM and llama bring up compelling points against each other. I saw Dom the lynch going towards MM today anyway, but do not want to discount llama of trying to force civ hands.

linki- well if we're trying to kill monty, you should vote for MM, @Dom.

Please explain why you think I am Monty.

I have tied for the lead in two lynches, yes, but this implies that I was not the victim in at least one of them.

#522

thellama73 wrote:
Elohcin wrote:MM has to be Monty unless there are other things at play with the secrets and all. I think Roxy is his partner. I of course have already stated why. She must be Sibella since she claims to have had her vote forced and no one can target themselves. Unless she just flat out lied :P Let's get these two out and then try to find baddie #3.
Eloh, I am deciding to trust you here. Between the two of us, we need to take down MM and his band of wicked warriors. I know a lot of people are out to get you, but I am going to stand with you from now on, even if it means my own death. This is the gamble I'm willing to take at this crucial point in the game.

Ditto to this. I believe that MM is Monty and should be the first priority for a lynch.

Voting MM

#523

Bye Golden. RIPIYWG. I am with llama, let's not spread the vote today. I voted MM.

#524

I'll go with MM

#525

I wish you all would lynch Elo.

Do you not wonder why she is voted for but never quite reaches a lynch total?

And now you follow llama who said he would help me lynch Elo and when he could have voted her and actually lynched her - he did not. He gave some razzle dazzle and voted for MM. Seems he is really trying to protect Elo. Why?

Ithink they are on a team together and feel they can wifom their way out of anyone putting them together bc their team of 3 are still alive.

WE are losing only civs this lynch is important please lets not waste it by following someone who lies aka llama.

#526

Sorsha why do you think MM over Elo?

#527

Roxy wrote:Sorsha why do you think MM over Elo?

I think yesterday's lynch post indicated that MM was to be lynched and he survived, just based on game play/participation I think that he's more likely Monty than llama is. If he's not then I think you're right about the two of them.

I think Scotty might be bad as well though. I was questioning him yesterday about how he was sure it was more likely that llama was Asquith Sr than Monty and I just don't buy his answer. I think it's because he knows who Monty really is..... And then I was targeted for a kill again last night.

#528

Roxy what do you think of fingersplints?

#529

Dom wrote:I'll go with MM

I see you haven't voted yet.

#530

Metalmarsh89 wrote:
Scotty wrote:Bye Golden!

I mean I was kind of hoping that I could see what Golden's alignment was, since it was partly influencing my decisions over llama and sorsha. Oh well.

However.

Sorsha being saved again is leading me to believe that she is very much good. No tomfoolery there.

I think both MM and llama bring up compelling points against each other. I saw Dom the lynch going towards MM today anyway, but do not want to discount llama of trying to force civ hands.

linki- well if we're trying to kill monty, you should vote for MM, @Dom.
Please explain why you think I am Monty.

I have tied for the lead in two lynches, yes, but this implies that I was not the victim in at least one of them.

Because of host error, I don't think Dom is Monty. I don't think Sorsha is, because she's survived twice. To me, that leaves you or llama. And you seemed to be the consensus vote yesterday. I'm honestly not trusting you of llama, but I don't know if Golden was bad, which is futzing with my reads. Granted, I might as well be dipping my toast in light fluid, because my reads have been crap at best this game.

And I don't know what you mean by victim. You mean civ? The first one you tied for went to another person, the second just happened. The only victim in the equation is my clarity.

I will most likely vote you, but it is on the basis of running with llama. I don't like how he's buddied up to Elo in the past day. So..

I want to vote both of you.

#531

Sorsha wrote:
Roxy wrote:Sorsha why do you think MM over Elo?
I think yesterday's lynch post indicated that MM was to be lynched and he survived, just based on game play/participation I think that he's more likely Monty than llama is. If he's not then I think you're right about the two of them.

I think Scotty might be bad as well though. I was questioning him yesterday about how he was sure it was more likely that llama was Asquith Sr than Monty and I just don't buy his answer. I think it's because he knows who Monty really is..... And then I was targeted for a kill again last night.

Yeah my thinking has been fluctuating on llama all game. When I added up the roles we know can survive a lynch, there are several roles that llama could be, a majority of which are civ. Plus the doc, if he is still alive. In reference to Golden's post that llama could be Asquith Sr., I'm more relaying that I think the more likely scenario is that llama is civ, not specifically that role. But I can see how my syntax didn't make that clear.

I have a great uncle in Vegas named Monty, but I'm still going back and forth on llama/MM as being Monty Navarro.

#532

Sorsha wrote:Roxy what do you think of fingersplints?

Splints is town. I have no reason to doubt her aorn.

#533

Scotty wrote:
Metalmarsh89 wrote:
Scotty wrote:Bye Golden!

I mean I was kind of hoping that I could see what Golden's alignment was, since it was partly influencing my decisions over llama and sorsha. Oh well.

However.

Sorsha being saved again is leading me to believe that she is very much good. No tomfoolery there.

I think both MM and llama bring up compelling points against each other. I saw Dom the lynch going towards MM today anyway, but do not want to discount llama of trying to force civ hands.

linki- well if we're trying to kill monty, you should vote for MM, @Dom.
Please explain why you think I am Monty.

I have tied for the lead in two lynches, yes, but this implies that I was not the victim in at least one of them.
Because of host error, I don't think Dom is Monty. I don't think Sorsha is, because she's survived twice. To me, that leaves you or llama. And you seemed to be the consensus vote yesterday. I'm honestly not trusting you of llama, but I don't know if Golden was bad, which is futzing with my reads. Granted, I might as well be dipping my toast in light fluid, because my reads have been crap at best this game.

And I don't know what you mean by victim. You mean civ? The first one you tied for went to another person, the second just happened. The only victim in the equation is my clarity.

I will most likely vote you, but it is on the basis of running with llama. I don't like how he's buddied up to Elo in the past day. So.. I want to vote both of you.

By victim, I mean the lynch was tied, but one person was chosen to be lynched (whether they died or not).

#534

thellama73 wrote:Reminder to the gang that there are three living baddies, so don't spread the vote out or they can vote in a bloc and be tied with the civilians tomorrow after their NK.

I think llama slipped in this post. I thought Golden was his teammate, but I believe llama admitted otherwise.

#535

Roxy wrote:
Sorsha wrote:Roxy what do you think of fingersplints?
Splints is town. I have no reason to doubt her aorn.

"Splints is town." That's quite a bold statement for a civ to make.

#536

Finally you call me a civ!

Slip much?

#537

Roxy wrote:Finally you call me a civ!

Slip much?

is this supposed to be ironic or????

#538

No Dom. Not ironic.

She has been saying I am bad since Day 2 agreeing with her logic from her Day 1 vote (bc she wanted to be "crazy") Then moved on to me being bad bc I am being all kinds of adverbs bad.

Now in her last post she says I am civ.

Is it bc she knows I am civ bc she is bad - yes I think so and I think that slip was unintentional.

#539

her point is that as a civ, you shouldn't know that.

#540

Why wouldn't I know it as a civ?

splints and I have been playing and hosting together for years. Though her track record at reading me is superior to my ability to read her.
I feel like I know her well enough to say she is civ and have no reason to doubt her aorn.

#541

Dom is right. I don;t think anyone can know for sure unless you are bad and she is not on your team. That is the only way you can know she is civ unless you have role checked her somehow.

#542

and what is aorn? That is the second time you used that word.

#543

Somehow? There is an ability that does that...
It doesn't really seem that far fetched to me so not sure why you are acting like it is so unlikely

I will probably be voting for you

#544

Elohcin wrote:and what is aorn? That is the second time you used that word.

Google says Association of Perioperative Registered Nurses....

Or as of right now

#545

Roxy wrote:Why wouldn't I know it as a civ?

splints and I have been playing and hosting together for years. Though her track record at reading me is superior to my ability to read her.
I feel like I know her well enough to say she is civ and have no reason to doubt her aorn.

I don't necessarily disagree that you might read splints well. I do think it's weird that you took her comment to mean that she thinks/knows you're civvie-- and have pushed it.

#546

Actually I don't want to miss another vote so I am going to vote Elo right now. I trust Roxy and I think she is right. It does seem like Elo has been being saved by llama. Iirc he is the one who first commented to me about greybonez and then when he was lynched he was like "you all should have listened to me about MM". seems sketchy

#547

if I am bad and llama has been saving me, why would he openly say he has just recently chosen to stick by my side? Wouldn't he keep hushed about that sort of thing?

#548

So it's weird for Rox to defend me, but not for llama to defend you? By your own logic, why wouldn't Rox keep hushed about that sort of thing if we were bad?

#549

I am not relating you being bad to her being bad.

#550

I'm not sure I understand what point you are trying to make then by that comment. It doesn't make sense at all for you to say that. If we aren't related to each either being bad, we can't both be bad. Your suspicion doesn't make any sense.

#551

fingersplints wrote:So it's weird for Rox to defend me, but not for llama to defend you? By your own logic, why wouldn't Rox keep hushed about that sort of thing if we were bad?

This is why I said that. I think Roxy is bad. I think you could be bad. But my thinking Roxy is bad has nothing to do with my thinking of you being bad and vise-versa. And anyway, Roxy has been defending you since you came into the game. So keeping hushed is not an option :P. Llama was not always on my side according to his posts. He has just recently thought to defend me. So, I am saying that if he was actually helping me this whole time b/c we are both bad and on a team together, then why would he all of a sudden openly defend me. Wouldn't he just keep quiet about saving me as you think is happening? Anyway. I am not bad and I don't think llama is either.

#552

Why would keeping hushed not be an option? She could have just not said anything. That seems like a pretty viable option to me, especially considering I had barely any mentions she wouldn't need to openly defend me. You on the other hand have a lot of suspicion, and would gain some from having someone defend you.

The way it looks to me is: llama says he is suspicious of you. Once the suspicion of you picks up he suddenly switched to defending you, making the earlier suspicion look fake. If you were teammates he could then say he mentioned suspicion of you early. Do you see now why this is suspicious to me?

#553

Metalmarsh89 wrote:
thellama73 wrote:Reminder to the gang that there are three living baddies, so don't spread the vote out or they can vote in a bloc and be tied with the civilians tomorrow after their NK.
I think llama slipped in this post. I thought Golden was his teammate, but I believe llama admitted otherwise.

Do you have some reason for thinking Golden was not civ?

#554

I only meant that the word keep implies she is already hushing. She cant KEEP being hushed about you being her teammate if she is already defending you. That is all I meant

#555

Um how am I already hushing when just earlier today I said I thought she was civ?

Your argument does not make sense imo.

#556

If you follow your own logic then llama needs to keep defending you

#557

Roxy wrote:Um how am I already hushing when just earlier today I said I thought she was civ?

Your argument does not make sense imo.

No, no, no. I meant you are already not hushing b/c you have defended her form the get go. You can't KEEP doing something that you weren't doing in the first place. Anyway, this has quickly turned into a very silly and unproductive conversation.

#558

I thought it started silly and unproductive

#559

None of you are making sense to me right now. Also I am drunk. Voting MM. His questioning other people is much too casual for being on the chopping block.

#560

It also wouldn't surprise me if Roxy or splints were bad. If MM is good, I'm gunning for llama 146% tomorrow. But I think at this point I don't feel bad voting for MM

#561

Scotty wrote:It also wouldn't surprise me if Roxy or splints were bad. If MM is good, I'm gunning for llama 146% tomorrow. But I think at this point I don't feel bad voting for MM

If MM is good, I'm not convinced there will be a tomorrow.

#562

thellama73 wrote:
Scotty wrote:It also wouldn't surprise me if Roxy or splints were bad. If MM is good, I'm gunning for llama 146% tomorrow. But I think at this point I don't feel bad voting for MM
If MM is good, I'm not convinced there will be a tomorrow.

Ah, I guess we would be in lylo if mafia got a kill in tonight..

Would you be nice and tell us if we just lost?

#563

Scotty wrote:
thellama73 wrote:
Scotty wrote:It also wouldn't surprise me if Roxy or splints were bad. If MM is good, I'm gunning for llama 146% tomorrow. But I think at this point I don't feel bad voting for MM
If MM is good, I'm not convinced there will be a tomorrow.
Ah, I guess we would be in lylo if mafia got a kill in tonight..

Would you be nice and tell us if we just lost?

I don't think we did. But everything is a gamble to a certain extent.

#564

Day 6 - Poor Monty

The family converged on the roof, facing down MM angrily. He backed away to the precipice, but they continued to advance on him.

"You don't know what you're doing!" MM implored. "I'm not the killer!"

"Oh yeah? I know you tried to kill me twice!" declared Sorsha.

"And I never liked you to begin with!" said Llama.

"Fine, it was me. And I have no doubt the rest of you will fall after my demise. One way or another, the D'Ysquith fami-"

They pushed him mid-rant, and MM fell into a thicket far below. As he extricated himself, the mob pushed a gargoyle off the roof and crushed him. Monty Navarro had been thwarted at last.

MM has been lynched. He was Monty Navarro. It is now Night 6. You have 24 hours to send your PMs in, although I'm going to see the Hobbit tomorrow, so I'm not making any promises about the time the night phase ends.

#565

Nice result!

#566

YES!!!! Thank the lord

haha. So relieved with this result. You never know. Okay, we have a fighting chance.

#567

Dom wrote:Nice result!

Why did you not vote?

#568

Also woohoo! I'm now behind llama. I still think Golden was bad. Which, to me, leaves just 1 more (or Phoebe, if my assumption that she has been searching for Monty and found him is correct.)

If we can find that last mafia tomorrow, and we still don't win, I'm certain that Phoebe is the last one to search for. But I guess we'll cross that bridge when we come to it.

Elo pushed the MM vote ahead, which IMO looks a lot better than Roxy. She's on the top of my board tomorrow. What's everyone else think?

#569

#570

Scotty wrote:
Dom wrote:Nice result!
Why did you not vote?

I keep forgetting.

Full Games	Civilian: Mafia: Independent:
Speed Games	Civilian: Fiddler on the Roof Mafia:
Heists	Civilian: MVP: RED vs BLUE
Burglaries	Independent: The Theme Is Literally a Burglary
Special Games	Civilian: Independent:

Full Games	Civilian: Mafia: Independent:
Speed Games	Civilian: Fiddler on the Roof Mafia:
Heists	Civilian: MVP: RED vs BLUE
Burglaries	Independent: The Theme Is Literally a Burglary
Special Games	Civilian: Independent:

Full Games	Civilian: Mafia: Independent:
Speed Games	Civilian: Fiddler on the Roof Mafia:
Heists	Civilian: MVP: RED vs BLUE
Burglaries	Independent: The Theme Is Literally a Burglary
Special Games	Civilian: Independent:

Full Games	Civilian: Mafia: Independent:
Speed Games	Civilian: Fiddler on the Roof Mafia:
Heists	Civilian: MVP: RED vs BLUE
Burglaries	Independent: The Theme Is Literally a Burglary
Special Games	Civilian: Independent:

2014 Sockys
2015 Sockys
Miscellaneous

2014 Sockys
2015 Sockys
Miscellaneous

2014 Sockys
2015 Sockys
Miscellaneous

2014 Sockys
2015 Sockys
Miscellaneous

Who Is Referencing Other Musicals?